Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Secret Gardener

Rate this book
‘Maruti took a newspaper package from his khaki satchel and handed it to Lalli . . . There was a wad of silky fluff inside. Nestled preciously in it, something glinted slyly like a jewel. It was one perfect fingernail, painted pink.’
24 Patwardhan Cross. The solitary bone that surfaces in the garden there doesn’t mean much to police surgeon Dr Q or Inspector Savio. But Lalli, who collects curiosities, finds it curious. Things get curiouser when a dying gigolo whispers the address in terror, and curiouser still when a mummified finger with a chic manicure turns up in the same garden.
Lalli might have ignored these curiosities had there not been a child at the heart of the matter . . .
As she investigates what makes this garden grow, Lalli uncovers a gruesome tale.

250 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 1, 2013

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kalpana Swaminathan

38 books19 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1 (5%)
4 stars
6 (35%)
3 stars
5 (29%)
2 stars
5 (29%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
Profile Image for Riju Ganguly.
Author 46 books1,957 followers
January 28, 2019
It's an established fact that most crimes in our society don't come up to the surface. Rather most victims simply lie in the perpetual darkness of shame, self-hate, agony, and slow-burning anger. The circle of pain expands, and there is no closure until death happens.
This novel is about such crimes. Appropriately enough, they come out as a result of diggings, not metaphorical, but actual.
All these are good. But the process got so long drawn that I got confused as to whether I am reading a crime novel or a very well written piece containing observations on social life etc.
I would stick to the short stories featuring last resort Lalli henceforth.
59 reviews
August 31, 2026
Good plot, but painfully average storytelling. Too many characters, very little depth, and I never really warmed to the overly confident Lalli or the rather passive Sita. The mystery itself was interesting, but too many things were left unexplained, especially the “why” behind everything. I dragged myself to the end only because a friend recommended it — definitely not picking up another book by this author.
Author 43 books59 followers
May 16, 2019
This is the first book by this author I've read, and overall I enjoyed it. The plot is complicated and at times confusing, even with the set of interlocking explanations near the end. Still, I admire the author's ability to build a complex plot and create some interesting characters, Dr. Q especially.
Profile Image for Dibyajyoti Sarma.
Author 8 books10 followers
August 13, 2014
I had the book with me for a long time. I even tried to read it once. But couldn’t just enter into the world of Sita and her ageing aunt, Lalli, the famous Tamil detective in Mumbai, and her ragtag group of allies, policemen Savio and Shukla and police doctor Q. I had not read the first two books, part of an apparent series.

Then yesterday, I picked up the book again, read the first few pages and I was on. Literally. By midnight, I was halfway through and I could not stop. I had a faint idea who may be the perpetrators of the crime, and I had to finish the book. I did. And now, I am a fan of Kalpana Swaminathan.

This is a detective novel, and I am sure the book will disappoint many for not being ‘detective’ enough. There are plot holes. There are co-incidents (even the major turning point of the novel, of Jai finding his way to Lalli’s house is a co-incidence) and there are not enough action.

But then, this is not just a detective novel, it’s an Indian detective novel. Now, this is important. Especially, Swaminathan considers it important. She takes the model of a classic detective tale (complete with the final ‘parlour scene’ where the detective unravels the mysteries), and makes it very Indian. In the parlour scene for example, they have a South Indian dessert, which is described with delectable detail. Even her images are Indian. And she is not just interested in the crime and the criminal, she is interested in other things, marital rape, for instance, or child welfare, or horticulture, or food. And her comic timing is seriously judicious. She does it sparingly, but with such panache, I was smiling.

Since this is a detective novel, I cannot give away the plot, but I can only tell my friends, fans of the detective novels of a certain JK Rowling, please, please, read The Secret Gardener.
Profile Image for The Hissing .
42 reviews5 followers
January 13, 2014
Actually in two minds about this book. I like the authors writing style and her way with words. It's the detective part of the book that I had a major problem with. This could have been a great detective novel but somehow the lack of tension in the narrative dulls the whole experience. Like I said the language and writing is great but the story unfolds in what I felt was a rather lackadaisical manner.
84 reviews23 followers
March 5, 2013
started slow,ended at breakneck speed.The plot seems unlikely,very unlike the author's other books which are very smartly written and are clever.am slightly disappointed but am eagerly waiting for the next Lalli book.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews