Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
They say the line that separates love from hate is thin. So thin in fact that the two almost coexist. Almost.

It’s also been said that when a dude is a jerk to a girl, it’s because, deep down, he wants her. I’m calling bullshit on all of it.

Tate Tracy is about to find out that I’m not the nice boy anymore. Nor am I a forgiving person. She might have been my best friend for eighteen years, but now, she’s no one. And if I have to remind her of that, I will. Even if we’re going to be stuck living in an apartment … together.

The trouble is, I’ve only ever had one weakness in life.

And it’s Tate Tracy.

229 pages, Paperback

Published June 8, 2023

997 people are currently reading
6014 people want to read

About the author

Hannah Gray

33 books1,449 followers
Hannah Gray spends her days in vacationland, living in a small, quaint town on the coast of Maine. She is an avid reader of contemporary romance and is always in competition with herself to read more books every year.

During the day, she loves on her three perfect-to-her daughters and tries to be the best mom she can be. But once she tucks them in at night--okay, scratch that. Once they fall asleep next to her in her bed--because their bedrooms apparently have monsters in them--she dives into her own fantasy world, staying awake well into the late-night hours, typing away stories about her characters. As much as she loves being a wife and mom--and she certainly does love it--reading and writing are her outlet, giving her a place to travel far away while still physically being with her family.

She married her better half in 2013, and he's been putting up with her craziness every day since. As her anchor, he's her one constant in this insane, forever-changing world.

Facbook Page: https://www.facebook.com/hannahgrayau...
Twitter: @AuthorHannahGr1
IG: @authorhannah_gray

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2,004 (33%)
4 stars
2,301 (38%)
3 stars
1,285 (21%)
2 stars
296 (4%)
1 star
109 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 464 reviews
Profile Image for Saskia M.
30 reviews1 follower
November 9, 2023
I normally love a silly little romance book but this one was TOUGH.

It’s giving “I’m not like other girls, I barely wear any makeup, I like space & science and stuff.” “Pick me,choose me, love me”.

I need my girl to have more self respect than that. This boy treated you like absolute garbage, called you so so many names, and basically harassed you. All because his mom died and you dipped out for college???? The bar feels like it has reached a new level of hell and I can’t do it.

Updating this review because whoever is giving this books 4 or 5 starts: ARE YOU OKAY???
Profile Image for Chloe.
303 reviews
July 20, 2023
there was just something inherently unlikeable about this whole book idk
Profile Image for Haily Volk.
441 reviews120 followers
August 22, 2023
4/5⭐️
3/5 🌶️

Tropes:
- Hockey Romance
- Forced Proximity
- Childhood Friends to Enemies to Lovers
- It’s always been you

Hannah girl did you put crack into these books because I’m addicted! It’s so hard to put this series down! I’m not a huge fan of friends to lovers trope but Link and Tate’s story was beautiful. You also threw in some enemies to lovers and I loved it.

Broken boy was the perfect title for this book because that was link. He was broken. He lost his mom and his best-friend all at once. My heart broke for him. However, I do think he was hard on Tate at times for her choices but he was having a hard time trusting her again. His character development is everything and that ending melted my heart.

Cam still has my heart but here comes Brody and I have a feeling that book is going to be GOOD. Brody has been catching my eye in the last two books so I cannot wait to jump into it.
Profile Image for Alex.
568 reviews23 followers
September 30, 2023
No woman should ever fall to her knees and beg the man to love her back.

This pretty much sums up my feelings.

Also he slept before her with many girls and after her, so wtf???
And yes, he was her first one and no one else reached his holiness.
Give me a break.....
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Crazyangel.
30 reviews9 followers
June 23, 2023
Childhood friends to lovers, Yes!! But really Tate & her mom really weak & doormat women……

Tate had such potential but com’on why is the heroine always the one to remain faithful & only one sexual partner while Linc was being a hoe all during high school & college
Profile Image for ᴀᴅᴇʟᴀ.
277 reviews6 followers
August 21, 2024
~unedited~

I hate you Link Stern, you do not deserve my bby Tate. I’m sick and tired of authors writing women as weak, Link mistreated Tate and she still waited for him and didn’t date anyone else while was out fucking everyone at Brooks. I love HEA’s in books, but Link was so terrible that I desperately wanted Tate to grow a back bone and leave his ungrateful ass behind. Hunter and Cam WOULD HAVE NEVER treated any girl like Link did.

