Men Under the Mistletoe

by Josh Lanyon, Harper Fox, Ava March

13 hrs and 23 mins

Baby it's cold outside. A man receives the gift of pleasure at the hands of two expert lovers. Boyhood sweethearts get a second chance at romance. Two very proper gentlemen indulge their forbidden desires. And a Christmas-tree farmer has an epiphany. It may be cold outside, but these four holiday novellas will warm you up.
This anthology includes:

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March
Winter Knights by Harper Fox
Lone Star by Josh Lanyon
The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell

Genres: M M Romance, Anthologies, Romance, Holiday, Christmas, Contemporary, Audiobook

14 pages, Audible Audio

First published December 5, 2011

About the author

Author of 100+ titles of Gay Mystery and M/M Romance, Josh Lanyon has built her literary legacy on twisty mystery, kickass adventure, and unapologetic man-on-man romance.

Her work has been translated into twelve languages. The FBI thriller Fair Game was the first Male/Male title to be published by Italy’s Harlequin Mondadori and Stranger on the Shore (Harper Collins Italia) was the first M/M title to be published in print. In 2016 Fatal Shadows placed #5 in Japan’s annual Boy Love novel list (the first and only title by a foreign author to place on the list). The Adrien English series was awarded the All-Time Favorite Couple by the Goodreads M/M Romance Group. In 2019, Fatal Shadows became the first LGBTQ mobile game created by Moments: Choose Your Story.

She’s an EPIC Award winner, a four-time Lambda Literary Award finalist (twice for Gay Mystery), an Edgar nominee, and the first ever recipient of the Goodreads All Time Favorite M/M Author award.

Josh is married and lives in Southern California with her irascible husband, two adorable dogs, a small garden, and an ever-expanding library of vintage mystery destined to eventually crush them all beneath its weight.


Find other Josh Lanyon titles at www.joshlanyon.com
Follow Josh on Twitter, Facebook, and Goodreads.

Reviews

[Ann · Rating 4 out of 5]

Read this one last season and now listening to it on Audible. It's a great anthology, probably one of my all time favorites.

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March, read by L.B. Townsend - 4 Stars
Yeah, so give me a guy with a sexy accent reading me historical Christmas smut and I'm happy. I will say that I'm glad I had read this one first, it was a smidge confusing with the different characters, but it was read well, and I really liked it. It's a heartbreaker though so make sure you can listen to most of it in one sitting to get to the HEA.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox, read by Jack LeFleur - 3.5 Stars
Jack La Fleur is the perfect narrator for this story. I think this is my favorite story that he's narrated. This was a heartbreaker too, but it was so beautifully told. I kinda wanted Art and Lance's story more than Gavin and Piers', they were just more appealing characters overall. A great story of fate and discovery.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon, read by Max Tatch - 3.5 Stars
Max Tatch is a great narrator but I wasn't thrilled with his southern accent. He kind of made Web sound too old. Love this story though, it just ends a little too abruptly and I would have wanted more of a complete ending.

The Christmas Proposition by KA Mitchell, read by James de Grassi - 4 Stars
This was the first time I'd heard this narrator and I really liked him. He would have been a better fit for Lone Star and then Max Tatch should have read this one. This is me doing a job I don't have or understand as an imaginary producer. This was a good story with some light angst and characters that frustrated the hell out of me, but seemed more real because of their dumbassery.

[Trio · Rating 4 out of 5]

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March ⭐⭐⭐
A nice friends to lovers historical romance. Unfortunately the narrator didn't work for me. It was hard to differentiate which character was speaking.

White Knights by Harper Fox ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I loved, loved, loved this one! Exactly the kind of paranormal romance I adore. Sweet and mystical, and full of warm holiday goodness... plus super cool paranomal moments with ghosts and curiosities with just a hint of "mmm, it could be real" or it could be explained with reason. Wonderful!

The audio is beautifully performed by Jack LeFleur.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon ⭐⭐⭐⭐
I enjoyed this story back in 2016, and I've owned the audio version for years. What a great opportunity to revist Josh Lanyon's Lone Star, Christmas in July (2022 style, that is).

It's a sweet story and I enjoy the picture Lanyon paints of this small Texas town. It's such a great ending with a nice compromise, and it's not the ending I was expecting (which is always good).

The audio version of Lone Star is nicely performed by Max Tatch.

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell not read yet

[Teri · Rating 4 out of 5]

My True Love Gave To Me by Ava March--3.5 stars
I liked this, I have read several books by Ava March and really enjoyed them. I was a little upset by the way Alexander just fucked Thomas and shoved him out the door, especially since it was his first time and he was so angry and I know that he felt badly about it, but God, that was really hard to read. I like second chance stories only in certain situations and this one worked for me.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox-4 stars
This is not my first by this author, I am a fan. I felt a little sad at the end, though. I wasn't expecting it to go the way it had and when it was starting to, my mind was spinning it in any other way, but it made me sad. I was glad that Piers and Gavin worked things out, G was almost like a shithead really, but I'm glad they took the time to talk and work things out. I think I was hoping for a different situation with Art and Lance, but I did like the story.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon --3 stars
This left me feeling a little melancholy honestly. I think the thing with his dad and the newspaper clippings and all, just made me sad. innis had some damn nerve! ugh. Was wishing he would get stomped to death by the reindeer. Anyhoo. I liked it, but it was just too short for me!

The Christmas Proposition by KA Mitchell--3-3.5 star
I was really feeling this until bryce wanted to make his declaration and dude like ran!!! I was all NOOOOO. But I did like it

[Karen · Rating 5 out of 5]

It's more from the ghost of Christmas Past...

I first read this anthology of Christmas stories back in 2011 when it was released as an e-book. While I'm not at big fan of anthologies this one is a collection of Christmas stories by some of my favorite M/M authors so resistance was futile and when I came across the audiobook on audible.com again resistance was futile and this was the perfect accompaniment to wrapping Christmas present and I loved the audiobook every bit as much as I enjoyed reading the e-book.

[Tammy · Rating 3 out of 5]

I fully listened to 2 out of the 4 stories, My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March and Lone Star by Josh Lanyon. The other two I don't know if I gave them a fair chance but I just wasn't interested.🤔

[Vio · Rating 4 out of 5]

A highly enjoyable Anthology with gorgeous characters and intriguing stories. A nice mix of the unusual and interesting a recommended Christmas read with a few twists, I really liked it!

[Lena Grey · Rating 5 out of 5]

Men Under the Mistletoe (Anthology) by Josh Lanyon, K.A. Mitchell, Ava March, and Harper Fox

'Men Under the Mistletoe' is one of the best holiday anthologies I've ever read. A Christmas story, by any of these authors, would be great, but a book with their talents combined creates real holiday magic. Although it's an eclectic collection, I found each story quite moving as I followed the characters through their trials and tribulations, all hoping for a second chance at love.


