What do you think?
Rate this book
Charmed #4
Stimmen aus der Vergangenheit
A shard of mirror for a broken reflection
A pocket watch with a cracked face
A cache of herbs to burn for protection
All will send me to another time and place.
Phoebe Halliwell is having a very bad day. A demon has pulled her centuries into the past. She has no way to tell her sisters she's alive, no way to get back to her own time—and the demon is trying to kill her.
Back in the present, Prue and Piper are devastated at losing their sister. But that isn't their only problem. Something is wrong with them, too. Somehow, they're turning...evil.
But why? And how can they stop it—without the Power of Three?
A pocket watch with a cracked face
A cache of herbs to burn for protection
All will send me to another time and place.
Phoebe Halliwell is having a very bad day. A demon has pulled her centuries into the past. She has no way to tell her sisters she's alive, no way to get back to her own time—and the demon is trying to kill her.
Back in the present, Prue and Piper are devastated at losing their sister. But that isn't their only problem. Something is wrong with them, too. Somehow, they're turning...evil.
But why? And how can they stop it—without the Power of Three?
151 pages, Hardcover
First published June 1, 2000
8 people are currently reading
1148 people want to read
About the author
Rosalind Noonan
36 books161 followersROSALIND NOONAN grew up in suburban Maryland and enjoyed being part of a large family. "With my four siblings, Saturday mornings were a blast," she says. "There was festival seating on the living room floor as we devoured cartoons and passed the Sugar Pops."
She caught the writing bug in second grade when she won first place in a poetry contest. "The prize was twenty dollars," she recalls. "That was big bucks for a second grader. I thought I was going to Disneyland." Wooed by the taste of fame and fortune, she kept writing.
After attending Wagner College in Staten Island, she remained in New York City where she worked as an editor for various book publishers. Noonan currently lives in the Pacific Northwest with her husband, a retired cop from the NYPD, and two children. Although she sometimes misses the rapid pulse of New York, she enjoys writing in the shade of towering two-hundred year old Douglas fir trees.
She caught the writing bug in second grade when she won first place in a poetry contest. "The prize was twenty dollars," she recalls. "That was big bucks for a second grader. I thought I was going to Disneyland." Wooed by the taste of fame and fortune, she kept writing.
After attending Wagner College in Staten Island, she remained in New York City where she worked as an editor for various book publishers. Noonan currently lives in the Pacific Northwest with her husband, a retired cop from the NYPD, and two children. Although she sometimes misses the rapid pulse of New York, she enjoys writing in the shade of towering two-hundred year old Douglas fir trees.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
June 19, 2023
„Stimmen der Vergangenheit“ ist der 4. Band der „Charmed“ Reihe. Bisher finde ich die Bücher zur TV-Serie eigentlich alle recht gut. Dieser Band ist auch wieder interessant und spannend, die Geschichte mit der Zeitreise nach Salem gefällt mir richtig gut! Sie passt auch wie die Faust aufs Auge zu den Charakteren der Serie. Die Autorin hat sehr gut recherchiert und sich Gedanken zu den Protagonisten gemacht. Diese Geschichte spielt abseits des offiziellen Kanons. Das fällt jedoch kaum auf, da sie sich perfekt in die Handlung einfügt. Ich kenne die Serie ziemlich gut, trotzdem habe ich mich zwischendurch ertappt, mich zu fragen, ob es davon nicht doch eine Serienfolge gibt.
Auf jeden Fall sind die Bücher meiner Meinung nach ein regelrechtes Muss für jeden „Charmed“ Fan! Ich vergebe 5 Sterne und eine klare Leseempfehlung!
Auf jeden Fall sind die Bücher meiner Meinung nach ein regelrechtes Muss für jeden „Charmed“ Fan! Ich vergebe 5 Sterne und eine klare Leseempfehlung!
April 25, 2015
Whispers From The Past is the fourth Charmed book, and for me it wasn't as good as the previous three that I've read. I loved the storyline of travelling back to Salem in the 1600s and meeting the sister's ancestor, but the sisters just didn't feel true to character. The feel you get for them in the show and in the previous books was much better. Hopefully I'll like the next one more.
