This collection is a bold endeavor that spans over 4 decades of material from the great Hugh B. Cave, one of the most prolific writers from the pulp era and beyond. Though it is estimated that Cave wrote over 800 stories in almost every conceivable genre, the focus here is on horror. For bigtime fans, the original Carcosa publication from 1977 is an absolute must-have, since it also features the incredibly spine-chilling illustrations from perhaps the greatest illustrator of spooky tales, Lee Brown Coye. The e-book available for Kindle sadly does not have any illustrations, but for those unwilling to heft out the pretty penny for a hard-copy, I still recommend the electronic version for its healthy helping of horror classics guaranteed to keep you occupied this Halloween season.
Without a doubt, this is a classic of the genre, but it is far from a perfect collection. Cave tended to recycle bits of stories in mixed-and-matched ways, which will lead to you feeling like you have read these somewhere before. Most of the tales are about vampires or crazy revenge plots, and there is only so much originality you can display by rehashing the same material.
But is it scary? Yes! And for those of you really interested in the content of this book, I am attempting to provide a short synopsis and honest review of each of the 26 stories in this giant tome. So stick around...
"Murgunstrumm"--I am largely not frightened by vampire stories as a rule, but this 1934 novella is one of the most scary that I've read in the subgenre. It builds tension and gloomy atmosphere exquistely with a claustrophobic setting for the final showdown in an isolated old pub in the woods. The titular Serbian bloodsucker is suitably chilling with his shuffling limp and malignant grin. In all, I was genuinely creeped out by this rather traditional vampire tale, and this story alone makes this collection worthwhile.
"The Watcher in the Green Room"--One of Cave's more famous tales with a nod to Poe, but overall unremarkable.
"The Prophecy"--Four young white hipsters decide on a late night trek to the slums in order to experience the charms of an unusual charismatic religious service. This could be possibly an early critcism of "cultural appropriation." Or it could be a racist warning away of Caucasian kids from hanging out in jazz clubs or other traditionally predominantly black venues of the time. However you interpret it, the story is a bit disjointed with an ending that comes out of nowhere like a sucker punch.
"The Strange Death of Ivan Gromleigh"--One of the scarier stories in the collection, this 1937 pulp feels a lot more contemporary if only for the overt sexual content and the implications of what the fiend may do to his female victims in this precurosr to the modern slasher subgenre. This is the first of many stories in this omnibus where the author seems a bit too preoccupied with a particular facet of female endowments, which in this case distracts from an otherwise interesting 20th Century take on the "Jekyll and Hyde" motif.
"The Affair of the Clutching Hand"--One of Hugh Cave's early efforts for the pulps, this is presented as a kind of murder mystery with a scifi twist. Cave's stories from this period featured a lot of sceintific types searching for a secret of immortality or returning people back to life, and this is one of the more effective. It is marred by more blatant racism, this time against "Orientals" and typical of this time period.
"The Strange Case of No. 7"--Another Radium-Age science fiction story, this 1930 yarn about a man who develops a method of killing someone but keeping their mind alive and alert has a similar structure to another of his more known shorts, "The Murder Machine." In both tales, a mad scientist creates a device to enact an elavorate revenge scheme because of unrequited love. Killing a person's body while preserving their mind intact makes a great premise for a "buried alive" torture horror, but the potential is wasted in this very creaky chiller that doesn't have the same punch that Cave's work would become known for in just a few more years.
"The Isle of Dark Magic"--Another crazy person is bent on uncovering the secret of life and death, this time to resurrect a deceased lover in the jungles of an isolated island in Oceania. This one is part of the Cthulhu mythos. Unsettling, but not very terrifying.
"The Whisperers"--Insanely creepy cosmic horror about an unknown force in a dark cellar that can change people--literally. If you have a fear of basements, read with caution!
"Horror in Wax"--An excellent reworking of "A Cask of Amontillado," this is a very tense read even though the reader always can guess what's coming.
"Prey of the Nightborn"--A pretty standard take about sexy vampires who fight over the soul of one hapless schmuck. More obsessive rambling about boobies points to Cave's serious breast fetish in addition to his penchant for the macabre.
"Maxon's Mistress"--To say much about this story would be to spoil it. There is a scene here that would be very stereotypical in modern slashers. Legal complications should have long interfered with what one of the characters does in this story, but depiste some flaws like this, it is a creepy short read.
