I want to be fair. It's an interesting story, told from the POV of a young man who was (for want of a better word) zombified at age 14, some time after the fact. In this imagining, the dead "freeze" in winter and are relatively harmless to the living, so our protagonist, Adam, has a lot of time on his hands to think and reminisce.
To put it bluntly, Adam's life sucked from the moment he was conscious of it. He was born into a world that had already fallen. His parents, sticking mostly to the mountains around the I-25 corridor in north-east Colorado, largely steered clear of other people, moving between a cabin and a cave depending on the seasons, making do with the most meagre of rations. They named their son Adam - a name with possible biblical significance, but perhaps not - and his life is one of privation, isolation, and physical abuse. Adam's options are rather bleak: death by zombie, or death by "tough love." Eventually, his mother escapes with him to an encampment of survivors they learn of near Colorado Springs.
By the time Adam arrives, he's close to 14 years old and not used to being around others. His only male role model was his abusive father, and his mother was not exactly his protector, and in the new environment he's largely left to fend for himself. He starts to get some friends, and someone to care about, though these concepts are alien to him; he acquires an enemy in short order, which comes a bit more naturally, and quickly learns how much he had learned from his father...and how fortunate his father likely was to have stayed behind. He learns that frontier justice can be swift, comprehensive, and vicious.
I won't give it all away. The book it titled Winter, and has chapters listing various seasons. The child ages in the course of about a year, and his experiences show an evolution from childhood to - if not puberty, the start of maturity. He discovers girls, and his first kiss. He learns to stand up for himself. He leaves his home - twice. He asks some big questions. And when he's bitten, he makes the choice to ride it out, to see what he becomes; he yearns to understand what lies beyond the dead eyes and snapping jaws.
Pros: I read the whole thing. That's not always a given these days. It reminded me a little of WARM BODIES by Isaac Marion, which I quite enjoyed. (The movie was fun; the book was darker and more serious but also excellent.)
Cons: I'll say this as compassionately as I can: the editing sucked. As in, I question whether an editor even touched the manuscript, or if the author bothered to do a second draft. There are too many basic grammar errors and clunky phrases to count. Unpolished is putting it mildly. The writing kept pulling me out of the story, and I worry that I missed some key pieces of thought the author wants the book to convey because of the sloppiness of the writing. I can tell he's aiming for profound ideas. Those ideas deserve a clear presentation.
I tend to be hard on books with interesting stories but bad editing because THEY WEE SO CLOSE TO GREATNESS. A book that's well edited but boring is just meh. A story that's compelling, AND doesn't get in its own way, is something truly special. I found many of the scenes in Winter interesting, but I was missing the thread that wove them together. I see pieces there that would have worked marvelously, but the completed puzzle remains a mystery.
The ending is ambiguous. If there is a sequel, I'd give it a chance. As it is, I end this one feeling mostly frustration and more questions than insights. And while I am often frustrated by Orson Scott Card's inability to let certain of his stories go - how many times has he rewritten Ender's Game? - in this case I wouldn't mind seeing the author take a crack at a revised and updated version of the story.