What do you think?
Rate this book
Destiny of the Doctor #3
Doctor Who: Vengeance of the Stones
Two RAF fighter jets are on a training flight over North East Scotland when one of them is plucked from the air and promptly disappears. UNIT are called in, and the Doctor and Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart are soon on the scene. They enlist the help of a local military officer — a young lieutenant by the name of Mike Yates.
The Doctor discovers a link to the recumbent stone circles that are plentiful in this part of Scotland. The stones are thousands of years old, and are soon revealed to hold a terrible secret. Then Mike Yates disappears, abducted by an alien race that has a grievance with humanity. Their intention is to harness the power of the stones in order to take their revenge. For the Doctor and the Brigadier, the race is now on to save their new friend Mike and the entire planet Earth.
The Doctor discovers a link to the recumbent stone circles that are plentiful in this part of Scotland. The stones are thousands of years old, and are soon revealed to hold a terrible secret. Then Mike Yates disappears, abducted by an alien race that has a grievance with humanity. Their intention is to harness the power of the stones in order to take their revenge. For the Doctor and the Brigadier, the race is now on to save their new friend Mike and the entire planet Earth.
1 pages, Audio CD
First published March 7, 2013
95 people want to read
About the author
Andrew Smith
58 books8 followersThere is more than one author with this name
Andrew Smith wrote the Doctor Who television story Full Circle and its novelisation. At the time of initial broadcast, he was the youngest writer to contribute to the TV series.
Smith submitted his work to more than one Doctor Who script editor. They replied with "positive criticism". Finally he sent The Planet that Slept, which became Full Circle.
Shortly afterwards, he became a police officer, spending a long time in that career.
Smith was approached by Big Finish and displayed interest in writing for them. Because he had started the trilogy with Full Circle, they asked him to write a Companion Chronicles story set in E-Space. The Invasion of E-Space was released in October 2010.
Andrew Smith wrote the Doctor Who television story Full Circle and its novelisation. At the time of initial broadcast, he was the youngest writer to contribute to the TV series.
Smith submitted his work to more than one Doctor Who script editor. They replied with "positive criticism". Finally he sent The Planet that Slept, which became Full Circle.
Shortly afterwards, he became a police officer, spending a long time in that career.
Smith was approached by Big Finish and displayed interest in writing for them. Because he had started the trilogy with Full Circle, they asked him to write a Companion Chronicles story set in E-Space. The Invasion of E-Space was released in October 2010.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
December 13, 2023
The Third Doctor has his own story in this. Series, also it is the entrance of Mike Yates into UNIT in his first encounter in said organisation.
Once again humans by accident awaken Aliens this time in Scotland. These alien fellows are discovered when by accident an airplane gets Downed by their energy output bringing UNIT and the Doctor.
The Aliens have been stranded on earth for millennia after an agressieve encounter with humanity. Now they want home but their civilizationno longer exist.
Once again UNIT choses a military solution which is a recurring discussion between the Timelord and the humans.
An excellent and recognizable episode in the 3rd Doctors lifetime. Part of a langer tale called the Destiny of the Doctor engaging 11 Doctors in 11 audiotales of approx. An hour
Great fun celebrating 50 years of the Doctor, in a year celebrating 60 years.
Once again humans by accident awaken Aliens this time in Scotland. These alien fellows are discovered when by accident an airplane gets Downed by their energy output bringing UNIT and the Doctor.
The Aliens have been stranded on earth for millennia after an agressieve encounter with humanity. Now they want home but their civilizationno longer exist.
Once again UNIT choses a military solution which is a recurring discussion between the Timelord and the humans.
An excellent and recognizable episode in the 3rd Doctors lifetime. Part of a langer tale called the Destiny of the Doctor engaging 11 Doctors in 11 audiotales of approx. An hour
Great fun celebrating 50 years of the Doctor, in a year celebrating 60 years.
November 1, 2020
This is a short story that is based on the television show. It is also part of a series with each story being a different Doctor. Each story can stand on its own but is also part of a bigger thread. In this one, The Doctor and U.N.I.T. discover a race of aliens that have been hidden in the earth for many, many years.
