Upon seeing the glowing reviews for this book I decided to buy it, as I teach SAT/ACT to students. What a disappointment! I started reading the book and it seems more like an infomercial than an actual SAT book. The "Black book" makes it seems like it's exclusive material not found elsewhere, kind of like someone getting a Black Card from American Express.
But upon reading the book, it's not exclusive material. I have seen other gimmick companies and people try to advertise "teaching the test" where the test taker supposedly does as little as possible to prepare and miraculously does well on the actual test. Not studying vocabulary...sure that sounds great. Kind of like telling students they can get straight A's while doing no homework. But it's not practical. Even Mike Barrett himself says you can omit 4 or 5 questions and still get a 750 on a reading section, which is untrue. Check out the scoring guide on just about any SAT and if you miss even two questions you're down to a 750. Nonetheless it is a gimmick. My students do study vocabulary and there is a huge difference between my students who actually study vocabulary and the ones who do not--on test day.
Mike says not to guess even when you've eliminated choices. This is simply not true: it has been mathematically proven that guessing even when you can safely eliminate just one answer, that you know is wrong, does pay off. And if you can safely knockout more than one choice you've tilted the odds even more in your favor. It isn't even open for debate: it has been done in experiments and proven to be correct.
I read the section on reading comprehension where Mike literally says use the skimming technique, read the whole passage or use any method you want. Seriously? How is that direction? It seems that this "strategy" along with most of the strategies in the book are completely vague. In fact, it seems the author majored in vague. Then, he goes on to say eliminate the four wrong choices in a reading comp. question and if you only have three to eliminate you did something wrong. But how do I specifically eliminate the four wrong choices...that is not given. Just generic, vague info on what type answer questions are normally wrong.
Then, I wondered, after teaching in the field for a long time, why I have never heard of Mike Barrett. Notice in the book there is not one testimonial, and not one review from a book, magazine or TV station. Those are the kinds of things I normally see in SAT/ACT books that are written by real pros. Upon looking further, I noticed Mike doesn't even list an address for where his "company" is located. Yet, he wants to charge people $350/hr. to Skype with him and it is in the thousands to have him travel to you and work one-on-one. What person in right mind would pay someone they hardly know, who has never been on TV or done any major interviews, that kind of money--especially when the person has no physical address.
Mike talks about college in his blurb listed here on Amazon but why does he hide the college he went to? Would any good SAT tutor have to do that? It looks like he went to University of Florida, which is an good school but not great, and certainly not the kind of school you would expect a self-proclaimed testing genius to go to. You would expect he would've gone to any Ivy League or similar college on full-scholarship.
Also, I saw Mike had a previous book called Grammatix, found on the Internet. Upon looking over that it seems this book is just a recycling of that book, and in many parts it is simply a cut-and-paste job from Grammatix.
In short, the whole thing is a huge scam. There are no great tricks or techniques here, the few clear suggestions he makes (not studying vocab, not guessing) have been proven to be wrong, and the author himself is a nobody in the industry--despite claiming to be a renowned expert! I remember the old infomercial where, I believe it was Don Lapre, mentioned how he made more money in one week working out of a 1BR apartment than most people made in a year. Yet Don was carted off to "Club Fed," eventually and exposed for the fraud he was. It kind of reminds me of the strategies in this book. However instead of selling Ginzu knives, or fast-buck real estate tips, Mike Barrett is selling bogus SAT tips and generic, vague and worthless information.