"Manling, you’re going to be the death of me!”
Before I dive into my ramblings, I thought I should mention that while this is a book review for ‘Trollslayer’ it turned into a musing upon other novels in the series. Well the first twelve novels any way. Not sure how that happened, but it did.
Gotrek, a Dwarf Trollslayer is a really hard character to like. You can’t relate to him well (unless your wielding a magical axe – if you do your awesome!). This is mainly as Warhammer fantasy generally revolves around non-human personas. It doesn’t help the realm is slowly being eaten up by Chaos, which makes for a rather [un]pleasant dire and bleak worlds. Think I messed up the meaning of words there, oh well, welcome to the Old World. So, the ‘Old World’ as it was called is essentially being eroded by all the bad and evil forces you can imagine (Chaos, Greekskins, Vampires, Undead, Dark Elves etc). Annihilation is inevitable to the realm of the Empire, those Dwarves in their mountain holds and their best friends the High Elves who tend to Ulthuan, while sipping, well, whatever Elves drink, in their lofty palaces - "We do not care for the troubles of mortals" - a typical throwaway comment by Elves, everywhere and is a mantra of Elves in any lore, honest. It’s a case of ‘how long can we hold the tide’ instead of ‘we can hold and win.’ For me personally, I love this about Warhammer fantasy stories. The bleak and unremitting characters and the unforgiving world they reside in. It’s grim-dark at it’s best in my opinion.
This, for me, make characters in Warhammer Fantasy who are really one dimensional – this isn’t a negative as you know exactly what to expect from Black Library novels. The best way I can describe Gotrek is ‘always forward, no questions, no remorse and no compassion. Felix helps centre the duo in a more humanistic way. So yes, Gotrek is a hard persona to like at times – he hacks, slashes and bashes skulls in. That’s his only remit. It’s a hard world after all! As I’ve mentioned this is balanced out with his oath bound companion Felix. He is rather humorous though another deeply flawed person. ‘Trollslayer’ helps set up the basis of the future novels – Felix, angry with his affluent parents and feeling pressured to continue in a family career he has no interest in – gets drunk and stumbles across Gotrek one day. Whereupon he swears an oath to follow Gotrek – it’s a little more involved than that, but trying to stay spoiler free here. Felix becomes Gotrek’s ‘remembrancer’ so he will record his deeds of heroism and valour, until his eventual doom. Felix, plainly around to give Gotrek dariness some much needed grounding. While the dwarf is slaying (literally) hundreds of foes such as, Greenskins, daemons and trolls (funnily enough). Felix stays at the background at first, but then later on fights at the dour dwarf’s side, dolling out some choice banter and more thoughts from a human’s perspective. Well without that it would just be wall-to-wall slayer-porn. I suppose, from the readers point of view, you either love or hate this type of archetypal characteristics. I personally struggled with the way Gotreks’s is so stone-wall as a character, that I found myself drawn to Felix more and more. I mean everyone loves the wise-cracking sidekick.