Lets just go ahead and throw it out there that he shoved a girl in Tate’s face by taking her back to their apartment and planned to have sex with her in the next room. Then, he proceeds to get mad at Brody for comforting her? I also thought it was really fucked up that Link would constantly barge into her room while she was naked and degrade her and not in the fun way. Oh, he also told her that he slept with half of the campus but it didn’t count because each time he did, he closed his eyes and pictured her 🥺. Like you’re fucking with me, right? And when Tate FINALLY was ready to move on and go party, the author pulled the Oliver-r*pist storyline out of her ass just to paint Link as the hero. This plot wasn’t even romantic it was borderline horrific, sexual assault shouldn’t be romanticized.

Apart from the fact that the men in this book aren’t shit (save Brody, Cam, and Hunter), there was no conflict solved. Tate’s deadbeat dad got his happy ending with his other family and Link’s absent father came out of the woodworks out of nowhere in the very last chapter to finally support his son.

Yeah sure, Tate fucked up when she left but her reasons behind her decision are so valid and you would think that her own best friend would try to understand or AT LEAST let her explain.

I am so pissed that they ended up together because I really feel like she deserved better than him, or she should’ve at least let him grovel A LOT.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Jamie Engel.
616 reviews247 followers
June 12, 2023
Although this is the second book in The Puck Boys series, you can easily read this book as a standalone, though you will get minor spoilers from the previous book.

This story follows Link and Tate. They were best friends for most of their lives, but after high school graduation, Tate left for Boston without letting anyone know. It left Link heartbroken and angry. Years later Tate finds herself in an awkward situation and ends up having to room with Link and his roommates. Link is still holding a grudge and tries to make it unbearable for Tate.

Let’s start with Link. I didn’t think I would be able to love any more than Cam but I am totally and utterly obsessed with Link. He is broody, angry and my heart broke for him. He definitely is not one to forgive and forget, but even when he was being not-so-nice, I still couldn't resist him. The little thoughtful things he would secretly do for Tate…SWOON I found myself getting so angry on Tate’s behalf throughout the story. I loved their connection and their story. I could not get enough of these two.

Tropes:
Sports Romance
Second Chance
Forced Proximity
Roommates
Enemies to Lovers

Overall: 5
Spice 3

Thank you to WordSmith Publicity and Hannah Gray for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Giota (the reader).
983 reviews193 followers
January 4, 2024
HOLY MOTHER OF ALL THINGS ANGSTY 🙀😱.
I never thought Link would turn out like this but MAN was he mean to Tate! He was deeply hurt by the only girl he ever loved, so he lashed out and BOI wasn’t it pretty!
But I get it, what Tate did, how she dropped him in the worst moment of his life because she was scared? Not cool girl, but it also broke my heart when after 3 years, Link verbally attacks her upon seeing her!
I get that this story might not be for everyone but it CERTAINLY was for me!
If you like:
✨childhood best friends to lovers to enemies to lovers (yup)
🖤it’s always been you
✨forced proximity
🖤I hate you but you’re mine
✨protective MMC
🖤college hockey romance

then this is for you! It’s intense and I LOVED it!
Profile Image for Brittany Vezer.
376 reviews30 followers
May 1, 2025
Link being the broken boy couldn’t have been a more perfect title. He was so broken.

The childhood friends to enemies to lovers plot is always so tough because you go THROUGH it with them. And go THROUGH it you did with Link & Tate.

I really enjoyed this and am excited to read more of the series.
Profile Image for Christina Sturgill.
1,602 reviews107 followers
January 5, 2026
Rating: 4.5/5 🌟
Spice: 3/5 🌶️
Characters: Link Sterns and Tate Tracy

This book made me cry right off the bat. It starts out with Link losing his mother to cancer and his best friend (Tate) moving away. He faces so much loss all at once so it's not a surprise that he's become a bit jaded and has some anger and resentment festering.

This is a friends to lovers turned enemies to lovers. Tate moves back and starts attending the same college. By a twist of luck, she also ends up being roomed in the same house and Link and Brody. These two really go through it and their HEA is hard won. My heart hurt for Link so much and I completely understood why he had such a hard time letting Tate back in. I liked Tate but she was frustrating. She had issues of her own that lead her to some (in my opinion) irrational choices that just ended up hurting them both. It was raw, human, real and that's one of the reasons I loved this story so much. Human's don't always make rational decisions. Sometimes we do things based off of emotions and one of the strongest emotions is fear. It can be the driving force for a lot of our choices and things we do in life. Tate was acting on that.

