“So great and so much like hell that no tongue could adequately express them.”That is how Martin Luther described the terrifying religious fears he suffered as a young man.
Up to now, no one has correctly diagnosed them. Dr. Osborn demonstrates that Luther’s tormenting thoughts represented an unmistakable case of clinical obsessive-compulsive disorder. Remarkably, Luther overcame his fears through employing a form of modern “exposure and response prevention therapy,” recognized today as the treatment of choice for OCD. Dr. Osborn makes clear that it was precisely through experiencing and curing his fears that Luther learned the truth about righteousness and faith. Without the benefit of his obsessional fears, one could argue, the Great Reformer would never have pursued the Reformation at all.
This book is essential reading for OCD sufferers, Martin Luther fans, historians, and students of religion and psychology alike.
What a great little find! The author does a fantastic job breaking down the clinical aspects of OCD (and treatment) with examples reflected through Luther’s life and writings.
For me, the book goes beyond a fascinating psychological case study and acts more as a tool that aids in self reflection. I have OCD and grew up in a Catholic household (though am no longer religious), and this book genuinely made me feel more grounded. Seeing aspects of my own life reflected through the life of Luther gave me comfort in the form of self-knowledge and reassurance.
I’d highly recommend this book to anyone struggling with OCD or any Protestants interested in why Luther broke from the Catholic Church
That Luther had OCD tendencies seems pretty clear to me. However, some of the smaller arguments and historical reconstruction of Luther are probably debatable. I'd love to see how Luther scholarship would interact with Osborn's view of Luther using Exposure and Response Prevention therapy (ERP) and his characterization of different phases in Luther's life. Without it being my expertise, I'm a bit skeptical of his explanations and think he might be imposing too much of his psychiatric background on Luther.
However, Osborn provides helpful insights that "OCD is triggered specifically when a person feels overwhelmed by the responsibility for preventing harm" (11). He notes that in the moment the thought feels like the most important thing in the world to deal with (27). He also helped me to better understand ERP, how prayer can become a compulsion, and the cycle of trying to not think thoughts (86-90). Hearing about religious OCD from Luther and patients of Osborn was great.
very interesting!! both the Martin Luther parts and the general information about OCD and its treatment in the appendixes. appendices? yes.
I'm usually wary when people try to diagnose historical figures, but Martin Luther having a bad case of scrupulosity OCD fits so well. No WONDER I immediately clocked this monk from 500 years ago as being "like me" when I watched the Martin Luther movie when I was 7.
Religious Scrupulosity or Religious OCD is a reading and research interest of mine. This book is a short but excellent read related to this topic. Dr. Osborn does a great job working with the biographical texts on Luther, the relevant psychological material, and the Scriptures. He highlights two extensive OCD episodes in Luther's life and how he responded to each of them. Along the way, Dr. Osborn points out how Luther's remedies might still be effective for Religious OCD suffers today.
An amazing read for someone who has OCD or loves someone with OCD, loves to learn about church history, or mental health! It was a quick and easy read, very engaging.
Agree with the author here. It would be interesting to examine Luther’s later life in light of this eg. Antisemitism, anger and inability to compromise.