What do you think?
Rate this book
The Phoenix Bride
A passionate tale of plague, fire, and forbidden love in seventeenth-century London from the acclaimed author of Solomon's Crown
1666. It is a year after plague has devastated England. Young widow Cecilia Thorowgood is a prisoner, trapped and isolated within the cavernous London townhouse of her older sister. At the mercy of a legion of doctors who fail to cure her grief with their impatient scalpels, Cecilia shows no signs of improvement. Soon, her sister makes a decision borne of she hires a new physician, someone known for more unusual methods. But he is a foreigner. A Jew. And despite his attempts to save Cecilia, he knows he cannot quell the storm of grief that rages within her. There is no easy cure for melancholy.
David Mendes fled Portugal to seek a new life in London, where he could practice his faith openly and leave the past behind. Still reeling from the loss of his beloved friend, struggling with his religion and his past, David finds himself in this foreign land, free and safe, but incapable of happiness—caring not even for himself, but only for his ailing father. The security he has found in London threatens to disappear when he meets Cecilia, and he finds himself torn between his duty to medicine and the beating of his own heart. He is the only one who can see her pain; the glimmers of light she emits, even in her gloom, are enough to make him believe once more in love.
Facing seemingly insurmountable challenges, David and Cecilia must endure prejudice, heartbreak, and calamity before they can be together. A Great Fire is coming—and with the city in flames around them, love has never felt so impossible.
1666. It is a year after plague has devastated England. Young widow Cecilia Thorowgood is a prisoner, trapped and isolated within the cavernous London townhouse of her older sister. At the mercy of a legion of doctors who fail to cure her grief with their impatient scalpels, Cecilia shows no signs of improvement. Soon, her sister makes a decision borne of she hires a new physician, someone known for more unusual methods. But he is a foreigner. A Jew. And despite his attempts to save Cecilia, he knows he cannot quell the storm of grief that rages within her. There is no easy cure for melancholy.
David Mendes fled Portugal to seek a new life in London, where he could practice his faith openly and leave the past behind. Still reeling from the loss of his beloved friend, struggling with his religion and his past, David finds himself in this foreign land, free and safe, but incapable of happiness—caring not even for himself, but only for his ailing father. The security he has found in London threatens to disappear when he meets Cecilia, and he finds himself torn between his duty to medicine and the beating of his own heart. He is the only one who can see her pain; the glimmers of light she emits, even in her gloom, are enough to make him believe once more in love.
Facing seemingly insurmountable challenges, David and Cecilia must endure prejudice, heartbreak, and calamity before they can be together. A Great Fire is coming—and with the city in flames around them, love has never felt so impossible.
336 pages, Paperback
First published March 12, 2024
128 people are currently reading
17605 people want to read
About the author
Natasha Siegel
3 books356 followersNatasha Siegel is a writer of historical fiction. She was born and raised in London, where she grew up in a Danish-Jewish family surrounded by stories.
Her next book, As Many Souls As Stars, releases November 2025 with Bloomsbury UK / William Morrow.
She is represented by Catherine Cho at Paper Literary.
Her next book, As Many Souls As Stars, releases November 2025 with Bloomsbury UK / William Morrow.
She is represented by Catherine Cho at Paper Literary.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 391 reviews
February 5, 2024
The Phoenix Bride unfolds the tale of two bereaved individuals, each grappling with feelings of powerlessness and a deep need to be heard.
Set in the latter half of the 17th century England, the story opens with Cecilia recounting her her marriage to William Thorowgood and the brief joy it brought her. However, her happiness is swiftly extinguished by the plague that claims her husband, leaving her a bitter widow who harbors resentment towards her environment and, at times, even her sister Margaret.
This narrative shifts between Cecilia and David Mendes, a Jewish physician who fled Portugal for England to freely practice his faith. In Portugal, the risks of being a surgeon – and a Jewish one at that – loom large, but England seems the safer option. David quickly becomes friends with Manuel and his family, only to mourn Manuel’s loss to the plague. Then, a letter arrives, summoning him to consult for the ailing Cecilia, whom Margaret has unsuccessfully tried to cure through numerous doctors.
During his second visit, while delivering medicine to Cecilia, Margaret informs David of Cecilia’s impending, yet unknown to her, marriage. Cecilia must recover before the autumn, or Margaret can no longer secure her husband’s support for her sister. David recalls his late friend’s advice to always do what feels right, which in his friend’s case, meant telling the truth. Yes David struggles with this, fearing the repercussions on his career from Cecilia’s family.
As a fire ravages wooden houses and bridges, altering its path with the wind and leaving many destitute, the lives of the two protagonists begin to shift with the changing circumstances.
Despite the somber backdrop, moments of humor emerge from the interactions between Cecilia, who detests nearly everything, and David, who strives to heal her bitterness.
The characters in the Phoenix Bride are richly developed. Following their period of mourning, they embark on a journey of self-discovery and hope, set against the historical context of the Jewish expulsion and their ongoing struggle to lead normal lives wherever they resettle.
This expertly narrated story is captivating and poignant, weaving together the lives of two people who dare to transcend societal norms. In an era where mingling of different religions was taboo, they uplift each other, finding a way to rise above their grief and discover a new perspective on life.
Review originally posted at mysteryandsuspense.com
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Set in the latter half of the 17th century England, the story opens with Cecilia recounting her her marriage to William Thorowgood and the brief joy it brought her. However, her happiness is swiftly extinguished by the plague that claims her husband, leaving her a bitter widow who harbors resentment towards her environment and, at times, even her sister Margaret.
This narrative shifts between Cecilia and David Mendes, a Jewish physician who fled Portugal for England to freely practice his faith. In Portugal, the risks of being a surgeon – and a Jewish one at that – loom large, but England seems the safer option. David quickly becomes friends with Manuel and his family, only to mourn Manuel’s loss to the plague. Then, a letter arrives, summoning him to consult for the ailing Cecilia, whom Margaret has unsuccessfully tried to cure through numerous doctors.
During his second visit, while delivering medicine to Cecilia, Margaret informs David of Cecilia’s impending, yet unknown to her, marriage. Cecilia must recover before the autumn, or Margaret can no longer secure her husband’s support for her sister. David recalls his late friend’s advice to always do what feels right, which in his friend’s case, meant telling the truth. Yes David struggles with this, fearing the repercussions on his career from Cecilia’s family.
As a fire ravages wooden houses and bridges, altering its path with the wind and leaving many destitute, the lives of the two protagonists begin to shift with the changing circumstances.
Despite the somber backdrop, moments of humor emerge from the interactions between Cecilia, who detests nearly everything, and David, who strives to heal her bitterness.
The characters in the Phoenix Bride are richly developed. Following their period of mourning, they embark on a journey of self-discovery and hope, set against the historical context of the Jewish expulsion and their ongoing struggle to lead normal lives wherever they resettle.
This expertly narrated story is captivating and poignant, weaving together the lives of two people who dare to transcend societal norms. In an era where mingling of different religions was taboo, they uplift each other, finding a way to rise above their grief and discover a new perspective on life.
Review originally posted at mysteryandsuspense.com
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
March 13, 2024
We all have wounds. Even doctors cannot cure an injured heart.
After only reading one chapter, tears already shone in my eyes. The Phoenix Bride is a historical novel about two people who both lost the love of their lives to the plague. Cecilia her beloved husband Will, David his best friend Manuel.
Natasha Siegel’s writing is gorgeous. Her prose is rich and abundant with beautiful descriptions of the scenery, especially plants and flowers and trees. It made me feel like I was in 1666 London, in the courtyard, the parks, and the busy streets with all the stalls. Cecilia's sadness is immediately palpable. Never one for temperance nor self-control, she now is a shadow of the girl she once was. David's grief is far more subtle, a quiet, almost forbidden kind of heartache, tucked far, far away, but so tangible between the lines.