I am loving the concept of this series with the self contained stories and the idea of them tying in with each other. My experience in this universe is all from the revival so this is really my introduction into these versions of The Doctor. That being said, I didn't think this did the best job of portraying The Third Doctor. The first two stories gave him a characteristic that one could sense in the audiobook. This Doctor was generic and nothing stood out. Actually I would go on and say this is more of an origins story for the character Mike Yates. I am not sure if he is character on the show but this read as if that was the purpose of this story. The best part of the story was the overall connecting thread and a cameo by a future presence from the revival.
So far, this is my least favorite of this series. That being said I still liked it and the hour that I listened to it i work flew by. For that I am grateful. On to the next one in this series.
I am loving the concept of this series with the self contained stories and the idea of them tying in with each other. My experience in this universe is all from the revival so this is really my introduction into these versions of The Doctor. That being said, I didn't think this did the best job of portraying The Third Doctor. The first two stories gave him a characteristic that one could sense in the audiobook. This Doctor was generic and nothing stood out. Actually I would go on and say this is more of an origins story for the character Mike Yates. I am not sure if he is character on the show but this read as if that was the purpose of this story. The best part of the story was the overall connecting thread and a cameo by a future presence from the revival.
So far, this is my least favorite of this series. That being said I still liked it and the hour that I listened to it i work flew by. For that I am grateful. On to the next one in this series.
March 3, 2025
2025 52 Book Challenge - Lunar New Year Mini Challenge - 2) A Wise Character
I thought this audiobook was pretty cool to show how Mike Yates first came into contact with UNIT, and the interactions between the Doctor, the Brigadier, Mike and the aliens all felt true of the 3rd Doctors era.
I also liked the plot, with aliens being stranded on Earth, much like the Doctor, by accident causing the incident that brings the Doctor and UNIT to Scotland and the debate between the Doctor and the Brigadier on the use of force.
I thought this audiobook was pretty cool to show how Mike Yates first came into contact with UNIT, and the interactions between the Doctor, the Brigadier, Mike and the aliens all felt true of the 3rd Doctors era.
I also liked the plot, with aliens being stranded on Earth, much like the Doctor, by accident causing the incident that brings the Doctor and UNIT to Scotland and the debate between the Doctor and the Brigadier on the use of force.
June 18, 2016
Hello friends.
It's me again. I am in a Doctor Who Phase so I am hearing some Doctor who adventures in audiobooks.
Well, for those who do not know, Doctor Who doesn't exist for the past 10 years with the beginning of season 1 in 2005. Well that was a continuation (not REBOOT) of a older series that started in 1963 and went for 26 years. There are 26 Seasons plus 11 from the XXI century.
In my home country Doctor Who never passed on TV and I didn't watch the first years of Doctor Who when it started in 2005. I am late watcher. Being a very strange person I like to have it all and watch it all even if it's impossible and Doctor Who is impossible. There are more than 700 episodes and more than 1000 audiobooks and not counting with the novelzations...
But I started from the First Doctor and went to the Second and stopped at the Third. I will try to restart and learn everything I can.
The third Doctor (my least favourite so far from the two previous ones) is a bit strange duck. He was stranded on Earth because of his actions on time-travel and messing things up. So he is trying to fix Tardis and at the same time helping UNIT with the Brigadier.
In this tale, the setting was very Doctor Who "version" Three - That I have to say. After the dissapearence of a plane in Scotland The Doctor and the Brigadier travel to Scotland to investigate the matter. They are helped by Mike Yates which tells them what is happenning. The Doctor imediately knows that the Recumbent stones they have found have something to do with it.
It's a fun story with the builders of the stone, which turn out to be alien beings, have been on statis for four thousand years. It seems that the inhabitants of the bristish islands messed them up so they went to "sleep" to cure their injuries only to be awaken by humans because of roadwork machines.
They wanted to know if mankind is more "gentle" now or if they are a threat. After the initial confrontation the Doctor says that their world has been lost and they are all that remain from their kind. But it seems the Brigadier doesn't trust the Doctor and the army kill one of the aliens so they make a plot to kill mankind.
But as I said, the Doctor is everywhere and the threat is not that real. That ruined the story for me. I felt no danger whatsoever. Enfin. A fun one-hour story but unless you watch the series don't bother.
It's me again. I am in a Doctor Who Phase so I am hearing some Doctor who adventures in audiobooks.
