What do you think?
Rate this book
All For #2
All for a Story
Monica Brisbane loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away--and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the "Capitol Chatter" newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves. Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson's paper, "The Bridal Call," but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the "Capitol Chatter," infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane. Under Max's direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
384 pages, Paperback
First published October 1, 2013
39 people are currently reading
704 people want to read
About the author
Allison Pittman
32 books655 followersAllison Pittman is the author of For Time and Eternity, Stealing Home, the Crossroads of Grace series, and her nonfiction debut, Saturdays With Stella. A high-school English teacher, she serves as director of the theater arts group at her church. She is also the co-president of a dynamic Christian writers group in the San Antonio, Texas area, where she makes her home with her husband and their three boys.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews
July 20, 2014
Max Moore's uncle died and left him his newspaper, which Max wants to spruce up with stories of virtue and heroism. Miss Monica's Bisbaine's column, Monkey Business, is all about the vice and sneakiness of the underworld, and she feels her position at the paper is threatened by his intentions.
I found it difficult to muster much sympathy for Monica. She had so much attitude, a stirrer and troublemaker all through. She was disrespectful of Max's position as boss and full of backchat. She put a huge emphasis on material luxuries, scorning honest, plainer girls like Anna and Zelda. And most annoying of all, she kept going out with that contemptible Charlie, even when she found out he was cheating on his wife. Apart from the moral implications, I was hoping she'd get tired of the patronising way he called her 'Mousie'.
I liked Max a lot more, but was puzzled that he'd fall head over heels in love with Monica so quickly. He kept mentioning his glimpses of a warmer, more vulnerable side to her, but I kept flipping back, wondering where he got them from. His attraction seemed to be based on her looks, her witty comeback lines and her small stature, none of which reveal much about character.
Even at the end, I'm not convinced theirs would be a match that would last the distance. She admits to herself that she flounders whenever she can't fall back on the flirting and sassy talk she's built as a way of life. She's not the sort of person I can imagine slipping easily into the role of devoted wife and later mother, making unwise, impulsive decisions until the very end. If you're into Jane Austen, it's like having a role reversal, with shallow Isabella Thorpe made heroine of Northanger Abbey, instead of Catherine Morland.
My favourite bits were Monica's flashes of conscience, which made her squirm. I like the honest principles of Alice Reighley, the president of the anti-flirting society. It's revealed that other girls who live more simple lives envy the lavish and flamboyant lifestyle Monica presents in her column. The story reveals this to be a farce built on lies, glitzy possessions and exaggerations. In reality, Monica's lifestyle is lean and hungry at the best of times.
This book is written in a cheerful tone, with some cute quotes such as 'His smile at their reaction produced a pair of dimples that might have been a pair of bullets, seeing how they brought the girls to clutch at their hearts.' If the novel had focused on Max's cleaning up of the paper (and we never get to see the public reception to that), and his relationship with his uncle, I might have enjoyed it more than focusing on the romance, which is a weird thing for a romance lover like me to say.
I found it difficult to muster much sympathy for Monica. She had so much attitude, a stirrer and troublemaker all through. She was disrespectful of Max's position as boss and full of backchat. She put a huge emphasis on material luxuries, scorning honest, plainer girls like Anna and Zelda. And most annoying of all, she kept going out with that contemptible Charlie, even when she found out he was cheating on his wife. Apart from the moral implications, I was hoping she'd get tired of the patronising way he called her 'Mousie'.
I liked Max a lot more, but was puzzled that he'd fall head over heels in love with Monica so quickly. He kept mentioning his glimpses of a warmer, more vulnerable side to her, but I kept flipping back, wondering where he got them from. His attraction seemed to be based on her looks, her witty comeback lines and her small stature, none of which reveal much about character.
Even at the end, I'm not convinced theirs would be a match that would last the distance. She admits to herself that she flounders whenever she can't fall back on the flirting and sassy talk she's built as a way of life. She's not the sort of person I can imagine slipping easily into the role of devoted wife and later mother, making unwise, impulsive decisions until the very end. If you're into Jane Austen, it's like having a role reversal, with shallow Isabella Thorpe made heroine of Northanger Abbey, instead of Catherine Morland.
My favourite bits were Monica's flashes of conscience, which made her squirm. I like the honest principles of Alice Reighley, the president of the anti-flirting society. It's revealed that other girls who live more simple lives envy the lavish and flamboyant lifestyle Monica presents in her column. The story reveals this to be a farce built on lies, glitzy possessions and exaggerations. In reality, Monica's lifestyle is lean and hungry at the best of times.
This book is written in a cheerful tone, with some cute quotes such as 'His smile at their reaction produced a pair of dimples that might have been a pair of bullets, seeing how they brought the girls to clutch at their hearts.' If the novel had focused on Max's cleaning up of the paper (and we never get to see the public reception to that), and his relationship with his uncle, I might have enjoyed it more than focusing on the romance, which is a weird thing for a romance lover like me to say.
May 19, 2017
Strike two for me and this author. This book felt odd, like the first one in the series. I didn't connect with the characters at all and I really hated Monica. She had some qualities and so hardships that were supposed to endear her to me, but I didn't like her.
The author has a lot of talent, It just isn't my style. I think I will skip on any future Pittman books.
The author has a lot of talent, It just isn't my style. I think I will skip on any future Pittman books.
July 13, 2017
This was a free purchase from Amazon before I had read the first story-All for a Song. I was intrigued by the synopsis of 1920s flapper journalist who writes a gossip column but then has the opportunity to change her flirtatious lifestyle. Unfortunately this fell flat for me. It was too cliche, too superficial and too rushed at times.
