What do you think?
Rate this book
Lucky Harbor #8
Always on My Mind
THERE'S NOTHING LIKE THE REAL THING After dropping out of pastry school and messing up her big break on a reality cooking show, Leah Sullivan needs to accomplish something in her life. But when she returns home to Lucky Harbor, she finds herself distracted by her best friend, Jack Harper. In an effort to cheer up Jack's ailing mother, Dee, Leah tells a little fib - that she and Jack are more than just friends. Soon pretending to be hot-and-heavy with this hunky firefighter feels too real to handle . . . No-strings attachments suit Jack just fine - perfect for keeping the risk of heartbreak away. But as Jack and Leah break every one of their "just friends" rules, he longs to turn their pretend relationship into something permanent. Do best friends know too much about each other to risk falling in love? Or will Jack and Leah discover something new about each other in a little town called Lucky Harbor?
242 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 24, 2013
191 people are currently reading
4770 people want to read
About the author
Jill Shalvis
388 books13.9k followersJill Shalvis is a NYT, USA Today, and Amazon Top 100 bestselling author of small-town romance and romcoms, known for big feels, found family, and plenty of shenanigans.
If you love small-town chaos, meddling friends and neighbors, sizzling chemistry, and heroes who fall hard for the one woman they absolutely did not plan on, you’re in the right place. Jill’s books blend laugh-out-loud moments with emotional gut punches, slow-burn tension, and deeply earned happily ever afters.
She writes the stories she loves to read: small-town romance and romantic comedies packed with heart, heat, second chances, grumpy/sunshine sparks, and the kind of found-family vibes that make you want to move right into the pages. Many of her series are perfect for binge-reading, and a number of her books are available in Kindle Unlimited and at major retailers.
When she’s not writing, she’s probably plotting new ways to torture her characters, avoiding laundry, or daydreaming about fictional men and the strong, complicated women who bring them to their knees—and then making them work for it.
You can follow Jill here on Goodreads to keep up with new releases, add her books to your shelves, and discover which small town you want to get lost in next.
If you love small-town chaos, meddling friends and neighbors, sizzling chemistry, and heroes who fall hard for the one woman they absolutely did not plan on, you’re in the right place. Jill’s books blend laugh-out-loud moments with emotional gut punches, slow-burn tension, and deeply earned happily ever afters.
She writes the stories she loves to read: small-town romance and romantic comedies packed with heart, heat, second chances, grumpy/sunshine sparks, and the kind of found-family vibes that make you want to move right into the pages. Many of her series are perfect for binge-reading, and a number of her books are available in Kindle Unlimited and at major retailers.
When she’s not writing, she’s probably plotting new ways to torture her characters, avoiding laundry, or daydreaming about fictional men and the strong, complicated women who bring them to their knees—and then making them work for it.
You can follow Jill here on Goodreads to keep up with new releases, add her books to your shelves, and discover which small town you want to get lost in next.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 819 reviews
October 8, 2013
2 ½ stars – Contemporary Romance
I'm a bit surprised to be rating this so low because I love this author and I've really enjoyed previous Lucky Harbor books. But this was a disappointment and my least favorite of the series, and I honestly found myself rather bored. I just didn't feel much connection between the H/h or find their friends to lovers romance all that convincing or exciting. I don't know, but I feel like this series might have run out of steam. It happens.
I'm a bit surprised to be rating this so low because I love this author and I've really enjoyed previous Lucky Harbor books. But this was a disappointment and my least favorite of the series, and I honestly found myself rather bored. I just didn't feel much connection between the H/h or find their friends to lovers romance all that convincing or exciting. I don't know, but I feel like this series might have run out of steam. It happens.
September 14, 2013
4 passionate, romantic, poignant, sexy, laugh out loud funny stars!
Always on My Mind is the 8th book in Jill Shalvis’ brilliant Lucky Harbor series. It’s all the things I mentioned above – passionate, romantic, poignant, sexy, laugh out loud funny – and then some.
From the Cover:
After dropping out of pastry school and messing up her big break on a reality cooking show, Leah Sullivan needs to accomplish something in her life. But when she returns home to Lucky Harbor, she finds herself distracted by her best friend, Jack Harper. In an effort to cheer up Jack's ailing mother, Dee, Leah tells a little fib - that she and Jack are more than just friends. Soon pretending to be hot-and-heavy with this hunky firefighter feels too real to handle . . .My Review:
No-strings attachments suit Jack just fine - perfect for keeping the risk of heartbreak away. But as Jack and Leah break every one of their "just friends" rules, he longs to turn their pretend relationship into something permanent. Do best friends know too much about each other to risk falling in love? Or will Jack and Leah discover something new about each other in a little town called Lucky Harbor?
I’ve truly enjoyed all the books in the series, but this one hits home in a very personal way, and I can totally relate to Leah’s demons because I share the same ones. But I just love the way Ms. Shalvis can take a character’s heartbreaking situations and turn the trials into triumphs, and the things that can tear you down into things that build you up.
And, as always, the entire cast of characters are people we can connect to. From young adults just trying to find their way in life, to the more “mature” adults who are “old enough to know better but too young (at heart) to care…” each and every person in Lucky Harbor is a person I want to know better. A person I’d love to have as a friend or neighbor, or significant other.
The Bottom Line:
Jill Shalvis is one of the few truly amazing voices in Contemporary Romance, and with Always on My Mind, she’s delivered a beautifully told story about letting go of yesterday’s pain so you can live and love like there’s no tomorrow.
My thanks to Grand Central Publishing and Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this story in exchange for an honest review. Again, it’s been a pleasure.
Read
February 7, 2019About 2.5 Stars, rounded down because I've finally realized that, OMG, all of this author's characters and stories and dialogue and prose are more or less the same from one book to the next, like to the point where I honestly find myself wondering if she copies and pastes from old manuscripts rather than writing wholly new and original material!
This book gave us a promising beginning and fairly strong end, but an incredibly frustrating and meandering middle. The subplot about an arsonist was mildly interesting but ultimately executed in a really sloppy way. Jack was likable enough but ended up identical to almost every single Shalvis hero ever, which was a shame because in initially he seemed to have a slightly more distinctive personality. Leah was very relatable to me, but her admitted tendency to run from conflict proved frustrating to read about over and over.
The main "plot" (or lack thereof!) involved the characters having sex, having the same endless, circular discussions with themselves and each other about how that sex shouldn't mean anything, and then...having more sex. I think maybe I should start limiting myself to Shalvis books that have a stronger element of mystery/suspense or just some plot beyond her usual tired thing: the H and h are obsessed with sex but lamely convince each other it doesn't mean more than that, have more sex, more of the same discussions about why the sex doesn't matter, and then randomly decide just in time for the book to end that---shocker---all that sex DOES mean they're supposedly in love after all.
This one at least hinted at a deeper emotional connection beyond Shalvis's usual heavy focus on physical attraction/interactions since they were friends from childhood, but as others have pointed out, for the most part Leah and Jack communicated more like awkward, distant acquaintances. If not for flashing back to the past, you'd never guess from their present interactions that they had any sort of bond. They're not especially open and honest with each other or even themselves, but they do have a physical attraction, which I've realized is the aspect of romance that Jill Shalvis seems to value or at least enjoy writing about most. (By the way, even Shalvis's minor characters who are already in supposedly deep and meaningful relationships all talk incessantly about 'getting some' and never seem to have any interest in any of the emotional aspects of a romantic relationship, lending weight to the common criticism that Shalvis writes romances about people in lust rather than in love)
I did relate to Leah since her flaws are similar to mine, and, as always, there were some funny and oddly inspiring (albeit fortune cookie-ish!) lines. It's those handfuls of funny and inspiring lines that keep me strangely addicted to Shalvis's books despite feeling more and more like they're 1. not especially well written and 2. are FAR too similar, with nearly identical heroes, "plots" (again, lack thereof), and even some of the exact same lazy descriptions and dialogue used over and over. ("She was sexy as hell, smart as hell, tough as hell." "Oh, shit. Shit. SHIT!" ---yes, Jill, we know you think tough guys cursing on every page makes them super cool. And then there are the identical, shallow and repetitive conversations among the three male friends and three female friends---and yes, there are always exactly three male friends and three female friends. The same exact descriptions of setting, people, sex, etc. There's sticking to a winning formula and then there's lazy, cookie-cutter repetitiveness, and Shalvis's books seem to be veering into the latter category for me :))
I've definitely derived some enjoyment from these books and think most readers will too, but I also think I need to try to break free of my addiction to this author and search for a different writer to fill my cravings for contemporary romance---preferably one who writes with more cleverness, originality and style, whose heroes aren't always the EXACT same and not especially interesting cardboard 'type', and, most of all, a writer who explores emotional and intellectual connections rather than just the physical side of romance!
This book gave us a promising beginning and fairly strong end, but an incredibly frustrating and meandering middle. The subplot about an arsonist was mildly interesting but ultimately executed in a really sloppy way. Jack was likable enough but ended up identical to almost every single Shalvis hero ever, which was a shame because in initially he seemed to have a slightly more distinctive personality. Leah was very relatable to me, but her admitted tendency to run from conflict proved frustrating to read about over and over.
The main "plot" (or lack thereof!) involved the characters having sex, having the same endless, circular discussions with themselves and each other about how that sex shouldn't mean anything, and then...having more sex. I think maybe I should start limiting myself to Shalvis books that have a stronger element of mystery/suspense or just some plot beyond her usual tired thing: the H and h are obsessed with sex but lamely convince each other it doesn't mean more than that, have more sex, more of the same discussions about why the sex doesn't matter, and then randomly decide just in time for the book to end that---shocker---all that sex DOES mean they're supposedly in love after all.
This one at least hinted at a deeper emotional connection beyond Shalvis's usual heavy focus on physical attraction/interactions since they were friends from childhood, but as others have pointed out, for the most part Leah and Jack communicated more like awkward, distant acquaintances. If not for flashing back to the past, you'd never guess from their present interactions that they had any sort of bond. They're not especially open and honest with each other or even themselves, but they do have a physical attraction, which I've realized is the aspect of romance that Jill Shalvis seems to value or at least enjoy writing about most. (By the way, even Shalvis's minor characters who are already in supposedly deep and meaningful relationships all talk incessantly about 'getting some' and never seem to have any interest in any of the emotional aspects of a romantic relationship, lending weight to the common criticism that Shalvis writes romances about people in lust rather than in love)
I did relate to Leah since her flaws are similar to mine, and, as always, there were some funny and oddly inspiring (albeit fortune cookie-ish!) lines. It's those handfuls of funny and inspiring lines that keep me strangely addicted to Shalvis's books despite feeling more and more like they're 1. not especially well written and 2. are FAR too similar, with nearly identical heroes, "plots" (again, lack thereof), and even some of the exact same lazy descriptions and dialogue used over and over. ("She was sexy as hell, smart as hell, tough as hell." "Oh, shit. Shit. SHIT!" ---yes, Jill, we know you think tough guys cursing on every page makes them super cool. And then there are the identical, shallow and repetitive conversations among the three male friends and three female friends---and yes, there are always exactly three male friends and three female friends. The same exact descriptions of setting, people, sex, etc. There's sticking to a winning formula and then there's lazy, cookie-cutter repetitiveness, and Shalvis's books seem to be veering into the latter category for me :))
I've definitely derived some enjoyment from these books and think most readers will too, but I also think I need to try to break free of my addiction to this author and search for a different writer to fill my cravings for contemporary romance---preferably one who writes with more cleverness, originality and style, whose heroes aren't always the EXACT same and not especially interesting cardboard 'type', and, most of all, a writer who explores emotional and intellectual connections rather than just the physical side of romance!
