Larissa is a spin-off or sidequel from her first novel Shade, it takes a minor side-character and tells her story that runs partly parallel to Shade but is so self-contained that even if you haven’t read or heard of Shade you wouldn’t notice how much it takes from that novel.
What’s so odd about the book is that the overall arc and where the character ultimately ends up parallels a lot of what went on in Shade, at least in the broadest strokes. Larissa is drawn into the conflict between the Q’rin, the humans, the Aesopians, and the Lyrri, though all this is filtered through her own perspective, that of a knife fighter who does it for a living and unlike Shade is more prone to stand her ground and fight instead of running away.
Given all this, what applied to Shade applies here as well. The writing draws in you and makes the whole book an easy and fun read despite all its shortcomings. And I’m not even saying that mirroring the broad strokes of Shade’s narrative is a flaw, as the devil is in the detail and Larissa really is her own character in many ways. But the writing is really what makes you want to go on, it’s just a joy how Emily Devenport is putting words on the page.
Just one example is the very first sentence in the book “This may sound deranged, but I think I owe my interest in knives to the serial killer who murdered my mother when I was nine”. This gives you an idea of how unpredictable the book can be even when you know the broad strokes of where the story is going. Eventually, Larissa runs away from Earth, ends up on Z’taruh (the world where most of the action of Larissa and Shade take place), becomes a fighter, becomes part of Oshrii’s stable of fighters, and eventually escapes the planet in opposition to Oshrii, who is the dominant Q’rin lord on the planet and who has allied himself with the Lyrri.
The same politics that dominated the second half of Shade to a large degree come into play here as well with whole scenes lifted from Shade, only from Larissa’s point of view.
Like with Shade, I have a hard time saying whether this is a good or a bad book, as it reads so easily but I’m not entirely sure about the rest. It has an interesting setting and towards the end throws in some more info we didn’t even learn in Shade that recontextualizes the entire conflict between Q’rin and Aesopians and humans and Lyrri. We learn that the Aesopians long ago took Neanderthals from Earth and made them into the Q’rin, though the revelations don’t end there. We also find out what the Aesopians were before they remade themself to look like Earth animals. It turns out, that before they were Aesopians they were Lyrri, which puts a really interesting spin on it.
On the other hand, I sometimes felt like I was reading Shade all over again despite the different protagonist and her unique viewpoint. And I enjoyed Larissa’s viewpoint, sure. She’s more direct than Shade, has a better idea of who she is and what she wants, and despite the demons that haunt her (especially the serial killer that killed her mother and almost her and how that relates to her affinity for knives) has a better way of dealing with things.
I do want to know why Emily Devenport opted to write a second novel that was so similar to her first, was it her publisher or her own wish? And I still don’t know how I feel about whether it’s good or bad that this book eerily mirrors the first one.