October 24, 2016
After fully enjoying All For a Song, I was a bit disappointed with All For a Story.
It took me several chapters to figure out the formatting (perhaps only a Kindle version issue). Once I figured out the formatting, I settled in and started to enjoy Max and Monica's story. Max inherited a publication that shares the fringes of society. Monica is happily living on the fringes. Max bring propriety to the publication and influences Monica's actions.
It was a good story and I look forward to continuing this series with All For a Sister.
It took me several chapters to figure out the formatting (perhaps only a Kindle version issue). Once I figured out the formatting, I settled in and started to enjoy Max and Monica's story. Max inherited a publication that shares the fringes of society. Monica is happily living on the fringes. Max bring propriety to the publication and influences Monica's actions.
It was a good story and I look forward to continuing this series with All For a Sister.
February 7, 2014
This is such a fun series. It's fresh and different from the usual Christian fiction I read. "All for a Story" is the second book in Allison Pittman's roaring twenties series. It has very little connection to the first book in the series, "All for a Song".
Monica, the heroine in the story is a journalist and a flapper.Max is the sweet,charming hero who is Monica's boss. I enjoyed reading how Monica changed and grew through out the story. Like some of the other books I've read by Pittman, the ending felt a little rushed, if not somewhat flat in comparison to the rest of this amazingly written book. I say this is a must read for all Christian fiction readers. By the way, great book cover!
Monica, the heroine in the story is a journalist and a flapper.Max is the sweet,charming hero who is Monica's boss. I enjoyed reading how Monica changed and grew through out the story. Like some of the other books I've read by Pittman, the ending felt a little rushed, if not somewhat flat in comparison to the rest of this amazingly written book. I say this is a must read for all Christian fiction readers. By the way, great book cover!
October 16, 2013
Um, this lady should never stop writing, first of all.
You get lost in her books and there's no way out.
This story is a story about a girl who realized that stories could have happily ever after. :)
You get lost in her books and there's no way out.
This story is a story about a girl who realized that stories could have happily ever after. :)
May 24, 2019
I loved Pittman's novels that were set in earlier time periods, but I'm not normally attracted to books set in the 1920s. I'm glad I took a chance on this one, though. It was a fun read, with a great message for modern women.
April 23, 2014
About this book:
“Monica Brisbane loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away--and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the "Capitol Chatter" newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson's paper, "The Bridal Call," but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the "Capitol Chatter," infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.Under Max's direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.”
Series: “All for” book #2. { I have not read book #1 “All for a Song” }
Spiritual Content- Proverbs 15:22, Philippians 4:8 and other Scriptures are quoted; Prayers are said; Max has a Faith and witnesses to Monica *spoiler* and near the end Monica wants to “come clean” and become a Christian. *end of spoiler*
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘screw’ and two ‘swanky’s; Lots of drinking & smoking.
Sexual Content- Minor (sexual) cussing including: one ‘floozy’; Flirting, lots of flirting *spoiler* after meeting with the Anti-Flirt club and couple of times, Monica tries not to flirt. *end of spoiler*; A couple of sayings: Tony says “Nothing but s*x, s*x, s*x” when talking about flirting, and Zelda says “Not like you modern girls, flaunting yourselves with your smoking and your s*x”; One very detailed kiss; Monica dates a married man and tries to break-up with him mid-way through the book, much to his ire.
-Monica Bisbaine
-Max Moore
P.O.V. switches between them.
355 pages
Set in 1923
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre & New Teens-
One star
Older High School Teens-
Three Stars
My personal Rating-
Three Stars
“All for a Story” would have gotten a much lower rating from me if it had ended differently. ;) While best for older teens (because of the flirting, smoking and going to clubs) I enjoyed it and am looking forward to reading the first book “All for a Song” and the third book “All for a Sister” coming out later this year.
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher for this review.
“Monica Brisbane loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away--and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the "Capitol Chatter" newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson's paper, "The Bridal Call," but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the "Capitol Chatter," infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.Under Max's direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.”
Series: “All for” book #2. { I have not read book #1 “All for a Song” }
Spiritual Content- Proverbs 15:22, Philippians 4:8 and other Scriptures are quoted; Prayers are said; Max has a Faith and witnesses to Monica *spoiler* and near the end Monica wants to “come clean” and become a Christian. *end of spoiler*
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘screw’ and two ‘swanky’s; Lots of drinking & smoking.
Sexual Content- Minor (sexual) cussing including: one ‘floozy’; Flirting, lots of flirting *spoiler* after meeting with the Anti-Flirt club and couple of times, Monica tries not to flirt. *end of spoiler*; A couple of sayings: Tony says “Nothing but s*x, s*x, s*x” when talking about flirting, and Zelda says “Not like you modern girls, flaunting yourselves with your smoking and your s*x”; One very detailed kiss; Monica dates a married man and tries to break-up with him mid-way through the book, much to his ire.
-Monica Bisbaine
-Max Moore
P.O.V. switches between them.
355 pages
Set in 1923
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre & New Teens-
One star
Older High School Teens-
Three Stars
My personal Rating-
Three Stars
“All for a Story” would have gotten a much lower rating from me if it had ended differently. ;) While best for older teens (because of the flirting, smoking and going to clubs) I enjoyed it and am looking forward to reading the first book “All for a Song” and the third book “All for a Sister” coming out later this year.
