May 29, 1145pm ~~ Review asap.
May 31, 1130am ~~ First of all, thanks to GR friend Sandy for telling me about this book. I never would have known about it otherwise, and even though I did not like it as much as I expected to, I did still enjoy the basic story.
This is a novel about a young girl in Spain who dreams of being a bullfighter. She is an orphan who was raised on the hacienda of a family who bred fighting bulls, and the two brothers of the family (Pedro and Manuel) agree to begin training her secretly to be able to fight bulls from horseback. Luna has no memory of her mother, who died in childbirth. But she has been told that her father was a great bullfighter, and something inside tells her she could be great too. She eventually learns the truth about her family ties, but does the knowledge come too late?
The story follows her from Spain to Mexico and back, and takes place in the mid 1930's when Spain was enduring the cataclysms of civil war. Luna must face this tragedy when she returns to Spain, but until then it means nothing to her. The only important thing is her training. So what will happen to her in Spain? Will she pull her head out of the bullring long enough to see what is going on in her country? Will she even care if she does?
I tried to like Luna, but as other reviewers have said, she was not really a very likable person. However, a matador needs such arrogance and such focus, so I could forgive her that, to a point.
What I could not forgive were the author's errors, which began to show up once Luna and her cuadrilla arrived in Mexico. I could rant and rave for hours but I will say only a few things. I once read an autobiography of an author (I don't remember the name) who said the most important lesson she ever learned about writing was that you have to get your moon in the right place in the sky. Which means you need to be certain about the details in your story. If an author does not know for sure which currency a country uses (Mexico is peso, Spain is peseta, even in the 1930's), or when a Rosca De Reyes is part of a fiesta (only on January 6, never in December during the posadas), that author needs to find these things out before starting to write.
And if the main subject of your book is bullfighting, an author really needs to know as much about it as possible before starting a project. That way it is less likely to see unfortunate scenes such as the one in Columbia for Luna's fellow student Armando. I will just say this: a bull's career is a one time event. They do not leave the ring under their own power unless there is an indulto, in which case they are allowed to go out to pasture and hopefully breed more bulls like themselves. But an indulto is only for those bulls who show such bravery and grace that they win the hearts of the crowd and it is a very rare event. No management would ever boast about having a killer bull in the ring and no matador worth his sword would accept such an opponent. There are rules, and no one would flaunt them openly the way the author described. Not with the bull in Columbia and not with the idea of shaving the horns for Luna's first bull. That is still sometimes done, but it is a shameful, cowardly act done in secret, in the dark, and an honorable matador would never accept such a thing being done and would certainly never go ask permission to do it.
So as much as I enjoyed the story on the one hand, I was very disappointed with it on the other. To end on a good note, I can say that this book led me to hunt for the autobiography of Conchita Cintron, the woman on the cover and obviously a major influence for the story. I had heard of her and have read a little about her, but now when the book arrives I will get to read her life story in her own words.
So I can say thanks to Sandy for that book too!