September 22, 2021
My favorite episodes were always the ones where something happened to turn the sisters temporarily evil. I also prefer Phoebe’s POV to Prue’s. This was fun.
April 26, 2024
Het vierde boek uit de reeks bouwt verder op het succesvolle concept. De drie Halliwel-zusjes krijgen het aan de stok met zwarte magiërs en/of demonen en moeten dan met "De Macht van Drie" een strijd op leven en dood voeren.
Toch is er weer wat speciaals aan de hand in dit verhaal. De macht van drie raakt gescheiden. Phoebe wordt naar het verleden getransporteerd, de schrijfster voegt daarmee ook nog eens het element tijdreizen en tijdparadox toe aan het geheel.
De achterblijvers gaan op zoek naar hun zusje maar geraken onder invloed van zwarte magie en veranderen langzaam van witte heksen in zwarte heksen.
Phoebe daarentegen verschijnt poedelnaakt voor de inwoners van het Salem, berucht voor zijn heksenverbrandingen, en wordt herkend als heks. Daar ontmoet ze wel enkel van haar voorouders maar het blijft lang een raadsel of dat nu ook een witte heks is, die eventueel hulp kan bieden, of niet.
Origineel, spannend, heel veel aktie, veel beschamende maar ook enkele ontroerende elementen en een verliefdheid die weer eens erg fout blijkt te zijn.
Deze reeks is nog maar net begonnen maar blijft zijn erg sterke nievau behouden. Dat belooft nog voor de toekomst.
Toch is er weer wat speciaals aan de hand in dit verhaal. De macht van drie raakt gescheiden. Phoebe wordt naar het verleden getransporteerd, de schrijfster voegt daarmee ook nog eens het element tijdreizen en tijdparadox toe aan het geheel.
De achterblijvers gaan op zoek naar hun zusje maar geraken onder invloed van zwarte magie en veranderen langzaam van witte heksen in zwarte heksen.
Phoebe daarentegen verschijnt poedelnaakt voor de inwoners van het Salem, berucht voor zijn heksenverbrandingen, en wordt herkend als heks. Daar ontmoet ze wel enkel van haar voorouders maar het blijft lang een raadsel of dat nu ook een witte heks is, die eventueel hulp kan bieden, of niet.
Origineel, spannend, heel veel aktie, veel beschamende maar ook enkele ontroerende elementen en een verliefdheid die weer eens erg fout blijkt te zijn.
Deze reeks is nog maar net begonnen maar blijft zijn erg sterke nievau behouden. Dat belooft nog voor de toekomst.
May 24, 2023
I liked how different this one was out of the first 4. I liked how they got to meet Prudence and be introduced to the Book Of Shadows before all the spells were written in it.
October 17, 2014
The fourth book in the Charmed series of books based on the TV series of the same name. I enjoyed this book more than I originally through I would, I had a blast reading it, and there were plenty of blasts and action to go around in this book. It is a welcome addition to the stories in the franchise, although it has some inconsistencies with the plot, but I'll let it go because the books are considered non-cannon. I try to piece together all media and fit them into one time line. A great light read. The only downside is that it's too short for me, and left me wanting more.
March 8, 2007
Well the only reason i read this book was because i used to be a charmed fanatic and i thought it would be cool to atucally read one of the books,and i was right i ended up liking the book just as much as the show.
September 29, 2015
I liked the time travel aspect of the story, but that was about it. The characters didn't feel genuine to the on-screen ones, I barely recognized them and that wasn't too enjoyable. The ending was so obvious and boring. Unless you are a huge Charmed fan, I'd suggest you skip this book.
February 15, 2025
Not the greatest. Phoebe's characterization was closest to that portrayed in the series. Piper's character was extremely immature and annoying. The book felt like it was written for the (very) young adult crowd. The story had potential, but the execution fell a little flat.
July 4, 2025
Rounded up to three stars.
