When the cover said a young superman graphic novel, I was not aware of just how young the story would be. Very quickly I realized I am not the target audience, which I can usually respect and still enjoy, but this was too juvenile for me.
This rendition of Clark Kent was so irritating; it painted him as arrogant, entitled and a downright brat. The story starts during a middle school football game, (the score is 55-0…seriously?) and Clark is a showoff and wants to use his power. In an interview after the game he says, “I’m the best player in the state and deserve this victory.” This is a different vibe than what we know of Clark Kent, and while I love different interpretations, this one was over the top and hard to get on board with. Some other examples of his dialogue: “Why do I have to hide all the time? I don’t want to act like I’m boring and normal,” “Name something I haven’t won lately.”
He is an annoying, arrogant kid that doesn’t want to hide that he’s special. It clashes a lot with the Superman everyone knows and loves, and while there isn’t as much material on Clark’s every day childhood, it is hard to introduce qualities and personalty traits that are so different than what we are used to, especially with a character as widely popular as Superman. This entire volume is Clark being overconfident and naive, overusing his powers and making mistakes typical for a kid his age, with much bigger repercussions.
And then there’s Lex. His character started off promising and then it seemed there was a time jump in his progression. He all the sudden was firmly on the “bad guy” path with such minimal development. Not to mention suddenly bald with zero explanation.
Plot aside, I like the art style in this edition. It is different than traditional superhero graphic novels, it has a more modern pop-art style that suits the younger demographic it is targeted for.
I was really excited for the concept of this volume, a young Clark Kent and Lex Luthor, how they meet, how their relationship progresses, but this just fell very flat.
~Thank you to DC Entertainment and NetGalley for the digital ARC.