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher for this review.
October 25, 2013
I won a copy from Goodreads First Reads.
Oy! We have an oldie book! All For A Story is a Christian, Historical Fiction, and New Adult to Adult book. But truly, it's not Monica who's a true Christian. It's Max Moore.
All For A Story doesn't give me a thrill like so many other books despite the fact that the ever so thirsty gossip, Monica Brisbane, hangs out in clubs with mobsters and gangsters. It's still pretty good considering that I read the entire book, without considering abandoning it. (Yeah, I have an incredible will to do things. *Roll eyes*)
I like the writing in the book because it's quite attractive and keeps me interested in the story. I feel that there's still something quite missing in the book. Maybe some other piece of information, the author is holding back? Or perhaps it's just a fidget of my imagination? Or maybe it's the plot. The plot is slow paced, just slow enough that you'll understand the story, but too slow for the events to get the blood flowing. Or maybe it's because of the characters? (Ha! The characters are definitely holding something back. Both of them are, Max and Monica).
Let's talk about Max Moore. That guy's a piece of something. Something is hot and hunky. I swear, Max is probably one of the reasons I keep reading. He's ambitious, wanting to turn Capitol Chatter into a "normal paper". (Please, how many "normal" newspapers are out there in the world. There's always a few criticizing the government. A little gossip trash isn't going to harm anyone, unless it's true of course. I never believe the tabloid magazines.) What else about this guy? Max really likes change, only if it is going towards his ideals (who isn't like that?). I don't really see a big change in his character for Max. Oh, yeah, he's definitely holding a secret back. Not a very shameless one though.
Monica Brisbane is a shameless flirt who isn't afraid of becoming a modern girl. She flirts. She gossips (like old ladies). She drinks. She goes to bars. She winks. And she flirts in a funeral. (My new best friend!) What about her ambitions? Well, she's smart and funny. She won't stop until she gets what she truly wants. She has the most amazing character development throughout All For A Story.
The ending of All For A Story is a complete wreck. I'm left open-mouthed, jaw on the floor by how completely nuts the author is because of how she left the ending. I wouldn't even call that an end! That's a hint-hint.
Rating: Three out of Five
-ofpaperandwords.blogspot.com
Oy! We have an oldie book! All For A Story is a Christian, Historical Fiction, and New Adult to Adult book. But truly, it's not Monica who's a true Christian. It's Max Moore.
All For A Story doesn't give me a thrill like so many other books despite the fact that the ever so thirsty gossip, Monica Brisbane, hangs out in clubs with mobsters and gangsters. It's still pretty good considering that I read the entire book, without considering abandoning it. (Yeah, I have an incredible will to do things. *Roll eyes*)
I like the writing in the book because it's quite attractive and keeps me interested in the story. I feel that there's still something quite missing in the book. Maybe some other piece of information, the author is holding back? Or perhaps it's just a fidget of my imagination? Or maybe it's the plot. The plot is slow paced, just slow enough that you'll understand the story, but too slow for the events to get the blood flowing. Or maybe it's because of the characters? (Ha! The characters are definitely holding something back. Both of them are, Max and Monica).
Let's talk about Max Moore. That guy's a piece of something. Something is hot and hunky. I swear, Max is probably one of the reasons I keep reading. He's ambitious, wanting to turn Capitol Chatter into a "normal paper". (Please, how many "normal" newspapers are out there in the world. There's always a few criticizing the government. A little gossip trash isn't going to harm anyone, unless it's true of course. I never believe the tabloid magazines.) What else about this guy? Max really likes change, only if it is going towards his ideals (who isn't like that?). I don't really see a big change in his character for Max. Oh, yeah, he's definitely holding a secret back. Not a very shameless one though.
Monica Brisbane is a shameless flirt who isn't afraid of becoming a modern girl. She flirts. She gossips (like old ladies). She drinks. She goes to bars. She winks. And she flirts in a funeral. (My new best friend!) What about her ambitions? Well, she's smart and funny. She won't stop until she gets what she truly wants. She has the most amazing character development throughout All For A Story.
The ending of All For A Story is a complete wreck. I'm left open-mouthed, jaw on the floor by how completely nuts the author is because of how she left the ending. I wouldn't even call that an end! That's a hint-hint.
Rating: Three out of Five
-ofpaperandwords.blogspot.com
March 22, 2014
All for A Story by Allison Pittman has quickly become a favorite for me. I have been so excited about this series for so long, and with each book it seems to get better and better. Every time I pick up an Allison Pittman book I am amazed at the wild ride I go on. She writes with such an elegance and honesty that brings goose bumps to my arms. Somehow every emotion fills each page, each word, and before I know it I’m carried away on the wings of the story, taken far away, never to return. It is a fact well known to me that when I read a book by Allison Pittman that I will be pondering the outcome for a long time to come. There is never a dull moment, and the minute I think I know what’s going on, I’m taken by surprise once again. In all honesty, there are too many things I could say about Allison’s writing style and elegance, and it would take all day, therefore I’ll refrain.
Monica Brisbaine’s personality caught my attention the instant I started reading, and before I knew it I was falling in love with her character. It is a rare thing for me to like the girl characters in books, since most times I feel that they are annoying and fickle. Yet, with Monica (and most of Ms. Pittman’s female characters as well), I felt an instant connection and tug on my heart. Her background story was very well thought out and believable, and definitely warranted the emotional strain that I could feel in Monica’s personality. Her struggle throughout the book to understand where she belonged and how to love was touching, and I couldn’t help but root for her and hope that she would find a true love in Christ.
