Firstly, author Erosa Knowles gets major kudos for even attempting and pulling off a D/s book with a male alpha submissive. Let's face it, few romance readers are ready for a submissive male of any sort (M/M romance notwithstanding) and unfortunately erotica tends to depict them as sissies and/or playing up the humiliation factor. Natural Law tried (and in my opinion failed) to craft a compelling alpha sub, but kept tripping on its own feet.
Now we have Lyon on a Leash and to say that I was pretty impressed is an understatement. For one thing, I appreciate the fact that that Ms. Knowles cared enough about the subject of BDSM to go and do the legwork. She stated in her acknowledgments the Dommes and subs she met and talked to. I think, just from her wording that she went into the scene with certain preconceived notions about male subs and that she left with a deeper understanding. That understanding is clear in the character of Marcus.
I've been in the scene. I've met and have known alpha subs like Marcus Lyon. They are, like him, rare and amazing men. What I loved about this book is the author doesn't constantly harp on his alpha-ness. She allows Marcus' actions towards Vera to do the work. It's subtle, especially to someone unfamiliar with the careful dance of D/s. Contrary to another review, Marcus is not a beta male (though I love them too). It takes a strong man, which Marcus is, to be willing to serve a woman in the way he does Vera--too bad she wasn't worthy until the end. I really loved how protective he was of her, but how he leashed his protector instincts when she said so. That was so hot. His control when Vera was sexually arousing him hit all my happy buttons. Seriously, I want a Marcus Lyon of my very own! A real alpha with guts! Sorry BDB boys, your chest beating and funny-spelled names just don't measure up to a man so secure in his masculinity that he lives to serve, honor, protect, love and cherish the woman whom he has given his heart. The fact that Marcus can and does without being threatened by Vera's independence...swoonworthy I tell ya!
I haven't really changed my mind about Vera since my updates. I still didn't like her and I still hate the "OMG I'm in the lifestyle but/because I have deep-seated emotional issues" trope that is far too common in these books. However, that's my view of her outside of the D/s milieu, where she was just a hot mess. When she's in Mistress mode, she's good. She understands the concept of safewords, she and Marcus negotiated the rules and more important, she LISTENED to his concerns. I would have liked a few aftercare scenes, just because I'm a stickler for those details. Yes, I am a hardass when it comes to my heroines. I don't expect perfection nor do they have to be drama-free; but it drives me batshit crazy that too many romance authors shortchange their heroines in order to build up the hero. It's almost a weird form of sexism. Oh, and what is up with the light-skin and red hair thing? I wasn't quite sure this was even an IR until a secondary character mentioned Vera's race. Granted, not a fan of food adjectives as skin tone, but as a writer whose stock in trade IS creativity, there had to be something better than the oblique (coy) references.
I would have liked more intense dungeon sessions between Vera and Marcus as well, though the auction scene at the beginning was well done. I also loved the mix of Dommes; they weren't all thin model types, but sounded like real women. Marguerite as "mama Bear" was wonderful, if a bit overprotective. I loved the respect shown towards the different types of subs. The author made no value judgments between the more alpha and less alpha males. Besides Marcus, Michelle/Michael was my favorite. The sex scenes were hot especially with the control factor thrown in, but please for future reference, no more "weeping p*ssies". That doesn't sound erotic, more like some form of an STD.
Lyon on a Leash is a risky romance. It's not for everyone, especially for those who like their tropes. I love a good femdom romance, and this one, in spite of the heroine fail, is still a keeper. Good job, Ms. Knowles.