At first glance, David is a confident man, but he feels responsible for everyone he’s lost, even his patients. He’s a Jew, and his faith, his doubts about it, and his restlessness, but also not being wanted in so many places, are an important part of The Phoenix Bride. While reading this story, my heart grew heavy, and my mind wandered to Gaza many times. Jews like David have been chased away over centuries from so many countries, but right now, it’s the Palestinians who are under attack, and at the same time, antisemitism is rampant. It makes me sad and almost desperate.
Life has value, regardless of who lives it.
I loved Natasha’s debut, Solomon’s Crown, but I think this one is even better. It’s a diverse story, not only because of David’s faith but also in sexuality and neurodiversity. The Phoenix Bride is soft and quiet, tender and full of yearning, heartwarming and devastating at times. This book is not a romance. It’s a love story between two people who’ve loved before, see themselves in the mirror of each other’s grief, and find solace in one another.
If only we could stay here always, you and I, and pretend the earth is no longer turning.
Natasha Siegel has cemented herself as an auto-read author for me, and I know she’s writing a sapphic story now, and I can’t wait for it!
Thank you so much, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine and NetGalley, for this beautiful ARC! It’s a story never to forget!
Follow me on Instagram
After only reading one chapter, tears already shone in my eyes. The Phoenix Bride is a historical novel about two people who both lost the love of their lives to the plague. Cecilia her beloved husband Will, David his best friend Manuel.
Natasha Siegel’s writing is gorgeous. Her prose is rich and abundant with beautiful descriptions of the scenery, especially plants and flowers and trees. It made me feel like I was in 1666 London, in the courtyard, the parks, and the busy streets with all the stalls. Cecilia's sadness is immediately palpable. Never one for temperance nor self-control, she now is a shadow of the girl she once was. David's grief is far more subtle, a quiet, almost forbidden kind of heartache, tucked far, far away, but so tangible between the lines.
At first glance, David is a confident man, but he feels responsible for everyone he’s lost, even his patients. He’s a Jew, and his faith, his doubts about it, and his restlessness, but also not being wanted in so many places, are an important part of The Phoenix Bride. While reading this story, my heart grew heavy, and my mind wandered to Gaza many times. Jews like David have been chased away over centuries from so many countries, but right now, it’s the Palestinians who are under attack, and at the same time, antisemitism is rampant. It makes me sad and almost desperate.
Life has value, regardless of who lives it.
I loved Natasha’s debut, Solomon’s Crown, but I think this one is even better. It’s a diverse story, not only because of David’s faith but also in sexuality and neurodiversity. The Phoenix Bride is soft and quiet, tender and full of yearning, heartwarming and devastating at times. This book is not a romance. It’s a love story between two people who’ve loved before, see themselves in the mirror of each other’s grief, and find solace in one another.
If only we could stay here always, you and I, and pretend the earth is no longer turning.
Natasha Siegel has cemented herself as an auto-read author for me, and I know she’s writing a sapphic story now, and I can’t wait for it!
Thank you so much, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine and NetGalley, for this beautiful ARC! It’s a story never to forget!
Follow me on Instagram
June 27, 2023
Hi! I wrote this book!
THE PHOENIX BRIDE is a love letter to immigrants, to faith, to London, to recovery from trauma and learning to forgive yourself. This is a book that deals heavily with themes of grief (there's a full list of content warnings on my website) but it's also full of joy, passion, and soul-deep yearning. If you like pining in your romances, tender touches and shy glances, then this one is for you!
THE PHOENIX BRIDE is a love letter to immigrants, to faith, to London, to recovery from trauma and learning to forgive yourself. This is a book that deals heavily with themes of grief (there's a full list of content warnings on my website) but it's also full of joy, passion, and soul-deep yearning. If you like pining in your romances, tender touches and shy glances, then this one is for you!
March 22, 2024
Stars: 2.5/5 (rounded up to 3)
Tropes and what to expect:
- Dual POV
- Slow burn romance
- forbidden romance
- queer representation
- historical fiction
Among other triggers this book does contain on page spouse death.
Overall I thought this was an interesting book. However, it didn't grab me as I had hoped it would and it took me some time to get through, despite it being quite short. The Phoenix Bride feels to me more of a focus on grief and historical fiction than on romance, and I had been expecting a more romantic book when I started reading. As a general historical fiction book, I do think it is quite beautiful and unique.
The writing style that Natasha used in The Phoenix Bride is intensely poetic. I had a bit of trouble with it, personally. I do think this could be someone's absolute favorite style, as I am often drawn to unique writing. Unfortunately it did not quite click like I was hoping it would. It felt poetic to the point of ambiguity at times, in a way that made for a less enjoyable read. I found myself wishing that things were more clearly explained without so much flowery prose.
I liked our main characters but I did not find them very unique, more so the FMC than the MMC. Nothing about Cecilia is going to stick with me long term. However, I did like David, and I felt that he was a more well fleshed out and clear character.
Thank you to Natasha Siegel and NetGalley for my ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Tropes and what to expect:
- Dual POV
- Slow burn romance
- forbidden romance
- queer representation
- historical fiction
Among other triggers this book does contain on page spouse death.
Overall I thought this was an interesting book. However, it didn't grab me as I had hoped it would and it took me some time to get through, despite it being quite short. The Phoenix Bride feels to me more of a focus on grief and historical fiction than on romance, and I had been expecting a more romantic book when I started reading. As a general historical fiction book, I do think it is quite beautiful and unique.
The writing style that Natasha used in The Phoenix Bride is intensely poetic. I had a bit of trouble with it, personally. I do think this could be someone's absolute favorite style, as I am often drawn to unique writing. Unfortunately it did not quite click like I was hoping it would. It felt poetic to the point of ambiguity at times, in a way that made for a less enjoyable read. I found myself wishing that things were more clearly explained without so much flowery prose.
I liked our main characters but I did not find them very unique, more so the FMC than the MMC. Nothing about Cecilia is going to stick with me long term. However, I did like David, and I felt that he was a more well fleshed out and clear character.
Thank you to Natasha Siegel and NetGalley for my ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
June 20, 2024
Cecilia Thorowgood is widowed and at the mercy of her (slightly) older sister. When her sister calls on a Jewish doctor named David Mendes to help cure her grief, they bond. Now is where there should be boners but this isn't a romance so instead of boners there are just heaps of feelings: feelings about love, about grief, about societal norms, about freedom, and feelings about feelings. Eventually, though, they do bone. Good job, everyone.
1. As mentioned, this isn't a romance; instead, it's a historical fiction that has romance in it. Slight difference, with different approaches to story beats and satisfactory endings and all that stuff: I don't list this as a complaint, but as a point of clarification.
2. So I didn't enjoy this very much, which—in this case at least—is very much a me thing vs. a book thing. I.e., the book holds together as an art: the prose is interesting and melodic; the characters are not entirely flat or uninteresting; the setting is decently rendered; the conflict is organic and resolved in a way that aligns with what we've been given. A decent art!
The issue is that I didn't...really...care about any of it? Which could very well be me and the headspace I am currently occupying. But I didn't really believe some of the internal angsting or resolution beats or even what would come next once the book ends. It just didn't hook me, at all, and I finished it mostly because it didn't give me a good enough reason not to—but not, you notice, because I actually cared about how it all came out.
3. I feel like the linden tree's presence should have meant more than I took away from this thing, with how shoehorned into the narrative it was. Yay trees, I guess?
4. I did enjoy Sam, but wanted more about who he was and how and why—there are flashes of it, but then the miasma of feelings about feelings kind of get in the way.
5. Ditto, Jan.
6. The fire of London was an interesting climatic point of the book, but it definitely felt far more disconnected from the story than it probably should have been, especially with a title like The Phoenix Bride. This is just a situation where an overarching metaphor—restoration and rebirth—is half-baked into the thing but hasn't fully integrated with a major plot point. The bones are there, but they're bare and kind of deadened.