Well, for those who do not know, Doctor Who doesn't exist for the past 10 years with the beginning of season 1 in 2005. Well that was a continuation (not REBOOT) of a older series that started in 1963 and went for 26 years. There are 26 Seasons plus 11 from the XXI century.
In my home country Doctor Who never passed on TV and I didn't watch the first years of Doctor Who when it started in 2005. I am late watcher. Being a very strange person I like to have it all and watch it all even if it's impossible and Doctor Who is impossible. There are more than 700 episodes and more than 1000 audiobooks and not counting with the novelzations...
But I started from the First Doctor and went to the Second and stopped at the Third. I will try to restart and learn everything I can.
The third Doctor (my least favourite so far from the two previous ones) is a bit strange duck. He was stranded on Earth because of his actions on time-travel and messing things up. So he is trying to fix Tardis and at the same time helping UNIT with the Brigadier.
In this tale, the setting was very Doctor Who "version" Three - That I have to say. After the dissapearence of a plane in Scotland The Doctor and the Brigadier travel to Scotland to investigate the matter. They are helped by Mike Yates which tells them what is happenning. The Doctor imediately knows that the Recumbent stones they have found have something to do with it.
It's a fun story with the builders of the stone, which turn out to be alien beings, have been on statis for four thousand years. It seems that the inhabitants of the bristish islands messed them up so they went to "sleep" to cure their injuries only to be awaken by humans because of roadwork machines.
They wanted to know if mankind is more "gentle" now or if they are a threat. After the initial confrontation the Doctor says that their world has been lost and they are all that remain from their kind. But it seems the Brigadier doesn't trust the Doctor and the army kill one of the aliens so they make a plot to kill mankind.
But as I said, the Doctor is everywhere and the threat is not that real. That ruined the story for me. I felt no danger whatsoever. Enfin. A fun one-hour story but unless you watch the series don't bother.
October 12, 2014
Published in 2013 by AudioGo (Blackstone/BBC)
Read by Richard Franklin and Trevor Littledale
Duration: 1 hour
As a part of the 50th Anniversary celebration of Doctor Who, the BBC released a series of audiobooks called Destiny of the Doctor . Each of the Doctors has a 1 hour audiobook story.
In Vengeance of the Stones the Doctor and UNIT are called in to investigate the mysterious disappearance of a RAF fighter jet from the skies above Scotland. While the Doctor is poking around he encounters Lt. Mike Yates for the first time (who becomes Captain Mike Yates and a companion in the television series).
The Doctor soon discovers that the disappearance of the jet is the work of an alien species that has a ancient grudge against humanity and that they are the reason for the prevalence of so many recumbent stone circles in this area.
Also, he discovers that...
Read more at: http://dwdsreviews.blogspot.com/2014/...
Read by Richard Franklin and Trevor Littledale
Duration: 1 hour
As a part of the 50th Anniversary celebration of Doctor Who, the BBC released a series of audiobooks called Destiny of the Doctor . Each of the Doctors has a 1 hour audiobook story.
In Vengeance of the Stones the Doctor and UNIT are called in to investigate the mysterious disappearance of a RAF fighter jet from the skies above Scotland. While the Doctor is poking around he encounters Lt. Mike Yates for the first time (who becomes Captain Mike Yates and a companion in the television series).
The Doctor soon discovers that the disappearance of the jet is the work of an alien species that has a ancient grudge against humanity and that they are the reason for the prevalence of so many recumbent stone circles in this area.
Also, he discovers that...
Read more at: http://dwdsreviews.blogspot.com/2014/...
July 23, 2020
A fun short tale featuring UNIT that is certainly inspired by and drawn from the Pertwee era. Also, interestingly, this adventure provided an introduction for Mike Yates and his first meeting the Doctor.
June 27, 2025
I heard some pritty negative things about this one but I quite enjoyed it. I wouldn’t say I love it, but I was so invested in the story and I liked the aliens in the story who were really fleshed out and interesting characters.
It’s been a while since I first listened to this one and I don’t remember much of the details, but I like the characters of the Armidians and is well narrated by Richard Franklin. I think the relationship that the main Arminian “Garlin Munn” has with his female cohort and when he looses her, it is genuinely tragic.
I would love to listen to this again so I can remember all the details as I liked them when I listened to it for the first time.
