Thanks to NetGalley for a copy of this ebook and this is my freely given opinion.
This continues the story of the spinsters of the Isle of Synne, and in the third story, we are given the story of Seraphina and her past, and it is so very sad, angsty, and emotionally entangled.
Thank goodness for the comedy relief of the potty-mouthed with a Scottish brogue parrot, Phineas.
The story starts in Scotland, 1808, when a young Lady Seraphina, the eldest daughter of an English Earl, has defied him and eloped with the young man she was friends with, then fell in love with, Iain MacInnes. Iain is an orphan who was recently working as a groom in the Earl's stables, but because he caught the eye of Seraphina, he was let go. The Earl has more ambitious plans for Seraphina than for her to wed so beneath her status. But in defiance of her father, Seraphina elopes with Iain, and they have so much love and hope for the future together...
But something obviously goes very awry shortly after. In the present day, over a dozen years after the couples marriage, Iain has made huge climbs in the world and is now wealthy the Duke of Balgair. But obviously, something has happened to separate him and Seraphina.
The two lovers were torn apart soon after their marriage by the schemes and manipulations of the devious and controlling Earl. Iain was under the impression that he, believing that he was a poor commoner, was ultimately not good enough for Seraphina and she had returned to her father who gave her the life she wanted, that Iain was unable to give her. Then he believed that she had died in a carriage accident. In the present day, Iain finds out otherwise when a long-belated letter from an old friend from the Earl's household arrives to inform him that his wife is still alive.
But the wounds from his heartbreak are deep and bitter, and Iain and his remaining relatives are aware of his need to marry and continue the dukedom. However, he is unable to do so if his wife is still alive and so he starts a quest to find the wife who betrayed and left him.
Seraphina, as we know, has been living on Synne with her two younger sisters for years. Her past is a great secret, even from her own sisters. She believes that Iain had betrayed her to her father for payment, when her father found and captured her, making her suffer and trying to break her spirit so she would fall in line with his plans to marry her for his social and political gain. He likewise has the same plans for her two younger sisters. However, knowing just how far her father would go, when she can, she steals her sisters away and lives on the run from him for years. The three of them lived like vagabonds, on the run, in fear of capture for years, before finding safety on Synne. Seraphina is deeply scarred by her past, and still suffers nightmares and fears, and refuses to speak to her sisters of her experiences, wanting to protect them from her past, even as they grew to womenhood. But she is strong and smart, and has built them a home and a business, running the Quayside circulating library and shop, and as the secret author of a popular serial, under the pseudonym S.L Keys.
Her past collides with her present when Iain tracks her down because of her stories. Believing that Seraphina had left him because he was unable to give her the life she had left behind, he hides his wealth and title, and threatens to unravel her secrets, and her safe life for herself and her sisters on Synne, by exposing her past, unless she travels with him to Scotland to dissolve their marriage.
Seraphina is left no choice but to agree, and she (and the foul mouthed fowl that is Phineas) are forced to travel alone with Iain for the long journey away from Synne, to Edinburgh. During that long journey, they are forced to confront the past, and their still deep feelings for each other, and learn the truth about their separation and how they were each played against each other by her father. We come to learn just how much Seraphina suffered at his hands and then what she suffered and sacrificed in order to get her sisters away and care for them, while on the run, proving just how resilient and strong she was.
Unfortunately, Seraphina, when she discovers that Iain is still keeping secrets from her, and how much she has changed from the wealthy pampered aristocrat she was, feels that there is no future for her an Iain, now that he is a part of the Society that she has turned her back on, and despite their new closeness and rediscovered feelings for each other, lets him go, so she can return to Synne and the life she made there.
But not before she has a final confrontation with her evil manipulative father, who lied about her and her sisters death, after ruining her life.
I loved the angsty story line and the long held feelings of Iain and Seraphina - the heights of young love, passion, happiness, the depths of betrayal and heartbreak, and long held bitterness and resentment. Then the ups and downs as they rediscover each other, and work to resolve those past hurts - this story is an emotional roller coaster and like a good cathartic cry. I loved how strong and resilient Seraphina was - even though she took far too much on her own shoulders and kept too many secrets deep down, and did not realize that until the end of her journey. I love that she was given the chance to confront her demons in the form of confronting her father, and coming out the winner; after all the emotional turmoil of her journey with Iain, she needed a win to save her and bolster her confidence and self respect, and I was so happy she got that. Iain had carried so much hurt, not just from Seraphina's supposed betrayal, but also from his childhood. Their journey was healing, not just of their past together, but also of just their pasts in general - a figurative journey out of their past emotional burdens about their families as well as their relationship with each other, in a literal journey. It was fitting that they both, in the end, opened up and unburdened themselves to their families to let go of the hurts and open themselves up to new, hopefully healthier and happier chapters in their relationships. Especially as they ultimately ended their relationship together.
But don't worry... there are ultimately HEAs in the end.
4.5 stars out of 5 - I just wish the abusive father, the Earl, had more of a comeuppance and suffered more for his evil doings. And again, thank goodness for the levity that Phineas provided, because the emotional burdens of Iain and Seraphina was very draining at times.
At the very least, it would have been satisfying, for me anyways, if Phineas pooped on his head or something.