To the future readers and writers of this generation and BEYOND,
I have decided to be completely honest in this review. I'm done with rounding up. I'm done with being altogether timid, cautious to shine a light on several issues that I used to pay no mind to with other writers. So...okay. Here we go. I did not like this book. Why, you ask? Because I couldn't. I tried diligently, oh yes I did, but it was difficult for me. As I made my way through Discovery, I tried to forgive the consistent slips in punctuation, typos, and the present and past tense follies circulating the pages with undying loyalty. But I just couldn't bring myself to do so, no matter how hard I tried to. So in that situation, what does one do? Just go all in and leave a scathing review? Eh, that's really not my style, I told myself repeatedly. I'm more of a person who has a conscience, an incessant need to reach out and help in any way that I can. Admittedly, I care about my fellow self-published writers, so I do try to personally voice my concerns with their work ahead of time in a personal message whenever the situation surfaces. So that's exactly what I did. I contacted Emma Jaye, the author of this very book. Full disclosure (this is relevant, I promise), she is/was the moderator of several review groups on Goodreads, and I took part in a few of them. Hi, you ghosters of the group, by the way! I stated how I felt and I gave many examples of things that she should fix. Various things that I willingly took the precious time out of MY time (and yes, it is precious) to assist with. I didn't critique the storytelling, the premise...nothing of the sort. I just got down to the basics. Sentences/things that simply have to be corrected because they're incorrect.
Immersion breakers for demonstrative purposes only:
"The Garian [capped here but not in the previous two instances] ship had larger corridors, higher ambient temperatures and light levels than the human vessel." [?? lighter levels?? more light levels?]
"...we've only had success when we've captured particularly [particular?] specimens."
"Huang gazed at the nude figure as she by-[delete hyphen]passed the ladder...Unfazed by the ten-foot drop, she walked;[change semi-colon to em dash] make that stalked[insert em dash] towards him."
"'Come, let us have some refreshment, and I will tell you what I know about Dakarans.' Ichannat placing [placed] its enormous blue-scaled hand on Huang's shoulder and guiding [guided] him away."
"'Eww, those bloody mice are back!' she exclaimed to the empty room and instinctively raising [raised] her purse as a defensive weapon while she peered around the central block of lockers."
Allow me to interject for a moment here. Up above are just five examples that could truly have been avoided. Easily, mind you. And the book is littered with examples like this. That's why I wasn't immersed while reading. They stop you in your tracks for a second. My immersion was broken one too many times. As well as my patience. Especially since I brought them to the author's attention with a resounding thud. Apparently, grace was not to be in the deck of cards. Instead of thanking me for spotting inconsistencies/errors and caring enough to come to her about it first, she lashed out like a spoiled teenager. Emma was quick to say that she had over twenty (self-)published books and that she's earned a comfortable living with her writing and by taking on paid beta-reads. Oh yeah, and it's merely my prerogative to leave a two-star review for this novel if I "don't agree" with her usage of commas, semi-colons, and hyphens. Even though it's so much more than that. With no exaggeration, this book is inherently plagued with problems. And also, it's not a presidential debate. It's a case of right and wrong. You know, it's always funny when a person flexes their ego instead of accepting inarguable mistakes that were made on their end. Look, we all obviously make mistakes with the projects we create every once in a while, but that doesn't mean a person has to be entirely blinded by their own delusions of grandeur when it comes to somebody kindly—and genuinely—attempting to help them out with it. That's the sign of a human being not wanting to improve, the type of person who's so enamored with a self-inflated literary depiction of themselves that they can't readjust and admit any shred of fault. With that attitude, you can't improve. It's simple science.
More immersion breakers...but this time, for your growing enjoyment, I have opted to randomly hop to any page in an experiment to see if there's a mistake within the manuscript in any given area. By way of making a distinctive point. And guess what? I found something each and every time. Three jumps forward and back inside the book, these were the things that I found:
Location 2858 of 3470:
THE ATTACK OF NO COMMAS!!
