When I was a young advertising executive back in the early 1980s, I learned a lot about the science of advertising from my major client, McDonald's. I learned how to plan and execute campaigns precisely to achieve optimum media reach, frequency, TRPs, cumes, and CPMs.
I learned about developing campaigns to win the greatest media "share of voice" and ultimately achieve the largest "share of mind," which of course we measured with research (unaided recall, aided recall, brand associations, etc., etc.).
But the Ronald McDonald House and a little girl with Wilms tumor taught me that hearts cannot be bought or sold with hard-core marketing but must be earned through good works and honest values, forthrightly expressed. I discovered something much more important from a consumer standpoint: "share of heart."
This is what Firms of Endearment teaches with its many insightful case studies about how "share of heart" can be achieved through integrity, humanistic values and community stewardship. I have learned in 30 years that we consumers have a lot of heart to give back to companies that take care of us and reflect our deepest values. It's a simple idea, yet profound and so timely.
One critical reviewer posting here does not apparently understand that appealing to endearing emotions -- and building brands based on appeals to the emotions seeking affinity (and their underlying core values) -- is the wave of the future. Consumers have multiple choices today in any category -- parity reigns -- and it's those companies making cogent and genuine appeals to the heart that will prosper more than those who remain stuck in 20th century approaches involving logical sales arguments, low-price positions as the primary business goal (e.g. Wal-Mart), obsession with killing competitors, and strong-armed sales tactics. Low pricing wins a segment of the market and always will, but I can't think of a widely admired firm that has achieved substantial "share of heart" when focused on making money over creating affinity with stakeholders.
The authors are suggesting a revolutionary idea: humanism can merge with capitalism through a truly win-win business/consumer strategy, an endearing strategy -- a 21st century capitalism.