On another note, there was Max Moore. Goodness, I could go on and on about Max! Truly, I believe him to be one of my all time favorite male characters of 2013. He had so much going for him; a strong personality that made him incredibly likeable, a deep faith in God, and a desire to do the right thing. He wasn’t overly perfect, but rather always striving to be the best he could be. Putting his stable personality with Monica’s flirty and untamed one made for a fun, wonderfully written story that sucked me in from the start!
Don’t hesitate to try Allison’s books for yourself. There is no doubt in my mind that you will be captivated from the very start, just as I was!
Monica Brisbaine’s personality caught my attention the instant I started reading, and before I knew it I was falling in love with her character. It is a rare thing for me to like the girl characters in books, since most times I feel that they are annoying and fickle. Yet, with Monica (and most of Ms. Pittman’s female characters as well), I felt an instant connection and tug on my heart. Her background story was very well thought out and believable, and definitely warranted the emotional strain that I could feel in Monica’s personality. Her struggle throughout the book to understand where she belonged and how to love was touching, and I couldn’t help but root for her and hope that she would find a true love in Christ.
On another note, there was Max Moore. Goodness, I could go on and on about Max! Truly, I believe him to be one of my all time favorite male characters of 2013. He had so much going for him; a strong personality that made him incredibly likeable, a deep faith in God, and a desire to do the right thing. He wasn’t overly perfect, but rather always striving to be the best he could be. Putting his stable personality with Monica’s flirty and untamed one made for a fun, wonderfully written story that sucked me in from the start!
Don’t hesitate to try Allison’s books for yourself. There is no doubt in my mind that you will be captivated from the very start, just as I was!
July 17, 2014
A poor excuse for Christian fiction
A terribly disappointing story. This book claims to be "Religious", "Christian fiction", "Inspirational." It is none of those. While the writing itself is decent, the story felt like Christianity was an after thought, something included to get particular people to read it. In theory, the book is about trying to make a tabloid a place for inspiration for a good life, but the truth is the novel glamorizes what it claims to condemn. In fact, the story would probably be more compelling outside of the Christian genre, because then the poor choices made fit into the worldview instead of knowingly making bad choices - and receiving good as a consequence. Because of these glaring inconsistencies I cannot recommend this book.
A terribly disappointing story. This book claims to be "Religious", "Christian fiction", "Inspirational." It is none of those. While the writing itself is decent, the story felt like Christianity was an after thought, something included to get particular people to read it. In theory, the book is about trying to make a tabloid a place for inspiration for a good life, but the truth is the novel glamorizes what it claims to condemn. In fact, the story would probably be more compelling outside of the Christian genre, because then the poor choices made fit into the worldview instead of knowingly making bad choices - and receiving good as a consequence. Because of these glaring inconsistencies I cannot recommend this book.
October 28, 2013
I loved the story. I loved how she brought the roaring twenties to life and how despite the era of what was going on, you always have God to turn to. I only wished the ending didn't end like that. I was looking for more.
May 6, 2019
Monica the female key player in this book was complex. A very young woman intent on leading her anonymous flapper lifestyle she was hard to like or feel any sympathy toward. She made bad decisions over and over again defying anyone to correct her. When her job was threatened by new boss Max it didn’t get much better. Max was likable but also too much of an innocent soul who didn’t seem to have much backbone at first. I read the entire book and found there was a series along the same lines as All For a Story. I am not inclined to read any of the others. The story moved slow and the characters not that interesting.
April 15, 2025
Pittman has crafted an exquisite masterpiece! I was immediately immersed into the drama. This novel is well written and nicely paced. These characters will linger long after turning the final pages. Deep spiritual truths are woven amongst the pages. I'm looking forward to reading the next installment in this series.
Recommend to readers who enjoy historical fiction.
I borrowed a copy from KU. I have expressed my honest view.
Recommend to readers who enjoy historical fiction.
I borrowed a copy from KU. I have expressed my honest view.
September 28, 2021
What a fun read! Plus it encouraged me. It's a pleasure to learn some details about a new era. My grandmother grew up at this time period and was a fan of the new Atlantic City Beauty Pageant, which is mentioned in the book. I was sorry that the book ended!
February 26, 2018
Loved the story. I think we all have a little Monica in us that comes out from time to time. Max was a delightful hero, and I enjoyed all the minor characters as well. Great series!
December 27, 2018
This was very well written and an enjoyable read.
October 12, 2019
An editor from Amie Lee McPhearson's newsletter inherits his uncle's gossip rag in D.C. and sets out to turn it to positive news during the flapper era.
July 26, 2021
????? the ending was kinda abrupt. max and monica weren't interesting though, and the story felt flat to me
January 14, 2022
An absolutely lovely book. I thoroughly enjoyed it. It transported me back to the 1920's and made me want to be monkey girl.
March 26, 2024
If there were a "less than zero" option, I would use that.
Totally stupid and a waste of time. Didn’t get past 20 pages and gave up.
Totally stupid and a waste of time. Didn’t get past 20 pages and gave up.
December 13, 2013
Monica Brisbane loves being a modem girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column takes her to all the local speakeasies in Washington D. C. and she loves dancing the night away scoping put new stories for her column. However, her future takes an uncertain turn when the owner of Capitol Chatter passes away, leaving Monica what will happen to her job and her beloved lifestyle.