"You may go home to your lovely wife and family now Melton."
"Sorry Sir"
Location 1144 of 3470:
:: beginning paragraph of Chapter 12 ::
MALICIOUS MISSPELLINGS!!
"The sharp stab of fear and adrenaline that shot threw [you mean through??] her, [delete comma] changed to outright rage as the two men laughed."
Really quick personal interruption here! If I had bought a physical copy (if one even existed) of this book instead of the digital version, I'd probably tell someone that I THREW it out in disgust. When they'd surely ask me why it had bothered me so much, I'd say that I just couldn't go THROUGH the pain of logically stringing together the badly-worded sentences anymore. See what I did there? Education is fun for all ages!
Location 1781 of 3470:
HURDLE THE WORDS! YOU CAN DO IT!
At Connor's blank stare Tamas continued. "Well in that case shall we get on with things? Hopefully after hearing my tale of woe you'll agree that it's in the best interests of this planet as well as yourselves to render assistance to our cause."
What do you think of those? By the way, I put that massive word hurdle last because there are many passages like that. And it's detrimental for any reader to sift through the swamp of it. It's not smooth. It's not even good.
Moving along!
What I have found interesting is Emma Jaye's strange stance in regards to any perceived problem within her writing. Now, there have actually been errors casually pointed out by not just me, but by several others (albeit with kid gloves). Reviewer Andromeda Bliss stated, "I don't know if the kindle version is more polished, but the edition I received would have benefited from intensive proofreading and editing." It's fascinating that Miss Jaye has gone out of her way to try and explain herself. She even includes a disclaimer in the beginning of one of her books that states:
"Please note that all spelling, grammatical constructions and cultural references derive from the weirdness of British English."
While that is decidedly to be taken into consideration, it doesn't account for the simple rules of punctuation or verb tense inconsistencies that are clearly being thrown under the "it's British English" blanket. Said blanket does not cover blatant disregard of the rules that would obviously make something easier to read and understand.
You may be wondering why I haven't rated this book the dreaded, soul-crushing one-star. Well, I didn't resort to such a low rating because Discovery neither offended me to an extreme, nor is it completely broken. The point here is that I was going to possibly give it three stars if I had just received word or some sort of assurance from the author that she'd improve the distracting errors snapping, crackling, and popping within the manuscript. But I didn't get that, sadly. What I got for my fellow writer sincerity was a person who is very much comfortable living in a bubble of obliviousness. No! Of course she cannot be bothered in her glass house by others trying to make her aware of some glaring issues. No, no!! And by God, she will ignore any and all stones thrown at said glass house. Perhaps it's because a mod hat is firmly on the head. Right?
P.S. As of this writing, there is only one other two-star review left for this book. And it's by a person who just stopped reading altogether. They didn't even finish it. You know why? They said the sentences were too jumbled and that they weren't sure if the author who wrote it speaks English as a second language or if the author is just writing too fast and skipping edits.
Well...
Have no fear, Amazon reviewer J. Mason! Your answer is as follows:
Emma Jaye clings to a crutch of her British upbringing in a dazzling showcase of egomaniacal denial. She cites her many structural mishaps with writing as mere preference instead of actual faults on display, which they are. And furthermore, she doesn't use a dedicated editor, which I suggested—either mine or any editor for that matter. Regardless, there's your pure clarification, whoever you are!
And to you personally, Emma...viewing this incomplete form of a book, I cannot put on the rose-colored glasses any longer. I cannot kiss ass like so many others have done for you in the groups, in fear of being shunned or cast out of what is an inconsequential and pretentious gathering. Yes, you are a writer, but you are a writer who needs to learn how to properly write without making the most commonplace errors. It can—and should—be rectified in all of your work. You owe it to the readers who decide to invest time in your books. Make it easier for them to read. Simple stuff.
And most importantly, to quote the wise words of Dr. Steve Brule...
"It's for your health."