A thoroughly enjoyable and engrossing story, though in certain places a tad idealistic, my favorite part of this book was the infectiously passionate way Lisa wrote of Scotland, and the Highlands in particular. I felt these character's sorrows, joys, and what it means to be Scottish, and even though Lisa made the rather unusual choice to write this book almost exclusively from the first person perspective of the heroine, the hero's wonderful inner traits, personality, and inner dreams and struggles all came across the page with crystal-like clarity, creating a warm love story tenderly and believably told.
But I think the thing which sticks out most in my mind as to why I loved it so was how much it reminded me of Outlander, in no small part due to the fact that most of it takes place during Bonnie Prince Charlie's rebellion. The completely horrific and utterly unnecessary massacre that occurred at Culloden and after has never been brought home to me with such bruising intensity, and the story and characters were all the better for it. The trials, anguish and loneliness each went through was tempered though by their absolute love and trust in God, even when it seemed down-right impossible to keep holding on; it gave me hope for my own life as well.