September 29, 2014
Jill Shalvis is an author I tend to drop everything for... especially the Lucky Harbor boys. I can't help it. She has this way of making me forget everything that's going on in my life for a few hours...letting me jump into the small town that is Lucky Harbor. Where the view is quaint and picturesque and the guys are all drool-worthy. And after the month I've had, I needed this book more than anything else in my life.
Leah and Jack have been friends forever... Or at least since they were in the 6th grade and Leah moved to Lucky Harbor. She immediately formed a friendship with Jack, who despite being two years older, became somewhat of a protector.
Leah grew up with her father hovering over her screaming at her telling her she wouldn't amount to anything, that she'd never succeed in life and she would always screw things up. Even with her mother who tried to support her positively and Jack who tried to show her that her father was wrong, she never believed in herself. She runs at the first chance and never follows her plans through.
Leah is back in Lucky Harbor though, helping her grandma. She left culinary school to take part in a reality cooking competition and the whole town is watching and hounding her, wondering if she won or not. Winning means $100,000 and the chance to own her own bakery. Even though she's back, she's determined to get out of Lucky Harbor before the last show airs.
Jack has lived in the shadow of his father's heroism his whole life. When his father died on the job, he was determined he would follow in his footsteps and become a firefighter too. Now he heads up Station #24. However, seeing how ruined his mother was after the loss of his father, he is determined never to give his heart so thoroughly to anyone.
With their stormy history slowly revealing itself, Leah tells a little white lie that puts these two on the path they have avoided their entire lives. Watching what happens was a wonderful mess to see.
One thing Jill excels at, and that I appreciate is her ability to take you to the town, to connect with the characters and like I said above, just forget about everything else going on for a couple of hours.
I love a good friends to lovers story, and Jill has given us one here. The connection that Jack and Leah had was believable and poignant and their chemistry was wonderfully done. I think though, that I would have liked a bit more about the night she left town. I feel like that wasn't explained as well as it could have been. However, it didn't take away from the story at all.
Romance books are always hit or miss for me, but I can usually count on Jill Shalvis to entertain me. Is the storyline completely new and different? No, it's apparent that Jill has a formula for her stories, but I will say that it totally works for me. Every. Single. Time.
Grab this one when it comes out... and if you haven't started the Lucky Harbor Series, you're seriously missing out on some of my favorite guys in romance!
Thanks to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for the advance copy for review!
This review can be found on my blog, Fic Fare, closer to publication:
Leah and Jack have been friends forever... Or at least since they were in the 6th grade and Leah moved to Lucky Harbor. She immediately formed a friendship with Jack, who despite being two years older, became somewhat of a protector.
Leah grew up with her father hovering over her screaming at her telling her she wouldn't amount to anything, that she'd never succeed in life and she would always screw things up. Even with her mother who tried to support her positively and Jack who tried to show her that her father was wrong, she never believed in herself. She runs at the first chance and never follows her plans through.
Leah is back in Lucky Harbor though, helping her grandma. She left culinary school to take part in a reality cooking competition and the whole town is watching and hounding her, wondering if she won or not. Winning means $100,000 and the chance to own her own bakery. Even though she's back, she's determined to get out of Lucky Harbor before the last show airs.
Jack has lived in the shadow of his father's heroism his whole life. When his father died on the job, he was determined he would follow in his footsteps and become a firefighter too. Now he heads up Station #24. However, seeing how ruined his mother was after the loss of his father, he is determined never to give his heart so thoroughly to anyone.
With their stormy history slowly revealing itself, Leah tells a little white lie that puts these two on the path they have avoided their entire lives. Watching what happens was a wonderful mess to see.
One thing Jill excels at, and that I appreciate is her ability to take you to the town, to connect with the characters and like I said above, just forget about everything else going on for a couple of hours.
I love a good friends to lovers story, and Jill has given us one here. The connection that Jack and Leah had was believable and poignant and their chemistry was wonderfully done. I think though, that I would have liked a bit more about the night she left town. I feel like that wasn't explained as well as it could have been. However, it didn't take away from the story at all.
Romance books are always hit or miss for me, but I can usually count on Jill Shalvis to entertain me. Is the storyline completely new and different? No, it's apparent that Jill has a formula for her stories, but I will say that it totally works for me. Every. Single. Time.
Grab this one when it comes out... and if you haven't started the Lucky Harbor Series, you're seriously missing out on some of my favorite guys in romance!
Thanks to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for the advance copy for review!
This review can be found on my blog, Fic Fare, closer to publication:
August 8, 2017
Sums up everything for me:
Way too much back and forth passive aggressive dialogue which got in the way of my enjoyment of this. The whole 'this is a pretend relationship, real, pretend, REAL!' merry go round just muddled everything for me. It left me confused with all the contradicting dialogue. I think Shalvis over did it with the forced tension and unspoken feelings between Jack and Leah. I don’t get how one drunk night of almost (not really) sex thirteen years ago lead to such supposed strained tension between them years later as adults. I mean...seriously? I had a really hard time buying this. Call me insensitive but I really thought this event was overblown and a lousy reasoning to use as tension & distrust between them. I don't remember seeing any of this supposed strained tension between these two in the previous book. This felt very contrived. Also most of the reasons used over why they couldn't/shouldn't be together were inconsistent and not viable enough to keep them apart. I really felt Shalvis was reaching here. The reasons why they shouldn't be together kept changing every time these two would get around to having a serious conversation.
The whole 'pretend' relationship and the rules they kept putting on just didn't work for me. If it's a fake relationship then what's with the rules? I didn't like the fact that a silly white lie forced them into playing along and eventually becoming friends with benefits. It cheapened what they had and all the history they shared. I've always loved reading best friends becoming lovers but going the friends-with-benefits route just doesn't work especially if 80% of the story they are denying any feelings and 'pretending' it doesn't matter. Really wish Shalvis would use another trope at this point because this sex-with-no-strings schtick is getting really old. What worries me is that she seems to be using the same formula in most of her books now, to the point that a lot of her stories are very similar and predictable. I'll be honest, I keep getting the deja vu feeling of 'haven't we been here before?' in the last handful of books from this series.
I thought all the flip flopping and Leah running off avoiding Jack like the plague was tiring, overdone and immature. I tried really hard to empathize with her given what she went through growing up with an abusive asshole father but honest to g-d the girl tested my patience with all the back and forth and going in circles. And the repetitive contradicting conversations just made them both come off silly and confusing. One minute her and Jack are talking about giving it a serious try and the next they are reminding each other it's all for pretend. Um..what? This goes on for more than half of the story. Leah I felt had a lot more growing up to do and I don't think there was a lot of character growth for her in here, it happened a little too late for me with all the hedging and avoiding facing her issues till the very last few chapters. I do think Jack was adorable and a total sweetheart and yeah he was a bit of a play boy and needed to get his shit together. It's like the both of them were their own worst enemy. At one point Leah self-depricatingly admits she needs therapy and I found myself agreeing. I understood her crippling fear of being a failure but I think Shalvis poured it on real thick with Leah's flighty testy indecisive personality. She didn't want to face or accept the fact that she would self-sabotage herself. It just muddled everything with all the back and forth conversations that would go nowhere.
I loved Kevin, Jack's rambunctious Great Dane. Once again the pet is the stand out star of the story. LOL He was hilarious and so adorable. Shalvis's animals are so much fun but it's starting to seriously come across like this at times:
I thought the arson subplot was a little bit forced especially how the culprit was 'caught' at the very end. Way too convenient and rushed. Jack not being able to figure it out through the entire book until the very end when he notices how someone walks and stands up? Eh. Seemed very contrived and a last minute wrap-up.
Shalvis's writing is enjoyable, she's a hit or miss author for me but I always come back to her for a light fun read. And the fact that brooding silent Ben gets a book next has me coming back for more again. *sigh* Aubrey better treat him right!
Way too much back and forth passive aggressive dialogue which got in the way of my enjoyment of this. The whole 'this is a pretend relationship, real, pretend, REAL!' merry go round just muddled everything for me. It left me confused with all the contradicting dialogue. I think Shalvis over did it with the forced tension and unspoken feelings between Jack and Leah. I don’t get how one drunk night of almost (not really) sex thirteen years ago lead to such supposed strained tension between them years later as adults. I mean...seriously? I had a really hard time buying this. Call me insensitive but I really thought this event was overblown and a lousy reasoning to use as tension & distrust between them. I don't remember seeing any of this supposed strained tension between these two in the previous book. This felt very contrived. Also most of the reasons used over why they couldn't/shouldn't be together were inconsistent and not viable enough to keep them apart. I really felt Shalvis was reaching here. The reasons why they shouldn't be together kept changing every time these two would get around to having a serious conversation.
The whole 'pretend' relationship and the rules they kept putting on just didn't work for me. If it's a fake relationship then what's with the rules? I didn't like the fact that a silly white lie forced them into playing along and eventually becoming friends with benefits. It cheapened what they had and all the history they shared. I've always loved reading best friends becoming lovers but going the friends-with-benefits route just doesn't work especially if 80% of the story they are denying any feelings and 'pretending' it doesn't matter. Really wish Shalvis would use another trope at this point because this sex-with-no-strings schtick is getting really old. What worries me is that she seems to be using the same formula in most of her books now, to the point that a lot of her stories are very similar and predictable. I'll be honest, I keep getting the deja vu feeling of 'haven't we been here before?' in the last handful of books from this series.
I thought all the flip flopping and Leah running off avoiding Jack like the plague was tiring, overdone and immature. I tried really hard to empathize with her given what she went through growing up with an abusive asshole father but honest to g-d the girl tested my patience with all the back and forth and going in circles. And the repetitive contradicting conversations just made them both come off silly and confusing. One minute her and Jack are talking about giving it a serious try and the next they are reminding each other it's all for pretend. Um..what? This goes on for more than half of the story. Leah I felt had a lot more growing up to do and I don't think there was a lot of character growth for her in here, it happened a little too late for me with all the hedging and avoiding facing her issues till the very last few chapters. I do think Jack was adorable and a total sweetheart and yeah he was a bit of a play boy and needed to get his shit together. It's like the both of them were their own worst enemy. At one point Leah self-depricatingly admits she needs therapy and I found myself agreeing. I understood her crippling fear of being a failure but I think Shalvis poured it on real thick with Leah's flighty testy indecisive personality. She didn't want to face or accept the fact that she would self-sabotage herself. It just muddled everything with all the back and forth conversations that would go nowhere.
I loved Kevin, Jack's rambunctious Great Dane. Once again the pet is the stand out star of the story. LOL He was hilarious and so adorable. Shalvis's animals are so much fun but it's starting to seriously come across like this at times:
I thought the arson subplot was a little bit forced especially how the culprit was 'caught' at the very end. Way too convenient and rushed. Jack not being able to figure it out through the entire book until the very end when he notices how someone walks and stands up? Eh. Seemed very contrived and a last minute wrap-up.
Shalvis's writing is enjoyable, she's a hit or miss author for me but I always come back to her for a light fun read. And the fact that brooding silent Ben gets a book next has me coming back for more again. *sigh* Aubrey better treat him right!
July 22, 2015
To start Goodreads is doing my head in as I have just finished a long review of this book and hit the upload button only to have the site crash on me! I haven't got time to completely re-write it so am gonna keep it short and to the point.
I really struggled with this one and it took me a whole week to get it finished whereas I normally read a book in 48 hours tops. I knew that if I put it down and grabbed something else then I wouldn't go back to it at all but wanted to read just in case it contained relevant information for subsequent stories. I just didn't find a connection between these two and for me the sexual tension just wasn't there, I actually wondered why on earth they were friends let alone an on and off couple! Jack did nothing for me and quite frankly I could have slapped Leah.
It really pains me to say all this about a Jill Shalvis book and to give it such a low rating as she is one of my favourite authors:( .... I don't know if this series has had it's run and it's time to give in or if it was just one of those things so will carry on with the next ones and make a decision afterwards.