1. As mentioned, this isn't a romance; instead, it's a historical fiction that has romance in it. Slight difference, with different approaches to story beats and satisfactory endings and all that stuff: I don't list this as a complaint, but as a point of clarification.
2. So I didn't enjoy this very much, which—in this case at least—is very much a me thing vs. a book thing. I.e., the book holds together as an art: the prose is interesting and melodic; the characters are not entirely flat or uninteresting; the setting is decently rendered; the conflict is organic and resolved in a way that aligns with what we've been given. A decent art!
The issue is that I didn't...really...care about any of it? Which could very well be me and the headspace I am currently occupying. But I didn't really believe some of the internal angsting or resolution beats or even what would come next once the book ends. It just didn't hook me, at all, and I finished it mostly because it didn't give me a good enough reason not to—but not, you notice, because I actually cared about how it all came out.
3. I feel like the linden tree's presence should have meant more than I took away from this thing, with how shoehorned into the narrative it was. Yay trees, I guess?
4. I did enjoy Sam, but wanted more about who he was and how and why—there are flashes of it, but then the miasma of feelings about feelings kind of get in the way.
5. Ditto, Jan.
6. The fire of London was an interesting climatic point of the book, but it definitely felt far more disconnected from the story than it probably should have been, especially with a title like The Phoenix Bride. This is just a situation where an overarching metaphor—restoration and rebirth—is half-baked into the thing but hasn't fully integrated with a major plot point. The bones are there, but they're bare and kind of deadened.
July 18, 2024
This was surprisingly good.
Extremey depressing, but really good.
Not much kissing, lots of people dying, and still kinda showcases hope and rebirth.
I rather enjoyed this and will be looking for more from Natasha Siegel.
Extremey depressing, but really good.
Not much kissing, lots of people dying, and still kinda showcases hope and rebirth.
I rather enjoyed this and will be looking for more from Natasha Siegel.
April 1, 2024
Why aren’t more people talking about this beautiful book? I borrowed it on a whim and am giddy over how wonderful it was.
February 28, 2024
“She is ivory and gold. She is Granada; she is the mezuzah on the doorframe. And someday, perhaps, things will change: the fire will end, a new summer will come, the linden will bloom again.”
I am absolutely astounded at how much I loved this story. I knew I was a fan of Natasha Siegel’s writing and her gorgeous, poignant historicals after Solomon’s Crown, but this really was a whole other level for me. Picture the most exquisite longing, the slowest, tenderest pining, magnify it by 100, and you’ll get The Phoenix Bride
Set in late 1600s London, it is the story of recently windowed, grief stricken Cecilia and the physician hired to treat her melancholy— a Jewish physician called David. Slowly, as the two get to know each other, they find a kindred spirit in both grief and love, and the walls between them, in station, religion and background, begin to crumble.
I adored the pacing and how character driven it was, especially around how careful the two MCs were with each other, and how softly they fell into love. Like in Solomon’s Crown, alongside the romance there’s a greater historical conversation happening. David is Jewish and fled Portugal years earlier with his father for England in the hopes of being able to practice their faith openly, despite the continuing persecution happening on both sides of the Channel. I found the aspects surrounding identity and privilege to be thoughtfully handled and full of delicate nuance, and enjoyed learning about a facet of history I was previously uneducated on.
If you’re a fan of a slow-to-trust romance with a rich historical background and a plethora of queer characters, I couldn’t recommend this more. With aspects of a forbidden romance that I truly couldn’t see a way around, I felt the longing between the characters to be together as keenly as if I was in the story. So many times I had to stop and reread passages that were so exquisite with pining I felt a bit ill (complimentary). I know it’s only February and I have a big year of reading ahead of me, but I can genuinely see this being one of my top reads of the year, and it has really cemented Natasha as one of my favourite historical writers.
I am absolutely astounded at how much I loved this story. I knew I was a fan of Natasha Siegel’s writing and her gorgeous, poignant historicals after Solomon’s Crown, but this really was a whole other level for me. Picture the most exquisite longing, the slowest, tenderest pining, magnify it by 100, and you’ll get The Phoenix Bride
Set in late 1600s London, it is the story of recently windowed, grief stricken Cecilia and the physician hired to treat her melancholy— a Jewish physician called David. Slowly, as the two get to know each other, they find a kindred spirit in both grief and love, and the walls between them, in station, religion and background, begin to crumble.
I adored the pacing and how character driven it was, especially around how careful the two MCs were with each other, and how softly they fell into love. Like in Solomon’s Crown, alongside the romance there’s a greater historical conversation happening. David is Jewish and fled Portugal years earlier with his father for England in the hopes of being able to practice their faith openly, despite the continuing persecution happening on both sides of the Channel. I found the aspects surrounding identity and privilege to be thoughtfully handled and full of delicate nuance, and enjoyed learning about a facet of history I was previously uneducated on.
If you’re a fan of a slow-to-trust romance with a rich historical background and a plethora of queer characters, I couldn’t recommend this more. With aspects of a forbidden romance that I truly couldn’t see a way around, I felt the longing between the characters to be together as keenly as if I was in the story. So many times I had to stop and reread passages that were so exquisite with pining I felt a bit ill (complimentary). I know it’s only February and I have a big year of reading ahead of me, but I can genuinely see this being one of my top reads of the year, and it has really cemented Natasha as one of my favourite historical writers.
April 19, 2024
This book was so beautiful and engrossing! I went in thinking it would be more of a historical fiction novel, so the lack of a traditional HEA wasn't an issue for me. I loved the setting and time period and found the relationship between David and Cecilia to be completely captivating.
I enjoyed the medical aspects of the story and thought that the way Cecilia described her feelings was so superbly handled. The diversity in the story played such an important role and touches on subjects of mental health, sexuality, and religion.
The characters were all vividly written, and I particularly loved Sam. He was an amazing side character and brought much needed humor and lightness to the story. The friendship and support he offered Cecilia were absolutely delightful.
Overall, this was beautifully written and emotional. It's something that will stay with me for a long time to come.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I enjoyed the medical aspects of the story and thought that the way Cecilia described her feelings was so superbly handled. The diversity in the story played such an important role and touches on subjects of mental health, sexuality, and religion.
The characters were all vividly written, and I particularly loved Sam. He was an amazing side character and brought much needed humor and lightness to the story. The friendship and support he offered Cecilia were absolutely delightful.
Overall, this was beautifully written and emotional. It's something that will stay with me for a long time to come.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.
March 12, 2024
A beautifully, written historical romance that deals with love after loss. I found myself fully absorbed into this book and loved the world building that the author was able to achieve.
David is a physician hired to treat Cecilia and they slowly build trust and a connection with each other even though there are multiple obstacles that make a future together impossible. This greatly benefits from having chapters from both David and Cecilia’s POVs and there’s a substantial amount of plot that keeps things moving along at a fast pace. I also enjoyed many of the charming side characters. This sort of faltered a bit for me in the end but I still appreciated how hopeful and brave both characters were.
Highly recommend this one! Thanks to Random House Ballantine and NetGalley for providing the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
David is a physician hired to treat Cecilia and they slowly build trust and a connection with each other even though there are multiple obstacles that make a future together impossible. This greatly benefits from having chapters from both David and Cecilia’s POVs and there’s a substantial amount of plot that keeps things moving along at a fast pace. I also enjoyed many of the charming side characters. This sort of faltered a bit for me in the end but I still appreciated how hopeful and brave both characters were.
Highly recommend this one! Thanks to Random House Ballantine and NetGalley for providing the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
April 13, 2024
Not my favorite. The characters were totally 21st Century in a 17th Century London setting. But can I just say that the cover is beautiful ??