Max Moore might hold the position of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson's paper, the Bridal Call, but it's clear that Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max finds out that his great uncle has passed away and left him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and moves to Washington D.C. to hopefully become a real editor-in-chief. He tries to clean up the scandalous paper and infuse it with his own values, but he's soon bumping heads with the equally determined Monica Brisbane.
With Max's guidance Monica goes on her most challenging assignment yet, infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Reluctant at first, Monica meets and mi goes with the girls but soon begins to doubt the wisdom of her flirtatious ways and when romance starts to blossom between her and Max, Monica must choose between the lifestyle the club chooses or the lifestyle she lived for so long.
Will Monica ever change her party and flirtatious lifestyle or will she continue down the path of destruction? Will Max trade everything for Monica or will he be able to convince Monica that there is a life without speakeasies and flirting? Will Max be able to turn the Capitol Chatter into a respectable paper or will he lose the fight against immorality? Can Monica change her ways or is she forever a party girl?
----------------------------
Due to my opinion of Allison Pittman's last novel, I wasn't expecting much out of this book. I fully expected to struggle through this one like the last and hate it at the end. I didn't. I actually enjoyed this one. Though my opinion of the enigmatic Aimee Semple McPherson hasn't budged an inch, I did enjoy the plot line for this and how radically different it was from the previous book in this series. I think Allison Pittman did a much better job with this book than the last.
This book had a romance! And a fairly good one at that. The character of Monica is uniquely lovable from the get-go and Max's serious nature didn't seem like it would mesh with Monica's but somehow the author managed to craft a romance that was sweet and lovable. Though it wasn't the best romance I've ever read, it was definitely welcomed compared to the completely confusing disaster of a semi-romance in the last book.
Usually I don't love women crusaders or women evangelist ever in a story, but I loved Alice Reighly and her Anti-Flirt campaign, probably because even though some of her rules are a bit stiff and outrageous, the general idea is one I follow everyday and never thought twice about it. It basically encourages women to not encourage the bad behavior of men by flirting back or making light of it. I think the idea is one every woman should consider to follow.
The story of this one was more engaging and felt less like I was watching a horrible tragedy happen right before my eyes, thankfully in that story the accident never happened but it still left a sour mark for me. In this story, there were moments of disappointment or like it might go down the disastrous path again but it pulled out of those situations and was actually a pretty nice story. I would've liked to have seen more of a transformation in Monica but part of me felt like this was a different look at how some people come to Christ.
This author gave me a much better story with this or and made me very glad that I didn't throw out all hope with the last book. Though I still don' love the radical type style that this author chooses, I think I'm becoming more accustomed to it and haven't given up hope yet of finding an amazing book by her. This book was good but I don't recommend it for just anyone.
Overall, I enjoyed this book a lot more than the previous book by her but I' still not sold on her writing just yet. This book is perfect for fans of Allison Pittman or fans of the Roaring Twenties. Keep this book away from your children this one is definitely not recommended for anyone other than adults. I give this book a four out of five.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for this review. All opinions expressed are my own.*
August 31, 2014
Allison Pittman in her new book, “All For A Story” Book Two in the All For A series published by Tyndale House Publishers brings us into the life of Monica Bisbaine.
From the Back Cover: Monica Bisbaine loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away—and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the Capitol Chatter newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.
Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, The Bridal Call, but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his great-uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the Capitol Chatter, infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Bisbane.
Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
Max is a man of morals, Monica is a flirt that likes to party and go to the speakeasys. She is even seeing a married man. Max takes over the newspaper that Monica is the gossip reporter for and Max sends her to the anti-flirt society for a story. Monica is a fish-out-of-water trying to learn why these women are trying to live against the very lifestyle that she lives. What do you do when your world is shaken and turned upside down? Allison Pittman is an extraordinary writer and she has assembled a unique cast of characters to bring this highly interesting story to life. Hope, restoration, and change are all brought to the table as Monica works with what she discovers. This is a page-turner as the story is highly interesting and you do not want to miss a moment of what is going on. Allison Pittman knows how to weave a captivating story with wonderful characters that breathe. I enjoyed reading this book and look forward to more from this highly talented author.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Tyndale House Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
From the Back Cover: Monica Bisbaine loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away—and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the Capitol Chatter newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.
Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, The Bridal Call, but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his great-uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the Capitol Chatter, infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Bisbane.
Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
Max is a man of morals, Monica is a flirt that likes to party and go to the speakeasys. She is even seeing a married man. Max takes over the newspaper that Monica is the gossip reporter for and Max sends her to the anti-flirt society for a story. Monica is a fish-out-of-water trying to learn why these women are trying to live against the very lifestyle that she lives. What do you do when your world is shaken and turned upside down? Allison Pittman is an extraordinary writer and she has assembled a unique cast of characters to bring this highly interesting story to life. Hope, restoration, and change are all brought to the table as Monica works with what she discovers. This is a page-turner as the story is highly interesting and you do not want to miss a moment of what is going on. Allison Pittman knows how to weave a captivating story with wonderful characters that breathe. I enjoyed reading this book and look forward to more from this highly talented author.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Tyndale House Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
December 1, 2013
Allison Pittman consistently delivers novels rooted firmly in faith and history. I am always excited to delve into her stories and experience the past. "All for a Story" reads like a 1920's movie, with flappers, speakeasies, dancing, and dialogue that seems completely authentic to the time period. Pittman also introduces readers to another product of the 1920s - the Anti-Flirt Society. The incorporation of less well-known pieces of history is one of the reasons that I love Allison Pittman's novels. She is an expert in blending historical facts into the body of a meaningful plot. Pittman delves deeper than the flappers of the Roaring Twenties to give readers a new perspective on the era.
