I almost had a problem with this book on account of its excellent writing. It is written in the first person, with alternate chapters told by Emma, a young married woman living in the 21st century, and by Jennet, an orphaned fifteen-year old living in the 18th century. After reading the first 'Jennet' chapter, I struggled to keep myself from skipping ahead and reading all the other Jennet chapters as fast as I could, forgetting about the overall flow of the story.
This is not a criticism of the Emma chapters; they are well-written and engaging. But, the heartbreaking story of Jennet, and the fascinating language used to tell it, both the speech patterns and the words themselves, would overshadow any story set next to them. (By the way, there was an interesting moment in the 21st century story when Mark is introduced and you realize from his grammar that he's a native of the area. And yes, that becomes relevant.)
But, the story arc belongs to Emma. She is a young married woman, a writer, newly moved into her dream home. She struggles to deal with a miscarriage. Her husband is loving, but spends much time away from home. She hears church bells tolling from under the water of the lake, where a drowned village lies. She begins having nightmares. (Those are the parts of the 'Emma' story that are as vivid as the 'Jennet' story--more than once I had to stop reading for a moment to deal with what seemed to be happening--it was so horrifying.) And, then she starts doing things that she does not want to do, that are contrary to her nature. And what is happening to her seems to parallel the story of Jennet that she is obsessively writing.
That story, Jennet's story, goes from one disaster to another worse one, with just enough hope along the way to make the final catastrophe even more devastating. And Jennet's character, Greek tragedy style, helps bring about that final catastrophe. (By the way, I love the character of Mary Farmer, who started out seeming fussy and irritating, and revealed herself to be someone filled with love and courage.)
The ending of the entire story felt a little rushed, when I first read it. When I look at it again, it seems just fine. So, I would highly recommend this to anyone who is intrigued by the idea of a gripping historical story intertwined with a modern ghost story.
I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.