"Dead Man's Belt"--Set entirely in a junkyard, a ghost returns from the grave for revenge. Like in "The Prophecy," there is so much slang and colloquialism written in eye-dialect to capture the pronunciation of the uneducated that it makes for a very hard read. If you have the patience to get through it, there is a rather satisfactorily gruesome end.
"Boomerang"--A great story with nothing supernatural involved, being more typical of detective pulps at the time, though this one was written for a 1939 issue of "Argosy." It is set in Borneo, inspired by the writings of Hugh Cave's contemporary and friend, Carl Jacobi.
"The Crawling Curse"--Another supernatural revenge tale involving marital infidelity and another animated body-part, this time set in steamy Indonesia. Very spooky. A minor character appears in this story named Captain Fournier, a powerful and noble moniker if you ask me.
"Purr of a Cat"--One of Cave's later pulps from 1942, filled with more breast obsession (I counted seven references just in this story) and another sexy vamp. Meh.
"Tomorrow is Forever"--This is a very short tale but an effective one about a lone German soldier who stumbles into a happy village where no one acknowledges him. A poignant literary monument to one of the great travesties of World War II that few Americans remember--the Nazi destruction of the village of Lidice.
"The Ghoul Gallery"--One of the best of the bunch! This 1932 tale is definitely a staple for any literary fan of scary stories. It is about an ancient curse onto a noble family that leads to members being mysteriously strangled in an upper room of their giant mansion by an assailant who is missing a thumb. Very atmospheric, it is hampered only by one flaw involving an oath that every male descendent takes to keep the curse a secret from subsequent generations lest they live their whole lives in fear. Considering the main characters can read all about the curse and this supposed oath in great detail in a volume of the family history located in the library, I would say the oath isn't very effective in keeping secrets...
"The Cult of the White Ape"--A drunken planter is abusive to his wife and the natives of the sacred land where he plans to start a rubber plantation. He gets his comeuppance in a weird and disjointed tale about "were-apes" that ends up making little sense in the end.
"The Brotherhood of Blood"--I found this one to be the worst of the collection because it was so ridiculous and nonsensical in its execution. A supposed expert in the supernatural tries to protect the last member of an ancient family where all heirs are doomed to become vampires on their 28th birthday. For being such an expert, the main character does pretty much jack about the situation, and then things get even sillier from there.
"The Door of Doom"--Haunted house stories don't get any more cliche--or better--than this! From the establishing description of a giant mansion with its towers looming over the moors, to the endless corridors leading to unused rooms and secret passages, this chiller is a perfect little read for an October night. It is a 1936 "old-dark-house" thriller that features four WWI vets who reunite at a spooky mansion for drinks and a little exploration, tended by a mysterious Chinese servant who warns them to not open a certain door. And of course, they do...
"The Death Watch"--Another Cthulhu mythos story and another attempt to raise someone from the dead. A Florida man learns how to build a radio that sends signals to the beyond. Not very engaging until the final few pages, which are creepy, but we have seen the same thing happen in other stories.
"The Caverns of Time"--There's a lot of whipping and bondage and weird wife-swapping going on in this odd 1943 short set in rural Appalachia. That's about all I can tell you. It makes little sense as to what the protagonist is even doing in the mountains in the first place, what the local yokels are up to with all their cult kinkiness, and whether or not any of it is real. It's unsettling yet stupid at the same time.
"Many Happy Returns"--A very clever and very short creeper from 1966 about a newlywed couple stopping at an old rest-stop for the night during a roadtrip. The house is run by an elderly couple who are oddly interested in birthdays...
"Ladies In Waiting"--This short from 1975 is the latest story to be written before the collection was published. It is unfortunately one of the worst despite Cave's years of writing experience at this point. There seems to be nothing here but a mishmash of multiple horror tropes shoehorned into a very generic "you-can-never-leave-the-house" plot with no real point.
"The Grisly Death"--At the dawn of the Golden Age of science fiction, Hugh Cave brought us this 1934 pulp novella that's got it all. An escaped lunatic out for vengeance, a deformed henchman, an old dark house with a horrific laboratory, a damsel in distress, hard-boiled detectives, evil dogs, surgical torture, and brutal cannibalistic murders. It's kind of gory for the time, but still feels very old-school. I loved it.
"Stragella"--Vampires at sea! This is another one of Cave's more famous tales, and is a great way to end this doorstopper of a book. Congratulations!