From speakeasies to anti-flirt meetings, Monica Brisbaine will go almost anywhere for a story for her Monkey Business newspaper column. The Monkey Business columns are clever additions to the plot with turns of phrase that seem like they could be straight from the 1920s. They show Monica as a woman who is well-versed in worldly ways, a cynical character with rough edges behind a polished veneer. Her flirtatious, flapper facade hides her true emotions. The layers begin to peel away when she meets her new boss, Max Moore, a man who is much more innocent than she. He challenges Monica's newspaper column and her entire way of life.
Max is a sweet hero, striving to live an honest and clean life and quietly showing his love for Monica. Unfortunately, Monica is not accustomed to being treated like a lady, and the road to her heart is a challenging journey. It is frustrating to watch Monica continue to keep Max at a distance, and she never seems to fully open up to him. As a result, the love story aspect of the plot feels a little unfinished. When the novel concludes, Monica seems to finally begin to open her heart to both Max and the readers. I have never had difficulty connecting with Pittman's characters in the past, but Monica is a challenge. Although her character softens throughout the plot, her wall never completely comes down, leaving me feeling detached. Regardless of my lack of connection, Monica's flapper persona is solidly constructed and a stark contrast to Max's more staid personality.
"All for a Story" is a well-written novel with fascinating history. I always recommend Allison Pittman's novels to other readers, and this one is no exception.
I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers through Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
From speakeasies to anti-flirt meetings, Monica Brisbaine will go almost anywhere for a story for her Monkey Business newspaper column. The Monkey Business columns are clever additions to the plot with turns of phrase that seem like they could be straight from the 1920s. They show Monica as a woman who is well-versed in worldly ways, a cynical character with rough edges behind a polished veneer. Her flirtatious, flapper facade hides her true emotions. The layers begin to peel away when she meets her new boss, Max Moore, a man who is much more innocent than she. He challenges Monica's newspaper column and her entire way of life.
Max is a sweet hero, striving to live an honest and clean life and quietly showing his love for Monica. Unfortunately, Monica is not accustomed to being treated like a lady, and the road to her heart is a challenging journey. It is frustrating to watch Monica continue to keep Max at a distance, and she never seems to fully open up to him. As a result, the love story aspect of the plot feels a little unfinished. When the novel concludes, Monica seems to finally begin to open her heart to both Max and the readers. I have never had difficulty connecting with Pittman's characters in the past, but Monica is a challenge. Although her character softens throughout the plot, her wall never completely comes down, leaving me feeling detached. Regardless of my lack of connection, Monica's flapper persona is solidly constructed and a stark contrast to Max's more staid personality.
"All for a Story" is a well-written novel with fascinating history. I always recommend Allison Pittman's novels to other readers, and this one is no exception.
I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers through Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
December 29, 2013
Monica Brisbaine loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away—and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the Capitol Chatter newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.
Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, The Bridal Call, but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his great-uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the Capitol Chatter, infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.
Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
All for a Story by Allison Pittman is a sweet and witty novel that captures the pace and beliefs of the Roaring Twenties with brilliant color. The plot line is fast paced, interesting, and contains an interesting blend of romance, humor, and heart-ache. The only thing that I did not really like was how the book ended. It concluded rather abruptly, and I would have loved to have had more closure on Monica's change of heart and her relationship with Max. The themes of the novel are clear and include topics such as trusting God, asking him and others for forgiveness, and choosing a life of morality over immorality. The narration of the novel was third person but the perspective from which it was told alternated between Max and Monica so that the reader had an idea of what both were thinking. The characters of Max and Monica were realistic and interesting. The complete oppositeness of their personalities made their exchanges amusing and enjoyable. As they learned more about each other, their oftentimes judgmental attitudes towards one another began to soften and they started to see beyond the flaws to the person beneath that God created. Overall, I highly enjoyed this novel, and I would highly recommend All for a Story and All for a Song by Allison Pittman to any reader looking for an inspiring and interesting historical novel.
Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, The Bridal Call, but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his great-uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the Capitol Chatter, infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.
Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
All for a Story by Allison Pittman is a sweet and witty novel that captures the pace and beliefs of the Roaring Twenties with brilliant color. The plot line is fast paced, interesting, and contains an interesting blend of romance, humor, and heart-ache. The only thing that I did not really like was how the book ended. It concluded rather abruptly, and I would have loved to have had more closure on Monica's change of heart and her relationship with Max. The themes of the novel are clear and include topics such as trusting God, asking him and others for forgiveness, and choosing a life of morality over immorality. The narration of the novel was third person but the perspective from which it was told alternated between Max and Monica so that the reader had an idea of what both were thinking. The characters of Max and Monica were realistic and interesting. The complete oppositeness of their personalities made their exchanges amusing and enjoyable. As they learned more about each other, their oftentimes judgmental attitudes towards one another began to soften and they started to see beyond the flaws to the person beneath that God created. Overall, I highly enjoyed this novel, and I would highly recommend All for a Story and All for a Song by Allison Pittman to any reader looking for an inspiring and interesting historical novel.
April 7, 2014
From Goodreads:
Monica Brisbane loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away–and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the “Capitol Chatter” newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, “The Bridal Call,” but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the “Capitol Chatter,” infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
My Thoughts:
This is going to be more of a mini review. Although it hasn’t been long since I read the book, it really didn’t stick out enough for me to remember the details. I hate when that happens. I was instantly drawn to the book because of the journalism angle.