I really struggled with this one and it took me a whole week to get it finished whereas I normally read a book in 48 hours tops. I knew that if I put it down and grabbed something else then I wouldn't go back to it at all but wanted to read just in case it contained relevant information for subsequent stories. I just didn't find a connection between these two and for me the sexual tension just wasn't there, I actually wondered why on earth they were friends let alone an on and off couple! Jack did nothing for me and quite frankly I could have slapped Leah.
It really pains me to say all this about a Jill Shalvis book and to give it such a low rating as she is one of my favourite authors:( .... I don't know if this series has had it's run and it's time to give in or if it was just one of those things so will carry on with the next ones and make a decision afterwards.
September 25, 2013
I am like a broken record with JS books, they are just so freaking amazing but this time I'll be honest that there was one factor that annoyed me to no end in this book, Jack and Leah were apart most of the book and were seldom together on page. I mean there are these two awesome characters who know each other so well, have awesome chemistry and they hardly spend time together, that was just plain mean.
Jack is a fire-fighter who followed in his hero father's footsteps. He is a stand-up guy and a ladies man, a fact his mother takes the blame for because she fell apart after her husband's death and believes that is the cause for Jack's commitment free ways.
Leah grew up with a father that constantly berated her, chipping away at her self-esteem and Jack was always there for her, wiping her tears, cheering her up and there was a brief time they could have been more, but afraid she ran away and now she's back to take care of her grandmother, when she tells Jack's sick mother a big fib, she and Jack are together. I liked the whole Lucky Harbor rumor mill going crazy after this news but felt the book tried to do much, they threw in an arson plot and made Jack spend more time at the fire-station than was needed.
The book also set up Jack's cousin Ben and Aubrey who we met in Ali's book here. Overall I love JS and this book is all kinds of sweet and sexy. Recommended!
Jack is a fire-fighter who followed in his hero father's footsteps. He is a stand-up guy and a ladies man, a fact his mother takes the blame for because she fell apart after her husband's death and believes that is the cause for Jack's commitment free ways.
Leah grew up with a father that constantly berated her, chipping away at her self-esteem and Jack was always there for her, wiping her tears, cheering her up and there was a brief time they could have been more, but afraid she ran away and now she's back to take care of her grandmother, when she tells Jack's sick mother a big fib, she and Jack are together. I liked the whole Lucky Harbor rumor mill going crazy after this news but felt the book tried to do much, they threw in an arson plot and made Jack spend more time at the fire-station than was needed.
The book also set up Jack's cousin Ben and Aubrey who we met in Ali's book here. Overall I love JS and this book is all kinds of sweet and sexy. Recommended!
November 3, 2014
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 STARS ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
★✩ WARNING ✩★
Do not attempt to read this book on an empty stomach! lol
This book was as usual, fun, sweet, sexy and... tempting!!! Halfway in the book I went in the kitchen and baked swirl caramel brownies!
Loved it. ❤️
★✩ WARNING ✩★
Do not attempt to read this book on an empty stomach! lol
This book was as usual, fun, sweet, sexy and... tempting!!! Halfway in the book I went in the kitchen and baked swirl caramel brownies!
Loved it. ❤️
September 13, 2013
LOVED it! This book was so funny - and so sexy. And had a terrific alpha hero and a lovable group of girlfriends. A winning combo for sure. The dialogue had me cracking up several times.
Now I can't wait for Ben's story - thank goodness I know it's in the works because there's an except in the back of the book. Yay!
Now I can't wait for Ben's story - thank goodness I know it's in the works because there's an except in the back of the book. Yay!
October 26, 2015
-- A Romantic Book Affairs Review
Ah, it’s like a fresh of breath air being back in Lucky Harbor. I adore this series and the hunky alpha heroes. Jill Shalvis’ writing is addictive and sexy and sassy. I really loved reading as Jack and Leah unravel and crash into a whirlwind of lust, desire, and finally… love
Leah Sullivan has never really known her path, but she’s always loved adventure. She grew up with an abusive and domineering father that expected her to be the best. Perfect. Yet no matter what she did, it was never good enough. When things would get bad, she would find solace in her rock and protector, Jack Harper, her childhood best friend. He always welcomed her with open arms and consoled her when the tears would fall. The relationship between Jack and Leah was incredibly touching and emotionally deep. I could tell they loved each other immensely.
But seventeen year old Leah decides to take off, leaving behind Lucky Harbor, and a broken hearted Jack, without saying goodbye. She attends culinary school to become a pastry chef and, eventually, goes on a cooking reality TV show, Sweet Wars. Leah comes home after the show is done filming to help her ailing grandmother with her pastry shop. As the show is airing, Leah is bound by contract to keep mum about the winner of the show. Of course, everyone in the small town of Lucky Harbor is watching and hounding Leah every chance they get, certain Leah has won because she is kicking ass. Though, Leah is not acting like a winner. So, now that Leah is back in Lucky Harbor, she has a chance to regroup her life, rekindle her friendship with Jack, and has developed good friendships with Aubrey and Ali. But her suitcase is not unpacked, since she has every intention to get the hell out of dodge before the last show airs.
Charming, sexy as hell, Lieutenant Jack Harper has always lived in the shadow of his father, who is now deceased. His determination and loyalty to be the baddest of the bad had him fighting fires as a ‘Hotshot’, but a knee injury forced him to go back home to work at the local fire station. Though, this time, Jack is trying to make a path for himself. Jack was hurt by Leah running out on him, but remained in touch with her over the years and kept their friendship status the same when she came home; always her protector and savior.
When Leah decides to tell Jack’s mother’s that she and Jack are dating to alleviate some of her worries, things get out of control between them quickly. Jack is not happy with Leah and is not interested in repeating history with her. He was once willing to give her his heart. Now he's not interested in having his heart broken again, knowing that Leah runs when things get too heavy. But he goes along with the charade anyway and creates rules for their ‘pretend’ relationship to keep her at arm’s length. When ‘pretend’ turns into ‘no strings attached sex,’ things become even more confusing between them and the rules start to bend. How long will this little game go on before they realize that it was never pretend but the real thing the entire time?
As Jack and Leah continue with their charade and dance around their feelings, there is no denying the lust and love they've buried for so long. I loved watching the cool and calm Jack brought to his knees by Leah; the one woman that’s always been on his mind. And it was just a matter of time before Leah realized that Jack is more than just her best friend; he’s her everything. But they both have a lot of issues to work through... in other words, they both really needed to pull their stubborn heads out of their asses to see they are perfect for each other.
I will admit to being a little concerned with this couple at first, when the chemistry between them felt lacking. Oh, there is an attraction, but I was worried with the way Jack was so angry with Leah over the ‘pretend’ relationship. Some of his harsh words absolutely slayed me. However, with one long overdue smoldering kiss between them, the lukewarm chemistry turned from to simmering to boiling in 0.2 seconds. Yeah, I was no longer concerned at this point. That’s what you call a slow panty melting burn that will make your toes curl.
“Now you,” she said desperately. “You have to lose something.”
“But you’re not finished.” He leaned back on his elbows, all long, sprawled-out grace. The caged leopard at rest…
Good lord. “Fine.” She shoved off her jeans. Dammit. To go with her sports bra, her panties were laundry day panties, faded yellow, and worse, they had “Thursday” printed across the butt.
It was Sunday.
Jack Grinned.
(LOL… I love this scene!)
Always on My Mind is the eighth book in the Lucky Harbor series. You can read this as a stand-alone, but it’s totally worth starting this series from the beginning. There is nothing like a good friends-to-lovers romance - one of my favorite tropes. And, once again, Jill Shalvis has created another page turner that will make you groan in frustration when her hero and heroine don’t play well together, but also melt your heart at the same time. There is also a dash of mystery added to the story that had me trying to guess who the villain of Lucky Harbor is. I love this town and its endearing, quirky people that put a smile on my face. It’s like coming home every time I read a Lucky Harbor book.
P.S. As a dog lover, I have to give a shout out to Kevin, Josh’s dog. That big oaf had me laughing like crazy with his silly antics. I can SO relate with that crazy dog, since I have two silly furry dudes, who drive me batty, but I love them to pieces.
Rating: B+
Heat: Hot
Find us on Twitter and Facebook too!
Ah, it’s like a fresh of breath air being back in Lucky Harbor. I adore this series and the hunky alpha heroes. Jill Shalvis’ writing is addictive and sexy and sassy. I really loved reading as Jack and Leah unravel and crash into a whirlwind of lust, desire, and finally… love
Leah Sullivan has never really known her path, but she’s always loved adventure. She grew up with an abusive and domineering father that expected her to be the best. Perfect. Yet no matter what she did, it was never good enough. When things would get bad, she would find solace in her rock and protector, Jack Harper, her childhood best friend. He always welcomed her with open arms and consoled her when the tears would fall. The relationship between Jack and Leah was incredibly touching and emotionally deep. I could tell they loved each other immensely.
But seventeen year old Leah decides to take off, leaving behind Lucky Harbor, and a broken hearted Jack, without saying goodbye. She attends culinary school to become a pastry chef and, eventually, goes on a cooking reality TV show, Sweet Wars. Leah comes home after the show is done filming to help her ailing grandmother with her pastry shop. As the show is airing, Leah is bound by contract to keep mum about the winner of the show. Of course, everyone in the small town of Lucky Harbor is watching and hounding Leah every chance they get, certain Leah has won because she is kicking ass. Though, Leah is not acting like a winner. So, now that Leah is back in Lucky Harbor, she has a chance to regroup her life, rekindle her friendship with Jack, and has developed good friendships with Aubrey and Ali. But her suitcase is not unpacked, since she has every intention to get the hell out of dodge before the last show airs.
Charming, sexy as hell, Lieutenant Jack Harper has always lived in the shadow of his father, who is now deceased. His determination and loyalty to be the baddest of the bad had him fighting fires as a ‘Hotshot’, but a knee injury forced him to go back home to work at the local fire station. Though, this time, Jack is trying to make a path for himself. Jack was hurt by Leah running out on him, but remained in touch with her over the years and kept their friendship status the same when she came home; always her protector and savior.
When Leah decides to tell Jack’s mother’s that she and Jack are dating to alleviate some of her worries, things get out of control between them quickly. Jack is not happy with Leah and is not interested in repeating history with her. He was once willing to give her his heart. Now he's not interested in having his heart broken again, knowing that Leah runs when things get too heavy. But he goes along with the charade anyway and creates rules for their ‘pretend’ relationship to keep her at arm’s length. When ‘pretend’ turns into ‘no strings attached sex,’ things become even more confusing between them and the rules start to bend. How long will this little game go on before they realize that it was never pretend but the real thing the entire time?
As Jack and Leah continue with their charade and dance around their feelings, there is no denying the lust and love they've buried for so long. I loved watching the cool and calm Jack brought to his knees by Leah; the one woman that’s always been on his mind. And it was just a matter of time before Leah realized that Jack is more than just her best friend; he’s her everything. But they both have a lot of issues to work through... in other words, they both really needed to pull their stubborn heads out of their asses to see they are perfect for each other.
I will admit to being a little concerned with this couple at first, when the chemistry between them felt lacking. Oh, there is an attraction, but I was worried with the way Jack was so angry with Leah over the ‘pretend’ relationship. Some of his harsh words absolutely slayed me. However, with one long overdue smoldering kiss between them, the lukewarm chemistry turned from to simmering to boiling in 0.2 seconds. Yeah, I was no longer concerned at this point. That’s what you call a slow panty melting burn that will make your toes curl.
“Now you,” she said desperately. “You have to lose something.”
“But you’re not finished.” He leaned back on his elbows, all long, sprawled-out grace. The caged leopard at rest…
Good lord. “Fine.” She shoved off her jeans. Dammit. To go with her sports bra, her panties were laundry day panties, faded yellow, and worse, they had “Thursday” printed across the butt.