I am devouring this series and cannot get enough. I am so excited to read Brody's story!
Profile Image for Whispered Secrets.
669 reviews22 followers
June 8, 2023
Tate and Link are magic. Their love and connection is what dreams are made of. It’s what you would call a real fairytale. They fell in love as children. Lost their way then as young college students they are thrown together one despises the other one, one regrets leaving the other. Yet they are both so helplessly in love with each other. They fight it as long as they can then just when you think it’s all going to be okay and love overcomes all…something happens that truly breaks them. Breaks them apart from each other and breaks them in general. Can they fight their way back to each other or is it really and truly over for good this time?
Hannah drags you through the mud then lifts you to the heavens with this read. One min your as high as a kite then next you drowning in your own tears. It’s a real rollercoaster ride so if you like those kinds of books then…you don’t want to miss this one.
Profile Image for ceci.
363 reviews53 followers
December 21, 2023
I loved this book so much, it has some of my favourite tropes like:
- childhood friends to enemies to lovers.
- hockey romance.
- it´s always been you.

This book follows Tate and Link, they were best friends until Tate left without telling anyone.
In this book we see how they react when they find each other some time later. They broke me and they put me back together, i loved them so much.
Profile Image for Jax♡.
290 reviews8 followers
June 21, 2023
Wasn't my favourite and the story in general was kind of lacking. This was definitely an easy read.
Profile Image for Nicole  D'cruz (kiwinikilovesreading).
459 reviews27 followers
June 14, 2023
**ARC REVIEW**
OMG why have I not read a Hannah Gray book till now!!! I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!

This is book #2 in the "The Puck Boys of Brooks University series" but can be read as a stand-alone. (p.s. I already know I want to read book one!).

If you love these tropes, you are going to love this book!
🏒Sports Romance (Ice Hockey)
🏒Second Chance
🏒Forced Proximity
🏒Roommates
🏒Enemies to Lovers

Both Tate and Link have been best friends and inseparable since Tate moved into the house next door to Link and his family. Tate loves Link but she can't be with him as Link is an aspiring hockey player and she did not want to end up hurt and in a toxic relationship like her mum and dad. Her dad chose his hockey career and the celebrity status over his family. What an a$$hole!

She decides that she is going to Boston after graduation but she wants one night with Link.

One night to pretend she was his and he was hers.

Link on the other hand declares his love for her and even thought he knows it's a bad idea, he still spends the night with her.

Everything changes when he wakes up and finds that she has left without even saying goodbye. Link is broken and filled with so much hate for Tate. She didn't even come back to attend his mum's funeral when he needed her the most.

Now a year later, Tate finds herself going to Brooks University to get a degree in aerospace engineering. She ends up moving into an apartment with two hockey players due to her initial living arrangements falling through. Tate's life is about to get worse when one of the hockey players she will be living with is Link and now she has to live in the room across from his.

Link is so cruel to Tate as soon as he could say anything to her but we all know he is doing this to hurt her as badly as she hurt him. They keep trying to avoid each other in the beginning but that can only last for so long........

Broken Boy was such a beautifully written book that had me laughing and crying and I didn't want to stop reading! I loved that even though Link pretended to hate her, he would still do the sweetest things for her and pretend it was Brody (the other flatmate, aka who gives her the nickname Tater-Tot) who was doing it.

I hope the next book is Brody's story because I loved his personality in this book!!

My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (I would give it a million stars if I could)
Spicy rating: 🔥🔥🔥🔥

If you love a hockey romance, make sure it add this beauty to your TBR!!!

Thank you to Hannah and Wordsmith Publicity for kindly sending me this ARC. This review is my own honest opinion on the book!!
Profile Image for Travelogged Blogs.
1,572 reviews131 followers
June 17, 2023
“I could be surrounded by a sea of people, all chanting my name, and I’d still look for her.” My heart aches. “Every. Single. Time.”

Once upon a time Tate & Link were bestfriends but ever since Tate left without saying goodbye, when Link was going through something difficult and needed her the most, he hated her. While I liked Link, I couldn't say the same about Tate. She was so confused and on one hand, she said she'll never date hockey players while on the other, she wished to be more than friends with Link. She couldn't make up her mind and I just felt frustrated by her thoughts. Link's character progression was very good and I could actually connect with him. Though the third act breakup in the end could've been avoided, I still enjoyed reading the book. Overall it was a 3.5 star read for me
Profile Image for BettyLovesBooks.
447 reviews18 followers
April 14, 2026
2.75 stars. Just ok hockey romance, with misunderstanding and angst galore as childhood best mates and youthful lovers finally get their second chance. It had heart, but a fair bit of repetition and predictability, combined with a lack of depth, limited this from attaining the bar set by Chelsea Curto and Elle Kennedy.

