I'm a big fan of the TV show Survivor, having not missed a single episode of the 29 (so far) seasons. Jeff Probst does an excellent job as the show's host. He certainly knows first hand what skills are needed to survive on an island for a number of days, weeks, or months. Skills like being able to find a food and water source, build a fire, and put together a safe and dry shelter. But can he translate that knowledge into an interesting and exciting middle grade adventure novel? I'm not so sure about that one. I'm not even positive how much of this book he even wrote. His co-author is Chris Tebbetts, but even he couldn't save this mess.
The story here is fairly weak and one that has been done before, and done much better. Four kids ages 9-13 are taking a sailing trip around the Hawaiian Islands while their just married parents are on their Hawaiian honeymoon. Two of the kids are the mom's, the other two belong to the dad. The idea is for the kids to bond while on the trip since they don't know each other well and have only recently become family. Early into the trip they are caught in a huge storm and the boat starts taking on water. The captain and first mate inflate the life raft for all of them to jump into and somehow end up inside it without the kids. They soon get taken away by the waves, leaving the four kids on the boat to fend for themselves. The boat ends up crashing on a rocky beach, where the kids spend the rest of the book figuring out how to survive until they are hopefully rescued.
There is very little character development, and what there is paints the kids as four very distinct stereotypes. Not much imagination there. The story is told in third person so I didn't ever feel like I knew any of the characters at all. All the dialogue between them deals with what they're going to do, how they're going to do it, or who knows how to do it best. There's no inner dialogue so I never knew what any of the characters were thinking or what they were feeling. It made them all extremely one dimensional and rather boring. I ended up not really caring about them at all. I know they will all be rescued eventually. The authors are just going to drag it out for two more books before that finally happens. The ending of this one is not a cliff hanger like so many trilogies written for this age group. It was really more of a “to be continued" type ending. So no rush to get them rescued if there's still two more books.
If I want to read an exciting action/adventure story geared toward the middle grades, my go to author will always be Roland Smith. He always writes fabulous stories with fully developed characters. Stories that are full of adventure, danger, and intrigue. Wonderful stories that I have a hard time putting down. Maybe Jeff Probst could learn a few things from him. Or better yet, read the Island trilogy by Gordon Korman, a book that this one has tried, and failed miserably, at copying more than just a few main plot points.
I'm being very generous giving this book 2 stars.