It was Sunday.
Jack Grinned.
(LOL… I love this scene!)
Always on My Mind is the eighth book in the Lucky Harbor series. You can read this as a stand-alone, but it’s totally worth starting this series from the beginning. There is nothing like a good friends-to-lovers romance - one of my favorite tropes. And, once again, Jill Shalvis has created another page turner that will make you groan in frustration when her hero and heroine don’t play well together, but also melt your heart at the same time. There is also a dash of mystery added to the story that had me trying to guess who the villain of Lucky Harbor is. I love this town and its endearing, quirky people that put a smile on my face. It’s like coming home every time I read a Lucky Harbor book.
P.S. As a dog lover, I have to give a shout out to Kevin, Josh’s dog. That big oaf had me laughing like crazy with his silly antics. I can SO relate with that crazy dog, since I have two silly furry dudes, who drive me batty, but I love them to pieces.
Rating: B+
Heat: Hot
Find us on Twitter and Facebook too!
October 27, 2013
I'm... disappointed in this latest instalment of the Lucky Harbor series.
While it still contained the quirky banter and feel-good romance of her previous books, Shalvis just missed base with this book. I spent the first 2/3 of the book confused as to Jack and Leah's stance relating to their relationship (or non-relationship in this case). Every time they conversed about their relationship they seemed to contradict the position they had at the beginning of the conversation. Jack and Leah also seemed to agree that there was no relationship, they didn't want a relationship and there would be no relationship. I kind of had to ask myself what the point of the conversation was. Everyone agreed - no relationship. So why did that scene just take up a chapter of this book?
I got pretty confused.
And a wee bit annoyed.
I waited and wanted this couple.
I wanted to like this couple.
So 1 star for the first 2/3 of the book and an extra 2 stars for the last third of the book. The last third gets it's shizzle together. It's tight, people have conversations and stick to the position they took at the start of the conversation, Jack and Leah pick a self-esteem issue and stick to it (finally making sense in the process). Oh and the arsonist plot actually showed up. It was tight writing, great character growth and a good plot... too bad it was only a third of the book.
Sorry Lucky Harbor, but I'll be back because one not so great book doesn't deserve a jumping off of the plank.
While it still contained the quirky banter and feel-good romance of her previous books, Shalvis just missed base with this book. I spent the first 2/3 of the book confused as to Jack and Leah's stance relating to their relationship (or non-relationship in this case). Every time they conversed about their relationship they seemed to contradict the position they had at the beginning of the conversation. Jack and Leah also seemed to agree that there was no relationship, they didn't want a relationship and there would be no relationship. I kind of had to ask myself what the point of the conversation was. Everyone agreed - no relationship. So why did that scene just take up a chapter of this book?
I got pretty confused.
And a wee bit annoyed.
I waited and wanted this couple.
I wanted to like this couple.
So 1 star for the first 2/3 of the book and an extra 2 stars for the last third of the book. The last third gets it's shizzle together. It's tight, people have conversations and stick to the position they took at the start of the conversation, Jack and Leah pick a self-esteem issue and stick to it (finally making sense in the process). Oh and the arsonist plot actually showed up. It was tight writing, great character growth and a good plot... too bad it was only a third of the book.
Sorry Lucky Harbor, but I'll be back because one not so great book doesn't deserve a jumping off of the plank.
November 25, 2025
I'm loving re-reading this series. Jill Shalvis hinted at another book in her last newsletter so I figured I'd re-visit Lucky Harbor before that. Yes, there's profanity and graphic sex but the snarky dialogue and love story is so enjoyable that I'm being a hypocrite and enjoying every minute!
Second reading: So here's the thing: Jill Shalvis and her 12 funny, sexy, steamy Lucky Harbor series has kept me sane in an insane time. As we "shelter in place" during this worldwide pandemic, it's been so nice to escape to a place with lots of hunky men, snarky conversation, and a wealth of HEAs! Thank you, Jill Shalvis!!!!
Totally trashy, way more steamy than I usually read, fun brain candy. I’m on a kind of challenging business trip and these silly, sexy, totally unrealistic love stories are keeping me happy and sane.
Lots of graphic sex and some profanity.
Second reading: So here's the thing: Jill Shalvis and her 12 funny, sexy, steamy Lucky Harbor series has kept me sane in an insane time. As we "shelter in place" during this worldwide pandemic, it's been so nice to escape to a place with lots of hunky men, snarky conversation, and a wealth of HEAs! Thank you, Jill Shalvis!!!!
Totally trashy, way more steamy than I usually read, fun brain candy. I’m on a kind of challenging business trip and these silly, sexy, totally unrealistic love stories are keeping me happy and sane.
Lots of graphic sex and some profanity.
October 8, 2013
The set up
Leah Sullivan returns to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother Elsie with her bakery as she recuperates from knee surgery. Leah dropped out of pastry school and participated in a reality TV show that's now airing. Everyone thinks she's the winner but Leah's bound by contract to keep the outcome secret and she plans to bail before the final show. Jack Harper, firefighter and her best friend since the 8th grade, gets caught up in her fib to his mother when Leah tells her they're now a couple. See, he's never lost his feelings for her but isn't willing to risk his heart only to have her run away again.
The issues
Jack's mother is recovering from her battle with cancer but has been pretty depressed. Leah told the lie to lift her spirits (it did, in a big way). Jack's got some history that's made him commitment shy but both he and Leah have another pretense...their "pretend" relationship is actually what they each secretly want with each other.
What I enjoyed about this story
I like this town and it's quirky residents and they don't disappoint in this story. In addition to Facebook being the source for the latest gossip, Twitter has finally found its way there, too. Leah's friend Aubrey and Jack's friend Ben were funny and perfectly set up for their story. The real scene stealer, though, was Jack's Great Dane Kevin who I'm convinced is just masquerading as a dog (who names a dog Kevin???).
Leah and Jack are two very complicated people and I liked them individually and what they were to the people in their lives. Her baking was an expression of her soul and she instinctively knew what her customers needed. Sometimes I felt like I could smell her concoctions. Jack is pretty honorable and conscientious and is surrounded by all the people he's touched. He's followed in his father's footsteps as a firefighter and is committed to his mother's well being, which was heartwarming. He had his family take in his best friend when he needed it and was Leah's solace when life with her father was unbearable.
What was missing
I wish I could better define it but something was missing in Leah and Jack's romance and they both were responsible. Friends to lovers stories are on my list of favorites but the spark just wasn't there. It may be because both of them had commitment issues and weren't even truthful to themselves when we got their private points of view. Their interactions were just too breezy and too much emphasis was placed on Jack's dating history. I liked them together but I kept thinking their own hearts weren't in it until the last scene (which was really very good).
The bottom line
I enjoyed the story and my return to this charming town. Jack and Leah are well defined characters with interesting lives and friends who kept things lively. There are lots of funny and steamy moments, especially whenever Kevin was in a scene. I actually was more intrigued with Aubrey and Ben and can't wait for the next book. There was a lot to like about this book even if the romance didn't captivate me.
(I received an ARC from NetGalley)
Leah Sullivan returns to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother Elsie with her bakery as she recuperates from knee surgery. Leah dropped out of pastry school and participated in a reality TV show that's now airing. Everyone thinks she's the winner but Leah's bound by contract to keep the outcome secret and she plans to bail before the final show. Jack Harper, firefighter and her best friend since the 8th grade, gets caught up in her fib to his mother when Leah tells her they're now a couple. See, he's never lost his feelings for her but isn't willing to risk his heart only to have her run away again.
The issues
Jack's mother is recovering from her battle with cancer but has been pretty depressed. Leah told the lie to lift her spirits (it did, in a big way). Jack's got some history that's made him commitment shy but both he and Leah have another pretense...their "pretend" relationship is actually what they each secretly want with each other.
What I enjoyed about this story
I like this town and it's quirky residents and they don't disappoint in this story. In addition to Facebook being the source for the latest gossip, Twitter has finally found its way there, too. Leah's friend Aubrey and Jack's friend Ben were funny and perfectly set up for their story. The real scene stealer, though, was Jack's Great Dane Kevin who I'm convinced is just masquerading as a dog (who names a dog Kevin???).
Leah and Jack are two very complicated people and I liked them individually and what they were to the people in their lives. Her baking was an expression of her soul and she instinctively knew what her customers needed. Sometimes I felt like I could smell her concoctions. Jack is pretty honorable and conscientious and is surrounded by all the people he's touched. He's followed in his father's footsteps as a firefighter and is committed to his mother's well being, which was heartwarming. He had his family take in his best friend when he needed it and was Leah's solace when life with her father was unbearable.
What was missing
I wish I could better define it but something was missing in Leah and Jack's romance and they both were responsible. Friends to lovers stories are on my list of favorites but the spark just wasn't there. It may be because both of them had commitment issues and weren't even truthful to themselves when we got their private points of view. Their interactions were just too breezy and too much emphasis was placed on Jack's dating history. I liked them together but I kept thinking their own hearts weren't in it until the last scene (which was really very good).
The bottom line
I enjoyed the story and my return to this charming town. Jack and Leah are well defined characters with interesting lives and friends who kept things lively. There are lots of funny and steamy moments, especially whenever Kevin was in a scene. I actually was more intrigued with Aubrey and Ben and can't wait for the next book. There was a lot to like about this book even if the romance didn't captivate me.
(I received an ARC from NetGalley)
March 8, 2014
Frustrating read. Not for me.
My take on this is that the characters’ actions and words do not fit their motivations. The main story is the romantic relationship between Leah and Jack. The entire book is full of I don’t want you. I don’t like you. This is just pretend. Lets have sex. The next day Leah says that was a mistake. We can’t do that any more. Then she buys condoms. Then they have sex again. This goes round and round for the whole book.
Jack’s thoughts are I’m not going to fall for her because if she leaves me it will kill me. Then he kisses her and keeps seeing her.
There were many misunderstandings, but the worst one was when Jack heard that Leah was leaving town, so he breaks up with her. He thinks she is leaving for good. She doesn’t tell him it’s temporary. She is just silent.
These things frustrate me. The unusualness here was that Leah had issues with perfection and failure. This caused her to never finish anything - to always be a quitter whether it’s school, work, or Jack. I guess that’s why every day she is quitting her relationship with Jack - but he’s the love of her life. Bottom line - it was not a good story for me.
The best part was Kevin the dog.
There are many books in the series. This is book 8. And even though I did not like this story, there is something valuable and enjoyable. It’s like you’re there, living in a small town on the ocean, being part of the community, knowing everyone. There’s fun in that.
AUDIOBOOK NARRATOR:
The narrator Annie Greene was very good as a performer/narrator, but she says contractions in a way that jars me. Instead of couldn’t, hadn’t, etc., she says couldet and hadet. If speaking slowly she says couldunt, hadant, woulden. Every time she did this my mind went “what’s she doing?” I’m sorry for complaining, but I really prefer generic TV anchor speak.
DATA:
Narrative mode: 3rd person. Unabridged audiobook length: 9 hrs and 29 mins. Swearing language: strong including religious swear words but rarely used. Sexual language: mild. Number of sex scenes: 7. Setting: current day Lucky Harbor, Washington. Book copyright: 2013. Genre: contemporary romance.
My take on this is that the characters’ actions and words do not fit their motivations. The main story is the romantic relationship between Leah and Jack. The entire book is full of I don’t want you. I don’t like you. This is just pretend. Lets have sex. The next day Leah says that was a mistake. We can’t do that any more. Then she buys condoms. Then they have sex again. This goes round and round for the whole book.
Jack’s thoughts are I’m not going to fall for her because if she leaves me it will kill me. Then he kisses her and keeps seeing her.