Either one person or a lot of people brought their Charmed tie-in novels to one of the two Half Price Book stores I frequent. Some I already had but I bought all of the others just to see how good they are.
There were only ten books covering the first three seasons of Charmed with Prue, Piper and Phoebe.
All of the rest focused on the last five seasons of Piper, Phoebe and Paige.
None of them are canon but do have elements from the show. Mentions of the club would put this as at least Season 2 since it is when Piper opened P3.
Out on a trip to buy shoes, a warlock starts attacking the Halliwell sisters in an alley. Piper's freezing power is a little off so they believe the warlock is very powerful and Phoebe can't have him running around San Francisco after innocents.
While Prue tends to Piper, Phoebe follows the warlock but then discovers that he is a demon as she grabs on to his slimy, scaly green tail. It opens up a portal and Phoebe is sucked into a vortex of green smoke.
When Prue and Piper reach the dead end of a high to climb wall, they find the clothes that Phoebe was wearing along with a pile of soot and oil covered material that was the demon's "human" disguise. A spell from the Book of Shadows meant to track Phoebe is indecisive or worst-case scenario...dead.
Phoebe is very much alive but has been sent back to the past by the demon...a time demon. She finds herself completely naked in a Puritan village, but it is her pierced belly button and crimson manicured nails that draw the attention of the townspeople more. They accuse her of being a witch, but Phoebe is saved by a handsome man named Hugh Montgomery, who shields her with his cloak and claims her to be his visiting "sister".
Phoebe feigns having no memory of what happened and says she was attacked by robbers and stripped of her clothing. Hugh takes her to stay with the Widow Wentworth who has been providing Hugh with a place to stay in payment of hiring him for her late husband's farm. Phoebe learns that she is in Salem circa 1676 but wonders exactly...why now and this place?
Almost knocking over a clay pot, Phoebe finds a gold crescent charm inside of it and one touch brings about a vision that Phoebe knows about all too well: a woman being burned at the stake with blonde hair and blue eyes.
It is Melinda Warren, the first witch of the Charmed Ones line and first writer in the Book of Shadows. A young woman in her early twenties and a child no more than five arrive with the same blonde hair and blue eyes as Melinda. The young widow introduces herself as Prudence and her daughter is Cassandra and in a sly bit of chit-chat, Phoebe learns the gold charm once belonged to Prudence's mother.
This is one of the Halliwell ancestors.
Prudence seems to be nice but the following morning, she gives Phoebe grief for sleeping in so late and Phoebe also notices that Hugh is a big flirt to both women. Going to fetch water, Phoebe comes across the demon, and he sets fire to Prudence's barn.
She believes it was Phoebe who started it, and Prudence doesn't take kindly to Hugh taking Phoebe's side more than hers. Later when Phoebe catches Prudence writing in the Book of Shadows, she finds the spell she was writing is a pretty evil one and Prudence even threatens to kill Phoebe the next time she even thinks of touching it.
Phoebe knows that the book never had spells to do harm or evil to innocents so why are they now?
In the present, Piper and Prue are trying to find Phoebe but soon their grief and guilt turn into squabbles where they can't stand each other. Prue notices the spells are changing in the book and when they tell how to get rid of warlocks and take their powers, both sisters are now on a high to tracking demons and wearing black clothes. The bigger problem is...they have no interest in saving their sister?
They are turning evil, and it all has to do with the whispers from the past...
The who, how and why all the good witches are going bad is the reveals made as the book goes along but how Prue and Piper turn back to normal and save Phoebe from the past without completely re-writing the future are the next big questions.
There is some sentimentality to the story and some sisterly bickering and snarking towards the end but having already watched Charmed, canon episodes from the show handled the same plots and themes much better.
One book down...twenty-one more to go.
Yep, you read that right, so it looks like I'm in for A Very Charmed Summer.
Either one person or a lot of people brought their Charmed tie-in novels to one of the two Half Price Book stores I frequent. Some I already had but I bought all of the others just to see how good they are.
There were only ten books covering the first three seasons of Charmed with Prue, Piper and Phoebe.
All of the rest focused on the last five seasons of Piper, Phoebe and Paige.
