What do you think?
Rate this book


448 pages, Hardcover
First published April 30, 2024
"Pretty, nice, Maddie Price. Missing. Kidnapped. Dead."
"Please know I say this with the utmost compassion, but you need a therapist, like holy crap."
"This is the trouble with girls like me, we don't stop, don't listen, don't shut up, don't say the right thing, don't say anything when it matter most. And we run, always from something, never towards anything."
"Maybe this can’t happen right now, but if I have to choose between it or you, I choose you everytime."
"No, two letters, one complete sentence."
"I dont think it's Maddy you miss, I think you miss you."
Not Like Other Girls (Bloomsbury, 2024) is the promising debut young adult novel by Meredith Adamo. Because so much contemporary YA writing seems to have a check-the-box, formulaic approach, I’m always looking for what makes a book different, what is has that I’ve not seen before. Not Like Other Girls includes a few well-traveled YA tropes–a missing girl, a fake relationship, scholarship-driven academic cheating–but Adamo’s main character Jo-Lynn is a fresh take.
Let’s start with her name. Jo-Lynn is called Jo, JoLynn, JoJo, Jo-Hyphen-Lynn, and a few other variations. This might not seem that important, but on some level it symbolizes her shifting identity–how she is seen by others and herself. People say she is “trouble,” “wild,” “reckless,” “not like other girls,” not to mention “easy” and a “slut.” Did the problem with her reputation start when Cody forwarded nude pictures of her to everyone at a party, or was that just the explosion from a fuse lit even earlier? I can’t say much more about that because part of this book’s importance is how Jo-Lynn unravels and faces the events that affected her.
Is Jo-Lynn bothered by her reputation? To a certain extent, yes, but she also doesn’t shy away from perpetuating it, and that’s what makes Jo-Lynn such a fascinatingly complex and maybe even inspirational character. She is smart, witty, vulnerable, brave, funny, brash, and in some ways her own worst enemy. Her family and schoolmates are all absorbed in their own agendas, leaving Jo-Lynn to figure things out on her own, but sometimes it’s just easier not to.
Things change though when her former best friend Maddie disappears. While I think the character of Jo-Lynn is the book’s strongest aspect, the plot is also compelling. Did Maddie run away, or was foul play involved? As in any good mystery, there is no shortage of suspects and motives. Maddie and Jo-Lynn are in a social group of academic achievers, and nobody knows how to get themselves in really interesting trouble like smart kids.
Not Like Other Girls includes a few sexually-charged scenes, but none of them are gratuitous. Adamo presents these moments in ways that lead readers to consider if they are instances of consensual romance or sexual violence. This is more clear in some places than others, and that’s one of the book’s valuable contributions to young adult literature.
Meredith Adamo’s Not Like Other Girls is for readers who like realistic fiction but who can maturely process issues of sexuality and promiscuity. Recommend this to those who want more books like Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson, The Agathas by Kathleen Glasgow and Liz Lawson, I Kissed Shara Wheeler by Casey McQuiston, or All the Fighting Parts by Hannah V. Sawyerr.
This review is also posted on my What's Not Wrong? blog in slightly different form.