This book is truly a hard book to read, not because it wasn’t well written – because it was a simple, easy to consume book – but because of the subject matter. From the first genocide in 140 BCE to the massacre in Srebrenica in the mid 1990’s. Consider all the horrible situations where civilization failed: Massacre of Mexica in 1521, the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre on August 24, 1572, Bloody Sunday in Louisiana in 1873, the Armenian Genocide of the early 1900’s, the killings in the Katyni Forest in 1940, South Africa’s Shootings at Sharpeville in 1960, My Lai Massacre in the Viet Nam War in 1968, the Cambodian Genocide from 1975-1979, and the 100-day madness in Rwandan in 1994. Yes, this is not a feel-good book.
Many of these annihilations are well known – the Armenian Genocide, My Lai, the Russian mass assassinations of Polish military leaders, Sharpeville incident that ultimately led to freedom in South Africa, the Cambodian genocide but others were ones I just read about or read more than I had in the past. The author did a fine job reviewing in great detail yet in a general, efficient manner. Having read some books on specific genocide – the holocaust, Armenian Genocide, the Katyni Forest, My Lai, and the Rwandan genocide, I still learned more while reading those chapters.
What was probably most shocking is how much is known of many of these genocides, including the first one over 2,000 years ago. Starting with the Third Punic War, the hatred of the Romans and the Carthaginians built. 50,000 Romans were killed in one day, the largest number of people killed in war in one day until WWII. What the author pointed out is that most of these people were killed by hand with swords and spears. Revenge was brutal. When the Romans later had the Carthage’s on the run and they refused to surrender, the Romans killed anyone they could, decapitating them and throwing babies into flames and raping women before they were torn apart. Anyone surviving the carnage was sold into slavery.
As the title of the book mentions, these exterminations often change conditions for centuries. When Catholics suddenly murdered their protestant neighbors on August 24, 1572, in what was known as the ST. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre, it separated Catholic and Protestant Churches for centuries – and was just mentioned by the current pope. These religious people did things that are unimaginable including baptizing infants by the blood of their parents who were just killed – then the Catholics killed the babies. Catholics wore white arm bands since that was really the only way to show the difference in these Paris residents. As a gift, Pope Gregory XIII was sent the head of Admiral Coligny.
The small country of Rwandan held a similar attack on people who shared more similarities than differences when the Hutu radicals turned on their Tutsi neighbors and killed 800,000 in four weeks starting in April 1994. Consider: there was no real difference between the two peoples since they shared a common language, faith, and cultural heritage. There was considerable intermarriage. The main difference was that the Hutus were usually wealthier. When in control of the country, the Belgians separated the two tribes by issuing identification cards in 1933 to lock in the differences and separate the population for their own use. Like with other genocides, this one was secretary planned but took place mostly through slaughter with machetes, chopping up bodies in front of children before they were also killed. Within weeks, 75% of the Tutsi population was eliminated in a systematic manner.
While we are reading every day about the quest for justice in Ukraine, this book reminded us of the two-day attack by a German special execution unit killing 33,000 Jews outside of Kiev. The German government had established killing squads known as Einsatzgruppen to exterminate entire Jewish communities in Ukraine, Poland, Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia before moving to a more efficient model with the ovens. While some of the SS men got hysterical carrying out their orders to murder men, women, and children, others carried out their commands in a silent, eerie obedience. When the German army got to Kiev, perhaps 150,000 of the Jews migrated to escape the violence. The increased antisemitic activities allowed for the Ukrainians to participate in the scapegoating of the Jews and permitted the German SS to take the Jews to a mass grave dug by the Jews and shoot them one by one then tossing babies into the pit of killed humanity. The pictures of the cold-blooded killing was hard to view and the accounting of the few survivors was even more difficult to read.
The book also covered a part of American history that I didn’t know about despite reading many books on American history and racial issues within our country. On Easter Sunday, Black freedmen were massacred when surrendering to members of the KKK and other former Confederate soldiers. Other Americans who were black were assassinated after being held and further others were hunted down while trying to escape. No one knows just how many Americans who were African Americans were killed but the range is between 62 and 153 but it is known that three white Americans were killed in the fighting. The case went before the U.S. Supreme Court, with the white justices siding with the racists, allowing further attacks on freed African Americans, using violence and intimidation to wrestle democracy away from the south.
Cumins’ book demonstrate that humanity can break down off of all kinds of divisions and old scores, creating an environment where the unimaginable can occur. Repeatedly it is planned, systematic, and brutal. Then, usually denied. Even the United States didn’t immediately call the senseless killing in Bosnia genocide and just recently labeled the genocide of the Armenians correctly.
And for various reasons, the world can look the other way or be slow in responding. Possibly it’s force, or not knowing what is happening. Sometimes countries that should get involved have their own selfish reasons to let the fighting take place. When people engage in genocide, they are trying to wipe our not just the civilization but the culture as we saw with the Romans ridding the world of the Carthaginians to the Nazis first going after the culture of the Jews before trying to completely exterminate them to in Bosnia when the Serbs attempted to eliminate the Muslims.
Repeatedly, Cummins raised the use of rape as a way to violate the community being attacked. While I knew that rape often followed attacks on people for centuries, the degree it is baked into these catastrophes is beyond comprehension. Rape was also used when the massacres were led by religious leaders, such as the Mountain Meadows Massacre in Utah in 1857. According to witnesses, two teens were raped by Mormons then shot even though the two begged for their lives after being raped and promised to “love him forever” if they were allowed to live. During the Armenian genocide, the Young Turks recruited Kurd's to a Special Organization killers who raped and robbed Armenians before killing them to eliminate the population. Probably the most outrageous arrangement covered in this book was in Bosnia where the government established eighty “rape camps” where women as young as 13 into their 60’s were held purposely to be raped repeatedly by soldiers of Serbian leader Radovan Karadzic and Serbian Army General Ratko Mladic.
This book would never be easy to read but has a long-time lesson, especially important today when our newspapers are filled with horrific violent activities from Puttin’s Russia against the Ukraine, killing people and trying to wipe out their culture, and what is happening today in Israel. It would have been helpful for the author to include chapter on how to realize the start of what might turn out to be the development of a genocide, common issues, and what our world leaders need to do to stop the next one.