I will start off by saying that this book is most definitely a Feel-Good Romantic Comedy. There was a cute set up, likeable characters, and funny moments. But ultimately, this fell pretty flat for me.
The book was very short and I wish it had taken place over a shorter timeframe, as well. I also wish we had focused even more heavily on our main characters rather than bringing in so many side characters. The shortness and lack of depth made it hard for me to really connect with anything that was happening.
I also had a hard time connecting with the characters because of the dialogue. It didn't feel realistic to me and I felt like there were a lot of times where the dialogue was clearly conveying something to the reader rather than feeling like real words that real people would exchange - especially not two people who are best friends and have known each other for so many years.
Gwinnie and Blake definitely did not feel like best friends to me. They felt like they had gotten to know each other a little bit back in the day and were reconnecting. It wasn't just because of the awkward dialogue - even some of the scenarios they got into didn't make sense based on their relationship. The birthday party was a great example. Was that the first time Gwinnie met Blake's siblings? That's how it came off and, while that isn't the wildest thing ever, it was strange to me that someone wouldn't have met and already been comfortable with their childhood best friend's family. I would have liked seeing these two deepen their friendship and become best friends but that's not what the set up was, so these scenarios didn't quite make sense for me.
I also felt like the third act conflict was over dramatized. I didn't think Gwinnie's reaction was fair in the moment and it was even less fair when she let Blake continue thinking she was hurt and upset for an entire week. That made me feel pretty annoyed with her, to be honest, which was a bummer because I did really like her throughout the rest of the book.
All of these things that didn't make sense to me plus the lack of depth in the characters made me very aware that I was reading a book. Everything felt like a plot point and not a real scenario. I think there was a lot of potential for this to be an amazing story, but I didn't hit the mark for me. I am sad this one didn't work for me, but it still has really fun characters and wholesome moments and I am sure it will resonate with many others!
I am very grateful to the author for an advanced edition of this story. All opinions are my own.