It’s been a while since I first listened to this one and I don’t remember much of the details, but I like the characters of the Armidians and is well narrated by Richard Franklin. I think the relationship that the main Arminian “Garlin Munn” has with his female cohort and when he looses her, it is genuinely tragic.
I would love to listen to this again so I can remember all the details as I liked them when I listened to it for the first time.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 25, 2017
This was a decent 3rd Doctor story featuring UNIT with the Brigadier, Benton and our apparent first meeting of Yates.
Two planes are affected by some strange glowing energy one night and it seems the stones of some local Scottish stone circles maybe be related. It's the usual running around and aliens and the Doctor begging patience from the Brigadier and being denied but it was a well-paced little romp and only an hour long short story; well read and decently sound-effects filled.
Enjoyable for fans of the 3rd Doctor as it captured his bluster and attitude nicely.
Two planes are affected by some strange glowing energy one night and it seems the stones of some local Scottish stone circles maybe be related. It's the usual running around and aliens and the Doctor begging patience from the Brigadier and being denied but it was a well-paced little romp and only an hour long short story; well read and decently sound-effects filled.
Enjoyable for fans of the 3rd Doctor as it captured his bluster and attitude nicely.
March 15, 2018
The third story in the series is read by Richard Franklin, who played UNIT officer Captain Yates in the TV series.
The choice of Franklin, rather than Katy Manning, as the narrator does seem an odd one, although it makes sense in the context of the story which is, in part about how Yates first joined UNIT. That, of course, is a story that has been told before in other media, arguably with more success. This version has him serving at RAF Lossiemouth for no particularly clear reason (given that he's an army officer).
The story is a reasonably straightforward UNIT-era story, with the Doctor and Brigadier sent in to investigate the disappearance of a fighter jet and its pilot over Aberdeenshire. It is reminiscent of both The Daemons and The Silurians from the TV show, although it struggles to make the antagonists as sympathetic as the latter does. The story pushes the military nature of UNIT, and is weakened by the absence of any significant female characters, or any civilian protagonists other than the Doctor - Liz Shaw would logically have been working with the Doctor at the time, but isn't even mentioned.
There are some nice touches, such as the use of the flying UNIT base from The Invasion, but overall it's an unremarkable story with a few plot holes and little of real interest.
The choice of Franklin, rather than Katy Manning, as the narrator does seem an odd one, although it makes sense in the context of the story which is, in part about how Yates first joined UNIT. That, of course, is a story that has been told before in other media, arguably with more success. This version has him serving at RAF Lossiemouth for no particularly clear reason (given that he's an army officer).
The story is a reasonably straightforward UNIT-era story, with the Doctor and Brigadier sent in to investigate the disappearance of a fighter jet and its pilot over Aberdeenshire. It is reminiscent of both The Daemons and The Silurians from the TV show, although it struggles to make the antagonists as sympathetic as the latter does. The story pushes the military nature of UNIT, and is weakened by the absence of any significant female characters, or any civilian protagonists other than the Doctor - Liz Shaw would logically have been working with the Doctor at the time, but isn't even mentioned.
There are some nice touches, such as the use of the flying UNIT base from The Invasion, but overall it's an unremarkable story with a few plot holes and little of real interest.
February 12, 2021
A slight improvement over the first two stories (Doctor Who: Hunters of Earth, Doctor Who: Shadow of Death) in this series, though I think the mystery, such as it is, is really thin at this point.
Recumbent Stone Circles are used to great effect in the story, though. They're only found in Scotland and are interesting all on their own.
Recumbent Stone Circles are used to great effect in the story, though. They're only found in Scotland and are interesting all on their own.
