What do you think?
Rate this book


366 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 16, 2023
Ooooh, loved this one until I didn’t!
This one follows Aria, Esme’s younger sister who last saw her big sis stolen away and now she lives in her heavily patriarchal and misogynistic village as the only one strong enough to stand up for the beaten down mothers, helpless children, and unclaimed women. But in her defiance to keep sneaking past the fence and bring back food and clothes for her people, four Kavari warriors—Dex, Kaiden, Zander, and Umber—have taken notice of their little Aleria and plan to master her—but not if they can’t see they’re part of the problem.
This was a lot more of a fascinating erotica because Aria had the skills of Katniss Everdeen but in an erotic setting. She had strength and skills, and she also had a compelling conflict: leaving the village meant abandoning those who needed her AND she had lingering compartmentalized resentment for the sister who hardly tried to come back for her.
And then it falls flat.
Aria is justified in her anger for many things, but the book punishes her for it or sweeps it under the rug. Dex, Zander, Kaiden, and Umber leave to meet extra forces, ignoring Aria’s words that their leave will call for a power vacuum to be filled with traitors, and, she’s right. She’s chained and tormented. By the time the men return, Aria is done, and the men realize how deeply they’ve ignored her words.
But then that goes away because sex happens.
…kay…
Esme eventually comes to visit Aria, and Aria leaves, unable to confront the sister who chose sex over her sibling. Esme says, “Don’t hate me”, and Arias…lets go of her resentment.
…kay…
????
While this is erotica, it’s still porn with plot. And the plot was compelling. Aria is one of my favorite character archetypes: the lone defender of the beaten and the broken. She and Frayne have a makeshift father-daughter relationship which should’ve been expanded upon rather than word-vomited to us. Not to mention Aria and Esme’s relationship being magically repaired with no emotional lashback. It’s 100% fair Aria has conflicted feelings about her sister. She was traumatized Esme was taken and had years to become the leader for malnourished people while Esme enjoyed her new pampered life.
Why would Aria feel comfortable?
What would’ve been great to happen if Aria didn’t fall into an easy relationship with Esme? Instead, Esme’s eager to rekindle and make up for lost time, but Aria’s standoffish. Aria asks Esme the fatal question: why didn’t you try harder to come back for me? Why did you start a new family while ignoring your current one? And I don’t think Esme would have a good answer for that because what answer can you give to that? And so, Aria would acknowledge Esme as her sister, but their relationship would need to be fractured for quite some time. Esme doesn’t deserve to get off Scott-free for choosing sex over a sibling. Aria deserves to have time to reconcile her feelings.
But this book was never about the plot.
It’s porn with plot, but the erotic discovery is at the forefront, not the general adventure of it.
So.
[Sad reader noises.]
Back to AO3 I go.