His Journey
Rory Muir is the modern day expert on Arthur Wellesley, 1st Duke of Wellington. He is a respected historian known for his work on the Napoleonic Wars, including his book on Wellington’s destruction of the French at Salamanca in 1812, the battle which proved Wellington was not just a defensive general. Wellington: The Path to Victory 1769-1814 is the first in a two part series and looks at the first half of Wellington’s life, showing how a younger son of an Anglo-Irish aristocrat little little potential grew into one of the most competent generals in world history. It ends with the invasion of France in 1814 and the first abdication of Napoleon Bonaparte. The book is meticulously researched and richly detailed. It offers a comprehensive examination of Arthur Wellesley, in his military, political and personal life before he became the Duke of Wellington.
Muir approaches Wellington with a blend of admiration and critical distance, providing a balanced portrait of a complex figure. He delves deep into Wellington’s early life, his family background, and his early military campaigns, particularly in India and the Iberian Peninsula. Muir’s narrative is both scholarly and accessible, avoiding hagiography while acknowledging Wellington's brilliance as a strategist and leader. One of the book’s strengths is Muir’s attention to detail. He draws extensively on primary sources, including letters, diaries, and military dispatches, to offer insights into Wellington’s character, motivations, and the challenges he faced. Muir is particularly effective in exploring Wellington's development as a commander, showing how his experiences in India shaped his tactical thinking and how his cautious yet decisive approach was crucial in the Peninsular War against Napoleon's forces.
Muir also addresses Wellington's political career and his relationships with contemporaries, such as his brothers Richard and William, Castlereigh, Canning, Bathurst and the Duke of York, painting a picture of a man who was as skilled in diplomacy and political maneuvering as he was on the battlefield. The author doesn’t shy away from discussing Wellington's flaws, including his aloofness, occasional arrogance, and his struggles with political life, which adds depth to the biography. He also addresses his relationship with his wife Kitty Pakenham, dispelling the myth that he married her for ‘honour’ after making a promise years before. Muir explains that when he returned from India he married her because he wanted to and it was only in later years they became estranged as is depicted by most biographers.
The narrative is thorough, sometimes overwhelmingly so, with Muir’s attention to military details occasionally bogging down the pace for readers less familiar with the intricacies of 18th and early 19th-century warfare. However, for those with a deep interest in military history, this level of detail will likely be appreciated. I fall into the latter category, so a thoroughly enjoyed this approach and as a result I cannot wait to tackle volume two. The book is more than just Wellington, it is a window into the age, the Napoleonic Wars and regency politics. Wellington was at the apex of this society, but did not have it all his own way. The Peace of Cintra being case in point where he was near done before he started. The book also highlights the difficulties of the Peninsula War and how this was a long and complex process to expel the French from Portugal and Spain over the course of five years. The allies suffered multiple setbacks including Sir John Moore’s ill fated retreat to Coruña in 1809. Wellington’s great victory at Salamanca was also at a time when their backs were against the wall and could have ended in disaster.
Overall, Wellington: The Path to Victory 1769-1814 is an authoritative and engrossing work that will appeal to both scholars and general readers interested in the Napoleonic Wars, military history, and the life of one of Britain’s greatest generals. Muir succeeds in providing a nuanced and comprehensive portrait of Wellington, making this book a significant contribution to our understanding of the man behind the myth. For me there is no apparent contender to the most comprehensive study of Wellington in recent years. Richard Holmes’ excellent but short biography is a great starting point, Christopher Hibbert’s focuses more on the personal as opposed to all aspects of his life and Elizabeth Longford’s offer still commands respect if a little dated. As such, this is clearly the go to.