One thing I liked about Pittman’s writing in this book is that it was still modern. There are many historical fiction books that I have read that I have a hard time getting through because the language isn’t necessarily the same as today. I know that it may be more historically accurate, but I never do well with them. Pittman did a great job of making me feel like I was back in the Roaring 20s with her writing.
I did enjoy Monica’s character… mostly. I liked how independent she was and she was very strong and outspoken. However, we weren’t morally on the same page. I did love her column in the paper though. Scandalous little thing that Monica Brisbane is.
However, with my likes, the story itself just fell short for me. There were parts, including threats from gangsters and Monica growing up a little throughout the book, but it just wasn’t my cup of illegal liquor.
I give All for a Story 3 out of 5 bookmarks. It is getting a lot of love on Goodreads though. Make sure to click the link below to read some more reviews.
Monica Brisbane loves being a modern girl in the Roaring Twenties. Her job writing a gossip column allows her access to all the local speakeasys in Washington, D.C., where she can dance the night away–and find fodder for her next article. But when the owner of the “Capitol Chatter” newspaper passes away, Monica wonders what will happen to her job, and the lifestyle she loves.Max Moore may hold the title of editor-in-chief for evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s paper, “The Bridal Call,” but Aimee calls all the shots. So when Max learns that his uncle has passed away, leaving him all his earthly possessions, Max resigns and heads to D.C. Determined to take over the “Capitol Chatter,” infuse it with his values, and turn it into a respectable paper, Max is soon bumping up against the equally determined Monica Brisbane.Under Max’s direction, Monica embarks on her most challenging assignment yet: infiltrating and reporting on the Anti-Flirt Society. Though reluctant at first, as Monica meets and mingles with the young women of the club, she begins to question the innocence of her flirtatious lifestyle. And when romance begins to blossom between Max and Monica, she must choose where her loyalties lie: with the young women of the society or the alluring pull of the speakeasy and its inhabitants.
My Thoughts:
This is going to be more of a mini review. Although it hasn’t been long since I read the book, it really didn’t stick out enough for me to remember the details. I hate when that happens. I was instantly drawn to the book because of the journalism angle.
One thing I liked about Pittman’s writing in this book is that it was still modern. There are many historical fiction books that I have read that I have a hard time getting through because the language isn’t necessarily the same as today. I know that it may be more historically accurate, but I never do well with them. Pittman did a great job of making me feel like I was back in the Roaring 20s with her writing.
I did enjoy Monica’s character… mostly. I liked how independent she was and she was very strong and outspoken. However, we weren’t morally on the same page. I did love her column in the paper though. Scandalous little thing that Monica Brisbane is.
However, with my likes, the story itself just fell short for me. There were parts, including threats from gangsters and Monica growing up a little throughout the book, but it just wasn’t my cup of illegal liquor.
I give All for a Story 3 out of 5 bookmarks. It is getting a lot of love on Goodreads though. Make sure to click the link below to read some more reviews.
May 27, 2014
All for a Story (click on book or see below for description)
by Allison Pittman
Downloaded free from Amazon on 5/4/14 (Released October 2013)
Rating: 4 bones
Finish Time: Too long because of my move. But a fun book that I really enjoyed! Monica Bisbaine aka “Monkey”, is an anonymous writer of a gossip column titled “Monkey Business” for a local New York paper during the 20′s (a decade I very much enjoy reading about.) I found out this book was loosely based on an actual writer known as “Lipstick” who wrote for The New Yorker in the 1920′s. (Fun fact the author shared at the end!)
To gather material for her column, Monica frequents many local speakeasies and is the topic of much conversation when her articles are published as they are vague, but could lead to trouble for some of the owners. Thus her need for anonymity. She has her share of male friends, one in particular, Charlie, who pops up throughout the book.
Early in the book, her boss, the owner of the paper where she works, passes away suddenly and everyone is worried for their jobs, especially Monica, as he tended to look the other way when it came to her column. But in comes the owner’s great-nephew Max Moore. With a strong faith, he has a different direction in mind for the paper, particularly Monica’s column. First order of business was to investigate the rising popularity of the “Anti-Flirt Club.” Again another real fun fact thrown in. Many chapters begin with one of their “rules” in their movement to empower women against unwanted male attention. (See below)
Flirting was definitely a gift of Monica’s (and I’d dare to say necessity in her field), so this “mission” was quite an interesting fit for her. But through it she meets other women, gets some good/bad (depends how you look at it) press from her column, and grows alongside Max. Both thrust into a world of unknowns, it is a good story with a few twists and turn thrown in. One being a bit unexpected, but really an almost coming of age, questioning who you are/want to be story. Monica is spunky, stubborn, opinionated, and makes for a fun main character!
Great read, fun read, I think you’ll like it!
http://mydogearedpurpose.com/2014/05/...
by Allison Pittman
Downloaded free from Amazon on 5/4/14 (Released October 2013)
Rating: 4 bones
Finish Time: Too long because of my move. But a fun book that I really enjoyed! Monica Bisbaine aka “Monkey”, is an anonymous writer of a gossip column titled “Monkey Business” for a local New York paper during the 20′s (a decade I very much enjoy reading about.) I found out this book was loosely based on an actual writer known as “Lipstick” who wrote for The New Yorker in the 1920′s. (Fun fact the author shared at the end!)
To gather material for her column, Monica frequents many local speakeasies and is the topic of much conversation when her articles are published as they are vague, but could lead to trouble for some of the owners. Thus her need for anonymity. She has her share of male friends, one in particular, Charlie, who pops up throughout the book.
