Read: 16Jan26,
5 Stars. OMG, i loved this. This tale had a different spin for Betty, where it was the H who became withdrawn from the h after their MOC, thinking he had rushed her into it and not wanting her to regret her choice, and his quiet angst was absolutely delicious.
Octavia (27), a beautiful and popular nurse, meets a handsome stranger in her casualty room when he carries in a little old lady who has been mugged. He seems to dislike her on sight, which annoys her, but he hangs around to ensure the old lady is well and even stays late after everyone is gone because Octavia has been left alone in casualty and her cover nurse has not arrived. She decides he is quite nice really, if a bit moody. He leaves at the end of the night without even telling her his name.
He is Lucas (39), and she meets him again on a cruise ship, where she is covering for the cruise ship's nurse who had taken ill. He is the ship's head doctor, covering for a colleague, and he seems angry to see Octavia there and is brusque with her. The head nurse, a beautiful older woman (35), is determined to catch Lucas for herself, and launches a campaign against Octavia, keeping her busy working and never giving her time off when Lucas has time off, and giving herself plenty of time off to go dining and dancing with him.
However, Lucas, being the head doctor is able to thwart Octavia's work schedule at times and he ensures that Octavia is able to see some of their ports of call by taking her off ship and showing her around places like Sicily. Snatching chances even when she's only been given a few hours off. They get along during their trips, but he remains aloof and distant once they are back on board, which makes her a bit sad.
However she is a confident girl, used to fun and being appreciated, and she doesn't pine for him. She tells herself she isn't that interested in him, though she knows this to be untrue.
I was immediately interested by both of their characters, though he remained somewhat mysterious for the first half of the book -- very much a much admired mystery man, popular with all the ladies, effortlessly capable at his job. And she is a very likeable girl.
SPOILERS AHEAD
Onboard ship, they also bond by saving a woman who needs emergency surgery during the night. But the way he blows hot and cold with her is disappointing to her and towards the end of the 2 week cruise, she starts to avoid him. Even so, she is sad on the last day at the thought of not saying goodbye to him and hopes to see him.
He does one better - he has arranged to drive her home, saying he wants to talk to her. She asks what about. To her shock, he proposes marriage. he says they get along well and are friends, and he has realised lately that he is lonely in life and he would like a partner. that he doesn't love her or expect love from her, but that they could be happy together. He is a widower (an RDD) and has a nine year old daughter, and he says they could be a family together.
She turns him down immediately. She has been proposed to before and never married anyone because she never was in love. she tells him she doesn't love him. Plus her father (an absent minded prof type) would be lonely without her if she married and moved to holland. He says, I will drive you home anyway and maybe you can think about it?
He takes her home and she invites him in to meet her father. But they arrive just in time for dad to say "Octavia, i wanted to see you again," and die. This was really quite sad. This book had more lingering grief than other Betty books but, as she usually does, she handled it with a light touch so that it didn't bog down the romance.
Lucas stays with her, managing everything and arranging the funeral while she is lost in her haze of grief. When she cant cope and cries out that she doesn't know what to do, he says that she can marry him and come home to holland. He is convincing and she agrees. She can't bear to go back to her normal life, which will be empty now.
They marry quickly and return to holland, where she is welcome with open arms by his 9 year old daughter and all the servants and his family. she is happily surprised to find two of her former old patients working in his home--she had mentioned being worried about them (old people with no money or family, nothing to live for) the day she first met Lucas, and it turns out he was the man who offered them a home and jobs! Dear Lucas.
Shortly afterwards, she meets Lucas's cousin Marcus, 28, an extrovert who is very keen on meeting the new bride, and keeps inviting her to go out and do things with him while Lucas is busy with work. At first, she turns him down, but Lucas encourages her to accept the invitations, and he is extremely busy with is work. It is his urging which drives her to accept and to spend time with Marcus. However, this in turn seems to make Lucas more remote and withdrawn from her.
Anyway, it was interesting to see a slightly reversed dynamic where we have the H being the one who withdraws and the h being the one who is social and outspoken and confident and ends up going on 'dates' with an OM, despite them not being real dates and the hubby pushing her to socialise with his cousin.