'My True Love Gave to Me' by Ava March

Love and hate form two sides of one intense passion and it's easier than one might think to slip back and forth over the fine line between them. In 'My True Love Gave to Me’ by Ava March, two young men, Alexander and Thomas, struggle with this concept. They feel love's passion, but without the necessary maturity and experience to manage it, they reach a rift which seems insurmountable; all the loving feelings turn into intense, almost unbearable pain. The thing about lost love is that once felt, there's always hope that it can be rekindled, if both parties are willing to forgive themselves and each other.

Alexander is bright, charming, self assured, and comfortable knowing that he favors men. He adores Thomas, showers him with love, and awakens him to his true nature. Although Alexander is able to embrace this, Thomas is not. He's plagued by doubts and fears which he can't overcome, no matter how hard he tries. When Thomas finally runs from his feelings, Alexander is thrown into a pit of despair which he's only able to survive by denying the validity of his love and trust for Thomas. His pain is so intense that he tries to run away from it. He shuts himself off from his emotions, which causes more harm than good. Sasha, Thomas's endearment for Alexander, makes it easier to differentiate between Alexander's positive and negative feelings. Alexander's calling Thomas by his first and last name serves the same purpose. Alexander needs to listen to the Sasha in him and believe what his heart tells him is true, but it's more easily said than done.

Thomas, after all, is only nineteen when the story begins. How many young men that age know who they are and what they want? He loves Sasha, but has trouble handling his overwhelming, taboo feelings. When he leaves, it's himself, not Alexander, from whom he is running. Being the shyer of the two, Alexander inadvertently pushes him farther than he is willing or able to go. This causes such cognitive dissonance that Thomas can't think and feels trapped. Avoiding the issue seems to be the only reasonable answer, but, after four years of running, he realizes that he's no further than when he started and is never going to be able to leave his love for Sasha behind. So, with hat in hand, so to speak, he comes back to try and make things right again. Giving the word persistence a new meaning, he fights his way through the walls Alexander has erected, right back into Sasha's heart.

This outstanding story has everything one would want in a historical romance: love, angst, despair, heart break, passion, forgiveness and reconciliation. If these ingredients appeal to you, then you will not want to pass up 'My True Love Gave to Me'.


'Winter Knights' by Harper Fox

How many of us wouldn't want to meet King Arthur and Sir Lancelot, the famous legends of Camelot? Gavin Lowden, in 'Winter Knights' by Harper Fox, is a historian who is fascinated with them. Never in his wildest dreams would he have ever imagined meeting Art and Lance and certainly not under such unusual circumstances. This clever story rides the fence between reality and fiction, all things are possible depending upon how you're inclined to interpret it.

Gavin is in his own little world. He takes a great deal for granted, especially his lover, Piers. Things are done according to Gavin's time table, in his way and he may or may not include Piers in the planning process. When Piers rebels and refuses to go along with Gavin's plans, Gavin is heartbroken, but has no idea how to fix his relationship with Piers. Gavin has to be shown rather than told how to make things right again, and Art and Lance are happy to oblige.

Piers loves Gavin, but is tired of everything having to be his way all the time. He hates conflict, so for far too long he says nothing. When he can take it no longer, he tells Gavin that it's over. Piers is a forgiving soul, willing to give Gavin another chance. Even thought it seems incredible, Piers believes Gavin's account of Art and Lance which makes Gavin realize just how much faith Piers has in him all along.

'Winter Knights' is a fascinating tale weaving legend and fact together in a unique way. Efficiently and poetically, Harper takes us through a number of unexpected twists and turns which are shrouded in duality, leaving us to consider what is real and what is not. This amazing story sheds new light on the knight in shining armor concept, because Harper's knights shine with a very passionate, mind blowing light. It's romantic, sensual, mysterious, full of angst and important life lessons. I believe that anyone with a romantic sense of adventure and a good imagination will enjoy it as thoroughly as I did.


'Lone Star' by Josh Lanyon

In ‘Lone Star' by Josh Lanyon, Mitch had to get away from the life that was smothering him, the small town, his desire to dance, his distant father, and most of all, his lover Web. When it seemed like there was no way to balance his dreams with reality, he had a decision to make and the only way he could do that was by abruptly leaving. Now, twelve years later in the midst of an emotional crisis, it's telling that he escapes to the place he'd sworn never to go again and finds that his perspective has changed drastically.

Mitch is very intense, high strung, talented, short tempered, and lonelier than he'd ever admit to being. When he left town, he thought everyone would forget him; he certainly never considered that they would be interested in his success. He misjudged them. It slowly dawns on him that the people who he thought didn't care, actually cared a great deal, particularly his father who was unable to show his love for Mitch, but actually loved him deeply.
Web's personality sets the tone for the entire story. He's wise, even tempered, strong, loving, and considerate. Some of his descriptions of Mitch were hilarious such as: “You're worse-tempered than a stripper in a cactus patch.” He does his best to accommodate Mitch as he wrestles with his conflicts and to show him just how much he cares.

This story swept me away with its easy going pace, genuine characters, close, small town sense of community, and its emphasis on family. It was both endearing and comforting. I can't imagine anyone not enjoying this story. I highly recommend it to everyone who wants to read a good love story, which is sentimental, sensual, insightful and ends happily.


'The Christmas Proposition' by K.A. Mitchell

There comes a time in everyone's life when they have to set priorities, examine their motives and decide if their loyalty to an ideal is necessary or if they are just clinging to it out of habit. In 'The Christmas Proposition' by K.A. Mitchell, Mel is at this crossroads in his life. Mel loves his family and takes his responsibility of maintaining their Christmas Tree farm very seriously, so seriously, in fact, that he's sacrificing his own happiness. When a former lover blows in from the past, Mel has a decision to make; he can either hold on to the past or reach for a second chance at love.

Mel is a nice guy with a great sense of humor, but has a problem seeing things as they actually are. He lets his sense of responsibility cloud his vision when it comes to those around him, particularly his sister who is a lot more capable than he gives her credit for. He thinks he has to do it all. He needs to be more assertive instead of just letting life happen. Fortunately, his love for Bryce wins out in the end and he goes on to claim the happiness he needs.

Introducing Bryce by having him give Mel a blow job after a three year absence, without even saying a word, is just plain down and dirty, but Mel and Bryce have that kind of relationship. When they come together, it isn't with a whimper, but a bang on all levels. Bryce has everything but realizes it doesn't mean much without Mel. I loved his assertiveness; yet he's willing to understand Mel's predicament while he subtly and not so subtly tries to convince Mel that his future lies with him.

