Sorry but truly, Gail Gibbons’ 1995 non fiction picture book The Reasons for Seasons for me and in my opinion leaves rather a bit to be both textually and also visually and illustratively desired.
For yes indeed, while Gibbons’ presented narrative for The Reasons for Seasons certainly strives to be informative, is verbally dense and as such of course most suitable for older children above the age of at least nine or so (mostly due to some rather sophisticated vocabulary being used), there are also some rather problematic informational gaps to be found within the text (such as for example Gail Gibbons mentioning in the section on spring that only birds and whales migrate, even though there are actually very many species of migrating animals, and that in The Reasons for Seasons animal migration thus seems to focus only on birds and whales in the spring part and then on just birds once again in the autumn section, well, I do find this informationally lacking, even factually false), and not to mention that the lack of an included bibliography with suggestions for further reading is a huge issue for me and especially so since The Reasons for Seasons is clearly meant for education and enlightenment purposes (to be used by older children, by teachers and parents) and that therefore a bibliography should be an absolute must and there not being one included by Gail Gibbons really does majorly lessen the teaching and the supplemental research value of The Reasons for Seasons).
And combined with the fact that the majority of the accompanying artwork feels too cutesy for Gail Gibbons’ printed words (and would with its bright cartoon like images be more suitable for a picture book geared towards much younger children), I really have not found Gibbons’ combination of text and images all that successful with regard to The Reasons for Seasons and thus only a two star ranking, a high two star ranking to be sure, but the lack of a bibliography for The Reasons for Seasons and that I aesthetically just do not think the illustrations mirror the narrative at all well, this certainly prevents me from upping my rating to three stars.