“The Murder Inn” is Patterson and Fox’s follow-up to their previous 2019 summer read - “The Inn” – which was an enjoyable read. With the second book in what is turning into a potential series, we return to the bed-and-breakfast inn located in the seaside town of Gloucester, Massachusetts. The inn is run by widower, Bill Robinson, a retired ex-cop from Boston who has moved on from his wife’s untimely death.
Bill has about ten residents, all with their own sordid backgrounds and troubled histories. They include Clayton Spears, the town’s sheriff; Nick Jones, ex-military man who fought in the middle east and suffers from PTSD; Angelica Grace Thomas-Lowell, bestselling author, vegan, and activist; Vinny Robetti, a retired (if possible) gangster; and Susan Solie, ex-FBI agent and Bill’s girlfriend.
This time, there are three interwoven plotlines that drive the novel. The first, two strangers arrive in town, a mother and son, who Clayton Spears finds himself drawn to, both professionally and on a deeply personal level. But Spears senses something is not right with the two… Second, a psychotic drug lord has quietly moved into town, using a house recladding business to cook drugs and distribute them along the east coast. This dangerous man is also a secret serial killer of women who has a very hard time controlling his desires… Third, Nick Jones is still suffering horrific dreams from his past military experience that haunt and keep him from moving forward with his life. Then he receives a message that a member from his squad has been found dead and his past comes racing back…
Although these storylines will not come across as new for most readers, Patterson and Fox find a way to make it fresh enough in their delivery, especially with relying on a multi-layered and interesting enough cast. The protagonist, Bill, is a good enough, well intentioned, yet flawed man who makes mistakes trying to do the right thing. He is an easy guy to cheer for throughout the overwhelming challenges thrown his way.
The rest of the tenants, and their own personal struggles blend in well, including Clayton’s falling for women way too easily, and Nick’s internal trauma that overwhelms his emotional state. The strength and qualities of these characters were the heart of this book. Their tenacity to get through their struggles and refusal to give up made this an enjoyable reading experience. One of the things I appreciated was how the authors chose to share some of the character’s secrets throughout the book but saved the bigger reveals for the end.
And just in case you think that I am ignoring some of the key weaknesses in the book, including several moments that weren’t realistic, the answer is no. I recognized them for what they were, which are common bumps along the way in most of Patterson’s novels, and we do what we always do - ignore them while focusing on the momentary escapist enjoyment he gives us. For example, both of these “Inn” novels had a drug lord as a major villain, which was a bit repetitive. Maybe next time we can get a different type of bad guy to harass our good guys and ladies.
Also, since “The Murder Inn” is only 300 pages long, a Harriet Blue novella – “Black and Blue” – a previously published Bookshots novella is included, which is a prequel to the four-book series also co-written with Fox. This was also an interesting read that helped lead the reader into the series and ended on a shocking reveal that those who read the series will know what I am referring to.
At the end of the day, reading Patterson books come down to one simple truth. His books are temporary mind candy – adventures filled with emotional and thrill rides that help us escape our daily grind and enjoy an exciting read that helps us forget about everything else. And when the story works well enough, we tend to set aside those obvious plot weaknesses to appreciate what he does well in his proven thriller recipe – to capture our attention and provide good entertainment.
Overall, “The Murder Inn” is that kind of mind candy that serves as a fun and enjoyable read. I give it, as well as "Black and Blue", both 3 out of 5 stars and wouldn’t mind visiting the gang in Gloucester again in the future. I think there’s more interesting things to discover and learn about them. We’ll see if the sales support another adventure with this winning team of underdogs…