April 23, 2024
3.25☆
this book started off very promising, but i wish the two main characters had bonded more before having their big kiss. i can't say much about the historical accuracy since i'm not familiar with 17th century england, but the author did use a very important historical event to move the plot forward and that aspect was done well. i liked the ending too, but overall, i didn't really connect with the characters.
pre-read: i don't read novels set in the 17th century much, so i'm excited to get to this one
this book started off very promising, but i wish the two main characters had bonded more before having their big kiss. i can't say much about the historical accuracy since i'm not familiar with 17th century england, but the author did use a very important historical event to move the plot forward and that aspect was done well. i liked the ending too, but overall, i didn't really connect with the characters.
pre-read: i don't read novels set in the 17th century much, so i'm excited to get to this one
December 6, 2023
I am going to say this book had a quiet beauty to it's storyline of two people each broken hearted by loss losing a beloved dear to their hearts and the sacrifice people sometimes make.
Thank you very much to author Natasha Seigel and NetGalley for a copy of this read.
Thank you very much to author Natasha Seigel and NetGalley for a copy of this read.
March 11, 2024
What does a "Happily Ever After" mean to you? Does a nontraditional HEA count? I personally consider this a historical romance that's heavy on the history, but still a romance.
Without specific spoilers, this is a forbidden romance: Cecilia, a widow from an impoverished noble background, falls for David, a Jewish physician. Cecilia and David are dealing with grief due to the loss of a loved one. Cecilia's husband Will and David's unrequited love, Manuel, both died of the plague during a recent outbreak. Through their relationship, they can begin the healing process. In 1665, their romance is dangerous for both of them. Cecilia's sister is determined to marry her off to another nobleman, Sam, while David is being courted by Manuel's sister. David's business depends on the beneficent eye of the Anglican community: if one of his patients dies, he could lose his livelihood or even his life.
David's careful balance of his Jewish heritage, his public persona, and what he sees as his debt to the Jewish community form a fascinating background to the book. Cecilia might come from a relatively privileged family, but her current position of impoverished widow dependent on her sister's charity allows her to sympathize with David's position. This is not a closed door romance, but it's not particularly explicit. And that HEA isn't ambiguous, but it's also not a public acknowledgement of David and Cecilia's relationship and love. I found it satisfying and appropriate, but I could see some readers finding it lacking.
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
Without specific spoilers, this is a forbidden romance: Cecilia, a widow from an impoverished noble background, falls for David, a Jewish physician. Cecilia and David are dealing with grief due to the loss of a loved one. Cecilia's husband Will and David's unrequited love, Manuel, both died of the plague during a recent outbreak. Through their relationship, they can begin the healing process. In 1665, their romance is dangerous for both of them. Cecilia's sister is determined to marry her off to another nobleman, Sam, while David is being courted by Manuel's sister. David's business depends on the beneficent eye of the Anglican community: if one of his patients dies, he could lose his livelihood or even his life.
David's careful balance of his Jewish heritage, his public persona, and what he sees as his debt to the Jewish community form a fascinating background to the book. Cecilia might come from a relatively privileged family, but her current position of impoverished widow dependent on her sister's charity allows her to sympathize with David's position. This is not a closed door romance, but it's not particularly explicit. And that HEA isn't ambiguous, but it's also not a public acknowledgement of David and Cecilia's relationship and love. I found it satisfying and appropriate, but I could see some readers finding it lacking.
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
October 3, 2025
4.5 ⭐ Inaspettato! Iniziato completamente a scatola chiusa dopo averlo trovato tra le offerte ebook, e mi ha conquistata. Un romanzo storico, ambientato a Londa nel 1666, che parla di perdita, lutto, diversità e lo fa tramite una storia d'amore proibito che mi ha scaldato il cuore. Avrei forse voluto più scene tra i due protagonisti prima del grande innamoramento, ma per il resto l'ho trovato davvero meraviglioso. Una scrittura pazzesca. Sicuramente leggerò altro dell'autrice.
" “It is a sickness,” she replies. “You are an affliction, David Mendes. I can’t be cured of you.” I say, “You are in need of a physician.” “I found one, but he only seems to have made the matter worse.” "
" I wish I could tell her how much I want her, that I could show it to her without the agony of trying to put it into words. I would remove my heart from my chest and give it to her, if she could somehow find proof through its dissection. I would hand her the scalpel myself. "
Non sapevo quale frase scegliere, c'è l'imbarazzo della scelta. La maniera con cui descrive la depressione, la speranza, il desiderio di due persone che non possono stare insieme...meraviglia.
" “It is a sickness,” she replies. “You are an affliction, David Mendes. I can’t be cured of you.” I say, “You are in need of a physician.” “I found one, but he only seems to have made the matter worse.” "
" I wish I could tell her how much I want her, that I could show it to her without the agony of trying to put it into words. I would remove my heart from my chest and give it to her, if she could somehow find proof through its dissection. I would hand her the scalpel myself. "
Non sapevo quale frase scegliere, c'è l'imbarazzo della scelta. La maniera con cui descrive la depressione, la speranza, il desiderio di due persone che non possono stare insieme...meraviglia.
March 11, 2024
Forbidden love
Don’t get me wrong, I love a good historical novel. When I first picked this up I just wasn’t in the mood, for something quite as deep. So I read a few lighter novels and then returned. I’m so glad I went back. The story has it all, illicit love, tragedy and rebirth.
I loved the sound premise to this story. Set in 1666 London. Time of the Restoration of the Stuart monarchy and King Charles. Cecilia Thorowgood’s husband has died of the plague. Cecilia is distraught. She’s suffers various doctors paraded before her trying to cure her of melancholy. David Mendes is a physician come Portugal, now living in a Jewish neighbourhood in Aldegate. He has been asked to treat Cecilia.
The story extends into a burgeoning friendship between Cecelia and David, Cecilia’s increasing fear of entrapment, a proposal of marriage from her sister’s husband’s nephew, her growing love for David, his fear of the harsh opinions of others (with good cause) all overshadowed by the Great Fire of London, when lives will be reshaped from a crucible of terror, just not in the way expected.
A Penguin Random House ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
Don’t get me wrong, I love a good historical novel. When I first picked this up I just wasn’t in the mood, for something quite as deep. So I read a few lighter novels and then returned. I’m so glad I went back. The story has it all, illicit love, tragedy and rebirth.
I loved the sound premise to this story. Set in 1666 London. Time of the Restoration of the Stuart monarchy and King Charles. Cecilia Thorowgood’s husband has died of the plague. Cecilia is distraught. She’s suffers various doctors paraded before her trying to cure her of melancholy. David Mendes is a physician come Portugal, now living in a Jewish neighbourhood in Aldegate. He has been asked to treat Cecilia.
The story extends into a burgeoning friendship between Cecelia and David, Cecilia’s increasing fear of entrapment, a proposal of marriage from her sister’s husband’s nephew, her growing love for David, his fear of the harsh opinions of others (with good cause) all overshadowed by the Great Fire of London, when lives will be reshaped from a crucible of terror, just not in the way expected.
A Penguin Random House ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
November 10, 2023
What a magnificent book. I absolutely loved this! Right from the beginning, Siegel establishes Cecilia as a strong, funny, loving young woman. I liked her immediately. She is very much in love but then the worst happens - the plague strikes her household - and she’s soon widowed. I was in actual tears by the time the first chapter had ended.
Cecilia’s grief over her beloved husband’s death is all-consuming when she meets David, a physician who is brought in to see her. David has also recently lost someone important to him and they end up establishing a connection because of it.
The grief is palpable and drives much of the book yet somehow it doesn’t feel weighed down with sadness. The writing in TPB is beautiful and powerful. It’s an exquisitely rendered love story set amid a backdrop of political and social turmoil. The profound relevance of this aspect of the story rather took me by surprise. The characters have just come out the other end of massive political upheaval, endured a plague, and are struggling with religious persecution and bigotry. Their social stability is questionable at best, especially for refugees and minorities. (The Author’s Note at the end has some interesting historical info that I recommend checking out.) David’s Jewishness and the forced relocation of his family from Portugal to England, as well as the relentless disdain he experiences in public, feels so timely.