January 15, 2021
あらすじ
王立空軍の戦闘機が訓練中に忽然と消えてしまう。必死の捜索にもかかわらずなんの手がかりも得られない。そこでUNITが捜査を担当することに。
ブリゲディアとドクターが現地入りすると、行方不明だったパイロットがストーン・サークルの近くで発見されたという報告があり、ドクターとマイク・イェーツ中尉は急行する。ところがパイロットは意識を取り戻したかと思うと、ドクターとイェーツの目の前でストーン・サークルの元に駆けていき、石に触れる。すると電光が走り、パイロットは絶命。しかし、ドクターとイェーツが石の表面に触れても何も起こらない。そこで、ドクターはパイロットと同じように飛行機で同じ時間帯に同じコースを飛んでみることにする。イェーツはその間、ストーン・サークルの警備を担当することに。夜空に飛行機で飛び立ったドクターはストーン・サークルから幾つもの光が天空に照射されるのを目撃。次の瞬間、飛行機は強い衝撃にみ��われ、ドクターは海への不時着を余儀なくされる。同じ頃、ストーン・サークルが緑に輝き出すのをイェーツは目撃。広がる光の中に巻き込まれたイェーツは何者かの声をきき、意識を失う。ストーン・サークルが4000年前にファラス星からやってきたアメリアンという種族の科学者で構成された調査団によってつくられたものと判明。彼らは原始時代の人類に6人の仲間を殺されたことで人類に不信感を持っていた。傷をいやすためカプセルで冬眠するが、昨今の道路や住宅建設で地面が振動したことで冬眠から目覚めたところだった。しかし、ドクターから自分たちの母星がはるか昔に星間戦争によって滅びたことをしり、種族を存続させるため人類を皆殺しにし、地球を自分たちの新たな母星にしようと企む。
感想
マイク・イェーツがUNITに入るまでの物語。ドクターがアメリアンたちをうまく説得しかかっていたところにUNITの攻撃に割り込まれ、結局アメリアンたちを暴走させてしまう。そういったところにブリゲディアはあまり悪びれたりはしないのだけれど、もしも、もうちょっとドクターを信用して交渉を続けさせてくれていれば、もっと平和的な解決法があったかもしれないと思うと残念だ。今回も11thからのメッセージ。歴代ドクターの中でも結構重厚な性格のドクター。将来的にあのキャラになると知るのはどんな気分だろう。
王立空軍の戦闘機が訓練中に忽然と消えてしまう。必死の捜索にもかかわらずなんの手がかりも得られない。そこでUNITが捜査を担当することに。
ブリゲディアとドクターが現地入りすると、行方不明だったパイロットがストーン・サークルの近くで発見されたという報告があり、ドクターとマイク・イェーツ中尉は急行する。ところがパイロットは意識を取り戻したかと思うと、ドクターとイェーツの目の前でストーン・サークルの元に駆けていき、石に触れる。すると電光が走り、パイロットは絶命。しかし、ドクターとイェーツが石の表面に触れても何も起こらない。そこで、ドクターはパイロットと同じように飛行機で同じ時間帯に同じコースを飛んでみることにする。イェーツはその間、ストーン・サークルの警備を担当することに。夜空に飛行機で飛び立ったドクターはストーン・サークルから幾つもの光が天空に照射されるのを目撃。次の瞬間、飛行機は強い衝撃にみ��われ、ドクターは海への不時着を余儀なくされる。同じ頃、ストーン・サークルが緑に輝き出すのをイェーツは目撃。広がる光の中に巻き込まれたイェーツは何者かの声をきき、意識を失う。ストーン・サークルが4000年前にファラス星からやってきたアメリアンという種族の科学者で構成された調査団によってつくられたものと判明。彼らは原始時代の人類に6人の仲間を殺されたことで人類に不信感を持っていた。傷をいやすためカプセルで冬眠するが、昨今の道路や住宅建設で地面が振動したことで冬眠から目覚めたところだった。しかし、ドクターから自分たちの母星がはるか昔に星間戦争によって滅びたことをしり、種族を存続させるため人類を皆殺しにし、地球を自分たちの新たな母星にしようと企む。
感想
マイク・イェーツがUNITに入るまでの物語。ドクターがアメリアンたちをうまく説得しかかっていたところにUNITの攻撃に割り込まれ、結局アメリアンたちを暴走させてしまう。そういったところにブリゲディアはあまり悪びれたりはしないのだけれど、もしも、もうちょっとドクターを信用して交渉を続けさせてくれていれば、もっと平和的な解決法があったかもしれないと思うと残念だ。今回も11thからのメッセージ。歴代ドクターの中でも結構重厚な性格のドクター。将来的にあのキャラになると知るのはどんな気分だろう。
February 10, 2021
I think I'm probably a bit harsh on this, mostly because I recently watched Invasion of the Dinosaurs and learnt about Mike Yates betraying UNIT and wanting to kill the entire population of earth, so I found it impossible to sympathise with him. However, it was a pretty good story with an interesting alien species who thought that humans were all violent and evil because of the actions of a few. Perhaps they shouldn't have taken their examples from the army. Anyway, it was quite a good story, I just struggled to feel invested in the plot.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 17, 2021
How did Mike Yates join Unit? There's a mystery unfolding involving a missing aircraft and a series of ancient stone circles. Mike Yates is asked to help Unit with their search and soon has an unpleasant close encounter with an alien force.
