Review: Born: A History of Childbirth by Lucy Inglis
As a feminist and a public health practitioner, I approached Born: A History of Childbirth with a mix of professional curiosity and personal reverence for the subject matter. Lucy Inglis’s sweeping historical account of childbirth is both a celebration and a sobering reminder of how deeply gender, power, and medicine intersect in the most intimate of human experiences. While the book is not explicitly framed as a feminist or public health text, its unflinching examination of childbirth’s evolution resonated with my work on maternal health disparities and bodily autonomy.
Emotional Reactions: A Journey Through Joy and Injustice
Reading Born was an emotional rollercoaster. There were moments of awe—learning about ancient birthing practices that centered women’s autonomy (like standing or squatting positions depicted in historical carvings)—and moments of rage, as Inglis meticulously documents how medicalization often stripped women of agency, relegating childbirth to a clinical, male-dominated spectacle. The chapters on forced sterilizations and coercive interventions hit particularly hard, echoing contemporary public health battles over reproductive justice. I found myself alternating between admiration for the resilience of birthing people throughout history and fury at the systemic injustices they’ve endured.
Constructive Criticism: A Feminist Lens on the Gaps
While Inglis’s research is undeniably thorough, I occasionally wished for a more explicit feminist critique of the power structures shaping childbirth. For instance, the book could have delved deeper into how race and class intersect with these histories—such as the forced sterilizations of marginalized women or the criminalization of pregnancy in certain populations. These issues are hinted at but not fully explored, leaving room for a more intersectional analysis. That said, I recognize that Born is a historical survey, not a manifesto; my critique stems from the public health practitioner in me who sees these connections daily.
Gratitude & Final Thoughts
Thank you to the publisher for the free copy. Born is a vital contribution to the canon of maternal health literature, offering both a tribute to the past and a mirror to our present struggles. For public health workers, it’s a reminder that the fight for equitable, respectful childbirth is centuries old—and far from over. Inglis’s work left me equal parts inspired and galvanized, a testament to its power.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) — A richly researched, emotionally charged history that will resonate with anyone invested in gender equity and health justice.
Note: My perspective is inevitably shaped by public health’s focus on structural inequities, but this book’s historical grounding offers invaluable context for today’s maternal health advocacy.