None of them are canon but do have elements from the show. Mentions of the club would put this as at least Season 2 since it is when Piper opened P3.
Out on a trip to buy shoes, a warlock starts attacking the Halliwell sisters in an alley. Piper's freezing power is a little off so they believe the warlock is very powerful and Phoebe can't have him running around San Francisco after innocents.
While Prue tends to Piper, Phoebe follows the warlock but then discovers that he is a demon as she grabs on to his slimy, scaly green tail. It opens up a portal and Phoebe is sucked into a vortex of green smoke.
When Prue and Piper reach the dead end of a high to climb wall, they find the clothes that Phoebe was wearing along with a pile of soot and oil covered material that was the demon's "human" disguise. A spell from the Book of Shadows meant to track Phoebe is indecisive or worst-case scenario...dead.
Phoebe is very much alive but has been sent back to the past by the demon...a time demon. She finds herself completely naked in a Puritan village, but it is her pierced belly button and crimson manicured nails that draw the attention of the townspeople more. They accuse her of being a witch, but Phoebe is saved by a handsome man named Hugh Montgomery, who shields her with his cloak and claims her to be his visiting "sister".
Phoebe feigns having no memory of what happened and says she was attacked by robbers and stripped of her clothing. Hugh takes her to stay with the Widow Wentworth who has been providing Hugh with a place to stay in payment of hiring him for her late husband's farm. Phoebe learns that she is in Salem circa 1676 but wonders exactly...why now and this place?
Almost knocking over a clay pot, Phoebe finds a gold crescent charm inside of it and one touch brings about a vision that Phoebe knows about all too well: a woman being burned at the stake with blonde hair and blue eyes.
It is Melinda Warren, the first witch of the Charmed Ones line and first writer in the Book of Shadows. A young woman in her early twenties and a child no more than five arrive with the same blonde hair and blue eyes as Melinda. The young widow introduces herself as Prudence and her daughter is Cassandra and in a sly bit of chit-chat, Phoebe learns the gold charm once belonged to Prudence's mother.
This is one of the Halliwell ancestors.
Prudence seems to be nice but the following morning, she gives Phoebe grief for sleeping in so late and Phoebe also notices that Hugh is a big flirt to both women. Going to fetch water, Phoebe comes across the demon, and he sets fire to Prudence's barn.
She believes it was Phoebe who started it, and Prudence doesn't take kindly to Hugh taking Phoebe's side more than hers. Later when Phoebe catches Prudence writing in the Book of Shadows, she finds the spell she was writing is a pretty evil one and Prudence even threatens to kill Phoebe the next time she even thinks of touching it.
Phoebe knows that the book never had spells to do harm or evil to innocents so why are they now?
In the present, Piper and Prue are trying to find Phoebe but soon their grief and guilt turn into squabbles where they can't stand each other. Prue notices the spells are changing in the book and when they tell how to get rid of warlocks and take their powers, both sisters are now on a high to tracking demons and wearing black clothes. The bigger problem is...they have no interest in saving their sister?
They are turning evil, and it all has to do with the whispers from the past...
The who, how and why all the good witches are going bad is the reveals made as the book goes along but how Prue and Piper turn back to normal and save Phoebe from the past without completely re-writing the future are the next big questions.
There is some sentimentality to the story and some sisterly bickering and snarking towards the end but having already watched Charmed, canon episodes from the show handled the same plots and themes much better.
One book down...twenty-one more to go.
Yep, you read that right, so it looks like I'm in for A Very Charmed Summer.
December 31, 2018
This was a quick and fun read! I really like the plot of this story and definitely could’ve seen this as an actual episode of Charmed. It did have some similarities to actual episodes, but I always loved the time travel ones!
It was fun going back to Salem in the heigh of the witch-hunting and meeting their relative from that time period. It was a really interesting plot watching Prudence (of the Salem) time drinking that tea which then cause her to turn evil which caused Piper & Prue to start turning evil in present day.