Early in the book, her boss, the owner of the paper where she works, passes away suddenly and everyone is worried for their jobs, especially Monica, as he tended to look the other way when it came to her column. But in comes the owner’s great-nephew Max Moore. With a strong faith, he has a different direction in mind for the paper, particularly Monica’s column. First order of business was to investigate the rising popularity of the “Anti-Flirt Club.” Again another real fun fact thrown in. Many chapters begin with one of their “rules” in their movement to empower women against unwanted male attention. (See below)
Flirting was definitely a gift of Monica’s (and I’d dare to say necessity in her field), so this “mission” was quite an interesting fit for her. But through it she meets other women, gets some good/bad (depends how you look at it) press from her column, and grows alongside Max. Both thrust into a world of unknowns, it is a good story with a few twists and turn thrown in. One being a bit unexpected, but really an almost coming of age, questioning who you are/want to be story. Monica is spunky, stubborn, opinionated, and makes for a fun main character!
Great read, fun read, I think you’ll like it!
http://mydogearedpurpose.com/2014/05/...
January 19, 2015
Monica Bisbaine loves all that the Roaring Twenties has to offer. She is frequently heading to the speakeasys and other places that a good girl really shouldn't be at. Yet, she finds herself wanting more. When Max Moore inherits the paper that Monica writes for, he is determined to bring changes to it. He wants to make it more than a tabloid. He wants to turn it into an uplifting and encouraging paper. When Max tells Monica that she needs to infiltrate the Anti-Flirt Club and to write a piece about them, Monica resists. Yet as she gets into the assignment, she discovers that maybe it's time for her to quit being the way that she is and to truly change.
It's been a long time since I read one of Allison Pittman's books. I can't really say why other than they've not made it onto my radar. This one was one I saw I had on my Kindle and saw it was on the Summer Reading list, so I thought why not.
I found it rather hard to hold my attention. Parts of it were really good. But I also thought that parts were really dull. Maybe it was the language of the Twenties. Maybe it was the way that Monica didn't really want to change. I don't know. It left me feeling a little disappointed.
I'm also not really sure that I liked the way that the threads of the story were not completely resolved. I liked the hopeful ending, but the way that that ending came about, I think I missed something. I know it's part of a series, but I also know it stands alone.
Still it was rich in historical detail. Others may enjoy this, but for me, this time period isn't one I really like to read about.
I read this book as part of the Tyndale Summer Reading Program. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction, Roaring Twenties, Jessica Dotta
Rating - 3 stars
It's been a long time since I read one of Allison Pittman's books. I can't really say why other than they've not made it onto my radar. This one was one I saw I had on my Kindle and saw it was on the Summer Reading list, so I thought why not.
I found it rather hard to hold my attention. Parts of it were really good. But I also thought that parts were really dull. Maybe it was the language of the Twenties. Maybe it was the way that Monica didn't really want to change. I don't know. It left me feeling a little disappointed.
I'm also not really sure that I liked the way that the threads of the story were not completely resolved. I liked the hopeful ending, but the way that that ending came about, I think I missed something. I know it's part of a series, but I also know it stands alone.
Still it was rich in historical detail. Others may enjoy this, but for me, this time period isn't one I really like to read about.
I read this book as part of the Tyndale Summer Reading Program. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction, Roaring Twenties, Jessica Dotta
Rating - 3 stars
November 4, 2013
Firstly, and as usual, it must be noted that I didn't buy this book. Instead, it came to me for free as the result of a Shelf Awareness giveaway. Despite that kind consideration, I give my candid opinions in this review. Also, it should be noted that I'm not a Christian so it may seem a bit odd for me to be reviewing Christian literature. Nonetheless, I'll review this book based on its literary merits and ignore any philosophical differences I may have with the genre.
On the positive side, the book is very competently executed and it's set in a period of history that's always amusing and vastly underutilized in literature. Pittman gives us a colorful and alluring rendering of the era and some fairly interesting characters.
To the negative, the Christian aspects of the novel seem to be an affectation and are poorly integrated. It's almost as if the author recognized that no mention of religion has been made in X number of pages and therefore has the characters suddenly decide to pray. I have great respect for literature in which the characters make Christian choices and live Christian lives but Pittman's novel seems to include prayerful interludes just for the sake of staying in the Christian genre. Lastly, the cover art appears to be a fairly horrifying photoshop job. Others in my family saw the cover sitting on the shelf and stated rather quizzically, "Doesn't really look like your sort of book...?" without even cracking the cover.
In summary, this would make an interesting novel if it would only make up its mind what it wanted to be.
On the positive side, the book is very competently executed and it's set in a period of history that's always amusing and vastly underutilized in literature. Pittman gives us a colorful and alluring rendering of the era and some fairly interesting characters.
To the negative, the Christian aspects of the novel seem to be an affectation and are poorly integrated. It's almost as if the author recognized that no mention of religion has been made in X number of pages and therefore has the characters suddenly decide to pray. I have great respect for literature in which the characters make Christian choices and live Christian lives but Pittman's novel seems to include prayerful interludes just for the sake of staying in the Christian genre. Lastly, the cover art appears to be a fairly horrifying photoshop job. Others in my family saw the cover sitting on the shelf and stated rather quizzically, "Doesn't really look like your sort of book...?" without even cracking the cover.
In summary, this would make an interesting novel if it would only make up its mind what it wanted to be.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews