I thought the author's name was somewhat familiar, then a quick check here confirmed that he'd written a little gem of a book called 'Legionary: The Roman Soldier's (Unofficial) Manual'. The genius of that book, and others in that series, is that they take very serious research and knowledge in the area of, say, being a Legionnaire, and turn in into a faux manual for being one. They are highly informed and highly entertaining reads, and try, as much as I remember, to keep up the illusion of being, just possibly, an actual manual, kind of, if you're willing to suspend dis-belief and go along for the ride.
I wish he'd taken this approach to this book on Ancient Magic, as that would have been, I believe, a better read, given the lighter tone of this book. I was expecting, or rather hoping, for a more serious examination of Ancient Magic, in this case, as practiced by the ancient Greeks and Romans. He does point out that most of the examples in this field come from grand fiction of the time, and does seem to rely rather heavily upon one actual magical work of the time for most of the 'serious' magic work represented in this essentially introductory piece. We are taken somewhat out of the spells woven by the book by references to modern examples of magical thinking that have survived to this day. They are illuminating in their own way, however, it did rather break the 'spell' for me.
The value of this book could have been moreso in the in-depth examination of how magical thinking differed in this alien time to our own de-glamoured times. Instead this was briefly touched upon early, then we were presented with examples from Greek and Roman fiction of portrayals of magic, sometimes with the caveat that this was indeed a fictitious, and, therefore, dramatic presentation of magic for poetic effect, rather than a 'practical guide', as promised by the book's title.
Having said that, there are genuine examples of magical passages, and the author does assure us in the acknowledgments that he has (to his wife's alarm) actually practiced some of the more benign spells presented in the text, for research purposes. I say, pics or it didn't happen.
More than anything, this book can be seen as possibly a missed opportunity, but the author did tease in the Acknowledgments that the person who suggested he write this book has written a 'scholarly and comprehensive text on the subject' and that he 'look(s) forward to seeing it in print.' So do I, if it lives up to that promise. This book doesn't quite live up to that promise, however.