There were many misunderstandings, but the worst one was when Jack heard that Leah was leaving town, so he breaks up with her. He thinks she is leaving for good. She doesn’t tell him it’s temporary. She is just silent.
These things frustrate me. The unusualness here was that Leah had issues with perfection and failure. This caused her to never finish anything - to always be a quitter whether it’s school, work, or Jack. I guess that’s why every day she is quitting her relationship with Jack - but he’s the love of her life. Bottom line - it was not a good story for me.
The best part was Kevin the dog.
There are many books in the series. This is book 8. And even though I did not like this story, there is something valuable and enjoyable. It’s like you’re there, living in a small town on the ocean, being part of the community, knowing everyone. There’s fun in that.
AUDIOBOOK NARRATOR:
The narrator Annie Greene was very good as a performer/narrator, but she says contractions in a way that jars me. Instead of couldn’t, hadn’t, etc., she says couldet and hadet. If speaking slowly she says couldunt, hadant, woulden. Every time she did this my mind went “what’s she doing?” I’m sorry for complaining, but I really prefer generic TV anchor speak.
DATA:
Narrative mode: 3rd person. Unabridged audiobook length: 9 hrs and 29 mins. Swearing language: strong including religious swear words but rarely used. Sexual language: mild. Number of sex scenes: 7. Setting: current day Lucky Harbor, Washington. Book copyright: 2013. Genre: contemporary romance.
June 25, 2021
My last Lucky Harbor book was in 2013. That's so long ago that I wasn't sure if I would be able to jump back in.
I did, jump back in but I honestly don't recall anything from the prior 7 books. Not a thing.
Anyway, I'm in a slump. Nothing seems to be working for me so I figured I try to get back to a series that I recall (oh see, I remember something) enjoying quite a bit.
I mostly enjoyed going back to Lucky Harbor but if I'm being honest, I just don't know if I liked Leah and Jack.
These two were supposed to be childhood into adulthood best friends. They have a connection and history and everything that should have made their transition to more than friends explosive.
I just never really felt the strong connection between them. When there were memories I got it but when they were together they didn't seem it if that makes sense.
I didn't really like Leah all that much. She for sure didn't seem to me at all that she would be "loved by the camera". Did she even ever smile in this story? She didn't seem to have any charisma or charm or well, anything but her baking skills.
I saw where another reviewer mentioned that the fake relationship was kind of unnecessary with all the history that Leah and Jack already had, that would have been enough for a friends to lover story and I agree. I guess it was a way to show how caring they were and what Jack's Mom meant to them both. But really, it was a little wonky.
Jack. Jack. Jack. Oh my. I did like him. All of him, haha! And I am over the moon happy for him and his new job!
The mystery was weaved nicely within the story. I knew who did it from the beginning but that didn't take away my enjoyment of it.
And lastly, Kevin. I love dogs, all animals actually and normally I'm a fan of them in my stories. I liked Kevin, I really did, he just had so much on page time and a lot of that was just not my kind of humor. So much gas, poop and eating of things (which, to me, wasn't all that funny, more dangerous) just seemed a little over the top.
The setup for the next one seems intriguing. Hopefully I'll continue and it won't take me 8 years this time.
I did, jump back in but I honestly don't recall anything from the prior 7 books. Not a thing.
Anyway, I'm in a slump. Nothing seems to be working for me so I figured I try to get back to a series that I recall (oh see, I remember something) enjoying quite a bit.
I mostly enjoyed going back to Lucky Harbor but if I'm being honest, I just don't know if I liked Leah and Jack.
These two were supposed to be childhood into adulthood best friends. They have a connection and history and everything that should have made their transition to more than friends explosive.
I just never really felt the strong connection between them. When there were memories I got it but when they were together they didn't seem it if that makes sense.
I didn't really like Leah all that much. She for sure didn't seem to me at all that she would be "loved by the camera". Did she even ever smile in this story? She didn't seem to have any charisma or charm or well, anything but her baking skills.
I saw where another reviewer mentioned that the fake relationship was kind of unnecessary with all the history that Leah and Jack already had, that would have been enough for a friends to lover story and I agree. I guess it was a way to show how caring they were and what Jack's Mom meant to them both. But really, it was a little wonky.
Jack. Jack. Jack. Oh my. I did like him. All of him, haha! And I am over the moon happy for him and his new job!
The mystery was weaved nicely within the story. I knew who did it from the beginning but that didn't take away my enjoyment of it.
And lastly, Kevin. I love dogs, all animals actually and normally I'm a fan of them in my stories. I liked Kevin, I really did, he just had so much on page time and a lot of that was just not my kind of humor. So much gas, poop and eating of things (which, to me, wasn't all that funny, more dangerous) just seemed a little over the top.
The setup for the next one seems intriguing. Hopefully I'll continue and it won't take me 8 years this time.
September 22, 2013
Always on My Mind: Number 8 in series (Lucky Harbor) Unfortunately, one of my least favorite Shalvis books to date. There is humor and charm.. but the main characters left something to be desired.More in depth review to come.
http://www.paranormalhaven.com/2013/0...
(Originally posted as a guest review)
I’m a nut for the cute and quirky contemporary romance novel, and Jill Shalvis has consistently delivered on all fronts. Always On My Mind is entry number eight within her Lucky Harbor series and features baker Leah Sullivan and the hunky fireman, Jack Harper. While the book is filled with Shalvis’ typical humor and charm, it mostly fell flat when it came to the overall execution.
Putting her baking skills to good use, Leah Sullivan has returned to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother at her bakery while avoiding the town’s questions about her recent stint on a reality tv cooking show. Sexy fireman Jack Harper has been Leah’s good friend since she was a teenager. Jack strenuously objects to the fib Leah tells his mother about the two of them being involved. Footloose and fancy free, Jack doesn’t let any woman get too close, but he reluctantly agrees to Leah’s deception.
Jack’s reasons for not wanting to get involved with Leah or anyone else for that matter come across as ordinary and foolish. He lost his dad at a young age and his mother never became involved with anyone else over the course of his life. He likes being a free agent and is well known for dating multiple women. There isn’t a lot of depth to his character and this led to me being pretty bored while I was reading.
Unfortunately for Always On My Mind, Leah’s character wasn’t any better. Raised by a verbally abusive father, Leah lacks the confidence that an otherwise bright and engaging woman might possess. Used to running when the going gets tough, she doesn’t really shed that part of her character.. and growth on her part didn’t come fast enough for me.
That being said, it’s not like the book isn’t without humor or charm. There are some great moments between Jack and Leah, especially at the beginning of their relationship “charade”. I also liked when the book took a few moments to highlight what presumably is the next couple, Ben and Aubrey. You met Aubrey in Ali’s book, It Had To Be You, and truth be told, I was more curious about Ben and Aubrey as opposed to Leah and Jack. There was an odd subplot in the book that involved several incidents of arson that ends with Leah being put in danger. This didn’t mesh with the overall tone of the book at all and had me wondering why it was put into the story in the first place.
In the hands of a different author, this story would be forgettable at best, and probably a DNF at worst. As Ms. Shalvis is an extremely capable author, I did like the story, but it’s not close to being one of my favorites.
http://www.paranormalhaven.com/2013/0...
(Originally posted as a guest review)
I’m a nut for the cute and quirky contemporary romance novel, and Jill Shalvis has consistently delivered on all fronts. Always On My Mind is entry number eight within her Lucky Harbor series and features baker Leah Sullivan and the hunky fireman, Jack Harper. While the book is filled with Shalvis’ typical humor and charm, it mostly fell flat when it came to the overall execution.
Putting her baking skills to good use, Leah Sullivan has returned to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother at her bakery while avoiding the town’s questions about her recent stint on a reality tv cooking show. Sexy fireman Jack Harper has been Leah’s good friend since she was a teenager. Jack strenuously objects to the fib Leah tells his mother about the two of them being involved. Footloose and fancy free, Jack doesn’t let any woman get too close, but he reluctantly agrees to Leah’s deception.
Jack’s reasons for not wanting to get involved with Leah or anyone else for that matter come across as ordinary and foolish. He lost his dad at a young age and his mother never became involved with anyone else over the course of his life. He likes being a free agent and is well known for dating multiple women. There isn’t a lot of depth to his character and this led to me being pretty bored while I was reading.
Unfortunately for Always On My Mind, Leah’s character wasn’t any better. Raised by a verbally abusive father, Leah lacks the confidence that an otherwise bright and engaging woman might possess. Used to running when the going gets tough, she doesn’t really shed that part of her character.. and growth on her part didn’t come fast enough for me.
That being said, it’s not like the book isn’t without humor or charm. There are some great moments between Jack and Leah, especially at the beginning of their relationship “charade”. I also liked when the book took a few moments to highlight what presumably is the next couple, Ben and Aubrey. You met Aubrey in Ali’s book, It Had To Be You, and truth be told, I was more curious about Ben and Aubrey as opposed to Leah and Jack. There was an odd subplot in the book that involved several incidents of arson that ends with Leah being put in danger. This didn’t mesh with the overall tone of the book at all and had me wondering why it was put into the story in the first place.
In the hands of a different author, this story would be forgettable at best, and probably a DNF at worst. As Ms. Shalvis is an extremely capable author, I did like the story, but it’s not close to being one of my favorites.
August 20, 2013
A copy of this book was provided to me by the publisher for an honest review at Romancing Rakes For The Love of Romance.
Always On My Mind is the newest entry in the Lucky Harbor small town contemporary series by Jill Shalvis, and a perfect example of why this series stands out in a category filled with so many other excellent competitors. In Always On My Mind, Jill Shalvis employs some of the most familiar romance tropes in such a way that they feel fresh and perfectly chosen to show how the past between its hero and heroine will become their present if they don’t heed the lessons learned this second time around.
Leah Sullivan has returned to her childhood home of Lucky Harbor to help run her grandmother’s bakery while that woman recovers from knee surgery, but doesn't intend to stay longer than she can help it. In Lucky Harbor, everybody knows everybody else’s business, and the last thing she wants is to be in the middle of all that when her appearance on the reality show competition, Sweet Wars, reaches its final episode.
When Jack Harper finds out that Leah is back in town, he’s not sure if he wants anything to do with her. They had been close friends back when Leah’s family still lived in Lucky Harbor, and only Jack knew how hard her family life had really been. She’d hurt him when she left town and it appeared to him that she’d never really stopped running. Ever since then, Jack had used his dangerous firefighter job as an excuse for never committing to a lasting relationship with anyone. But that didn't mean that Leah’s return would change anything, no matter what his ideas his mother Dee might have.
It’s clear from how Jack and Leah cautiously circle around each other in public that there’s more to their past than just a close childhood friendship, but it’s only when Leah claims a real relationship with Jack in an attempt to cheer up Dee that all hell breaks loose. The fake/pretend relationship romance trope is one of my favorites, and the way Jill Shalvis executes it in this story is something I haven’t seen very often. Because for both Jack and Leah, pretending they are dating and in love is genuinely painful, and it stirs up emotions that they both had thought were buried for good.
The town of Lucky Harbor with all its familiar characters and goings-on is the perfect setting for Jack and Leah’s story, providing a genuine sense of why each of them made the life choices which first kept them apart and now might finally bring them back together for good. But what I loved best about Always On My Mind was how Jill Shalvis neatly side-stepped the various plot devices that might have been used by a less sure-handed writer. Just because we all know there will be a Happily Ever After ending doesn't mean that the route there has to be simplistic or obvious. There were several points during the book where I thought something specific was definitely going to happen as the various subplots wound down, yet I was happy to be wrong every time.
It’s rare for a writer with a long-running series to hit it out of the park every single time. But Jill Shalvis has done exactly that with Always On My Mind. I highly recommend it to both longtime fans of the series and new readers, as it’s now officially my favorite Lucky Harbor book.
