By Nishat Fatima. Grade: B+
Seriously, Sitara? is an all around feel-good chick-lit with a heroine who is not Barbie thin and beautiful but still gets Ken. There is no mystery ridden sub-plot to unnecessarily complicate a story, or a secondary love story of the protagonists’ friends. These are common plots used by writers so that they get a third angle to work with, but Nishat Fatima doesn’t dip there, and keeps her focus singularly on Sitara, her thirty-something grumpy journalist for the international publication Homme.
With no plot line except to bring the hero and heroine together for their happy-ever-after, the author walks a tightrope as she ensures the reader stays involved and entertained for the three hundred pages.
Nasser Khan is the leading Bollywood Khan, after the original triumvirate. After a very painful break up with his fiancee Richa, another Bollywood product, Nasser has become a recluse. So when the Homme magazine gets a chance to an exclusive interview with the superstar, Sitara’s boss gives her the piece, if only to piss off the people who worked at getting the interview in the first place. Sitara can hardly keep her Khans straight, and her intellect is too sharp to consider Bollywood entertaining. Which is why we get a classic meet-cute, complete with Sitara getting drunk and throwing up all over this Bollywood legend. Fate decides to keep throwing them in each other’s path, and pretty soon Sitara is helping Nasser and his estranged brother grow closer, getting hit on by his best friend and having dinner with his family. There is little conflict to make the story intriguing, mostly just their hang ups in getting involved with someone that drastically different.
I loved Nasser. Despite his stardom, he is a very grounded character. He makes tea for his family, gets punched by people he pisses off, has unresolved childhood issues and gets scolded by his parents for mundane mistakes. There is little reference to his superstar status; he could have been holding any famous job for all the difference it made.
The narration is lively with a lot of great one-liners. There are frequent laugh out moments and the eclectic cast of secondary characters is plain hilarious. Sitara is likable enough, suitably funny and sarcastic to attract Nasser’s attention, yet I feel that not enough focus was given on the how’s and why’s of their courtship. I couldn’t see exactly what Nasser saw in her that made her so remarkably different from the hundreds of women he has had or can have. Usually the author shows in a myriad ways about the connection her protagonists share to negate the improbability of their happy-ever-after but I saw no such episode here. Sitara does question whether a relationship of an ordinary girl with a multi-millionnaire star will ever work out, but the resolution is weak and half-hearted.
These are all minor points, yes, but attention to them would have made a great book absolutely terrific. I love my chick-lit, and I know nothing is better to chase the blues away. This one does a great job. Go for it if you are looking for three hours of entertainment that won’t tax your brain, even if it is a read-’em-and-forget-’em story.
Originally reviewed at Vaultofbooks.com, a close-knit community of fanatical readers. We are looking for perceptive readers who can write well, and we are eager to provide lots of free books in exchange for reviews. Shot us a mail at contact@vaultofbooks.com”