2.5 stars rounded down. On a remote Scottish island, a Christian cult believes that their founder (Malachi Dove) has lost his mind and is in league with the devil, having gone so far as to conjure a demon as a help-mate. Journalist Joe Oakes is called in to write a feature on the island exposing Dove...and all hell breaks loose.
That's the great premise of "Pig Island'. Unfortunately, it's also where the greatness ends.
Here's the rest of it: Okay writing. Characters about as gripping as a bag of stale popcorn. Tension that flat-lines through most of the book...and you can guess the final twist at around the midway point. Some graphic descriptions of corpses that fail to engender pity or any emotion other than that's nasty .
Themes: cults, belief in the supernatural, does evil really exist?, revenge, physical & mental abnormalities, journalism, erotic attachments, erotomania.
This is the first Hayder I've been able to finish. I DNFed both "Poppet" and "Ritual" after about 100 pages due to the utter lack of any tension build-up and the (largely) flat characters, even though both books were touted as scary thrillers (no-scare, no-thrill scary thrillers apparently).
"Pig Island" suffers from the same problem, but the subject matter and the fact that I'd never actually finished one of hers, kept me going.
Here's something hardly any other review has mentioned:
Some readers have been rather put off by the erotic feelings Joe Oakes has for a woman with a parasitic limb. But that's rather tame and cursorily handled in comparison to Joe's wife, Lexie's, in-your-face erotomania. (Erotomania: a woman becoming convinced that a highly skilled man with a socially prestigious job, usually a specialist doctor/lawyer, is madly in love with her -- he just can't show his true feelings due to XYZ.) That's exploited for all it's worth and doesn't fit the distanced, 'watching from across the room' narrative voice of Oakes, which makes it feel like bleach thrown into a scummy, stagnant pond for effect. Erotomania is a real, if rare, delusional condition.
Both Joe and Lexie are abnormal in many ways. Just as abnormal as Dove and his daughter, who are presented as freaks.
And that's perhaps where the problem with "Pig Island" is to be found: all the main characters are cracked. Nobody is totally sane and Hayder doesn't do a very good job of demonstrating that, as the use of 1st person for the tale automatically drives a lot of that very important insight underground.
We'd need to see these characters from the outside, in 3rd person, rather like we see Angeline or the police officers from the outside, for their abnormalities to really stand out and make an impression. As it is, it's way too subtle and many readers who read for plot and not detail will utterly miss it.
Due to this authorial mistake, the entire idea melts into a soft goo rather quickly that feels about 200 pages too long. And the little thread of smoke at the end is a major cop-out.
I'm giving this one the dead average of 2.5 as that's pretty much what it is. It's not bad enough for the Tree-Murder shelf. It's just an average novel that missed its mark.