This story was inspiring, and sexy, and surprising. I loved the interaction between Mel and Bryce which was intense in every way. I loved that Mel valued family and wasn't going to leave without a viable solution, but who in spite of it all, was able to overcome this overbearing sense of responsibility and go with his heart. I really liked the characters, the style, and the twist at the end. I recommend this story to anyone who likes their romance on the earthy side, yet still full of love and passion.


NOTE: This book was provided by one of the authors, for the purpose of a review on Queer Magazine Online

[Jennifer · Rating 3 out of 5]

"My True Love Gave to Me"

by Ava March

Ava March is a popular m/m romance novelist who specializes in historicals particulary Regency England. This novella follows this pattern. The main characters are Thomas Bennett and Alexander Norton who meet as young men at Oxford University. They are attracted to each other immediately, but, when it comes time to really show Alexander his feelings, Thomas leaves the country for four years. In this story, he arrives back in London to convince Alexander that he regrets leaving him, but realizes how much his actions changed Alexander.

There is alot packed into this little story. Readers are provided detailed, but not overdone scenes of the early part of Thomas and Alexander's relationship. The wonders of first love are especially poignant here as is the scene where Thomas leaves. I really felt for Alexander and had a hard time forgiving Thomas later on. The later section did have a few melodramatic moments, but moved along at a realistic pace. Thomas and Alexander have definite chemistry throughout the story and this was shown beautifully in the sensual scenes without being smutty. The conclusion was very sweet and proved a satisfying way to wrap up Thomas and Alexander's story.

4 OUT OF 5 STARS

****************

"Winter Knights"

by Harper Fox

Harper Fox's contribution is a contemporary romance with a supernatural twist. The narrator is Gavin, a folklore doctoral student, who is dealing with the fact that his Catholic lover, Piers, dumped him rather than tell his family the truth about his sexuality. Gavin had been planning on spending Christmas for the first time with Piers and was so devastated by Piers's decision that he found himself wandering in the middle of a blizzard. He is rescued by two mysterious men that remind him of the mythical King Arthur and Lancelot, conveniently named Art and Lance, and learns how to save his relationship with Piers.

This is my first Harper Fox story and I was definitely intrigued. The writing style was smooth and easy to understand and the first-person narrative was executed almost flawlessly. I did have a hard time understanding Gavin at first, but he definitely grew on me. I really liked how Fox slowly revealed key aspects of Gavin and Piers's relationship in a way that did not put the sole blame of their problems on either men. I also enjoyed the depiction of Art and Lance and their relationship. They were sweet and completely comfortable with each other. I was a little taken aback by the m/m/m scene with Art, Lance, and Gavin and thought that the story didn't need it. There is a minor supernatural aspect to this story, but I won't go into too much detail in order to avoid spoilers.

3.5 OUT OF 5 STARS

***************

"Lone Star"

by Josh Lanyon

Lone Star is a contemporary, western romance between two former childhood sweethearts. Mitch and Web were best friends growing up in a Texas small town who grew into lovers once they reached their teenage years. But, a heated confrontation led Mitch to leave town to become a professional ballet dancer. Twelve years later, Mitch comes back to settle his father's estate and reunites with Web who has become a Texas Ranger.

I really enjoy most of Lanyon's work, but I found this one a little lacking. I liked the premise and the characters. As a former dancer, I loved the character of Mitch and his explanation of the world of ballet. Web seems like a sweet guy that I would like to have learned more about. The beginning of the story was great. There was drama from Mitch and Web meeting again and some cute interactions with the townspeople, but nothing ever really happened from there. I would love to have seen this idea in a longer format so Lanyon could concentrate on the Mitch/Web relationship beyond the sudden realization of their feelings. There was a vague supernatural element that never took off and the ending was very abrupt and not extremely satisfying. I do hope that readers check out Lanyon's other stories because I don't feel like this novella is a great example of his amazing talent.

3 OUT OF 5 STARS

************************

"The Christmas Proposition"

by K.A. Mitchell

In this novella, readers meet Mel and Bryce, two former lovers who meet up again around the holidays. Mel is runs his family's Christmas tree farm while Bryce is a high-style millionaire. Their love affair ended a couple years ago after a misunderstanding. Now, these two reunite at a diner where Mel works part-time. Bryce is determined to show Mel what he has been missing by remaining at the family farm while Mel comes to grip with the fact that he never completely got over Bryce.

This is my first experience with K.A. Mitchell's writing and, while it was not my favorite, I enjoyed this story enough to try some of her other longer works. Both Mel and Bryce were decent characters and I liked the logistics of the reunion plot. I had a hard time getting into their actual romance in a story this length and would have loved to seen this plot in a longer work. That being said, I did find myself enjoying myself and got through the story quickly. It was a nice, easy read for a rainy afternoon. Also, I should warn readers that this is probably the most graphic novella in this collection.

3 OUT OF 5 STARS

***************

OVERALL ANTHOLOGY RATING: 3.5 OUT OF 5 STARS

[Alex · Rating 4 out of 5]

Overall
An excellent collection of four Christmas novellas, these stories capture the spirit of the holidays and warm you to your toes better than a cup of spiked cocoa. A nice mix of hot sex, warm loving, and cold shoulders, you may think you know how some of these end, but others will surprise you. Check these out for Christmas, or for any time you want to curl up with some holiday cheer.

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March
Stars: 4/5
This is my first read of anything by March, so I don't know if somewhat-flowery language is the norm, but it definitely worked in this piece. I rarely read historicals, but I'm always impressed when I do and I can FEEL how much research and knowledge went into them. March obviously knows a thing or two about the time period and uses what I assume is all the appropriate language, although sometimes it may be a bit too much for those not familiar with the terms. The story starts off sweet, but the blurb tells us that it's not going to continue, which makes their secret kisses and Alexander's hopefulness all the more difficult to bear when the fallout happens.

Because the novella's blurb (not listed above) gives away the break up, I found the beginning a bit slow, since I knew what was going to happen. However, it was worth reading through, because it developed both characters as they were as youths--hopeful and adventurous yet kind, and sweet and self-sacrificing, always wanting to do the right thing. Seeing the change between the years and how the time altered them, made the changes more significant and the struggle for Thomas to prove himself to Alexander all the more daunting. While moments of the ending were a touch saccharine for my liking, it was a proper reward for all their emotional struggles.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox
Stars: 5/5
Twining together reality and the supernatural, Arthurian legend and love, this novella brings to life the spirit of the past, the present, and the future. Initially, Gavin comes across as the hero while Piers is the faulted Catholic blinded by his hateful religion. But what I loved about the story is that Gavin isn't as right as the reader is led to believe in the beginning. He has faults, some which have majorly disrupted his relationship with Piers, not that the other man doesn't have some faults as well. There is so much going on in this story, from the various Arthurian references, the presence of the rescue workers, Gavin and Piers' relationship, and all the other factors that push the events along.