Siegel has crafted such unique characters and a unique story in The Phoenix Bride. It is a stunning, gorgeous work, a quiet story with weighty and profound themes and exquisite writing. All in all, a very worthy successor to Solomon’s Crown. The rare sophomore effort that bests its predecessor. An absolute must read.
5 stars out of 5
Many thanks to Penguin Random House for providing the digital arc.
- dual POV
- m/f
- historical (1660s)
- forbidden love
- lgbtq rep
Cecilia’s grief over her beloved husband’s death is all-consuming when she meets David, a physician who is brought in to see her. David has also recently lost someone important to him and they end up establishing a connection because of it.
The grief is palpable and drives much of the book yet somehow it doesn’t feel weighed down with sadness. The writing in TPB is beautiful and powerful. It’s an exquisitely rendered love story set amid a backdrop of political and social turmoil. The profound relevance of this aspect of the story rather took me by surprise. The characters have just come out the other end of massive political upheaval, endured a plague, and are struggling with religious persecution and bigotry. Their social stability is questionable at best, especially for refugees and minorities. (The Author’s Note at the end has some interesting historical info that I recommend checking out.) David’s Jewishness and the forced relocation of his family from Portugal to England, as well as the relentless disdain he experiences in public, feels so timely.
Siegel has crafted such unique characters and a unique story in The Phoenix Bride. It is a stunning, gorgeous work, a quiet story with weighty and profound themes and exquisite writing. All in all, a very worthy successor to Solomon’s Crown. The rare sophomore effort that bests its predecessor. An absolute must read.
5 stars out of 5
Many thanks to Penguin Random House for providing the digital arc.
- dual POV
- m/f
- historical (1660s)
- forbidden love
- lgbtq rep
April 28, 2024
This is a book of historical fiction that takes place in London, 1666. It is told from the POV of two main characters: Cecelia Thorowgood, who is a Gentile and a young woman grieving the death of her husband by the plague. and David Mendes, a physician who has emigrated with his father (who is also a physician) from Portugal to England, so that they can worship openly as Jews.
The various themes woven through the story are grief, loss, religion, social prejudice, homosexuality, (even a bi character) and the Great Fire of London. Cecelia and David develop feelings for each other, but there are challenges each must face in spite of their love, and events take place that have an impact on their situation.
I understood the struggles Cecelia and David faced, but I didn't feel their emotions. and this was a great disappointment, because I wanted to connect to these characters. Siegel's story takes place in the year 1666, but it felt like a modern tale, except for the Great Fire of London, which occurs at the end. Also, the vague ending did not appeal to me. I liked the premise of the book, and several of the minor characters were very interesting. I also liked Siegel's beautiful and lyrical prose.
The various themes woven through the story are grief, loss, religion, social prejudice, homosexuality, (even a bi character) and the Great Fire of London. Cecelia and David develop feelings for each other, but there are challenges each must face in spite of their love, and events take place that have an impact on their situation.
I understood the struggles Cecelia and David faced, but I didn't feel their emotions. and this was a great disappointment, because I wanted to connect to these characters. Siegel's story takes place in the year 1666, but it felt like a modern tale, except for the Great Fire of London, which occurs at the end. Also, the vague ending did not appeal to me. I liked the premise of the book, and several of the minor characters were very interesting. I also liked Siegel's beautiful and lyrical prose.
March 12, 2024
★★★★★ - 𝐛𝐨𝐨𝐤 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰
The Phoenix Bride by Natasha Siegel
༘Spoiler free ༘
⭐️4.5/5
Historical Fiction, Romance, Women’s Fiction
Dual POV
➳ Forbidden Love
➳ Slow Burn
➳ Seventeenth Century England
➳ Grief
➳ LGBTQIA+ Representation
✨ “If only we could stay here always, you and I, and pretend the earth is no longer turning.“ ✨
In 'The Phoenix Bride', amidst the remnants of London's devastating plague, a tale of forbidden love, resilience, and unyielding human strength takes flight. Cecilia, a young widow consumed by grief, encounters David, a foreign healer, as the looming shadow of the Great Fire of London descends. Their romance faces societal barriers and imminent catastrophe, yet their unwavering pursuit of each other amid chaos unveils the beauty of a love powerful enough to endure and transcend trials and tribulations.
📚📚📚
In the wake of the devastating 1665 plague in London, the story unfurls around Cecilia Thorowgood, a young widow cloistered in her sister’s home, ensnared by unyielding grief. To aid her, her sister engages the services of David Mendes, a foreign physician with unconventional methods. David, a Jewish immigrant seeking refuge, grapples with personal loss and religious dilemmas.
As Cecilia and David navigate their emotional maelstroms, a clandestine love burgeons between them. Yet, their affection faces a number of challenges—prejudice, individual heartaches, and the looming shadow of the impending Great Fire of London. Amidst societal biases and personal struggles, the two defy the odds, determined to fight for their love in the face of the catastrophic event.
Against a backdrop of plague, fire, and societal divisions, the narrative weaves a poignant tale of love, resilience, and the wholehearted unwavering devotion, showcasing the capacity to endure even amid overwhelming trials and tribulations.
❧✧･ﾟ: *✧･ﾟ:❦:･ﾟ✧*:･ﾟ✧❧
✨ I fell in love with this book from the the book delves into societal prejudices, personal desires, and the tension between individual passions and societal norms, making it a compelling and immersive read within the historical romance fiction genre.
✨the character arcs in "The Phoenix Bride" were rich and multi-layered, drawing me into the intricate lives and internal struggles of the characters. The evolution of Cecilia, David, Sam, and Jan’s growth, conflicts, and relationships seem to intertwine in a way that shapes their individual journeys, showcasing the depth of their emotions, desires, and internal conflicts. The unexpected connections, hidden intentions, and societal pressures contribute to the complexities of their personal transformations. The relationships, felt deep and authentic.
✨ the core themes in "The Phoenix Bride" focus on the resilience of love amidst societal expectations and personal struggles during a historical period. Throughout the narrative, the story effectively explores the complexities of human connections, hidden motives, and individual desires in the midst of turmoil. The themes of love's challenges, conflicts, and societal norms persistently shape the characters' journeys and interactions.
✨The story was absolutely captivating and enthralling, leaving me deeply engaged with the characters and their journeys. However, as much as I loved it, I found myself yearning for an epilogue or some form of update on where our beloved characters ended up. The resolution was satisfying, yet an additional glimpse or closure on their lives post-events would have been a welcomed extension, providing a bit more closure and insight into their futures.
✨The prose of The Phoenix Bride is vividly descriptive, seamlessly blending emotional depth and historical detail. It eloquently portrays characters' emotions, struggles, and desires against the backdrop of 17th-century London, offering an intimate exploration of love and societal expectations within the historical context.
✨ 10/10 would recommend, i can’t wait to get my hands on this book and to have its beautiful cover and story gracing my shelves!
Thank you to Natasha Siegel, Random House Publishing Group, Dell and NetGalley for the opportunity to provide my honest opinion on the ARC of this book.
The Phoenix Bride by Natasha Siegel
༘Spoiler free ༘
⭐️4.5/5
Historical Fiction, Romance, Women’s Fiction
Dual POV
➳ Forbidden Love
➳ Slow Burn
➳ Seventeenth Century England
➳ Grief
➳ LGBTQIA+ Representation
✨ “If only we could stay here always, you and I, and pretend the earth is no longer turning.“ ✨
In 'The Phoenix Bride', amidst the remnants of London's devastating plague, a tale of forbidden love, resilience, and unyielding human strength takes flight. Cecilia, a young widow consumed by grief, encounters David, a foreign healer, as the looming shadow of the Great Fire of London descends. Their romance faces societal barriers and imminent catastrophe, yet their unwavering pursuit of each other amid chaos unveils the beauty of a love powerful enough to endure and transcend trials and tribulations.
📚📚📚
In the wake of the devastating 1665 plague in London, the story unfurls around Cecilia Thorowgood, a young widow cloistered in her sister’s home, ensnared by unyielding grief. To aid her, her sister engages the services of David Mendes, a foreign physician with unconventional methods. David, a Jewish immigrant seeking refuge, grapples with personal loss and religious dilemmas.
As Cecilia and David navigate their emotional maelstroms, a clandestine love burgeons between them. Yet, their affection faces a number of challenges—prejudice, individual heartaches, and the looming shadow of the impending Great Fire of London. Amidst societal biases and personal struggles, the two defy the odds, determined to fight for their love in the face of the catastrophic event.
Against a backdrop of plague, fire, and societal divisions, the narrative weaves a poignant tale of love, resilience, and the wholehearted unwavering devotion, showcasing the capacity to endure even amid overwhelming trials and tribulations.
❧✧･ﾟ: *✧･ﾟ:❦:･ﾟ✧*:･ﾟ✧❧
✨ I fell in love with this book from the the book delves into societal prejudices, personal desires, and the tension between individual passions and societal norms, making it a compelling and immersive read within the historical romance fiction genre.
✨the character arcs in "The Phoenix Bride" were rich and multi-layered, drawing me into the intricate lives and internal struggles of the characters. The evolution of Cecilia, David, Sam, and Jan’s growth, conflicts, and relationships seem to intertwine in a way that shapes their individual journeys, showcasing the depth of their emotions, desires, and internal conflicts. The unexpected connections, hidden intentions, and societal pressures contribute to the complexities of their personal transformations. The relationships, felt deep and authentic.
✨ the core themes in "The Phoenix Bride" focus on the resilience of love amidst societal expectations and personal struggles during a historical period. Throughout the narrative, the story effectively explores the complexities of human connections, hidden motives, and individual desires in the midst of turmoil. The themes of love's challenges, conflicts, and societal norms persistently shape the characters' journeys and interactions.
✨The story was absolutely captivating and enthralling, leaving me deeply engaged with the characters and their journeys. However, as much as I loved it, I found myself yearning for an epilogue or some form of update on where our beloved characters ended up. The resolution was satisfying, yet an additional glimpse or closure on their lives post-events would have been a welcomed extension, providing a bit more closure and insight into their futures.
✨The prose of The Phoenix Bride is vividly descriptive, seamlessly blending emotional depth and historical detail. It eloquently portrays characters' emotions, struggles, and desires against the backdrop of 17th-century London, offering an intimate exploration of love and societal expectations within the historical context.
✨ 10/10 would recommend, i can’t wait to get my hands on this book and to have its beautiful cover and story gracing my shelves!
Thank you to Natasha Siegel, Random House Publishing Group, Dell and NetGalley for the opportunity to provide my honest opinion on the ARC of this book.
March 14, 2024
I would like to read a thousand more books by this author, please.
April 16, 2024
3.75
what's a Phoenix? a bird burn to death in its fire and then reborn in its ashes.
plot: Cecilia has been depressed for over 134 days, living in London in her sister's townhouse, somewhat trapped, due to the reason of her beloved husband dying to plague, who chose her as a second option but at least he loved her regardless of it all, I guess.
She sought a doctor to improve her depression state, perhaps due to reasons David, the doctor, understands her pain, and misery and she grew attached to him emotionally and mentally, after all, he lost his first love to a plague as well, so he understands her well.
So the story is with a problem of society and caste differences as David is a Jew and people in 1666 weren't acceptable to Jews, meanwhile, Cecilia is a noble and a Christian.
“I think I have fallen in love,” I say. “Fool that I am for it.”
I wonder how many people in the past were forced to leave their lovers and marry someone else because of the caste system and society-level differences. Nobles and poor fall in love but can't be together cause of their background differences.
opinions: The love aspect is less and more focused on the historical background of 17th-century London. Cecilia learns how to live her life again towards the end although with great difficulties and heartaches.
The plot shows how 'sometimes you love someone so dearly that you need to let them go' for them to be happy, as you can't keep them in your shackles.
Cecilia is often described as how she will prefer to be burned just for the sake of it (not burn burn) and that's how a phoenix is reborn. Cecilia is referred to as a phoenix because she is just like it, she is reborn as a new person where she is still the same but happy.
The poetic phrases are chef's kiss.
oh, and of course The Great London fire, The city was made a phoenix, razed by fire, born from ashes.
what's a Phoenix? a bird burn to death in its fire and then reborn in its ashes.
plot: Cecilia has been depressed for over 134 days, living in London in her sister's townhouse, somewhat trapped, due to the reason of her beloved husband dying to plague, who chose her as a second option but at least he loved her regardless of it all, I guess.
She sought a doctor to improve her depression state, perhaps due to reasons David, the doctor, understands her pain, and misery and she grew attached to him emotionally and mentally, after all, he lost his first love to a plague as well, so he understands her well.
So the story is with a problem of society and caste differences as David is a Jew and people in 1666 weren't acceptable to Jews, meanwhile, Cecilia is a noble and a Christian.
“I think I have fallen in love,” I say. “Fool that I am for it.”
I wonder how many people in the past were forced to leave their lovers and marry someone else because of the caste system and society-level differences. Nobles and poor fall in love but can't be together cause of their background differences.
opinions: The love aspect is less and more focused on the historical background of 17th-century London. Cecilia learns how to live her life again towards the end although with great difficulties and heartaches.
The plot shows how 'sometimes you love someone so dearly that you need to let them go' for them to be happy, as you can't keep them in your shackles.
Cecilia is often described as how she will prefer to be burned just for the sake of it (not burn burn) and that's how a phoenix is reborn. Cecilia is referred to as a phoenix because she is just like it, she is reborn as a new person where she is still the same but happy.
The poetic phrases are chef's kiss.
oh, and of course The Great London fire, The city was made a phoenix, razed by fire, born from ashes.
March 7, 2024
This book was absolutely stunning! I loved the alternating POV's between Cecilia and David. The writing itself was beautiful. I thought the historical setting was intriguing and captivating and loved how medicine was a key part of the story. The Jewish representation was so well done and I adored David entirely. Cecelia was a nice contrast and I enjoyed her character arc throughout the book. This was quick-paced and lyrical and I was invested from page one. It's diverse not only in faith and religion but also in sexuality, mental health, and neurodivergence. The way Natasha described certain events or certain feelings was absolutely brilliant. There was also a nice balance of lightness amidst all the heavy moments and I thought it was done so well. I loved this book! Thank you to Random House for providing me with an e-ARC to read and review!
Read
July 14, 2024The only line in this so far that has feel significant, or original, is in the epigraph. (Thanks, John Donne!)
I don’t mean that to be as savage as it might sound, there’s nothing wrong with unoriginality in fiction and I have this in paperback so it’s absolutely possible that I give it another shot when I’m in the mood for something that’s mentally soothing. And I also don’t mean it to be that savage because the intro was actually quite compelling!
But on a line by line basis I just suddenly thought - “why read this when I could be doing literally anything else. What would reading this add to my life?” And I had to set the book down. Blame Pat Barker - Regeneration, it turns out, is hard to follow!
DNF on p. 16.
I don’t mean that to be as savage as it might sound, there’s nothing wrong with unoriginality in fiction and I have this in paperback so it’s absolutely possible that I give it another shot when I’m in the mood for something that’s mentally soothing. And I also don’t mean it to be that savage because the intro was actually quite compelling!
But on a line by line basis I just suddenly thought - “why read this when I could be doing literally anything else. What would reading this add to my life?” And I had to set the book down. Blame Pat Barker - Regeneration, it turns out, is hard to follow!
DNF on p. 16.
January 23, 2024
Thank you to Random House Publishing - Ballantine for the ARC of the Phoenix Bride in exchange for an honest review!
Natasha Siegel is one of the greatest writers of our time. Her books are like music, like a song that plays on your mind, like a symphony of perfect notes, and words, and feelings. I absolutely adored Solomon’s Crown and thus The Phoenix Bride became an immediate highlight of 2024, a must-read for me that more than earned its place. Poignant, meaningful, and deeply satisfying, the Phoenix Bride should be on everyone’s shelf this year. It comes out March 12th, and you should smash that pre-order button NOW.
TPB tells the story of romantics David Mendes and Celia Thorowgood, who meet by chance. Plague has swept through England, and left Celia a widow. Now distraught and diagnosed with melancholy, Celia lives with her sister and entertains the endless parade of doctors who prod her to resolve her incurable mindset. Her sister eventually hires David, a foreigner and Jew, to tend to Celia’s state. Unlike the others, he isn’t invasive, he respects her autonomy, and only makes recommendations, acknowledging that he or anyone is limited in their ability to “cure” her. As David and Celia begin to spend more time together, something unexpected overtakes them both, igniting something that simply cannot be.
This novel has a little something for everyone. It’s more romantic than steamy, living in the pining and the painful want of love. It contains queer characters and subplots, and explores the perspective of many different minorities trying to make their way in England in the 1600s. There are supportive male friendships and understanding husbands, and the bittersweet mixture of lost and found that makes up a life. It’s something beautiful, something rare, not unlike the bond that David and Celia have. There is no cure for melancholy, and there is no cure for love, but perhaps some things are meant to be felt rather than controlled. Siegel tells a masterful tale, creating the type of book that changes you as much as it thrills you. And maybe even opens you up to something new.
Natasha Siegel is one of the greatest writers of our time. Her books are like music, like a song that plays on your mind, like a symphony of perfect notes, and words, and feelings. I absolutely adored Solomon’s Crown and thus The Phoenix Bride became an immediate highlight of 2024, a must-read for me that more than earned its place. Poignant, meaningful, and deeply satisfying, the Phoenix Bride should be on everyone’s shelf this year. It comes out March 12th, and you should smash that pre-order button NOW.
TPB tells the story of romantics David Mendes and Celia Thorowgood, who meet by chance. Plague has swept through England, and left Celia a widow. Now distraught and diagnosed with melancholy, Celia lives with her sister and entertains the endless parade of doctors who prod her to resolve her incurable mindset. Her sister eventually hires David, a foreigner and Jew, to tend to Celia’s state. Unlike the others, he isn’t invasive, he respects her autonomy, and only makes recommendations, acknowledging that he or anyone is limited in their ability to “cure” her. As David and Celia begin to spend more time together, something unexpected overtakes them both, igniting something that simply cannot be.
This novel has a little something for everyone. It’s more romantic than steamy, living in the pining and the painful want of love. It contains queer characters and subplots, and explores the perspective of many different minorities trying to make their way in England in the 1600s. There are supportive male friendships and understanding husbands, and the bittersweet mixture of lost and found that makes up a life. It’s something beautiful, something rare, not unlike the bond that David and Celia have. There is no cure for melancholy, and there is no cure for love, but perhaps some things are meant to be felt rather than controlled. Siegel tells a masterful tale, creating the type of book that changes you as much as it thrills you. And maybe even opens you up to something new.
July 4, 2024
The Phoenix Bride fits into the genre of historical-fiction-with-people-much-more-cool-with-sexual-and-gender-diversity-than-they-were-in-real-life (I probably need to find a shorter term). This isn't a complaint, just an observation. In fact, I enjoy many of these improbable versions of history. It's fun meeting my identity and values in a new setting.
If you're comfortable with historical-fiction-with-people-much-more-cool-with-sexual-and-gender-diversity-than-they-were-in-real-life, you'll probably be delighted by The Phoenix Bride. And maybe I'm underestimating the past. The Phoenix Bride is set during the restoration—and those weren't exactly prudish times.
Newly widowed Cecilia, who has been languishing, is finally provided with a doctor who understands: David Mendes. No blood-letting and leeches for him. He just listens carefully and provides herbal remedies. Minor problem—he's Jewish and the guardians of propriety in Cecilia's family are quite perturbed to see a relationship growing between Cecilia and David.
What the family wants is for Cecilia to marry her brother-in-law's nephew Sam who lives just across the street in a grand town house and is a regular figure in court events. This is where things get interesting because Sam is a very odd sort of duck: awkward as all get-out, loudly enthusiastic about all sorts of things—and very, very rich. (I admit, Sam was my favorite character in this book. I adored his natural unconventionalism and generosity of spirit.)
The novel has a number of twists which I won't go into because I don't want to spoil other readers' fun. Suffice it to say, The Phoenix Bride features all sorts of love, most of which are heart-warming in the own ways. If you want a summer read that has drama, but is clearly headed somewhere joyful, this is just the book you need.
I received a free electronic review copy of this title from the publisher via NetGalley; the opinions are my own.
If you're comfortable with historical-fiction-with-people-much-more-cool-with-sexual-and-gender-diversity-than-they-were-in-real-life, you'll probably be delighted by The Phoenix Bride. And maybe I'm underestimating the past. The Phoenix Bride is set during the restoration—and those weren't exactly prudish times.
Newly widowed Cecilia, who has been languishing, is finally provided with a doctor who understands: David Mendes. No blood-letting and leeches for him. He just listens carefully and provides herbal remedies. Minor problem—he's Jewish and the guardians of propriety in Cecilia's family are quite perturbed to see a relationship growing between Cecilia and David.
What the family wants is for Cecilia to marry her brother-in-law's nephew Sam who lives just across the street in a grand town house and is a regular figure in court events. This is where things get interesting because Sam is a very odd sort of duck: awkward as all get-out, loudly enthusiastic about all sorts of things—and very, very rich. (I admit, Sam was my favorite character in this book. I adored his natural unconventionalism and generosity of spirit.)
The novel has a number of twists which I won't go into because I don't want to spoil other readers' fun. Suffice it to say, The Phoenix Bride features all sorts of love, most of which are heart-warming in the own ways. If you want a summer read that has drama, but is clearly headed somewhere joyful, this is just the book you need.
I received a free electronic review copy of this title from the publisher via NetGalley; the opinions are my own.
March 4, 2024
Like a phoenix that rises from the ashes, love can grow from grief. Two individuals, separated by class and faith in a society that can never allow them to be together, fall in love against all odds. Set against the backdrop of 1600s London, this story follows a widow and a Jewish doctor as they process their respective losses in the face of societal expectations.
I loved this book, and couldn't put it down. The writing was poetic and powerful. Natasha Siegel creates a brilliant, lovable cast of characters in a complex world that feels real from its historical grounds. Most importantly and impactful, I loved the reference to a range of real issues that still plague the modern world: women's rights and independence, LGBTQ+ relationships, inter-faith and interracial relationships, anti-Semitism, and more.
I can't recommend this book enough. I am very grateful to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Let me know if you check it out!
I loved this book, and couldn't put it down. The writing was poetic and powerful. Natasha Siegel creates a brilliant, lovable cast of characters in a complex world that feels real from its historical grounds. Most importantly and impactful, I loved the reference to a range of real issues that still plague the modern world: women's rights and independence, LGBTQ+ relationships, inter-faith and interracial relationships, anti-Semitism, and more.
I can't recommend this book enough. I am very grateful to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Let me know if you check it out!
April 18, 2024
I really enjoyed this book. It was very well written.
March 21, 2024
I sure did have a lot of feelings while reading this.
January 29, 2025
I have only just heard about this book earlier this week via clicking on Felicia Davin's blog post I saw on bluesky and only a few hours hours later, I was done. The setting—17th century London between the plague and the Great Fire—is so refreshing for historical romance and the synopsis was so compelling that I just had to. It called to me. Combined with how lovely the writing is, and I’m certainly starting 2025 on a good note.