Favorite Quote:
Leah stopped at the foot of the stage and looked up at Jack. “I was wrong,” she said.
Jack curled a hand around his ear, like he hadn't caught her words.
“I was wrong,” she repeated.
“Oh, I heard you.” He smiled. “I just like the sound of the words on your lips.”
Always On My Mind is the newest entry in the Lucky Harbor small town contemporary series by Jill Shalvis, and a perfect example of why this series stands out in a category filled with so many other excellent competitors. In Always On My Mind, Jill Shalvis employs some of the most familiar romance tropes in such a way that they feel fresh and perfectly chosen to show how the past between its hero and heroine will become their present if they don’t heed the lessons learned this second time around.
Leah Sullivan has returned to her childhood home of Lucky Harbor to help run her grandmother’s bakery while that woman recovers from knee surgery, but doesn't intend to stay longer than she can help it. In Lucky Harbor, everybody knows everybody else’s business, and the last thing she wants is to be in the middle of all that when her appearance on the reality show competition, Sweet Wars, reaches its final episode.
When Jack Harper finds out that Leah is back in town, he’s not sure if he wants anything to do with her. They had been close friends back when Leah’s family still lived in Lucky Harbor, and only Jack knew how hard her family life had really been. She’d hurt him when she left town and it appeared to him that she’d never really stopped running. Ever since then, Jack had used his dangerous firefighter job as an excuse for never committing to a lasting relationship with anyone. But that didn't mean that Leah’s return would change anything, no matter what his ideas his mother Dee might have.
It’s clear from how Jack and Leah cautiously circle around each other in public that there’s more to their past than just a close childhood friendship, but it’s only when Leah claims a real relationship with Jack in an attempt to cheer up Dee that all hell breaks loose. The fake/pretend relationship romance trope is one of my favorites, and the way Jill Shalvis executes it in this story is something I haven’t seen very often. Because for both Jack and Leah, pretending they are dating and in love is genuinely painful, and it stirs up emotions that they both had thought were buried for good.
The town of Lucky Harbor with all its familiar characters and goings-on is the perfect setting for Jack and Leah’s story, providing a genuine sense of why each of them made the life choices which first kept them apart and now might finally bring them back together for good. But what I loved best about Always On My Mind was how Jill Shalvis neatly side-stepped the various plot devices that might have been used by a less sure-handed writer. Just because we all know there will be a Happily Ever After ending doesn't mean that the route there has to be simplistic or obvious. There were several points during the book where I thought something specific was definitely going to happen as the various subplots wound down, yet I was happy to be wrong every time.
It’s rare for a writer with a long-running series to hit it out of the park every single time. But Jill Shalvis has done exactly that with Always On My Mind. I highly recommend it to both longtime fans of the series and new readers, as it’s now officially my favorite Lucky Harbor book.
Favorite Quote:
Leah stopped at the foot of the stage and looked up at Jack. “I was wrong,” she said.
Jack curled a hand around his ear, like he hadn't caught her words.
“I was wrong,” she repeated.
“Oh, I heard you.” He smiled. “I just like the sound of the words on your lips.”
June 15, 2014
What a sweet, sweet escape! This book was fun, sexy, and a downright great read!' I forgot how much I missed the people of Lucky Harbor.
July 1, 2018
Oh my gosh. These two. I wanted to shake. them. so hard! lol
The Gist: Jack's mom is ill and in a glorious moment of pure special Leah decides to cheer her up by telling her that Jack and Leah? Well they're totally a couple! What was she thinking? Hell if anyone knows! Especially Jack who totally has girls he's dating and his best friend Leah...is not one of them.
Oh my. Yes, Jack and Leah were special. I enjoyed them, though. Jack s a solid guy. Firefighter, dependable, loves his mama and his goober of a great dane. It's hard not to love him. And Leah. She's a bit flighty and tends to run when things get tough but she's sweet and tries hard and is an amazing pastry chef.
They've been best friends since they were teenagers. They love each other and drive each other crazy. And wooboy did this throw their very platonic relationship into a tailspin. Which was pretty fun to watch. The town and I enjoyed that. Even if we were all shaking out heads at the two at the same time. There's some nice sparks and heat. And some total blunders.
A bit of suspense as suspected arson cases pop up around Lucky Harbor. Honestly that was probably the weakest point. It was super easy to figure out that element.
All in all, a pretty solid read.
The Gist: Jack's mom is ill and in a glorious moment of pure special Leah decides to cheer her up by telling her that Jack and Leah? Well they're totally a couple! What was she thinking? Hell if anyone knows! Especially Jack who totally has girls he's dating and his best friend Leah...is not one of them.
Oh my. Yes, Jack and Leah were special. I enjoyed them, though. Jack s a solid guy. Firefighter, dependable, loves his mama and his goober of a great dane. It's hard not to love him. And Leah. She's a bit flighty and tends to run when things get tough but she's sweet and tries hard and is an amazing pastry chef.
They've been best friends since they were teenagers. They love each other and drive each other crazy. And wooboy did this throw their very platonic relationship into a tailspin. Which was pretty fun to watch. The town and I enjoyed that. Even if we were all shaking out heads at the two at the same time. There's some nice sparks and heat. And some total blunders.
A bit of suspense as suspected arson cases pop up around Lucky Harbor. Honestly that was probably the weakest point. It was super easy to figure out that element.
All in all, a pretty solid read.
September 18, 2013
I’m a nut for the cute and quirky contemporary romance novel, and Jill Shalvis has consistently delivered on all fronts. Always On My Mind is entry number eight within her Lucky Harbor series and features baker Leah Sullivan and the hunky fireman, Jack Harper. While the book is filled with Shalvis’ typical humor and charm, it mostly fell flat when it came to the overall execution.
Putting her baking skills to good use, Leah Sullivan has returned to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother at her bakery while avoiding the town’s questions about her recent stint on a reality tv cooking show.Sexy fireman Jack Harper has been Leah’s good friend since she was a teenager. Jack strenuously objects to the fib Leah tells his mother about the two of them being involved. Footloose and fancy free, Jack doesn’t let any woman get too close, but he reluctantly agrees to Leah’s deception.
Jack’s reasons for not wanting to get involved with Leah or anyone else for that matter come across as ordinary and foolish. He lost his dad at a young age and his mother never became involved with anyone else over the course of his life. He likes being a free agent and is well known for dating multiple women. There isn’t a lot of depth to his character and this led to me being pretty bored while I was reading. Unfortunately for Always On My Mind, Leah’s character wasn’t any better. Raised by a verbally abusive father, Leah lacks the confidence that an otherwise bright and engaging woman might possess. Used to running when the going gets tough, she doesn’t really shed that part of her character..and growth on her part didn’t come fast enough for me.
That being said, it’s not like the book isn’t without humor or charm. There are some great moments between Jack and Leah, especially at the beginning of their relationship “charade”. I also liked when the book took a few moments to highlight what presumably is the next couple, Ben and Aubrey. You met Aubrey in Ali’s book, It Had To Be You, and truth be told, I was more curious about Ben and Aubrey as opposed to Leah and Jack. There was an odd subplot in the book that involved several incidents of arson that ends with Leah being put in danger. This didn’t mesh with the overall tone of the book at all and had me wondering why it was put into the story in the first place.
In the hands of a different author, this story would be forgettable at best, and probably a DNF at worst. As Ms. Shalvis is an extremely capable author, I did like the story, but it’s not close to being one of my favorites.
- Ronnie
Putting her baking skills to good use, Leah Sullivan has returned to Lucky Harbor to help out her grandmother at her bakery while avoiding the town’s questions about her recent stint on a reality tv cooking show.Sexy fireman Jack Harper has been Leah’s good friend since she was a teenager. Jack strenuously objects to the fib Leah tells his mother about the two of them being involved. Footloose and fancy free, Jack doesn’t let any woman get too close, but he reluctantly agrees to Leah’s deception.
Jack’s reasons for not wanting to get involved with Leah or anyone else for that matter come across as ordinary and foolish. He lost his dad at a young age and his mother never became involved with anyone else over the course of his life. He likes being a free agent and is well known for dating multiple women. There isn’t a lot of depth to his character and this led to me being pretty bored while I was reading. Unfortunately for Always On My Mind, Leah’s character wasn’t any better. Raised by a verbally abusive father, Leah lacks the confidence that an otherwise bright and engaging woman might possess. Used to running when the going gets tough, she doesn’t really shed that part of her character..and growth on her part didn’t come fast enough for me.
That being said, it’s not like the book isn’t without humor or charm. There are some great moments between Jack and Leah, especially at the beginning of their relationship “charade”. I also liked when the book took a few moments to highlight what presumably is the next couple, Ben and Aubrey. You met Aubrey in Ali’s book, It Had To Be You, and truth be told, I was more curious about Ben and Aubrey as opposed to Leah and Jack. There was an odd subplot in the book that involved several incidents of arson that ends with Leah being put in danger. This didn’t mesh with the overall tone of the book at all and had me wondering why it was put into the story in the first place.
In the hands of a different author, this story would be forgettable at best, and probably a DNF at worst. As Ms. Shalvis is an extremely capable author, I did like the story, but it’s not close to being one of my favorites.
- Ronnie
October 7, 2013
3 stars. Cute and charming book. Not my favorite in the series because I had a hard time connecting with jack and Leah. I found myself more interested in Ben and Aubrey and their story.
Read
December 8, 2013I'm pretty sure these Lucky Harbor books are my new crack. I'm going to start from the beginning and read them all, and I'm not one bit guilty about it.
August 15, 2018
AudioBook Review:
Stars: 4 Narration 4 Story 3
I hate to say it, but aside from some wonderful moments with Kevin, the intractable Great Dane, I had more trouble letting go of ‘expectations’ and rolling on with this friends to lovers story that started with a ‘fake’ relationship, added in a serial arsonist for tension, and allowed the heroine to take far too long to grow up. But I truly did adore Leah and understood her issues: it’s well-accepted that children who experience extreme traumas and abuse often circle that young age and have a harder time recovering from the abuse, and Leah had all of those hallmarks. Taking her father’s harsh words to heart, she’s not a finisher, she doesn’t revel in challenges or difficult moments, and while she relies on being ‘everything to everyone’, she’s often caught out stuffing her own feelings in lieu of playing the role.
Jack, for his part had enough issues and one is the four-legged terror named Kevin: eater of everything, single-minded and seeing himself as the world’s most adorable lap dog, yet every inch a Great Dane. Sure, Jack is wonderful with him, but he’s never directly dealing with the out-of-control pup like he should, and perhaps that reflects his own need to ignore his own stuff. His health – as a knee injury makes him less capable and competent at his job as a firefighter, the seeming ‘death-wish’ that he has in disregarding his own safety – perhaps a hangover from his firefighter father’s death on the job when he was young. But, Jack won’t let anyone close enough to hurt him again by leaving – and that includes his friend Leah.
Oh the back and forth in this one was almost interminable – they are so well suited, yet hide behind the subterfuge of a ‘relationship’ that pleases Jack’s mother, yet keep setting rules and guides in place – almost every one of which is soon broken. A serial arsonist purring all of the firefighters in danger, with clues aplenty as to identity yet Jack, the ‘always on’ guy missing near every one. And then their relationship – the slow burn, the attraction that both are denying and not believing in. It all felt overly protracted, and while some of the issues are resolved, I couldn’t wholly believe in a happy ever after ending for them: not without a determination on both sides to be honest, open and share everything – even when it scares them.
Narration for this story is provided by Annie Greene, and she managed to present Leah and her friends clearly and with solid personalities, bringing their emotions, friendship and camaraderie clearly to the front. For this is a story of friends and families, and each stood solidly here. Jack’s presentation was clear as well, and other characters that appeared were distinct and their interactions easy to understand and enjoy. I’m still a HUGE Shalvis fan, and can’t wait to get into the next book – I just didn’t love this one as much as others in the series.