I don't want to say too much, for fear of giving away the wonderful little twists that this story provides, but I will say this was a wonderful tale and it's levels and depth were brilliantly handled.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon
Stars: 3.5/5
While I enjoyed the characters and the resolution of this novella, overall the story didn't really grab me. In addition, the reindeer ploy was creative but I felt like its presence needed more explanation or attention. It feels like a tool to get the two men together--and it's fine if that's what it is there for, but as the reader, I shouldn't be so keenly aware of its place as a tool. While it's a minor issue, it reappears often enough to make the narrator wonder if he's crazy--and the lack of resolution leaves the reader wondering the same thing.

What I liked about the story is mainly the resolution, which felt right for the situation and the characters, who seem to be as opposite as possible. If it weren't for how this story ended, I probably would have scored this lower, because while the characters entertained me, they didn't feel exciting and new, although they played out their roles with some fresh touches. In addition, the warmth of Wet's family both among each other and to Mitch was a perfect, heart-warming touch to this holiday story.

The Christmas Proposition by KA Mitchell
Stars: 4.5/5
This story resonated a classic holiday feel although it isn't resolved by the leading man Mel learning the meaning of Christmas. Instead he learns the meaning of trust and love and taking chances and relying on others. It sounds rather trite and silly when I say it, but Mitchell does an excellent job bringing everything around.

In some ways the resolution is too easy, but in reality, the struggles Mel sees are not actually there (or no longer require his exacting attention). While this story definitely has a rich man throwing money around, I didn't feel like it suffered from the "rich man solves all problems for poor man" syndrome. A happy story with minimal angst scattered throughout as Mel tries not to be angsty and instead focuses on what he has now, since he has no hope of it in the future.

Finally, I think one of my favorite elements of this story is Bryce asking what childhood trauma caused Mel to be so mistrusting, and Mel says there is none. I just love that someone pointed out (bluntly) that just because we're screwed up now, doesn't mean there was one thing that screwed us up.

Requested this book for review.
Be sure to check out my other reviews on my blog.

[Heather C · Rating 3 out of 5]

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March ★★★☆☆
I actually read this one after completing the Brook Street Trilogy. And while it isn't my favorite of the series, I did enjoy it.  I already know that Bennett and Norton are pretty much going to last forever, but I would be questioning that at the end of this story if I hadn't already read the rest of the series. 


Winter Knights by Harper Fox
I'm not sure if I will read this story There is menage


Lone Star by Josh Lanyon ★★★☆☆
I really wanted to love this, but I just couldn't.

My Rant:
♦ The odd use of "y'all" as a singular pronoun kept pulling me out of the story. Each time I read it I was looking for a 3rd person in the scene. I'm sure there are people out there that use it that way but I've never in my life heard it, and I live in the South. I hear and use "y'all" every single day and it is always plural! Always!!
♦ It took me 4 days to finish reading it.
♦ After 12 years of not seeing or speaking to each other, the MCs are back in love with each other and planning a future together after 2 days!
♦ The ending was too predictable and unrealistic.
♦ It is forgettable.
♦ What happened to the reindeer??! The MC kept "seeing" a reindeer but that whole plot line was just dropped! It seemed pretty important to me since it almost killed him.

My Praise:
♦ Umm...it was a somewhat enjoyable read and there was a hot scene.

So basically, this did not feel at all like a "Josh" story to me and unfortunately I feel disappointed.


The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell ★★★★☆
This was a great Christmas novella. The sex was hot and the ending was sweet (although a bit rushed). I really like the story overall. I kinda liked both MCs even though Mel was a whiny idiot and Bryce was a controlling ass. There were quite a few smutty scenes between these two; I'm just sad I didn't get the chance to see them do it in the barn!

[LenaLena · Rating 3 out of 5]

Only the last story in this collection had a real connection to Christmas. And no mistletoe in sight....


My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March 2.5 stars

Okay Regency romance. I tend to like regency and I think it has great potential as a setting for m/m, it being a hanging offense back then and all, but I have not often seen it done well. The problem I had with this story is that Alexander's change of heart came about really abrupt and the story ended abrupt too.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox 4.5 stars

Best story of the bunch. I really, really enjoyed this one, even if the sex scenes didn't do too much for me. I love the references to the Arthurian stories, obvious and not-so-obvious (like how Gavin/Gawain and Piers/Parsifal's personalities match those in the old stories). I love Gavin's journey of self reflection. Well worth it.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon 3 stars

It's Josh, so the writing is good, but the story was a bit devoid of real life messiness. Twelve years apart, but no catching up to do? Nothing has changed, so we're right back where we started?

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell 3.5 stars

Liked the story. Liked the Christmassy feel of it. Liked the sex. It's just that the end felt really tacked on. It should have ended at the wedding.

[Hemmel M. · Rating 3 out of 5]

My True Love Gave To Me:
First, I disliked the booming sound of this publication. Also, after every editorial cut, the volume changed. The narrator goes on my 'avoid' list, with his random pauses after every few words and lack of voices.
It might be too late for readers of this review, but you should avoid reading the blurb. It covers 50% of the novella and the 50% groveling got tedious fast.

Winter Knights :
Beautiful story, marvelous narrator.

Lone Star:
Forgetable. Narration was all right but the edited sentenced added at a later point, sounded different.

The Christmas Proposition was a nice story although in the end I missed some emotion. I did not like the ending. Good narration.

[Krissy · Rating 4 out of 5]

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March = 4
Winter Knights by Harper Fox = 2
Lone Star by Josh Lanyon = 3
The Christmas Proposition by KA Mitchell = 4

[DaisyGirl · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.0 Stars

The emo in me I loved this Christmas m/m anthology. It was hot, sweet, with just the right amount of angst. Many of the stories were about second chances, which I love.

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March 5.0 Stars
My first story by Ava March but definitely not my last! Also my favorite of the anthology.

Four years ago, Alexander Norton's first love, Thomas Bennett, broke his heart when he fled to New York without a word. So when Alexander encounters Thomas at a holiday ball, he is determined not to let on how much he still hurts. Thomas, on the other hand, has returned to for one reason only: Alexander. Having finally come to terms with his forbidden desires, Thomas will do whatever he must to convince Alexander to give their love another chance. But instead of the happy, carefree man Thomas once knew, Alexander is now hard and cynical. Saddened to know he's to blame for the man's bitterness, Thomas resolves to reignite the passion he knows lies hidden behind the wall of disdain.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox 4.0 Stars
The longest story in the book. A little PNR; a little menage; a little spicy ... a whole lot of wonderful!

Historian Gavin Lowden is in Northumberland on Christmas Eve for two reasons: to find evidence of a romantic bond between Arthur and Lancelot, and to finally tell his partner Piers that he loves him. Piers has promised to come clean with his conservative family and join Gavin for their first holiday as a couple, but at the last minute, he bails. Devastated, Gavin heads out onto the moors alone, just as snow begins to fall...

