Strangeville
by Kenneth Tingle
I'm very on-the-fence about this book. It was a pleasant enough story, I guess, although I think it went a bit over the mark or the moral aspect. So, here we go. NOTE: spoilers ahead.
The book was very well edited and proofed. The flow of the story was good. The characterizations were okay. There was conflict on multiple levels. There was a final resolution that tied up most loose ends. Because of all of that, and because I didn't totally hate it, I gave it three stars.
However, I didn't really like it. The premise is modern man vs. the stress of modern life, basically. We open with our main character, who was intending to commit suicide but chickened out at the last minute. Then he receives a surprising phone call from his Aunt, who he hasn't seen since his parents were killed when he was young. He's unhappy in his work. He's unhappy in his personal life. In fact, this phone call, and his decision to go visit with his aunt for a week or so is the first positive thing that's happened to him recently. Along the way he has car trouble and wanders the countryside, ending up in a small rural town. The vehicles are all 1950s era; the local TV and radio stations are just that -- all local programming. No other tv or radio reaches the town. The people are all honest, hard-working people who believe in helping out others, but they are completely unaware of modern day life, especially technology. They don't know what a cell phone is, the think "Gone With The Wind" is a new movie, and none of them ever leave the town for anything. It sort of reminded me, in a way, of the 1989 John Travolta movie, "The Experts."
What I was not fond of was the author's overuse of spelling/misspelling in dialogue to represent the town folk as simple, uneducated, and controlled. Just being simple doesn't equate to being dumb, but that was how I felt the inhabitants of Strangeville were depicted. The conflict is, of course, that these people are being controlled by their Mayor and a few of his friends, yet, they don't seem to mind it. They are happy living simple lives that the ruling group provide for them through the sale of coal from the mine that provides the basic source of employment in the area. None of the inhabitants leave the town (which made me wonder about population control, although that subject is never mentioned). The main character struggles with the order he is given to not enlighten the locals with knowledge of the outside world, and with whether he wants to leave the town himself. In the end, he makes the decision to not only keep the secret of technology in the outside areas, but to settle in with people who have become not only his friends, but his family. Nice story? Yes, it does point out that having high stress jobs, modern never-0ut-of-touch technology, and materialistic lifestyles perhaps are not the best way to live a peaceful and meaningful life. However, the general plot seemed maudlin and a bit insulting to the simple way of life. I wasn't sure, after finishing the book, whether the writer believed he was serving up a diatribe against the exhausting and often impersonal modern lifestyle, or if he was telling the story of a guy who couldn't make it in the modern world and needed to step back to a simpler time -- even though that situation was visited on this entire town through lies, deceit, and complete control.
So, some of you will find this modern fairy tale to be charming, I'm sure. Almost a modern day "Brigadoon," without the 1 day every 100 years aspect. I just found it disturbing.