I received an AudioBook copy of the title from Hachette Audio for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
Review first appeared at I am, Indeed
Stars: 4 Narration 4 Story 3
I hate to say it, but aside from some wonderful moments with Kevin, the intractable Great Dane, I had more trouble letting go of ‘expectations’ and rolling on with this friends to lovers story that started with a ‘fake’ relationship, added in a serial arsonist for tension, and allowed the heroine to take far too long to grow up. But I truly did adore Leah and understood her issues: it’s well-accepted that children who experience extreme traumas and abuse often circle that young age and have a harder time recovering from the abuse, and Leah had all of those hallmarks. Taking her father’s harsh words to heart, she’s not a finisher, she doesn’t revel in challenges or difficult moments, and while she relies on being ‘everything to everyone’, she’s often caught out stuffing her own feelings in lieu of playing the role.
Jack, for his part had enough issues and one is the four-legged terror named Kevin: eater of everything, single-minded and seeing himself as the world’s most adorable lap dog, yet every inch a Great Dane. Sure, Jack is wonderful with him, but he’s never directly dealing with the out-of-control pup like he should, and perhaps that reflects his own need to ignore his own stuff. His health – as a knee injury makes him less capable and competent at his job as a firefighter, the seeming ‘death-wish’ that he has in disregarding his own safety – perhaps a hangover from his firefighter father’s death on the job when he was young. But, Jack won’t let anyone close enough to hurt him again by leaving – and that includes his friend Leah.
Oh the back and forth in this one was almost interminable – they are so well suited, yet hide behind the subterfuge of a ‘relationship’ that pleases Jack’s mother, yet keep setting rules and guides in place – almost every one of which is soon broken. A serial arsonist purring all of the firefighters in danger, with clues aplenty as to identity yet Jack, the ‘always on’ guy missing near every one. And then their relationship – the slow burn, the attraction that both are denying and not believing in. It all felt overly protracted, and while some of the issues are resolved, I couldn’t wholly believe in a happy ever after ending for them: not without a determination on both sides to be honest, open and share everything – even when it scares them.
Narration for this story is provided by Annie Greene, and she managed to present Leah and her friends clearly and with solid personalities, bringing their emotions, friendship and camaraderie clearly to the front. For this is a story of friends and families, and each stood solidly here. Jack’s presentation was clear as well, and other characters that appeared were distinct and their interactions easy to understand and enjoy. I’m still a HUGE Shalvis fan, and can’t wait to get into the next book – I just didn’t love this one as much as others in the series.
I received an AudioBook copy of the title from Hachette Audio for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
Review first appeared at I am, Indeed
February 21, 2018
Leah and Jack's story was really fun to read. I love the way this starts out and how they become a couple. Lucky Harbor is a wonderful small town. Can't wait to read Aubrey and Ben's book.
October 8, 2019
Leah, o tânără patiser talentată, frumoasă, plină de viață, care nu are încredere în ceea ce poate realiza în viată datorită unui tată abuziv, care toată viața lui a desconsiderat-o. Cei care i-au fost întotdeauna alături au fost bunica Elsie și Jack — cel mai bun prieten al ei și pompierul orașului.
Jack este un tânăr amuzant, curajos, care evită să aibă o relație serioasă.
Totuși, datorită unei minciuni, cei doi ajung să fie împreună, au o relație. Cu toate că susțin că nu este una reală, toți din jurul lor își dau seama de adevăratele lor sentimente.
Ei când o vor face?
O carte foarte frumoasă și dulce.
Jack este un tânăr amuzant, curajos, care evită să aibă o relație serioasă.
Totuși, datorită unei minciuni, cei doi ajung să fie împreună, au o relație. Cu toate că susțin că nu este una reală, toți din jurul lor își dau seama de adevăratele lor sentimente.
Ei când o vor face?
O carte foarte frumoasă și dulce.
September 26, 2013
Review: Always On My Mind by Jill Shalvis Leah Sullivan has spent her whole life running and feeling like she is not good enough. Growing up with an abusive father did a real number on her psyche and she has never gotten over the things he said to her. She is back in Lucky Harbor running her grandmother’s bakery while she recovers from knee surgery and trying not to think about her recent stint on the show Sweet Wars. Unfortunately, the whole town is watching Sweet Wars eagerly awaiting the final outcome.
The one person that has always been there for her was Jack Harper. He has been her best friend since she was young. There might have been a time where they could have been more but Leah blew that by running, the thing she is best at. Since then they have kept those feeling buried deep until now when Leah steps in it. Trying to make Jack’s mom feel better she blurts out that they are dating. Nothing could be further from the truth but Jack agrees to keep up the pretense because he sees how happy his mom is.
Now Jack and Leah are stuck together and Jack has made it clear how much he really isn’t happy about the arrangement. For someone who is supposed to be Leah’s bff, Jack doesn’t seem to like her. In fact, there are several times where Leah comments that she is sorry he has to pretend to like her. That part was so confusing to me, they are said to have these long denied feelings but I didn’t ever get that vibe from Jack. If anything, he seemed annoyed most of the time and then pacified when sex was brought into the equation.
There is some of Ms. Shalvis’ trademark humor….
“So now you owe him.”
Leah quivered at the thought but brushed that aside. “I’m not going to sleep with Jack. I was just trying to do him a damn favor.”
“Oh, I doubt there will be any sleeping involved,” Aubrey said. “Danica was quite clear. she said she gives great date three. My guess is that it’s at least oral. Maybe even the biggie.”
“The biggie?”
“Butt stuff,” Aubrey said in a dramatic stage whisper.
…and an adorable dog named Kevin. Without those two things I would have considered stopping around the midway point. There was a little something lacking, something different from what we got from those first two trilogies in Lucky Harbor. It is kind of sad when I get excited to have Sawyer give Jack a ticket.
The last quarter of the book changed and that was because we finally saw Jack make up his mind. He made a firm decision and went forward with it instead of constantly bemoaning the fact that, though every woman in town seem to be throwing themselves at him, he couldn’t do anything about it. Really, how many women were going to rub in the fact that Leah had taken him off the market and he was not happy about it? So many times Jack would think about the feelings he had for Leah but they sure were buried underneath a bunch of thinking with his little head.
Another reason I read to the end was to find out how Leah came out in the Sweet Wars competition and then everyone’s reaction to that episode. I don’t want to spoil it but when that times does come I was fully involved in the book. Any reticence I had with the beginning had melted away.
Lucky Harbor is one of my favorite romantic contemporary series and Always On My Mind was a good installment. If you like this series then I think you will also enjoy this one. It wasn’t my favorite but I do have high hopes for the final book in this trilogy. Audrey is hysterically mean and Ben is a hot stuff badass and I think they will go well together. Final grade- B
Favorite Quote:
“How can you fall for the person who knows you better than anyone else?”
“The question is,” Aubrey said just as quietly, “how can you not?”
The one person that has always been there for her was Jack Harper. He has been her best friend since she was young. There might have been a time where they could have been more but Leah blew that by running, the thing she is best at. Since then they have kept those feeling buried deep until now when Leah steps in it. Trying to make Jack’s mom feel better she blurts out that they are dating. Nothing could be further from the truth but Jack agrees to keep up the pretense because he sees how happy his mom is.
Now Jack and Leah are stuck together and Jack has made it clear how much he really isn’t happy about the arrangement. For someone who is supposed to be Leah’s bff, Jack doesn’t seem to like her. In fact, there are several times where Leah comments that she is sorry he has to pretend to like her. That part was so confusing to me, they are said to have these long denied feelings but I didn’t ever get that vibe from Jack. If anything, he seemed annoyed most of the time and then pacified when sex was brought into the equation.
There is some of Ms. Shalvis’ trademark humor….
“So now you owe him.”
Leah quivered at the thought but brushed that aside. “I’m not going to sleep with Jack. I was just trying to do him a damn favor.”
“Oh, I doubt there will be any sleeping involved,” Aubrey said. “Danica was quite clear. she said she gives great date three. My guess is that it’s at least oral. Maybe even the biggie.”
“The biggie?”
“Butt stuff,” Aubrey said in a dramatic stage whisper.
…and an adorable dog named Kevin. Without those two things I would have considered stopping around the midway point. There was a little something lacking, something different from what we got from those first two trilogies in Lucky Harbor. It is kind of sad when I get excited to have Sawyer give Jack a ticket.
The last quarter of the book changed and that was because we finally saw Jack make up his mind. He made a firm decision and went forward with it instead of constantly bemoaning the fact that, though every woman in town seem to be throwing themselves at him, he couldn’t do anything about it. Really, how many women were going to rub in the fact that Leah had taken him off the market and he was not happy about it? So many times Jack would think about the feelings he had for Leah but they sure were buried underneath a bunch of thinking with his little head.
Another reason I read to the end was to find out how Leah came out in the Sweet Wars competition and then everyone’s reaction to that episode. I don’t want to spoil it but when that times does come I was fully involved in the book. Any reticence I had with the beginning had melted away.
Lucky Harbor is one of my favorite romantic contemporary series and Always On My Mind was a good installment. If you like this series then I think you will also enjoy this one. It wasn’t my favorite but I do have high hopes for the final book in this trilogy. Audrey is hysterically mean and Ben is a hot stuff badass and I think they will go well together. Final grade- B
Favorite Quote:
“How can you fall for the person who knows you better than anyone else?”
“The question is,” Aubrey said just as quietly, “how can you not?”
September 20, 2013
Review posted: Happily Ever After - Reads
Blog rating: C+
Best friends for years, Jack was Leah’s rock when she was growing up with a verbally abusive father. She’s never been able to finish things and find success in her life, due to the abuse and that includes her relationship with Jack. They came close years ago to moving beyond just friends, but Leah bailed and left Jack and Lucky Harbor. She went to school, but didn’t finish with one semester left, she ended up on a reality baking show, which is currently airing while she’s back in Lucky Harbor and she’s adamant that she hits the road again before the finale airs. But, she didn’t count on telling a little white lie to Jack’s mom who’s fighting cancer. To get her to smile and ease some of the guilt Jack’s mom is feeling about his lack of commitment to any relationship, Leah tells her that they’re dating. Jack’s mom is excited, but Jack – not so much.
These two best friends start having a pretend relationship with promises and ground rules that nothing is going to happen beyond the pretending. Yeah, right! Their feelings don’t stay pretend for very long, it takes one kiss for each of them to wonder what it would be like to truly be together. And once they are, especially for Jack, he seems more willing to see this relationship through, but he knows Leah and he knows it’s just a matter of time before she splits again.
While I liked the story well enough, something just felt like it was missing. Jack and Leah are nice together but I didn’t feel any sparks, chemistry, or even the banter that I’ve come to love in this series just wasn’t there. There are some sweet moments, especially when we find out just how rough Leah’s childhood was and how Jack and her Grandma were the only ones there for her. Those moments were heartbreaking and it does make sense about why Leah acts how she does now, but there was just something missing between them. I also thought they moved from friends to lovers pretty quick. Yes, they’ve known each other for years, but for some reason it seemed fast, even with the pretend relationship.
I did really enjoy Jack. He goes from a fire fighting playboy, trying to live up to his dad’s hero status, to all about Leah just like that, even when their relationship was pretend. He’s sexy, they’re sexy together, but still, I didn’t find myself caring about them. They’re definitely nice together and I loved the role Jack plays in Leah’s life as she struggles to step up and start making decisions for her and not based on her fears that come from the past.
The town felt a little more in the background then they have been in previous books. There are some fun girlfriend scenes with Leah, Ali and Aubrey, especially for Aubrey as her story is set up with Ben. And everyone should look out because Lucille is working both Facebook and now Twitter!