Gavin stumbles into an underground chamber, where strange happenings cause him to question what is real and what is fantasy. He's found by two mysterious men who offer him a bed for the night—and awaken him to nuances of erotic pleasure he didn't know existed. Pleasure he hopes to share with Piers.

When Piers learns that Gavin has gone missing, he is desperate to find him. He knows now breaking up was a terrible mistake, and he's ready to take the next step in their relationship—if it's not already too late.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon 3.5 Stars
I liked this one well enough. My biggest gripe: the ending was too abrupt and nebulous for my liking.

Growing up in rural Texas, Mitchell Evans's ambition to be a dancer made him a target. Though he found success in New York City, Mitch is at a crossroads, and heads home for the first time in twelve years to figure things out. When what appears to be a reindeer jumps out in front of his car, he drives off the road and into the path of the one man he hoped to avoid.

The last person Texas Ranger Web Eisley expects to see four days before Christmas is his first love. He hasn't seen Mitch since they quarreled over coming out to their friends and family years ago. Though he's not in the closet now, Web has worked hard for the respect of his fellow officers, but he still regrets the loss of Mitch in his life. And his bed.

The attraction between them is as strong as ever, and it doesn't take long for the men to pick up where they left off. But is love enough to keep Mitch in town in the New Year?

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell 3.5 Stars
Cute story about love on a Christmas tree farm. The ending was a roller coaster but well worth the ride.

It's Christmas in Epiphany, Pennsylvania—the busiest time of year for Mel Halner. But running the family Christmas tree farm has worn down his love for the happiest season of all, and lately Mel's been wondering what if he'd said yes to a ticket out of town with millionaire Bryce Campion three years ago.

Bryce isn't used to people saying no to him, and he can't forget Mel or their brief but sizzling affair. He might not have been offering forever, but Bryce can't understand a guy as sexy and smart as Mel choosing to stay rooted on the family farm over enjoying the high life with him. He's determined to make Mel see what he's missed out on the first chance he gets.

Bottom-line: Sexy, sassy, holiday fun with a nice helping of romance. Recommend!

[Ann · Rating 3 out of 5]

Men Under the Mistletoe was an enjoyable anthology even if I had a few problems with some of the stories. I’m going to review each story separately in this review but I have a small critique point in regards to the complete anthology.

I was a bit disappointed that all stories featured lovers who had a fight and broke up only to get back together on or around Christmas. I’m not sure if this was in the guidelines for the anthology but I would have wished for a bit more variety.

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March: 3/5 stars
Set in the 19th century it follows the love story of Alexander and Thomas which ended in Thomas running away, because he was scared and frightened by his own feelings and the society which sees their love as a crime. Four years later he comes back to win Alexander back.

What I really liked about My True Love Gave to Me is that I felt an emotional connection to the characters; I really felt their fear, anguish, anger and love. My qualm with the story is a bit too many sex scenes for such a short story.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox: 4/5 stars
Gavin, researching for his doctorate about the legend of King Arthur and Lancelot, is excited, because this will be the first Christmas he gets to spend alone with his boyfriend Piers, a devout Catholic. But things don’t go as they were supposed to; Piers doesn’t come, resulting in the couple breaking up. Gavin is devastated and goes out to Hallow Hill, a place where the round table supposedly appeared before one man’s eyes. Things go awry though and he encounters something supernatural.

Definitely my favourite story of the anthology. It sucked me right in and held my attention throughout. Gavin was not an all-together sympathetic character which I enjoyed. He has his faults and they become clearer as the story progresses and as we find out more about his and Piers’ relationship.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon: 2/5 stars
Ballet dancer Mitch comes back home to Texas after 12 years, running away from the pain caused in New York and to manage the belongings of his estranged father who has died 6 months prior. He encounters Web, a Texas Ranger who was his boyfriend when he left home. Mitch realizes that he isn’t over Web yet and the same goes for Web.

While the story is fine I found Lone Star very lacking, especially emotionally. I never felt a connection to either of the two main characters nor did I like them very much. It’s not that they’re unlikable but rather very flat and bland. As a friend holds Josh Lanyon in high regards and gives a lot of praise I was rather disappointed.

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell: 3/5 stars
Mel manages and works on the family’s Christmas tree farm, being the most responsible in his family. Since the money isn’t enough he works in a diner where he meets Bryce again, a man who pretty much left without a word three years ago after a two-month affair. But things didn’t happen exactly the way Mel remembers them and he isn’t as over Bryce as he thought he was.

The Christmas Proposition made me smirk more than once, because it had some funny parts. I found it enjoyable overall but didn’t find Mel and Bryce that convincing characters. I liked the secondary characters more than the two.


Disclaimer: An ARC has been provided by the publisher through Netgalley for reviewing purposes.

[S · Rating 4 out of 5]

As a compilation, Men Under the Mistletoe is a fun, erotic, Christmasy read. 4 stars out of 5 for the anthology as a whole. The stand out story is The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell.

Lone Star
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
A sweet story of coming home to a place you no longer consider home. Of the brutal assault of memory and the lesson that time really doesn't heal wounds, it just changes perspective. Mitch has escaped his small town roots to become a principle dancer for the American Ballet Theatre. Twelve years gone, he runs almost immediately into the reason he left - Texas Ranger Web Eisley.

I would love to see these two in a full-length book. There just wasn't enough room in a short story to do them justice. Regardless, Lanyon uses the words he has to build the background of a complex falling out, to show the undying love of the entire Eisley clan, and to try to explain the sacrifices Mitch has had to make to get where he is professionally.

3.5 stars out of 5.

The Christmas Proposition
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
Whoa. What I learned from The Christmas Proposition:

1. Attic sex is hot. And that's not a euphemism.
2. Christmas trees are meant to be enjoyed at all hours of the day, and from all sorts of angles.
3. Buying your significant other a Range Rover should not be considered an engagement ring, but it's still a pretty bad ass move.
4. Like a good Boy Scout, one should always be prepared - with at least lube and a chain. Not necessarily to be used at the same time.

4.5 stars out of 5. Loved this short story!!

Winter Knights
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
Apparently, if you get lost in the right place in England, at just the right time, a whole world of sexual initiation is there for the enjoying. I've been hiking in all the wrong places.

If you're into knights and a good ghost story, then Winter Knights is an interesting read. The MCs are so naive and inexperienced it's laughable at points, but in a very distracted, nutty professor kind of way that's almost endearing.

3 stars out of 5.