She is increasingly frustrated that Lucas is so busy and that he never talks to her about his personal or his work life. She has realised she is in love with him, and craves to know everything about him, but he wont give her even a little bit. He becomes distant and mocking if she probes too much. She realises that he never wanted her love and feels she must hide it at all costs.
I had read about this role reversal in other reviews and thought I wouldnt like it, but actually it worked really well and was very satisfying because the reader can sense that they are both pining for one another and yet he is so withdrawn we really dont know what is going on in his mind. There was a plentiful emotional undercurrent and chemistry between then to keep us fully interested in the story.
ENDING SPOILERS
Her getting stuck in traffic in dangerous icy conditions with his young daughter in the car is what triggers their fallout near the ending. He had warned her to leave a kid's bday party at 4.30pm before rush hour, and she meant to, but then Marcus had come in, and had been telling her about some girl he had decided to marry, so she got delayed leaving. and then the weather turned terrible and a fog rolled in, and traffic ahead of them crashed, leaving them vulnerable to also being crashed into on a motorway, a scary situation. Lucas found them and rescued them from it, but when she tells him she was delayed because of marcus, he is furious. He tells her that she should have known better than let her emotions run away with her when a child was involved. She is furious with him for thinking she would put his daughter in danger.
He then suddenly takes her back to england, saying she needs to make decisions about what to do with her dad's house, but she realises that he is making plans for her to be able to go back to that house if their marriage breaks down.
It's interesting that in other Betty books it is the male who says things that terrify the female and leave her on cliff-hanger tenterhooks, which drive us crazy because why doesn't the damn man know why what he said terrified the girl and drove her away from him! lol. But here the roles are reversed and we can totally see the innocence of what she said and how she might have no idea about the impact on him. She said things like "Marcus wants to get married soon" and, after she had gotten tipsy and chatty during dinner and dancing, the next morning she worriedly said, "I didn't say anything to you last night, did I?" which is hilarious because the poor man now thinks she has planned to marry marcus! lol. But really she was worried that she had let slip that she loved Lucas. Laughing my head off at this.
When they return to holland, she realises she cannot bear for him to not love her back and cannot bear the distance he is putting between them and resolves that she must leave him. She picks her moment on the evening before a big posh dinner party they are throwing, having worked up her courage and being unable to hold back, especially since she has hardly seen Lucas with him being so busy working.
He goes white in the face, thinking she is about to break things off with him. The poor man. His agony is palpable, especially after she says "I need to talk to you about me and marcus." Lol!! And the poor man dives in and says I suppose I knew all along you would choose marcus because he is younger and he has so much free time, to which she replies, no, he's going to get a job so that he can marry that girl he likes. Lol, she isnt looking at his face so doesnt see his expression. Then she blurts out she is going to leave lucas because she loves him and cant bear that he doesnt love her back. After which we get an explosive and very satisfactory declaration of love from him, and he sweeps her into his arms and kisses her. Yay! Lucas gets his girl!! He says he knew he loved her ever since they operated on the cruise ship. But then he worried he had rushed her into marriage and he was trying to give her the space to decide who she really loved without interference. Aw, quite noble of him really.
CONCLUSION
I absolutely loved this one. Having read over 100 betty books by now, I didnt think I would find another 5 star betty read left, but i absolutely inhaled this one. It was intriguing and fast paced from the start. The section on the cruise ship really highlighted him as the desirable and capable doc in charge (yum, that crisp white ship's doc uniform tho!) and i kinda loved that the OW nasty nurse was hot for him and chasing him around, and how he could not resist making plans to take Octavia off ship for sightseeing and how he adored seeing her joy at seeing all the sights. He even lamented that he would have liked to show her Rhodes (when the nasty head nurse made sure octavia was working). I also loved how aloof he was with the h at the start because I think he didnt want to fall in love at that point and was scared a bit of the emotions that Octavia awoke in him. And yet he jumped the gun and proposed the minute they were off ship and there was the chance he wouldnt see her again. He was so patient even when she said no. His ego didnt lash out and he still wanted to drive her home. Gotta love that. I even loved the MOC section where we got to see Octavia pining for him. This book had lots of emotion and was so poignant and had a decent bit of angst. I look forward to rereading it again at some point.