I don't think I"ll write an in depth review for this book, like I usually do, but I definitely have a few things I want to mention about it.
Overall, I liked the story, and the premise of this book, but there were a few things that I found lacking, things that were missing that could have really put this over the edge into brilliance. Oh well.
So this is the story of a 14 year old kid who's struggling with the transition into adulthood and is on the wrong track in life, sneaking out for parties at night, gambling in school, etc. And one night, when sneaking out to go to a party, he instead ends up on a train that takes him back in time to see some of the events that led to his life being what it is. The train then does this whole "It's a Wonderful Life" kind of thing and shows this kid what his life would look like if continued down the path he was on, what will happen to his family, etc. It's very Christmas Carol like that, but that part I very much enjoyed. I wish they'd just expounded on how this shit actually happens though.
All his jaunts to not his own time, I was into those. When he went into the past, I couldn't help but thinking that I probably would do the same things if I were him, and go try to see people that were supposed to be a huge part of my life, but weren't.
SPOILER ALERT: (Read on at your own risk, cuz I fucking warned you)
The part with teh going back in time bit that bothered me wasn't the meeting of his dad, and it wasn't even the alteration of events, or Jake realizing that it might be his FAULT that his dad was never around because of his choices here, it was the way that his dad disappeared. And this is where the book didn't deliver as strongly as it could have, in my opinion. What exactly was it that happened to his dad, where did he actually go, and how does that work? Now I know it's still early on in the book, so we definitely wouldn't have gotten answers here, but I've read the thing, and I can tell you that nowhere were there answers to my burning questions.
I can suspend disbelief enough to just go with it in regards to the magic train that makes people have this "ghost of whatever time of their life" experience, but I did want to know more about HOW it worked. Specifically, what the fuck happened to Jake's dad and how. In the end, if he existed enough to go through that, how come he didn't exist enough to be seen by anyone else, and could he be seen by anyone in the train station when he was supposedly just some bum? What's up with the other people on the train? Who are they, where'd they come from, how'd they wind up trapped there? These are the things that I wanted to know about, and if I'd gotten them, this would have been a book I LOVED.
As it stands now, the book is a cute cautionary tale about putting yourself on the right path and I think for some teens, this story could be helpful, and even to the point that for kids that are LIKE Jake, and need to read this book to maybe see themselves in it, and get back on the right path, more world-building, or any actually, would only hurt that cause cuz it would clutter the message. But for me, and I think a lot of the people who read YA for fun, if this book had done exactly what it did, wit the cautionary tale, but also added in some actual character development and delved into the train and the little world there, this could have become a really cool pseudo-fantasy, magical realism/contemporary tale. And it could have still been about a boy who needs to get back on the right path, but it also could have been more exciting, suspenseful, maybe, depending on how those questions were answered, it even could have contained more horror.
I dunno, I suppose in the end, probably the aim of this book was just what it read as, a short, easy and simple book about a boy who had an experience that pushes him to get his shit together, and for the kids who can relate to the story and learn something from it, I bet it's perfect just as is. Maybe it's me, and maybe it's just another case of "decent book, wrong reader," because I just wanted something MORE, and I think this idea, this story, had the potential to BE more, and that would have been a pretty cool book. But in the end, I guess it just wasn't that book, and probably wasn't supposed to be, and I'm probably expecting too much.