My True Love Gave to Me
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
I'm not usually into historicals, but this one got under my skin. I was surprised to find emotional depth in a such a short story. The story of Sasha and Thomas begins with a curious need and innocent liaisons between two teenagers only beginning to learn what it means to be gay. And then Thomas leaves, betraying the love and trust of Sasha, and the subsequent years of separation slice both the MCs down to slivers of who they used to be together, finally building to an unrelenting blazing rage and desire upon their reunion that assaults you until the last words. Yeah, it was that intense and it never let up. This was not a light read by any means. But the intensity of their emotions feeds into scorching encounters with each other. Well worth the read.

3.5 stars out of 5.






Review note: I received a copy of this book through Netgalley.

[Lily · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book was full of delightful surprises that left me squealing with joy, shocked in horror and oddly appreciative of the turn away from a typical HEA mm romance.

First story is My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March. This was the most boring story of the bunch, which is not to say it was bad. AM gives us a solid historical romance where 2 young men enter a taboo relationship of gay love. But on Christmas day one lover jilts the other. Thomas completely abandons Alexander because he can't deal with the whole gay in English society thing. He leaves the country to escape homo-temptation, but comes back 4 years later ready to fight for Alexander's forgiveness and love. I personally would've preferred more grovelling, but overall a thumbs up.
Second story Winter Knights by Harper Fox. This was my favorite just cause it was soooo trippy. It was like a literary menage of Charles Dickens' Christmas Carol, the Knights of Camelot, and the Fault in Our Stars script. Also there was an actual menage of sex between King Arthur, Lancelot and Gavin. So hextuple points to HF. What I loved most about this though was how we started out really feeling for Gavin as we journey through is POV and he realizes he is in fact a douche. And the transformation is just so sincere and real. All the characters in this story were so fleshed out it just made the crazy trippiness between reality and fantasy even more trippy because I cared so much about everybody.
Lone Star by Josh Lanyon
Sexy ranger cowboy exes and hot male dancers. YES! This was a heartfelt reunion between pro dancer Max and his ex Web. They parted as confused young men, but meet again over the holidays. Sparks fly, old feelings are rehashed and a new determination for love blooms. This time Web is sure not to let Max slip through his fingers again. Super heartfelt Texan romance with warm family vibes and a hot ranger in a cowboy hat and boots. XP
The Christmas Proposition by KA Mitchell
Never have I felt so tortured by a main character as I did with Mel. He lives in a small town taking care of his family's tree farm. Then rich, sexy, bigger than life Bryce comes into town. Then he leaves. Mel is heart broke. But then Bryce comes back obviously trying to woo Mel again. And Mel-he-he proceeds to engage in the most torturous mating dance of 'yes' 'no' ever. I give points for making me care so much, but it was a little evil of KAM to dangle the HEA in front of me like some weird game of keep away with my feels.

I would read any one of these stories again of they got their own stand alone books. This was an awesome experience and I totally recommend it! ^_^

[Hal Evergreen · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was a little dismayed when I realized that every story in this anthology involves protagonists who have prior history with each other. I tend to prefer stories in which the protagonists meet for the first time and develop their relationship from there. That said, two out of the four stories handled the "old flame" story line pretty well.

My True Love Gave To Me
Ava March
2.5 stars

I've heard some good things about Ava March's writing, but this story was just okay. There was a little too much melodrama for my taste. It was hard to take either of the characters seriously, since they seemed to overreact alarmingly to every situation. Angst is all very well, when there's a good reason for it. I just never really figured out what these two Regency-era gentlemen had to be so angsty about. Yes, I know being gay in Regency England couldn't have been easy, but that didn't seem to be the main source of these two characters' difficulties. Mostly, they were both just absurdly mule-headed, until they weren't, and then everything was mushy hearts and flowers.

Winter Knights
Harper Fox
4 stars

This story was excellent. It has a bit of menage (m/m/m), but that really wasn't the focus of this tale. Instead, "Winter Knights" is the story of a man who, after getting unceremoniously dumped by his closeted Catholic boyfriend, comes to realize his own devastating role in the collapse of his relationship. It's not an easy story to read (it was hard for me to witness Gavin's painful soul-searching without recognizing a few of my own faults), but that just makes the hope-filled ending more rewarding. It was worth the price of the whole anthology just to discover this story. I will definitely be reading more by this author in the future.

Lone Star
Josh Lanyon
2 stars

This was my least favorite story in the anthology. Forgettable plot, forgettable characters, forgettable love scenes, etc. I have sampled Josh Lanyon's writing in the past, and he has never managed to capture my interest yet. Unfortunately, this story was no exception.

The Christmas Proposition
K.A. Mitchell
3 stars

This was not K.A. Mitchell at her best. The dialog was clever and the sex scenes were blazing-hot, per usual. What was lacking was character development. After reading several of Mitchell's novels, I have come to expect a higher-than-average level of complexity and depth in her characters. Unfortunately, this story was just too short for me to get to know either of the characters well. It still made me smile, though.

[SueM · Rating 4 out of 5]

There is considerable variety of genres and styles found in this collection of Christmas-themed stories, and sadly, there is a range in quality too.

For me, the outstanding story was Harper Fox's Winter Knights. In a contemporary story mixed with Arthurian legends and supernatural elements, two lovers come to terms with themselves and each other. Despite its shorter than novel length, this reads like a full length novel, with complex character development, surprising emotional depth and threaded with whimsy, understated humor and love that can last the ages. It is a beautiful heartwarming story with enough heat to make it truly outstanding. 4.5 - 5 stars.

Ava March's historical romance My True Love Gave to Me. takes you on an angst-filled ride as two young men learn to love each other despite convention, yet are heartbroken as convention interferes with their plans. It is a story of learning the value of love and forgiveness, where courage is needed to both face pain and their past. A solid story - 4 stars

Josh Lanyon isn't capable of writing a truly bad story, but I found Lone Star to be not one of this author's better stories. This story seemed a little predictable, despite the hint of paranormal elements, and for me, the characters didn't have the depth that I have come to expect from Lanyon. The easing of past pain and forgiveness seem to happen rather suddenly, and the pacing seemed a bit off overall. As I said, it is not a bad story, but certainly not one of Lanyon's brightest efforts. 3 - 3.5 stars

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell probably appealed the least to me out of the four stories, yet I can't exactly say why. This story certainly has the highest heat rating of the four, but rather than love, I felt more lust than anything else from the main characters, as their emotions felt hidden for a good part of the story. By hiding the characters emotions, I think Mitchell was trying to emphasize the uncertainty both characters felt about their relationship. This would probably work quite well in a story of greater length, but it just left me feeling less than involved in the story. 2.5 - 3 stars.

[Tatiana · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 stars

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March - 3*
Winter Knights by Harper Fox - 2*
Lone Star by Josh Lanyon - 3*
The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell - 2*

[Chris · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars. Another exceptional collection of holiday-themed m/m romance from Carina Press. Ava March's historical was very good. (Poor Sasha! Then... poor Thomas!) Harper Fox's story drew me in slowly, then seduced me utterly. So good! Its excellent epilogue should serve as the standard to which all other epilogues should strive. Josh Lanyon's story was a pretty good read, but left me with too many unanswered questions to be truly satisfying. Finally, KA Mitchell's story kept me wondering how things were going to turn out until the absolute end.