I did love this quote from a pivotal moment though:

“I said some things.” I cringe. “I don’t know if she even wants me anymore.” “If you plan on being together forever, you’re gonna say a helluva lot more things that’ll piss her off.” He chuckles. “I promise you that. But it doesn’t matter what tears you apart in those moments of anger and frustration. It matters that you go back and fix it.”
Profile Image for Kylie.
727 reviews1,379 followers
July 30, 2023
4.75/5 ⭐️
2.5/5 🌶️

I’m emotional, let me come back to this review.
Profile Image for Megan Coggins.
737 reviews168 followers
January 17, 2024
Childhood best friends to enemies to lovers ⭐️
Hockey
Second chance
“Nerdy” girl
Forced proximity

Link x Tate = cute

No major icks
This series is 🔥
Profile Image for Jenn.
100 reviews4 followers
June 7, 2023
This is my first novel by Hannah Gray, and most certainly will NOT be my last!

First off…Hannah had such a way of inserting everyday sayings, songs and humor into her writing. From McDonalds fountain Diet Cokes, to songs by Morgan Wallen, to the ole saying “Does a bear $&@! in the woods”. Very refreshing!

Now for the review…

Meet Link, oh complicated treat buying Link, he tragically lost his mom to illness, and as a result lost the dad he once had as he shut out the world. Link poured his heart into hockey and Tate, his best friend. But after years of denying his love for her, he finally confessed. Only to find Tate leaving at a time when he needed her the most.

As a result, he vowed to never forgive Tate….

Now meet Tate, aka Tater tot, estranged daughter to a NHL legend who left his family in shambles. Tate constantly is confronting childhood demons while trying to remain focused while studying to be an aerospace engineer. She captured Link’s heart at a young age and at first sight

Tate made a promise to herself, NOT to date sports players. To avoid enduring unwanted fame and disruption that once plagued her family. But Link is like no other. Her best friend, the guy that always saved her and her one and only love.

The book starts off with finding their way back via forced proximity, sharing an apartment. What can go wrong?! Ha !

These two battle the line of love and hate throughout. You as a reader will endure laugh out loud bantering, steamy sessions, angsty angst, swoony side characters and a slew of miscommunications and untimely misfortunes.

BUT, you get an HEA and in my opinion a beautiful epilogue.

!Check trigger warnings!

Favorite quote: “Tate, I’ve only had two loves in my life. Hockey and you. But I’d walk away from the game right now if it meant you were mine forever.”

Xo, Jenn
Profile Image for Kirsten | Bookish.kir.
720 reviews341 followers
June 7, 2023
- hockey
- best friends to frenemies to lovers
- forced prox
- “won’t date athletes”

When Tate moved in next door to Link they instantly became inseparable best friends. But one night, feelings are confessed and they blur the line of friendship and while one thought it was the beginning of something amazing, the other saw it as a chance to say goodbye. Link woke up the next morning to Tate being gone. She left for Boston earlier than planned without so much as a goodbye. And to make the day even worse…Link learned that his mother’s cancer had returned, and she was dying. Fast forward 3 years, Tate transfers to Brooks University, but Link is not willing to forgive and forget.

Well Hannah Gray, you’ve done it again. I loved this book so much. The characters, the plot, the angst, the spice…fabulous! Plus getting peeks of my boyfriend Cam Hardy was a nice bonus! I really felt for both Link and Tate. They each had been through some tough experiences growing up, with Link’s mom’s cancer and Tate’s dad being well Tate’s dad. I understood the anger behind Link’s actions and his POV showed just how much he was struggling with the fact that he still really cared for Tate despite everything, and it just broke my heart. I also sympathized with Tate and her not being comfortable in the limelight. Overall I really enjoyed this story and will recommend it to anyone who is looking for a hockey, best friends to frenemies to lovers romance!

So far this series and these characters are phenomenal, and I am beyond excited for Brody’s book!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
🔥🔥
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Kristina Maysonet.
1,860 reviews36 followers
June 7, 2023
Broken Boy is book 2 in The Puck Boys of Brooks University series. It can be read as a standalone but is best to read in order to get the whole world building. 