It’s virtually impossible to be disappointed with a Lucky Harbor book, and while I did like the story, I just can’t say it’s up there as one of my favorites in the series. I missed the banter and sexy chemistry that’s always been present in past books in the series. All that said, even though Always On My Mind didn’t work so well for me, Lucky Harbor still remains a place that I look forward to visiting again.
Blog rating: C+
Best friends for years, Jack was Leah’s rock when she was growing up with a verbally abusive father. She’s never been able to finish things and find success in her life, due to the abuse and that includes her relationship with Jack. They came close years ago to moving beyond just friends, but Leah bailed and left Jack and Lucky Harbor. She went to school, but didn’t finish with one semester left, she ended up on a reality baking show, which is currently airing while she’s back in Lucky Harbor and she’s adamant that she hits the road again before the finale airs. But, she didn’t count on telling a little white lie to Jack’s mom who’s fighting cancer. To get her to smile and ease some of the guilt Jack’s mom is feeling about his lack of commitment to any relationship, Leah tells her that they’re dating. Jack’s mom is excited, but Jack – not so much.
These two best friends start having a pretend relationship with promises and ground rules that nothing is going to happen beyond the pretending. Yeah, right! Their feelings don’t stay pretend for very long, it takes one kiss for each of them to wonder what it would be like to truly be together. And once they are, especially for Jack, he seems more willing to see this relationship through, but he knows Leah and he knows it’s just a matter of time before she splits again.
While I liked the story well enough, something just felt like it was missing. Jack and Leah are nice together but I didn’t feel any sparks, chemistry, or even the banter that I’ve come to love in this series just wasn’t there. There are some sweet moments, especially when we find out just how rough Leah’s childhood was and how Jack and her Grandma were the only ones there for her. Those moments were heartbreaking and it does make sense about why Leah acts how she does now, but there was just something missing between them. I also thought they moved from friends to lovers pretty quick. Yes, they’ve known each other for years, but for some reason it seemed fast, even with the pretend relationship.
I did really enjoy Jack. He goes from a fire fighting playboy, trying to live up to his dad’s hero status, to all about Leah just like that, even when their relationship was pretend. He’s sexy, they’re sexy together, but still, I didn’t find myself caring about them. They’re definitely nice together and I loved the role Jack plays in Leah’s life as she struggles to step up and start making decisions for her and not based on her fears that come from the past.
The town felt a little more in the background then they have been in previous books. There are some fun girlfriend scenes with Leah, Ali and Aubrey, especially for Aubrey as her story is set up with Ben. And everyone should look out because Lucille is working both Facebook and now Twitter!
It’s virtually impossible to be disappointed with a Lucky Harbor book, and while I did like the story, I just can’t say it’s up there as one of my favorites in the series. I missed the banter and sexy chemistry that’s always been present in past books in the series. All that said, even though Always On My Mind didn’t work so well for me, Lucky Harbor still remains a place that I look forward to visiting again.
May 14, 2019
A friends to lovers story about Leah, a baker, and Jack, a firefighter.
Leah and Jack had been best friends since Leah moved to Lucky Harbor and .
Years later, they're both grown up and Leah has returned to town after being away for a long while. She's still fighting with her demons, but is also a kind person who wants to help the people she cares about, so when Jack's mother who is suffering from cancer confides in her that she is worried about Jack's inability to have a real relationship with a woman, she lies to her and claims that the two of them are together.
Jack is puzzled, but wanting his mother to be happy so that she can recover sooner, he goes along with Leah's lie and the two start fake dating. Their chemistry is far from fake, however, and soon they start making and then breaking rules about their not so fake relationship.
Feelings might become stronger, but both of them have to deal with their own issues before a relationship between them can succeed.
A light story set in the familiar Lucky Harbor town with its many colorful residents. There is a Christmas novella next in the series, A Christmas to Remember, before we get Jack's cousin Ben's and Leah's friend Aubrey's story in Once in a Lifetime.
Previous book reviews:
✦ It Had to Be You (Lucky Harbor, #7)
✦ Under the Mistletoe (Lucky Harbor, #6.5)
✦ Forever and a Day (Lucky Harbor, #6)
✦ At Last (Lucky Harbor, #5)
✦ Lucky in Love (Lucky Harbor #4)
✦ Head Over Heels (Lucky Harbor #3)
✦ Kissing Santa Claus (Lucky Harbor #2.5)
✦ The Sweetest Thing (Lucky Harbor #2)
✦ Simply Irresistible (Lucky Harbor #1)
Leah and Jack had been best friends since Leah moved to Lucky Harbor and .
Years later, they're both grown up and Leah has returned to town after being away for a long while. She's still fighting with her demons, but is also a kind person who wants to help the people she cares about, so when Jack's mother who is suffering from cancer confides in her that she is worried about Jack's inability to have a real relationship with a woman, she lies to her and claims that the two of them are together.
Jack is puzzled, but wanting his mother to be happy so that she can recover sooner, he goes along with Leah's lie and the two start fake dating. Their chemistry is far from fake, however, and soon they start making and then breaking rules about their not so fake relationship.
Feelings might become stronger, but both of them have to deal with their own issues before a relationship between them can succeed.
A light story set in the familiar Lucky Harbor town with its many colorful residents. There is a Christmas novella next in the series, A Christmas to Remember, before we get Jack's cousin Ben's and Leah's friend Aubrey's story in Once in a Lifetime.
Previous book reviews:
✦ It Had to Be You (Lucky Harbor, #7)
✦ Under the Mistletoe (Lucky Harbor, #6.5)
✦ Forever and a Day (Lucky Harbor, #6)
✦ At Last (Lucky Harbor, #5)
✦ Lucky in Love (Lucky Harbor #4)
✦ Head Over Heels (Lucky Harbor #3)
✦ Kissing Santa Claus (Lucky Harbor #2.5)
✦ The Sweetest Thing (Lucky Harbor #2)
✦ Simply Irresistible (Lucky Harbor #1)
September 5, 2013
I've really enjoyed the Lucky Harbour series in the past, but this installment featuring Jack and Leah was a disappointment.
From the beginning I couldn't connect with either character. They were meant to be life long childhood friends and a lot of their story was based off this fact, with readers getting glimpses into moments from their past. But from the outset when the two characters interacted in the present of the story, they felt like strangers getting to know each other. Neither one acted comfortable or as if they'd known each other for ages. There was mention of the fact that they both knew each other better than anyone and yet I never once felt this was true. Leah and Jack were stilted and awkward with each other, their exchanges off and kind of like they were on a perpetual merry-go-round, repeating the same information over and over.
The whole premise of the story felt a bit off to me as well. Leah makes a split second decision to tell Jack's ill mother a fib to make her happy, that she and Jack are an item, and then they quickly decide to go ahead with the 'lie' but just 'pretend' to be lovers. But then quickly jump into bed with each other, although they set some stupid ground rules first - which just seemed pointless. The whole reason for their 'deception' seemed forced and kind of unreal and the reasons they each went along with it confusing and unstructured.
I can't say I really loved either character, and especially found Leah annoying and immature and her inability to be honest with herself or Jack was a constant irritant.
Also, it was a small thing but noticeable - every break in time in the story or start of a new section began with "the next morning..." or "the next day she/he..." it's an easy way to start a new section, but when every new part of the story starts this way or there was a flip in perspective it started to get tiresome.
Definitely not my favourite of the series.
I missed the flavour of Lucky Harbour and felt that this book could have been so much better.
I was intrigued by Ben and Aubrey though so I may just tune it to see where their story leads.
Thank you to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for giving me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review
From the beginning I couldn't connect with either character. They were meant to be life long childhood friends and a lot of their story was based off this fact, with readers getting glimpses into moments from their past. But from the outset when the two characters interacted in the present of the story, they felt like strangers getting to know each other. Neither one acted comfortable or as if they'd known each other for ages. There was mention of the fact that they both knew each other better than anyone and yet I never once felt this was true. Leah and Jack were stilted and awkward with each other, their exchanges off and kind of like they were on a perpetual merry-go-round, repeating the same information over and over.
The whole premise of the story felt a bit off to me as well. Leah makes a split second decision to tell Jack's ill mother a fib to make her happy, that she and Jack are an item, and then they quickly decide to go ahead with the 'lie' but just 'pretend' to be lovers. But then quickly jump into bed with each other, although they set some stupid ground rules first - which just seemed pointless. The whole reason for their 'deception' seemed forced and kind of unreal and the reasons they each went along with it confusing and unstructured.
I can't say I really loved either character, and especially found Leah annoying and immature and her inability to be honest with herself or Jack was a constant irritant.
Also, it was a small thing but noticeable - every break in time in the story or start of a new section began with "the next morning..." or "the next day she/he..." it's an easy way to start a new section, but when every new part of the story starts this way or there was a flip in perspective it started to get tiresome.
Definitely not my favourite of the series.
I missed the flavour of Lucky Harbour and felt that this book could have been so much better.
I was intrigued by Ben and Aubrey though so I may just tune it to see where their story leads.
Thank you to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for giving me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review
September 20, 2013
Jill Shalvis is a brand new author for me, let me just state for the record, I fell head over heels in love with her writing style. Always On My Mind is book 8 in her Lucky Harbor series; I never once felt like I was lost or missing anything important due to not reading the others. However, just an FYI, I will definitely continue reading more of Ms. Shalvis's work in the future! Her writing has reminded me of why I have been a big fan of Contemporary Romance for so long!
What I loved:
* I loved everything about this book from start to finish.
* The characters were well written and developed to perfection. I adored how different their personalities were in contrast to each other, yet they totally balanced each other out.
* I also had a blast with the interactions between Jack and Leah, their relationship is a mix of sweet and spicy, along with a bit of drama to round it all out.
* One of my favorite all time relationship types are the ones that mature from childhood friendship to soul mates. For me, this type of love always brings something special to the table, as I believe it makes them stronger and more connectable as a couple.
* The hero is a hot as hell firefighter; let me repeat that,HOT AS HELL FIREFIGHTER! Seriously, what's there not to love about a hometown hero?
* Any way, my list could go on forever, as I said I loved everything I experienced with this couple and their journey.
What I struggled with:
* Nada! Absolutely, nothing comes to mind.
Leah and Jack were super cute! These two blended with Jill's stimulating writing comes as a high recommend from me. As an added bonus, you don't even need to read this series in order. Therefore, if you're looking for a light quick engaging read, grab this hot firefighter and pastry chef and settle in for some warm entertaining chemistry.
Thank you, Jessica and Forever, for the opportunity to read and review an ARC of Always On My Mind in exchange for my honest opinion.
What I loved:
* I loved everything about this book from start to finish.
* The characters were well written and developed to perfection. I adored how different their personalities were in contrast to each other, yet they totally balanced each other out.
* I also had a blast with the interactions between Jack and Leah, their relationship is a mix of sweet and spicy, along with a bit of drama to round it all out.
* One of my favorite all time relationship types are the ones that mature from childhood friendship to soul mates. For me, this type of love always brings something special to the table, as I believe it makes them stronger and more connectable as a couple.
* The hero is a hot as hell firefighter; let me repeat that,HOT AS HELL FIREFIGHTER! Seriously, what's there not to love about a hometown hero?
* Any way, my list could go on forever, as I said I loved everything I experienced with this couple and their journey.
What I struggled with:
* Nada! Absolutely, nothing comes to mind.
Leah and Jack were super cute! These two blended with Jill's stimulating writing comes as a high recommend from me. As an added bonus, you don't even need to read this series in order. Therefore, if you're looking for a light quick engaging read, grab this hot firefighter and pastry chef and settle in for some warm entertaining chemistry.
Thank you, Jessica and Forever, for the opportunity to read and review an ARC of Always On My Mind in exchange for my honest opinion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 819 reviews