What a sweet little book! I purchased a used copy after I met the author, Syd Blue, at an author's event we were both attending. It didn't seem like *my* type of story, but I teach 7th grade Language Arts, and next quarter we are hosting "STEAM Wars" (STEAM = Science,Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Mathematics). I decided to finally sit down and read Circle to see if it might connect with the STEAM curriculum. And BOY DOES IT EVER. I was really impressed how Syd's knowledge of aircrafts, genetics, and environmental issues shined through in the progression of a fun adventure story.
My favorite part of the novel is the character, Mandy (full name Mandala), the visiting alien. She is ADORABLE. Being the only child on planet Circle, she wears her heart on her sleeve and instantly trusts everyone. Her everyday greeting of "Hi, I love you" made me giggle every single time, not to mention her other nuances, like throwing the dishes out in the backyard, or saying things like "I like this planet, I haven't been murdered once!" I also loved reading about Circle. It was intriguing to imagine a planet that biodegrades organic items super-fast, and the challenges of living in such a place. I also enjoyed imagining the inhabitants of Circle napping on banana hammocks, eating from disposable bone plates, and wearing fingernail-shoes. Syd does a great job of conceptualizing an extraordinary planet without falling back on cliches.
Oh, and the very last line of chapter 31 made me sob like a baby.
My only critique (and this is totally a personal preference thing) is that the novel had an Avatar-vibe that I'm simply growing weary of in books/movies. Thank goodness for the character Angela--she was the one voice in the book that cared deeply about the environment in a way that didn't villain-ize the human species.
This was a very slight blip in an overly awesome radar though, and I look forward to reading this book with my seventh graders.