This is Tate and Link's second chance at love. They were best friends for most of their lives. Tate has an AWFUL father that has made her swear off athletes and of course Link's goal is to make it to the NHL. One Night together sent Tate running. Link was left heartbroken and angry. Years later Tate finds herself in an awkward situation having to room with Link and his roommates. Link is still angry and is straight up rude to Tate. I get that he was hurt but the level of rudeness from Link stopped him from being a book boyfriend BUT I still loved the story. 


There is a lot to be revealed in this book. Tate has a lot of family drama to deal with and my heart just breaks for her. I wanted nothing more than for her to tell her father off! When Link starts to be there for Tate during this, they have a shift in their relationship. But there is something that is still bound to keep them apart. 


I absolutely loved this enemies to lovers second chance. It was an emotional ride and already know it will be a favorite this month.
Profile Image for Chris ˚₊· ͟͟͞͞➳❥.
523 reviews29 followers
September 29, 2023
4⭐️ Soo good! I’m in my sports era right now and I am constantly looking for new books by new authors…so having never read a book by Hannah Gray before, I was a bit apprehensive.
Was it perfect? No!! But me personally, I’m willing to overlook details that I dislike in a book if it’s angsty enough and if I can really feel the longing and tension between the main characters! Which was the case here!


What I liked:

* the friends to enemies to lovers trope
* the chemistry between Tate & Link, they really felt like soulmates
* I loved how angsty it was, agh the longing between those two🙌🏻
* the protective side of Link and how his love language was acts of service
* the side characters
* I liked how Link confronted Tate almost immediately about why she left him the way she did. In most books, when the main characters are separated for a very long time due to various reasons…the hero or heroine (depends on who was hurt/wronged/“betrayed”) avoids talking about the elephant in the room. Well not in this book, my friends! He went ballistic!😂



Now for the things that weren’t so great:

* the beginning was a bit difficult to read. Maybe because Link was a bit of a jerk to Tate, even though his behavior was justified and understandable in that situation. He began to soften towards Tate around 50% and from that point on, he was amazing!
* I would have loved to see a couple more romantic scenes where they were together. Because for the first half of the book they were constantly fighting and in the second half we did get some scenes but they felt a bit rushed and then there was the thirt act scene….so yeaah…
* I was a bit annoyed by how Tate simply ghosted him with only an email as goodbye. But in the end, you could really see how much she regretted taking that decision and she redeemed herself.

So yeah, this was my first Hannah Gray book, but it certainly won’t be my last!

Ps: English is not my first language, so I’m sorry for any grammatical errors
Profile Image for Tammy - .
1,128 reviews143 followers
June 3, 2023
If I have one weakness when it comes to fictional heroes, it's a broken boy with a dirty mouth and a chip on his shoulder, and this Broken Boy has all of that and more.

Link and Tate were once best friends, but all that has changed. It doesn't matter that Tate is now Link's new roommate, living just across the hall. He is determined to show her that he's not forgiving and that he's no longer the nice boy that she once knew. There is a very thin line between love and hate though and Link soon finds himself walking along that line.

Now, let me start with Link. From the very beginning of this story, my heart broke for this boy even when he was broody and angry. He definitely is not one to forgive and forget, but even when he was being not-so-nice, I still couldn't resist him. I loved Tate from the beginning too, and I found myself getting so angry on her behalf throughout parts of this story. The frenemies-to-lovers chemistry between these two was perfectly written and I enjoyed every moment of them together.

Although this is the second book in The Puck Boys series, you can easily read this book as a standalone. I haven't yet read book 1, but now that I've had a taste of Brooks University, I'll definitely be catching up. I can't wait for Brody's book next as he's definitely one character that I want to see more of.

Hockey is one of my top sports romances and I'll now be adding this hockey series to my list of favorites.
Profile Image for Mackenzie.
431 reviews1,158 followers
June 13, 2023
I don’t know what Hannah is putting in these books but I am obsessed! I’m really not a friends to lovers type girly but I loved Link & Tate’s story so much.

The story starts out with Link losing his mom & his best friend (Tate) all at once. He vowed to himself that if Tate ever came back to him, he would never forgive her. Fast Forward a couple of years & Tate is now attending Brooks University, where Link plays hockey. Tate finds herself in a situation where she ends up having to live with Link & his teammate, Brody. What she wasn’t expecting though, was the hatred Link had for her upon seeing her again.