To the story proper, ‘Trollslayer’ is a collection of short stories that introduce both title characters. The first is called ‘Geheiminsnacht’, this one was about human sacrifice (scary stuff!) to their Chaos gods. Another upon Gotrek and Felix’s backstory in regards how they met and to reasons why Felix swears that oath to Felix – it’s all rather amusing, especially during a military parade and a very drunk Gotrek. So, their backstory really is fleshed out over the course of William King’s novels (the first six novels I believe). The most interesting story ‘Wolf Riders’ from ‘Trollslayer’ focuses on character progression which reveals Gotrek’s flaws and possibly more interesting his desires for the future – which are basic, but you get some insight into the dwarf. The same can be said for Felix. While the duo found themselves offering their services to a Duke making his way to the Border Princes after having his land seized. Felix falls in love (rather to quickly) – love and Warhammer, an interesting combination. Anyway, it just felt awkward at best. Having said this, throughout Felix’s tenure with Gotrek, it can be a rather emotional ride, it’s a regular occurrence for Felix anyway. Leaping forward here, I feel Nathan Long (who pens the second six novels after William King) really delves into Felix’s emotions, desires and the things he doesn’t want – a rich, uncaring family for one. The continuation from ‘Wolf Riders’ is ‘The Dark Beneath the World’ whereupon they go on a quest with a zealous fanatic called Aldebrand for Zauberlich, a heirlorm of the Templars of the Fiery Hearts. Spewing trolls are afoot in this one, it’s a rather good one, mixing some lore about Karak Eight Peaks with some laughable moments involving Alderbrand. I mentioned Kat before, she appears in ‘Blood and Darkness’ it’s a rather bleak story but while passing through Drakwald Forest they stumble across a sole survivor of a beastman attack, Kat. Kat is a recurring character and one I personally really like, given that her story is actually both harrowing but very Warhammer[ish]. There are a few other stories such as ‘The Mark of Slaanesh’ which looks a how the populace of the Empire become cultists and one other called ‘The Mutant Master’ it’s like Swamp Thing but is controlled by a master… cunning!
So, what I didn’t like. Well, Gotrek to be frank. He just comes across boring. I’ve mentioned previously how I feel he is just one thing and nothing else. That changes much later in the series, but sheez. ‘Just. Be. Interesting.’ Nothing really happens throughout the first six novels – of course ‘things; happen, but Gotrek doesn’t develop as a character. I mean he loses an eye, gets knocked out, stabbed etc, but these are generally afterthoughts for the reader as there’s no real character progression with the Trollslayer. It doesn’t help as he is pretty much invulnerable, to anything (apart from magic, but even then, still invulnerable). It’s his rune axe you see. It just makes the fear of death as redundant. He hardly get’s injured, apart from losing his eye in ‘Trollslayer’. As I’ve mentioned, Felix really helps to deflect that Gotrek is just so bland. Though after a while even Felix’s humour and wit really struggled to draw my attention. At times (I hate doing this) I was precis reading as I knew how the fights were going to end. This sadly transferred to both characters. Felix’s continual musings about ‘what-ifs-buts’ were pointless in the end, for me anyway.
That’s not to say the novels are bad. Blimey, that previous paragraph sounds ranty. There’s a lot of positives though and they outweigh the negative. They are exactly what you should expect from Warhammer fantasy novels. Well those that are written well. William King really helps to bring to life the Warhammer world, especially during Gotrek’s and Felix’s struggles with Grey Seer Thanqual – who is bloody funny himself. The Grey Seer is highly amusing for me – Nuln’s never seen a comedian like him. Nathan Long excels at his attempt to give some rather lacking characters to the ensembled cast – like Ulkira, who is brilliant. The tried and tested formula of a climactic battle works fine. It’s just, at times, the characters get bogged down by the endless conflicts. However, when they are interesting it’s generally involving their companions. Ulkria, is particularly appealing as she challenges both Gotrek and Felix. There are a few others including Kat, who makes several appearances, as well as the wizard. I should mention Ulkria got her own series, also written by Nathan Long.
What both King and Long do well is convey the realities of battle and war – which should be expected given the setting, but it’s done so well. Some times they don’t face insurmountable odds, other’s like the Greater Daemon they face in ‘Daemonslayer’ or the twisted dragon from ‘Dragonslayer’ really give the reader some idea of the sheer malice and evil they face. Wait till the Slaanesh wizard twins later, oomph! This is surely what Warhammer is about, right? The battles, the type of character that Gotrek is, these are to be expected, I was just hoping for a little more character progression with Gotrek, which sadly doesn’t really happen until the twilight novels.
I’m not going to go in-depth into each novel as I kind of feel I owe them a review on their own, which is something I’ll get around to one day. Expect lots of fighting, battles with some humour thrown in and you can’t go wrong. I will say, these novels aren’t timeless, but they are a good read for what they are.