[⚣Michaelle⚣ · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.2 Stars

Lone Star 4.1 Stars
Winter Knights 4.2 Stars
My True Love Gave to Me 4.1 Stars
The Christmas Proposition 4.4 Stars

[Camy · Rating 3 out of 5]

Audiobook.

Okay / good-ish; all of them nothing special. Didn't love any or find them particularly gratifying. A good listen. Okay-ish narrators. Comfortable stories, but none really wonderful or moving.

Middling. Nice. Helped me along my household chores.

[Deeze · Rating 3 out of 5]

Overall a sweet and simple collection of 4 short stories. A little something for everyone kinda thing. For me the last 2 stories worked best.

[Mandy*reads obsessively* · Rating 3 out of 5]

My True Love Gave To Me 3*

Winter Knights 4*

Lone Star 3.5*

the Christmas Propostion 3*

[Jerry · Rating 5 out of 5]

Most of these stories were great and since Harper Fox was a solid 5 star, I gave the whole anthology 5 stars.

Lone Star, Josh Lanyon, 4 stars, good narration.
Mitch & Web are a great story masterfully told. For some reason, I did not care for the narrator's voicing of Web, just a little too cliched for me with a clipped gruff sound, it made it hard to warm up to him. As much as I thought of the writing, I could see how it was going to end with just the introduction of the studio. Another in this anthology that would make a great full novel, but I am happy to have had the short story.

Winter Nights, Harper Fox, 5 stars, great narration.
I love Harper Fox's works. This was an interesting preposition weaving the Arthurian legend into a contemporary piece. At first the MC Gavin was too overbearing to me, then his adventure occurred. His relationship to 'Arthur' who rescued him started off as good, then I was turned off by some of the actions with Art & Lance. Suddenly I realized that this was in his mind or an out of body experience or paranormal. I was then enthralled with the updating of Arthur and Lancelot being rescuers, just brilliant! The main story is of Gavin and Piers who need to work out their relationship and take a leap of truly being in love. As many who reviewed the stand alone story have said, this would be a great full length novel. It was definitely the best of the stories and wonderfully narrated. I think Ms. Fox has written more of the Arthurian legend and will check out those works.

My True Love Gave to Me, Ava March, 3 stars
This was a historical and I can kind of see how the set up could happen, but I usually think no one could be that cold-hearted with the MC leaving so abruptly. Also with the other MC becoming so cynical. Did not really enjoy it that much.

The Christmas Proposition, K.A. Mitchell, 4.5 stars (wanted to give it 4 for the ending, then I relented) good narration for all characters.
Melchior (yes one of the three kings) and Bryce are the MCs and I really enjoyed their story. I have not read many books set in this part of the US. I thought Tiffany was a bridezilla and guess that Mel's friendship with her was so long and deep he just did whatever because of that long relationship. I liked Bryce but kind of thought he needed better communication skills and how did he get to be the owner of his company with such poor interpersonal skills? The expected happy ending was cut short by the standard M/M trope of "no communication" and I swore at Mel for it and also at K.A. for writing it and then realized that me and my husband recently had a major flare up of "no communication" and I had to get over being upset because yes, communication issues can happen to even long term relationships let alone Mel's and Bryce's rekindled one.

Narrators, but not sure who did which story and I couldn't find online.
Max Tatch (narrator)
James de Grassi (Narrator)
Jack LeFleur (Narrator)
L.B. Townsend (Narrator)

[☾⋆⁺ Nurse After Dark · Rating 4 out of 5]

My True Love Gave To Me – Ava March
3/5 --- tropes historical romance, angry revenge sex, second chances

His gaze somehow knew exactly where to go, landing with unerring accuracy on the most handsome man to ever grace a ball.

I could tell from the start that this author knew their regency romances! The language and setting was all true to period, which is fun because it’s typically a lesser utilized time period for M/M romance. That being said, I did find the whole story a bit too long for what it was. The flashback could’ve ended a chapter sooner, along with some of the push-pull in the middle between our MCs.

Winter Knights – Harper Fox
5/5 --- tropes MMM, first time, toys, several different mentions of death, one involving MCs

In the end, it was Lance who broke the silence. "Hoi, Your Majesty. Why should I get the couch?"
Art gave him a loving grin. "He was my rescue. But... fair question. Come here then, handsome, while he makes his mind up."

As soon as I read the blurb, I realized that sometime in my reading past, I've read this novella before! It was long enough ago that the twist (and what a twist it was!) surprised me again. Also, I didn't expect the spice to be as hot! The whole plot, spinning around mythology like it was, was fun and engaging. I look forward to re-reading this one next year!

Lone Star
5/5 --- tropes cowboys, second chance, stalker reindeer?

A lone star blazed in the midnight blue sky.
It looked like the Christmas star, which was appropriate seeing that it was four days till the holiday, but with Mitch's luck it was more likely a crashing jet plane headed straight for him.
Incoming!

Every time I read Josh Lanyon, I start out my reviews with a big ole, slap on the knee exclamation - "Classic Josh Lanyon". And this continues to be true. You meet the guys. You love the guys for very different reasons. You watch *them* fall in love - with a few ups and downs. The end. Consistency must be their key because if they keep writing, I'll keep reading!

The Christmas Proposition
5/5 --- tropes The best smut in the whole anthology

Bryce did a lot of that, working with his crews, disguised as a regular human and not someone who'd made ten million dollars before he turned thirty. Kind of like one of those Greek gods who used to go out among the mortals to see who was worthy. I suspected he had ab equal amount of arrogance.

This was the perfect end to the anthology - not only do we get the hottest spice, but its super cute too - "Well, look at that. Your thought bubble popped all on its own." Argh, right in the feels. And the Christmassy vibes from the tree farm are A+!

This anthology will be an easy annual re-read!

[Mandi · Rating 4 out of 5]

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March

Alexander and Thomas are in love. Both 19 years old, while Alexander has fooled around with a few other boys his age, neither have ever been in a serious relationship. Alexander is actually the first boy Thomas has ever kissed. The feelings are all very new and intense for both of them. Being young and in love isn’t as carefree as you think, especially in the early 19th century. Thomas is scared of others finding out and still doesn’t feel confident about his feelings toward men. Alexander is a little surer of himself and pushes Thomas for a physical relationship.

One of my favorite things about Ava March stories is the way she writes such great chemistry and emotional intensity between her heroes. And she tricked me with this story. I thought it was going to be a straight-forward love story with these men exploring their new feelings for each other. Instead, she skips ahead four years and really throws an emotional wrench into their relationship. It becomes a bit darker, and both heroes really have to work at the HEA. Well done.