Broken Boy was the perfect name for this book because that’s exactly what Link was. I really felt for him & all that he had experienced. Although I thought he was extremely hard on Tate at times, I could understand why he was so hurt. But I loved how much you could really feel their love for one another through the pages. Of course the spice in this book was *chefs kiss* — as always coming from Hannah.

I loved getting to experience all the characters again. Cam Hardy has my heart but I have a feeling Brody is coming for it 🥹 I’m so excited to read his book next!

Tropes:
- Sports Romance 🏒
- Childhood Friends to Enemies to Lovers
- Forced Proximity
- It’s Always Been You

5/5⭐️
3/5🌶️
Profile Image for Olga 🌺.
571 reviews8 followers
April 5, 2024
It’s as if I am reading parallel worlds of the same plot. This book highly resembles Sticks and Stone by S. Massery. Stormy history. Aggressive MMC. Wronged by the FMC. Let’s see where this goes though.

The story is hot and cold with both of them not being able to be without the other. They’re sweet. They grew in personality as young adults especially Tate having to face her dad’s shitty history with his family and the reality that not all men fall in the same basket.

However, and this is a weird thing that I have 😁, I hate it when other women (side characters) are mentioned as goddesses or so beautiful when it is the FMCs story. I meannnn!!!! I want all girls to be beautiful and gorgeous and hot with no exception. Not any one more than the other. Extra beautiful people will get extra attention from other people even if they’re in love. It’s in our nature to appreciate beauty and in the surreal world that I mentally live in all women are equally beautiful. Period.

That said. I loved this story. It’s sweet with its own side of dilemma and the always anticipated HEA. 🩷🩵
Profile Image for Maddy.
505 reviews38 followers
August 28, 2023
4.5 ⭐️s!

Hannah, MY GAL, idk what you put in this hockey romance series but i am absolutely FERAL for these men. I am not typically a friends to lovers gal, but friends to enemies to lovers… sign me the heck up.

I loved Tate and Links story, not as much as Cam and Addison, but still the drama between link and tate was top tier. I mean i physically felt the pain during some of the arguments with them trying to hurt each other… this book was an emotional rollercoaster to say the least.

Brody and Tate’s friendship was an adorable addition to this story. I loved their brother/sister dynamic and how easily they got along. When he kept saying broken people get each other, ugh i just know his story is gonna be so good.

I love this series, loved this story, love these characters.

-College Hockey Romance
-Forced Proximity
-childhood friends to enemies to lovers
-it’s always been you
9 reviews
May 8, 2024
First half of the book I hated him, second half he was really sweet but i won’t forget and so i can not fully forgive
Profile Image for Kalliopi.
53 reviews
April 4, 2026
2.5
im SO happy it's over.theyre childhood friends had sex once before college then she ghosted him for a few years and then ended up having to live at the spare room in his apartment. it was not horrible, easy read, entraining enough, but let's talk about the fact that everything was about aggressive sex. I'm all in for a little possessiveness and a little aggressiveness but omg if you keep saying you want to hurt her and ruin her I'll think you're on the verge of abuse. also why did we keep saying she's broken and he's just So Angelic. like, give me a break. and ALSO the writing is so silly, feels like I wrote it twelve years ago(why were they saying the hated each other and calling each other the villain and a monster, that's so silly, they did that in the first book too silly guys), but that wasn't so bad. All in all I didn't want to stop reading it but would not recommend. Had a lot more thoughts while reading it but I can't remember them now.
Update: Read some negative reviews (so fun) and I remembered that he was so meannnnn for the first half of the book and she was just accepting it and then begging him for forgiveness, Ew. spoiler warning ⚠️: he literally barged into her room while she was naked and kept yelling at her and saying horrible things to her. and this happened twice guys(before they were even together). it's just a humiliation ritual at this point, definitely not hot or cute or romantic idk what the author was trying to do with all that. Also just remembered: she's like only ever been with him and he's a total slut which on its own is not a bad thing, normally I would totally support, but Jesus, he slut shames her at some point for kissing a guy and when he finds out that she's never been with anyone else after or before him he gets all proud and possessive (but when he was sleeping with every girl he could find he was picturing her so it's equal🥹🥹 κιουτσι πουτσι). If it was just that I might have been able to look over it but keeping everything else in mind it all felt very much like "purity culture above all" to me. I don't like this guy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 464 reviews