3,5 long live anal plugs
I've never been more unsure of how to rate a book. I am not even sure why I chose to read this book, as in I really can't remember the moment when I actively decided I wanted to read it and set to purchase it. Menage, multiple partners, poly...not my usual preferred genres. I have a conflicted, ever-developing relationship with poly, so I not-so-subconsciously try to avoid books with these elements, at least I did. I think I landed on a pretty fluffy ground for a casual pick. I enjoyed this story much more than I thought possible, the fact that the writing was better than I expected helped quite a lot.
This is an extremely woman-friendly story. The heroine is loved, adored and pampered by all and everyone she comes in contact with, everything is superconsensual, all the time, she is unexperienced but has no problems accepting and embracing her own lust and desires and feelings, there is no shame and her little doubts/fears about what she's embarking on are quickly worked through. The sex scenes are good, believable without turning into impossible gymnastics, mostly focused on her sensations, even if here and there the author fades into some purple prose. Never mind, I re-read them several times.The brothers are simple adorable, the family as a whole impossible to resist. And there even is a lot of kissing AND a plot!
So why am I not more enthusiastic about it? Because there really is nothing new about this story, nothing super exciting. And there were a bit too many tropes: dangerous mobster obsessed with innocent girl, girl in protective custody all skittish and thirsty for human contacts that must keep her big secret, instalust turning quickly into eternal love, too-perfect cowboys all doing right by her (most of the time), painful past for the men as well with one particularly tortured male character, adorable twin children...I could go on! I mentioned the existance of a plot, but it really is a thin construction to provide the heroine with a minimum of background, the necessary danger to push her into the arms of the McLendon brothers and introducing a lot of characters. It could have been soooo much more, a real thriller element, I really loved all her little paranoid safety measures. The villain is dealt with in a shooting scene so generic and lacking specifics that I wondered how could anyone be so damn scared of him after all. Come on, she was so terrified of him, of being found, of bringing anyone in danger and that's how he meets his end? I'm sorry, I didn't buy it.
Also, totally unexcusable: if you're introducing an element of Italian mob, DO IT RIGHT : don't choose random names that are anything BUT Italian, if you make the villain have some piece of text in Italian, you better make damn sure it is CORRECT, and not one word mispelled ant the rest in Spanish! I almost DNF at that point, seriously. I don't care it's an erotic menage romance, no excuse for being sloppy.
Now, the men. Loved their brotherly dynamics, loved how they took care of their twin sons, loved they were all hard workers and loved how they really shared, no jealousy, loved the realistic details of using condoms and training the heroine towards anal sex and DP considering the group sex to come and how careful they always were with her desires. But I could point out that considering how inexperienced she was and how overwhelmed she was by emotions and sexual gratification, I doubt she could really refuse or direct anything, at least not at the beginning. I even liked the characterizations even though they were not deep and also quite trite. We have the intense/brooding brother, the playful/mischievous one and the sensitive/sensual. I didn't like feeling the author favouring Matt and Grey over Mason. Grey was often too hysterical and uncommunicative for me and I didn't really see how playful Matt was, I was told. Mason was the only man who consistently checked with the heroine about her feelings, fears, problems, putting her well-being and needs before his own, also sexually, letting her talk and or/ask for help, talking to her helping her getting used to new situations. He was the emotional meter of everyone. Matt and Grey were often just greedy and impulsive, I felt like he had less sex scenes with the heroine and less descriptive. Also, Mason is the 'legs' man...if you give him the weakest preference, once again, you must do it right, it can't just be about having them tight around his waist!!! Where is the adoration? Where's the caressing, kissing, kneading, licking, biting, scratching from feet to pelvis, where he should get finally lost in her vagina? Or the positions where he can have more access to most of her legs? Nope, nothing at all. The two oral sex scenes were given to Matt. Meh.
Usual menage readers probably know tons of books better than this, yet I believe this is a very, very nice read. Lust and love strike almost instantly, it goes with the genre, but Gabby and her men really are lovely and steamy together and it's a pleasure to see her enjoy herself so much and finally finding a great loving family. Funny banter, mega fluffy romantic lines, generous amounts of passionate kissing, positive sex vibe in all scenes...anyone less picky than me will love it even more.