Rating: B

Winter Knights by Harper Fox

Here’s the blurb:

Historian Gavin Lowden is in Northumberland on Christmas Eve for two reasons: to find evidence of a romantic bond between Arthur and Lancelot and to finally tell his partner, Piers, that he loves him. Piers has promised to come clean with his conservative family and join Gavin for their first holiday as a couple, but at the last minute, he bails. Devastated, Gavin heads out onto the moors alone, just as snow begins to fall …
Gavin stumbles into an underground chamber, where strange happenings cause him to question what is real and what is fantasy. He’s found by two mysterious men, who offer him a bed for the night — and awaken him to nuances of erotic pleasure he didn’t know existed. Pleasure he hopes to be able to share with Piers.
When Piers learns that Gavin has gone missing, he is desperate to find him. He knows now breaking up was a terrible mistake, and he’s ready to take the next step in their relationship — if it’s not already too late.
Honestly, I read this blurb and wasn’t looking forward to this story. I’ve read a couple of previous Harper Fox books, though, and really enjoy her voice so I read this one with a little bit of trepidation. I do think the beginning is slow, but after we start to get into the story, I think this turned out to be my favorite one in the collection.

Harper Fox twists the story of King Arthur and Lancelot in a pretty unique way — to the point where you aren’t quite sure if this story really happened or not. And the emotions you go through with Gavin — from despair to acceptance to joy at being reunited with Piers — are so well done. I couldn’t help but smile at some of the parts of this story. I’m really loving this author and can’t wait for more from her.

Rating: A-

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon

Josh Lanyon gives us a warm, quiet Texas Ranger and a high-strung, very accomplished ballet dancer and that makes for a somewhat different romance. Mitchell lives and breathes ballet, having worked very hard to make it in the American Ballet Theater. After his father’s death and walking in on his lover on the receiving end of being pleasured by a woman, he decides to make a quick trip to his hometown in Texas to settle his father’s estate. Twelve years prior, he had been in love with Web, but it was too hard for Web to come out of the closet. Both young and ambitious, Mitchell fled to New York to pursue dance and never looked back while, Web became a Texas Ranger.

But now they are reunited and those feelings come back to the forefront. Even though Mitchell is somewhat hotheaded and has a bit of a temper, this turns out to be a very low-key, quiet romance. It’s not necessarily a question of do they love each other, but how they are going to make their romance work living in two different parts of the country. And what I liked is that we get an HEA, but their entire future isn’t laid out for us. They have such big decisions to make and, fortunately, Josh Lanyon doesn’t force them to make their decisions in such a short story. I really enjoyed that Mitchell was a ballet dancer — you don’t run across that in a lot of romance books. Web has a warm, extended family that gave this book a small-town feel.

Rating: B

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell

This one is by far the sexiest and dirtiest story of the group, and I really enjoyed it. After his parents died, Mel helps his siblings run a big tree farm in Pennsylvania. He has two jobs and a sister who struggles with prescription-drug abuse, so he has a lot on his plate. In the past few years, natural gas has been discovered underground in his small town, which has brought in tons of gas drillers. It’s become a big business, and Mel sees lots of workers go through his town. One in particular, Bryce, has made more than just an impression. Bryce is not only a gas worker, he actually owns the gas company. Bryce and Mel became very involved about three years ago. But Bryce traveled a lot for his job, and Mel wasn’t ready to leave his family obligations. But now Bryce is back.

These two can’t keep their pants on when they are around each other. Whereas in the other three stories, there was always the pressure of one of the heroes coming out and coming to terms with being gay, in this story, these two are out and have no issues being together. And it is hot. I think this is the first I’ve read by K.A. Mitchell, and I definitely need to read more from her.

Rating: B+

Overall Rating: B+

[Genevieve · Rating 5 out of 5]

A great collection of books from different authors. Loved them all.

[willaful · Rating 4 out of 5]

Although all the lovers are male, in many ways this is a typical Christmas romance anthology: it features a Regency, a ghost story, a Western, and a humorous first-person contemporary, and though the sex scenes are explicit, the emphasis is mostly on the romance. All of the stories are also available as separate ebooks.

My True Love Gave to Me by Ava March.

A simple, but emotionally charged historical romance. Alex and Thomas fell in love as students at Oxford, but Thomas was too frightened to continue their romance and ran away to New York. Four years later, Thomas has realized that he’ll never be able to stop wanting men or loving Alex -- but the Alex he left behind is now very bitter and reluctant to be vulnerable again. Despite the historical setting, the focus is almost entirely on the emotional/sexual aspects of their situation, with lots of good gut-twists. 4 stars.

Winter Knights by Harper Fox.

Within a conventional framework -- a supernatural event on Christmas eve teaches the protagonist some important lessons -- this beautifully written story goes far beyond convention. Folklorist Gavin is devastated when his devoutly Catholic lover Piers dumps him and tells him he’s marrying a woman; he wanders out in the snow and becomes trapped in a cave, hallucinating about finding the site where King Arthur and his knights are sleeping, waiting to be called back to life. When Gavin is saved by two kindly and handsome rescue workers, Art and Lance, he spends an astonishing night with them and gains new insight into his relationship with Piers and his feelings about Pier’s religion.

Winter Knights is told in the first person, a very useful narrative form for an m/m romance, because of the pronoun issue -- but it’s also structurally significant to the story, as we discover that in some ways Gavin has been not a reliable narrator and there was a lot more going on with him and Piers than he initially revealed. And this is not the typical first person of romance, relentlessly breezy or ironic, but an evocative and emotional telling that gives the setting and characters life. The plot is maybe a little too busy, but overall this is a gem. 4.5 stars.

Lone Star by Josh Lanyon.

After his estranged father's death, ballet dancer Mitch returns to the Texas town he grew up in and rediscovers some of the good things he left behind -- like his high school boyfriend Web, who's now a Texas Ranger and no longer determined to stay in the closet. A good read, but not as inspired as I expect from Lanyon. A suggested supernatural element is never explained and the ending ties up too neatly. 3 stars.

The Christmas Proposition by K.A. Mitchell.

Mel, the responsible one in his family (as well as the gay one), stayed behind to tend his Christmas tree farm while the two important lovers in his life moved on. Now one of them is back and he seems as into Mel as ever -- but does he want commitment? And if he does -- does Mel?

This story has more, and more graphic gay sex scenes than any other in the anthology, yet oddly enough I found it the least convincing. It read like chick lit, and the narrator’s voice persisted in sounding like a woman to me, no matter how many times he mentioned his dick or what he was doing with it. It did have funny spots, and an interesting environmentalist conflict between Bryce and Mel. 2 stars.