Over the last fifteen years, Jane Connor has become further and further estranged from her younger sister, Esme. So when she gets a surprise call from her one evening on the brink of a violent thunderstorm, she’s taken aback. The news that Esme has left her wealthy, blue-blooded husband and wants to crash with Jane at their childhood home is shocking—but definitely welcome—news. Perhaps this will be an opportunity for the two to finally mend their relationship—one that was fractured after what Jane did when she was just seventeen.
The only problem is that Esme needs a ride and, with the impending storm, the last thing Jane wants to do is drive. After all, the cleavage of their lives can trace back to another such evening when lightning lit the sky. Jane must make a decision—face her fear after all these years and hurry to her impulsive sister’s side or make Esme take control of her own life regardless of whatever trouble she might be in. The choice itself splits Jane’s life into two—the reality in which she rescued her sister and the alternative that left Esme in the city alone.
In the reality in which Jane races into the city, she finds herself face-to-face with a barely grateful Esme. Within days, she’s become a less than gracious houseguest who refuses to supply even the smallest detail about her life and what fills her days. It seems that Jane’s hope for fixing their relationship is hardly going to happen, as she finds Esme giving her an increasingly cold shoulder. The situation only gets worse until the friction finally explodes and the two must at last deal with the deep, dark secret from their past. Will it bring them together once and for all? Or will it ruin both of their lives?
In the other reality, Jane refuses to drive in the thunderous rain and suggests Esme crash with a friend. Just twenty-four hours later, however, her sister has vanished. With the police not seeming to care, Jane feels compelled to search for her sister instead. The more she looks, though, the more secrets she seems to uncover. Running the gamut from good news to alarm-inducing, Jane begins to wonder if the truth to why Esme disappeared lies in the past. Will she be able to piece everything together in time? Or has Esme vanished for good?
Wowzers. What a truly thought provoking book! From the start, The Split pulled me in deep as the diverging timelines took me down a thoroughly twisty path that ended with quite the duo of shocking events. Together, they were an impressive rollercoaster ride complete with plenty of red herrings and alternate theories, leaving me spellbound from the very first word. Add in the thick backstories and well-developed characters, and it was a definite hole in one to this thriller loving snob.
It was the plot that was pure dynamite, though. As the two storylines split into separate thriller timelines of home and gone, the events branched and then merged over and over, raising the idea that no matter our choices, sometimes the results just might be a foregone conclusion. Just the same, the deftly played climax and poignant finish left me utterly shocked and with my jaw on the floor. The only thing that irked me with latter was the somewhat open ending. IYKYK, but I’m not a huge fan of those.
As for those characters, Esme and Jane were masterfully illustrated through vivid character studies that showed two very different sisters. As the secrets were unfurled, those contradictions were never more apparent and I grew to side with first one sibling and then the other until the final reveal. At the same time, however, I would’ve liked a bit more exploration of the past before the end of the book. I can’t say much more or it will spoil the plot, but, needless to say, it would’ve definitely rounded out the riveting premise.
The only teeny, tiny complaint that I had was the somewhat repetitive nature that the prose took on over the course of the novel. Granted, this was natural considering the split timelines and similar events, but when phrases were repeated word for word, it became a bit much. In the end, though, it didn’t detract all that much as I fell in love with this novel hook, line, and sinker.
All in all, this was quite the triumph with two dynamite thrillers between one gorgeous cover. With enticing family drama, a tempting mystery in the past, and almost more secrets and lies than I could count, I was over the moon. So despite its minor flaws, this debut adult thriller was yet another slam dunk by Kit Frick. Now I’m eagerly awaiting whatever she comes up with next—be it for teens or adults—as I’m game for either. Rating of 4 stars.
Thank you to Kit Frick and Emily Bestler Books/Atria for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: February 13, 2024
Scroll down for my potentially plot spoiling trigger list.
Trigger warning: dementia, a missing sibling, death of a parent, drunk driving, suicide, mention of: drug overdose, infidelity, forced captivity