As usual the Doctor tries to negotiate a peace between the aliens and Unit, but things don't go well. The aliens are now determined to have their revenge on humanity. The battle between Unit and the aliens feels like a Havoc style action sequence, perfectly at home as part of the televised episodes.
As usual the Doctor tries to negotiate a peace between the aliens and Unit, but things don't go well. The aliens are now determined to have their revenge on humanity. The battle between Unit and the aliens feels like a Havoc style action sequence, perfectly at home as part of the televised episodes.
December 21, 2021
This third Doctor story was good, but I didn't like it quite as much as the previous second Doctor story. I like the third Doctor, in general, but I haven't seen/heard/read too many of his stories, so I can't say too much about how accurate the tone of this one is. I think this one would have been fun for a die-hard third Doctor fan, but if you're not that familiar with that era, then it might not do much for you.
August 31, 2018
Skip this one. Not worth the time. It's VERY Mike Yates heavy. The man who played Mike Yates narrates this and does not do a good job. He really hams it up when he voices Yates. I had to turn the volume down several times due to his groaning and yelling. The plot wasn't great and didn't grab me at all.
April 17, 2023
Loved this story - the absolute best and most realistic (if Dr Who can be called that) origin story for Mike Yates joining UNIT (and I've read a few!!). As he is one of my favourite characters it was also a joy to hear Richard Franklin, who played Captain Yates in the show, perform the audio ...and he was just so good... Great stuff❣️
May 24, 2020
The idea of aliens wanting revenge for something humans did is a little repetitive, but it's not that bad.
Wonderfully narrated, as always. And I like the connection between Doctors they made on this series of audiodramas. The universe of Doctor Who is really bigger on the inside.
Wonderfully narrated, as always. And I like the connection between Doctors they made on this series of audiodramas. The universe of Doctor Who is really bigger on the inside.
July 23, 2025
A 1 hour audio book. The Doctor as he works with UNIT to solve some of the 1960s mysteries of the stone circles of Scotland. Overall, the death rate in this book is high and for the most part I don't think anyone ever listens to the Doctor unless its about the science.
September 2, 2025
I quite enjoyed this one. Some of the others in the series haven't been all that great, but I thought this one was intriguing and managed to accomplish a lot in such a short time. Plus, we meet Mike Yates for the first time.
January 19, 2026
🎧I love Doctor Who and needed a little pallet cleanser. Thus one was good, entertaining and fun, but not amazing. The third Doctor is my second favorite and I love that this introduced Mike Keats, but the story was not quite 5 star
July 21, 2017
Very suspenseful! Very interesting story and easy to follow. Excellent voice acting! I liked it! :)
January 21, 2018
A very solid, kind of an origin story for Captain Mike Yates. Enjoyable enough, but doesn't stand out as a story in of itself - in either a good or a bad way. Consider this a strong 3.
January 30, 2018
Nice backstory how Captain Mike Yates ended up joining U.N.I.T.
February 28, 2018
Richard Franklin was great as Mike Yates but he didn't work doing the voice of the Doctor or the brigadier.
May 20, 2020
2.5 stars.
July 9, 2020
I didn't particulare care for the Autor spoke.
July 15, 2020
Another well done offering from Big Finish.
The plot reminded me of something, but now I can't remember what.
But all in all enjoyable, and nice to see the Brigadier.
Definitely worth the listen
The plot reminded me of something, but now I can't remember what.
But all in all enjoyable, and nice to see the Brigadier.
Definitely worth the listen
July 18, 2020
3.5/5 stars
November 16, 2021
Verbazend verhaal.
January 31, 2022
Cool idea, kind of like Outlander, which was inspired by DW.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews