After thinking this through, I've decided on giving Released 3.5 stars. While I really enjoyed the book, there were a few aspects of it that were confusing, annoying, and frustrating. Allow me to explain.
Possible spoilers!
Exhibit A: Suki's POV
This is the first genie story I've read in quite some time. And what really had me excited was that, instead of the book being in the Releasors point of view, it was instead in the genie's. The general concept of Suki's powers and story was well-thought out. She grants her Releasors three wishes, but they have to be used for
selfless
reasons. For good. It's a rule that Suki herself has never wavered from or changed, no matter what the cost.
Suki definitely had personality, but I didn't think the author executed her point of view very well. Many of the chapters were in 3rd person, but it makes it seem like Suki is seeing everything happening. And that is the part that felt odd to me. It was hard to go from reading about the other characters, and then to what Suki is doing at the same time. Not only do the two girls get the spotlight, but the two villains do as well. It was sometimes hard to go back and forth between all of them, especially when plot points were interwoven together.
Exhibit B: Flashbacks
Suki is over 300 years old, and she's lived and traveled all over the world. She's been with a lot of different Releasors over the years, and some who were very influential people. She's always been a good friend, giving them advice on love and life, making sure that they were doing their best. She's the type of genie who uses her powers to bring out a person's potential and best qualities. She helps them live a good life, and she never leaves until they're gone (most of them don't use up all three wishes until later on in life).
I didn't think the flashbacks were handled very well. They were not clearly separated from the present, and some of them seemed like fillers in the story before the major plot points were revealed. And when Suki was telling stories, she tended to get side-tracked and start talking about something else. The girls would have to remind her about what she'd started talking about in the first place. Let's just say, I don't remember very much about her past lives. There was just so much history told, both through flashbacks and in conversations. And some of it didn't seem essential to either the story, or why Suki is the way she is now.
Exhibit C: The Characters
The characters are the most important part of the story, aside from the plot. If the characters seem weak, annoying, or I essentially end up hating them, then the author is doing something wrong.
Don't get me wrong, I liked the characters. But I didn't end up loving any of them. Except for Raven, who was a fantastic villain, I was confused by some of their personalities. Especially Charlotte. When she finds out that the guy she's crushing on was involved in her best friend's accident, she's all like, You must be wrong. Oh, he's so hot, I don't care. I was not a fan of her and Phineas' relationship, nor the fact that she didn't listen to Samantha's or Suki's advice to stay away from him. He was not the good guy here. Charlotte's personality is made up to her being the sensible and safe one out of the two best friends. Instead, hers and Sam's personality and roles are reversed throughout the story.
I also wasn't totally convinced of Suki. She's lived everywhere, yet she has a very clear southern US accent. She said the south was one of her favorite places on earth. But if she's lived all over the world, one would think that her accent might include all sorts of different dialects and speech, as well as with the way she talks. Her accent was not the only part of her personality I wasn't keen to agree with. I also didn't like the advice that she gave the girls. She told Samantha to go after a taken guy. I'm sorry, but this is coming from the woman who wouldn't have sex with the very hot and protective James because she still had her southern morals? I didn't like that, or the fact that she had them get makeovers to win over the guys they were crushing on. So, you're essentially telling them that if they didn't look like you, no guy will want them? Yeah, I wasn't a huge fan of Suki, actually. And it sucks, because she is the main character.
Exhibit D: The Ending
Am I the only one confused by the ending? What did Charlotte do? (I'm probably missing the whole point and it's right in front of my face).
***
Before you maim me for all the negative, I really did enjoy the story!
I loved how Suki wouldn't grant wishes unless it was for the most unselfish of reasons. As long as it was for good. I liked where the story was heading, although I'm still confused by a lot of the aspects. I liked James and Sam the most. Although, who James is and why he was there was a little hard to understand. I thought Raven was a brilliant villain, and I was intrigued to find out her motivations for everything. And that ending leaves me wanting to know more! :)