I had high hopes for this book.
I was super intrigued by this book. I had no idea who came up with the term "Jump the Shark", I just knew it was a term I'd been hearing for a very long time. The introduction to this book gave such a fun history, and led me to believe I was REALLY going to enjoy the chapters about television shows.
WOW is that introduction misleading! Awful!
And not just because I didn't agree with a large portion of where he said shows, celebrities, and musicians jumped the shark. (Also sports, but who gives a shit about sports?) Not everyone is going to agree on a subject like this, because if you're a fan of a show, you are a fan, and if you enjoyed it to the end, clearly you thought it was worth sticking around for.
I mean, there's a chapter on Buffy the Vampire Slayer. I am CLEARLY an impartial judge when I say um no.
Also, he says Madonna jumped the shark when she went from pop diva to sex crazed. Uh, really? Because I'm pretty sure she was doing damn great until we got to her Kabbalah phase.
Also, MAN can I tell how old this book is. Not even one mention of Tom Cruise jumping on the couch. I can just imagine his shark related metaphor for that one.
I feel for him with the shark metaphors. As someone who used to write blogs, I realize how difficult it can be to keep saying the same thing over and over again, and trying to find fun ways to work it. But dude. Just...just stop mentioning sharks, can you do that? We get it. We actually got it when, at the beginning of each chapter, the question is asked, "When did _____ jump the shark?"
We're not going to forget we're talking about sharks. Please stop mentioning fins and circling and blood in the water. Please.
I'd like an updated version of this book to come out, with some heavy editing, and over 10 years worth of bad shows and badly behaved celebrities to cover.