What do you think?
Rate this book


176 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1976
For the most part, the drawings remind me of the "dramatic" style cartoons that used to be in the newspapers, Dick Tracy, Prince Valiant, those kinds, which is not necessarily a bad thing, and suits the tone of the story. However... well, the best word I can think to describe the book entirely, is "sloppy". A lot of the text has obvious incorrect wording (weak editing) and the horseperson in me takes offense when the text mentions the horses "trotting" and the pictures obviously show them cantering (lack of knowledge). If this sort of thing had happened once, I may have convinced myself to get over it, but it is frequent and through the entire graphic novel and when you make mistakes in both your pictures and your text, you can't say you have a quality graphic novel.
Style-wise, though the "dramatic" cartoon style worked, I would have liked a story with color (Black Beauty's world is dark enough without all being in black and white). The edits to the story, shortening a lot of the harsher times I didn't have a problem with, as their full awfulness is still felt, just less dwelt upon.
Content notes: Swearing is mentioned as happening, but is not written out. No sensuality issues. Several instances of animal abuse or carelessness, occasionally with the animal reacting violently and injuries or deaths to both people and animals is shown as the result.