I really enjoy this rather peculiar series. It's actually quite dark, despite the humor and the concept of a walking, talking, skeletal tough as nails detective. The further along this series gets, the less I feel it is a friendly domain for younger readers. If you're the precocious sort who started reading adult novels at the age of 11, then sure, this is still harmless. But it's quite violent and has some very dark themes.
I started this as a loan from the library, and I was gutted that I ran out of time and it had to go back, in the middle of a crucial scene. I absolutely had to buy the audiobook off Audible, and I have no regrets. I already downloaded the sequel.
Four books in, we see Valkyrie's (aka Stephanie)'s character maturing and becoming more of an independent and completely capable fighter for good in her own right. She's developing both her elemental magic and necromancy skills. I love that she actually saves Skulduggery and won't give up on him when he's given up on himself. They learn more about each other, the dark secrets that he broods over, and her dark future destiny. A cabal of their enemies form a formidable plan for revenge that could have world-breaking consequences, and the two have to work with their small group of allies to save the world. I like the dimension to the characters, as you learn that the good guys aren't always as good as you'd like to think, and vice versa. The motives of the characters go deep and give you something to think about. Although some of the side characters are not always heavily fleshed out, I didn't feel like there were any unsatisfyingly cardboard characters.
I'm loving how each book makes the world bigger, and no plot threads are left dangling. There's plenty of action and harrowing moments. There's some of the standard supernatural creatures, but also some unique kinds of being, along with distinctive twists on the old themes. I mean, Spring-Heeled Jack is a character!
If I were to quibble, I would say the author's writing style is more telling than showing, but somehow, it doesn't come off as passive or less interesting. Where things leave off, there's evidence that things are going to continue along the dark pat this book begins.
The narrator is great, giving each character just the right inflection. He is a hug part of why the jokes land so well. He also gives the baddies, and often Skulduggery and his allies, all the menace that is a part of their characterization.
I've never read anything like these books, that's for sure. I never thought I'd get so involved with this series that I picked up from the library on a lark. I think ten-year-old me would have ate this up, just as much as me who is a whole lot older than that!
A well deserved 4.5/5.0 stars.