Cecilia is a grieving widow, having lost her husband to plague. Her overbearing twin sister calls doctor after doctor trying to cure her. Finally, she calls a less conventional one. David is a Portuguese Jew, a recent immigrant to England where he can live and practice medicine in relative freedom. He, too, knows loss all too well. Their love is impossible, he is a Jew and Cecilia must remarry a nobleman, they’re both deep in their own grief, and life keeps throwing them obstacle after obstacle. But again and again, they find each other.
It’s sad and gentle and kind and achingly beautiful.
What I liked the most about it is simply how god damn well it’s written. The gorgeous prose is part of it, sure, but also the character work and readability and the way it works as a whole. It’s very, very hard to make me buy into the forbidden romance trope, but here it really works. The obstacles to their relationship feel realistic and the stakes high. Interfaith relationships in the 17th century were risky and complicated, nevermind the difference in status. However impoverished and reliant on relatives, she is still a noblewoman and he a doctor.
Their grief also makes both of them prickly and prone to self-sabotaging, struggling to consider the possibility that they might deserve to be happy. Cecilia more obviously so at first, and David in more subtle ways, but the element is there. I was at the edge of my seat wondering how the hell could they ever make it work. It didn’t seem the type of book to make it easy for the protagonists or the reader—and not to say too much, but the ending is indeed a tentative but hopeful HFN.
And there is so much else to like! I loved the setting, especially that it’s 17th century instead of the usual 19th. Don’t get me wrong, nothing wrong with the 19th century, but a person does get tired of it. The author clearly tried for as much authenticity as possible given patchy historical records, too (see: Author’s Note) and it shows. It’s also much queerer than a synopsis makes it sound—David himself is bisexual, his best friend Jan is gay, and both have a history of visiting molly houses. I also liked that Cecilia’s forced fiancé isn’t a bad guy. He’s a very likable golden retriever type with big ADHD vibes, as cornered into the whole arrangement as she is, and perfectly willing to help out. It’s sweet. Especially in a book as heartwrenching as this.
So: If all of the above sounds good to you? Don’t wait. Run and get it while the library queues are still reasonable 😉
Enjoyment: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Recommended to: anyone looking for a beautifully written exploration of grief and healing, those tired of every historical romance being 19th century
Not recommended to: those who don’t like purplish prose, those for whom a HFN isn’t enough
Content warnings: antisemitism, homophobia, death of a loved one
More reviews on my blog, To Other Worlds.
Cecilia is a grieving widow, having lost her husband to plague. Her overbearing twin sister calls doctor after doctor trying to cure her. Finally, she calls a less conventional one. David is a Portuguese Jew, a recent immigrant to England where he can live and practice medicine in relative freedom. He, too, knows loss all too well. Their love is impossible, he is a Jew and Cecilia must remarry a nobleman, they’re both deep in their own grief, and life keeps throwing them obstacle after obstacle. But again and again, they find each other.
It’s sad and gentle and kind and achingly beautiful.
What I liked the most about it is simply how god damn well it’s written. The gorgeous prose is part of it, sure, but also the character work and readability and the way it works as a whole. It’s very, very hard to make me buy into the forbidden romance trope, but here it really works. The obstacles to their relationship feel realistic and the stakes high. Interfaith relationships in the 17th century were risky and complicated, nevermind the difference in status. However impoverished and reliant on relatives, she is still a noblewoman and he a doctor.
Their grief also makes both of them prickly and prone to self-sabotaging, struggling to consider the possibility that they might deserve to be happy. Cecilia more obviously so at first, and David in more subtle ways, but the element is there. I was at the edge of my seat wondering how the hell could they ever make it work. It didn’t seem the type of book to make it easy for the protagonists or the reader—and not to say too much, but the ending is indeed a tentative but hopeful HFN.
And there is so much else to like! I loved the setting, especially that it’s 17th century instead of the usual 19th. Don’t get me wrong, nothing wrong with the 19th century, but a person does get tired of it. The author clearly tried for as much authenticity as possible given patchy historical records, too (see: Author’s Note) and it shows. It’s also much queerer than a synopsis makes it sound—David himself is bisexual, his best friend Jan is gay, and both have a history of visiting molly houses. I also liked that Cecilia’s forced fiancé isn’t a bad guy. He’s a very likable golden retriever type with big ADHD vibes, as cornered into the whole arrangement as she is, and perfectly willing to help out. It’s sweet. Especially in a book as heartwrenching as this.
So: If all of the above sounds good to you? Don’t wait. Run and get it while the library queues are still reasonable 😉
Enjoyment: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Recommended to: anyone looking for a beautifully written exploration of grief and healing, those tired of every historical romance being 19th century
Not recommended to: those who don’t like purplish prose, those for whom a HFN isn’t enough
Content warnings: antisemitism, homophobia, death of a loved one
More reviews on my blog, To Other Worlds.
December 7, 2023
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!
After reading Solomon’s Crown last year, I was so ready for anything else Natasha Siegel decided to make. Solomon’s Crown blew me away and became one of my fave reads of the year.
Natasha is back with another story of forbidden love in a historical setting. When I began reading again a year and a half ago, I didn’t expect to be so invested in historical romances, but here we are.
My heart broke so much for Cecilia and David. Both dealing with a grief that is too big for them to bear. Love is such a beautiful and devastating thing. I wanted to hug them both tight and tell them they were allowed to be happy. I almost wanted to cry on my lunch break from how bleak it became at times. But then I also wanted to cry at the end. Natasha is such a master with the way she writes both hope and despair.
While romance is a huge theme of this book, it also goes into mental illness and religion. David is Jewish and has fled to London with his Father in order to practice freely. I appreciated seeing David struggle with his religion as well as with his sexuality in this story. We also see Cecelia struggle so much with her depression. I don’t think this is a normal thing in the 1600s, so it was so interesting seeing how it was dealt with.
While Cecilia and David were amazing characters, this story is also one where the side characters are just as great. Jan and Sam stole the show in some parts for me. Sam was a really friend. I was cheering him and Jan on the entire time.
I kept going back and forth on if anyone in this book was worth hating. I can say that things were said and done that made me angry and I felt like they would be unforgivable, but the time period gives me pause. At least the right people seemed to understand in the end.
This will obviously be one of my faves of the year and I’m so excited I got to experience it early. I will deff go buy it in March.
After reading Solomon’s Crown last year, I was so ready for anything else Natasha Siegel decided to make. Solomon’s Crown blew me away and became one of my fave reads of the year.
Natasha is back with another story of forbidden love in a historical setting. When I began reading again a year and a half ago, I didn’t expect to be so invested in historical romances, but here we are.
My heart broke so much for Cecilia and David. Both dealing with a grief that is too big for them to bear. Love is such a beautiful and devastating thing. I wanted to hug them both tight and tell them they were allowed to be happy. I almost wanted to cry on my lunch break from how bleak it became at times. But then I also wanted to cry at the end. Natasha is such a master with the way she writes both hope and despair.
While romance is a huge theme of this book, it also goes into mental illness and religion. David is Jewish and has fled to London with his Father in order to practice freely. I appreciated seeing David struggle with his religion as well as with his sexuality in this story. We also see Cecelia struggle so much with her depression. I don’t think this is a normal thing in the 1600s, so it was so interesting seeing how it was dealt with.
While Cecilia and David were amazing characters, this story is also one where the side characters are just as great. Jan and Sam stole the show in some parts for me. Sam was a really friend. I was cheering him and Jan on the entire time.
I kept going back and forth on if anyone in this book was worth hating. I can say that things were said and done that made me angry and I felt like they would be unforgivable, but the time period gives me pause. At least the right people seemed to understand in the end.
This will obviously be one of my faves of the year and I’m so excited I got to experience it early. I will deff go buy it in March.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 391 reviews