It was fun going back to Salem in the heigh of the witch-hunting and meeting their relative from that time period. It was a really interesting plot watching Prudence (of the Salem) time drinking that tea which then cause her to turn evil which caused Piper & Prue to start turning evil in present day.
July 25, 2018
This would have been one of the episodes where I would say "Oh that was alright, what's happening next week?". I feel like this was a combination of the episodes where the Charmed ones go back to save Melinda Warren to ensure that she is safely born, and the one where Prue is kidnapped and forced to marry a Warlock and the sisters turn evil. It wasn't REALLY original.
That being said, gotta love when the sisters go dark, even if it's only a brief time.
That being said, gotta love when the sisters go dark, even if it's only a brief time.
August 28, 2018
"She was one of the Charmed Ones, and that was all that mattered." This book was total 'cheese'. But, I enjoyed it. I loved the show SO much & own all of the seasons on DVD. The show is 100% better! I have had this one book out of the entire series for many years and decided to pick it up for a quick/fun read. None the less, it was a guilty pleasure to re-visit the Halliwell sisters via flipping through pages.
September 18, 2023
I enjoyed going back in time and seeing The Charmed Ones ancestor Prudence. Prue and Piper are going dark because of a time traveling demon sure was interesting. Phoebe, piecing together what was happening to Prudence and writing a message to her sisters in The Book Of Shadows to warm them was genius.
My only criticism is that I found a lot of typos in this book. Ugh.
Im enjoying this series as much as I did the tv show.
My only criticism is that I found a lot of typos in this book. Ugh.
Im enjoying this series as much as I did the tv show.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 23, 2018
There were some facts the writer happened to ignore, like the Salem witch trials took Place in 1690 until 1692, but the book mistook the timeline. Not sure if it was good to have Phoebe completely naked (there were children who liked the series after all). Otherwise it was a good read.
May 7, 2019
currently at home in Scotland. found a crate of old books in the basement and to my surprise about 30 charmed books!
on the first page I’ve written “Jamie Scott aged 10”
wowza.
bit of light fun, nothing too serious
on the first page I’ve written “Jamie Scott aged 10”
wowza.
bit of light fun, nothing too serious
January 14, 2020
I’ve been trying to find these books for years, but I’ve specifically been looking for this one because it was always my favorite. I’m glad that it’s still held up for me after all these years. ☺️ Nostalgia all the way.
January 3, 2024
C'était bien mais j'ai pas trop été conquise par cette histoire de saut dans le passé ^^ même si elles y rencontrent la fille de leur ancêtre Mélinda Warren. L'histoire dans le présent avec Piper et Prue et le fait qu'elles volent les pouvoirs c'était n'importe quoi ^^
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 20, 2025
I am the biggest fans of charmed and I adore these little extra stories. This was a new one and I loved it! Charmed will forever be my go to tv series and now I’ve found the books they will be a comfort read.
August 8, 2017
Read this book when I was around 12 and loved it. Well, I loved everything with "Charmed" :)
May 23, 2019
Stellenweise sehr brutal, aber alles in allem gut zu lesen.
May 27, 2020
Was in need of a dose of Charmed and this fitted the bill
April 1, 2022
Love charmed
May 4, 2022
A little silly a times, but this was actually quite a strong story considering its length. Also time travel ftw
Read
December 3, 2022Kicsit másra számítottam ettől a könyvtől, de élveztem, hogy Phoebe a múltban barangolt.
July 25, 2023
the story line and execution of this book was a let down.
May 17, 2024
I finally finished reading this! It only took me a MONTH! I liked this one, it was fun at times and slow at others. I think it was cool that they got to meet another ancestor.
June 6, 2024
This one was decent. Phoebe has always been the better character of the 3. This also felt very familiar like I’d seen a tv episode like it or maybe it’s just the tropes it uses.
October 2, 2024
This was so boring, the story starts from nowhere and ends up nowhere, the demon is uninteresting, the time travel meh.
At least the girls were somewhere near their characterisation from the show.
At least the girls were somewhere near their characterisation from the show.
March 15, 2025
An interesting storyline, though very quickly resolved at the end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews