It seems curmudgeonly of me not to like a book about a kind and dedicated foster mother who takes in damaged children and works tirelessly to heal them, I know. And I do applaud Ms. Harrison for her priceless work as a foster parent, but judging the book and not the person, I have to say eh.
The story is a combo of sticky sweet (watch me make cookies and soup and cookies again and kiss boo-boos and have sensitive heart-to-hearts, not like those BAD mommies) and Law & Order SVU voyeuristic icky. You don't have to bake a single cookie to be a better mom than those who starve and beat their kids right up 'til the moment when they turn them over to a pedophile boyfriend, so enough already with the heavily-drawn contrast, you already won, Kathy.
But more significantly, there's little examination of why she feels compelled to continue taking foster kids when, as she herself says, the kids she already has would all benefit from more attention and one-on-one time. Yeah, I know that part of the reason is that foster homes are scarce and she's constantly getting calls from workers desperate to place kids with her. But she shows, without really analyzing, that she takes new children basically to fill a void in her attention span. When things are calm and none of the other four emotionally damaged or mentally ill children in her home are in crisis, she gets itchy and voila! here's another child with immediate concerns to focus on. Kind of creepy.
As a mother of four pretty average kids, I find it hard to believe that a mom with six kids, four of whom are under 10 and have PTSD, Tourette's, etc., would ever feel underutilized enough to "need" another foster child.
And finally, there is very little critique of the systems that are producing the damaged children she is brought. She points out that kids are more likely to die in foster care than out of it, but doesn't say why that is. She singles out many of the therapists and social workers she deals with as being really great compared to others, but there's not much elaboration of all the ways the others she has had to work with aren't so great. And that's the greatest flaw of the book, to me. As a popular title, it has a chance, while telling the kids' stories, to raise awareness in readers of how child protection fails children, parents, and foster parents. But there's not much of that here. So I praise her fostering, but not the book.