What do you think?
Rate this book
Through the Skylight
Two tantalizing tales, magically intertwined, cross cultures and span centuries as three kids set out to save the lives of three others—who just happen to live in the Middle Ages!
A stone lion roars...
A sleek black cat speaks...
A faun leaps from the canvas of a painting...
When Jared, Shireen, and Miranda are each given one glittering gift from an old Venetian shopkeeper, they never fathom the powers they are now able to unleash; they never expect that their very reality is about to be utterly upended. And the adventure has hardly begun.
For in another time, centuries earlier, another trio—Rashid, Maria, and Francesca—have been thrown together under terrible They have been kidnapped and, along with hundreds of other children, will be sold into child slavery. Unless, that is, they can find some way to save them all.
But all their fates lie in the hands of Jared, Shireen, and Miranda. The future—and the lives—of these three very modern children become entirely intertwined with those of the children from the past. Danger, it seems, has a way of spanning centuries.
“Reminiscent to Cornelia Funke’s Inkheart .” — School Library Journal
A stone lion roars...
A sleek black cat speaks...
A faun leaps from the canvas of a painting...
When Jared, Shireen, and Miranda are each given one glittering gift from an old Venetian shopkeeper, they never fathom the powers they are now able to unleash; they never expect that their very reality is about to be utterly upended. And the adventure has hardly begun.
For in another time, centuries earlier, another trio—Rashid, Maria, and Francesca—have been thrown together under terrible They have been kidnapped and, along with hundreds of other children, will be sold into child slavery. Unless, that is, they can find some way to save them all.
But all their fates lie in the hands of Jared, Shireen, and Miranda. The future—and the lives—of these three very modern children become entirely intertwined with those of the children from the past. Danger, it seems, has a way of spanning centuries.
“Reminiscent to Cornelia Funke’s Inkheart .” — School Library Journal
400 pages, Paperback
First published March 19, 2013
10 people are currently reading
641 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews
December 21, 2013
I loved the book's premise: the idea of an animated stone lion and mythological Roman fawn; Aladin's Tale come to life; a connection to the Children's Crusade. Intriguing. The setting of Venice, both modern and Renaissance, was rich with the promise of imagination.
However, the adventures' plot relied primarily on the character's fate and happenstance rather than their personal choices. It was stymied also by the literacy device used to tell the historical characters' story, actually reading from an old book. This device, while interesting at first, soon staled and felt like exposition. To me, the theme of religion within the book seemed forced and awkward and unbelievable. What modern tweener would not immediately recognize an Islamic prayer? Plus, there were times when the characters--when they did make choices--made ones that lacked common sense. At one point a character controlled a surly dragon through the possession of an artifact. He then gave that artifact to another for a moment, and yet the dragon did not rebel or return to his place of origin. Nor was any explanation given as to how the character could momentarily suspend that magical world's rules of magic.
Despite these flaws, I would probably try another book by this author.
However, the adventures' plot relied primarily on the character's fate and happenstance rather than their personal choices. It was stymied also by the literacy device used to tell the historical characters' story, actually reading from an old book. This device, while interesting at first, soon staled and felt like exposition. To me, the theme of religion within the book seemed forced and awkward and unbelievable. What modern tweener would not immediately recognize an Islamic prayer? Plus, there were times when the characters--when they did make choices--made ones that lacked common sense. At one point a character controlled a surly dragon through the possession of an artifact. He then gave that artifact to another for a moment, and yet the dragon did not rebel or return to his place of origin. Nor was any explanation given as to how the character could momentarily suspend that magical world's rules of magic.
Despite these flaws, I would probably try another book by this author.
April 20, 2013
How much is our destiny foretold and how much is due to free will? That surprising conundrum and its startling answer wind through this tale about La Serenissima and the ancient history that brings three siblings in contact with an adventure from the past and a sinister force that wears the cowl of a holy monk.
A modern book about enchantment had better have something unusual about it and this book has them in spades. Moving statues, pictures that come to life and talking cats and birds are just a few of the wonders that permeate this book about a story that spans centuries and calls on six unlikely heroes. I was utterly enrapt by this novel and found the characters no less gripping than the adventure story it told. Even, as one character says, this is a story that benefits from having children in it, the adults play their small parts as well, making this novel one older teens can enjoy.
A modern book about enchantment had better have something unusual about it and this book has them in spades. Moving statues, pictures that come to life and talking cats and birds are just a few of the wonders that permeate this book about a story that spans centuries and calls on six unlikely heroes. I was utterly enrapt by this novel and found the characters no less gripping than the adventure story it told. Even, as one character says, this is a story that benefits from having children in it, the adults play their small parts as well, making this novel one older teens can enjoy.
May 8, 2013
A children's fantasy novel that had so much potential effectively reveals itself as a mess.
Having read a few other middle grade fantasies set in the city of Venice (Water Mirror and The Undrowned Child to name some), I was eager to see what Baucom's magical vision of this ancient landscape. What I read was a tale that was influenced by C.S. Lewis but lacked the subtlety of his religious undertones. In fact, I would call the religious themes in this novel overtones, as they come across as awkward. They seem to insist upon themselves.
The story begins with three siblings. Jared, Shireen and Miranda. Jared and Shireen are adopted from India and Miranda is the biological daughter or their parents. The children are living in Venice with their professor father and mother who home school them. They are drawn into an odd bookshop where they are given an ancient text which talks about the Thousand and One Nights but is the story of a boy named Rashid who travels with his uncle. They are also "given" two magical rings and a magical die. The rings allow the girls to communicate with cats and bring the stone lions of Venice to life. The die allows Jared to call fourth characters in famous paintings. One of these are a faun named Silvio for instance. It also turns out that the siblings' names and descriptions are written in the book of Rashid... who is still somehow alive and under the influence of an evil christian preist from the time of the Crusades. Are you getting a headache yet?
Anyway, at this point there is a lot of oddly placed religious lipservice in the book. Jared, Shireen and Miranda are mentioned to say their prayers everynight. We don't get a sense that they feel any sort of connection to prayer, just that it is something they do. Also, the stone lion (Lorenzo il Picolo) that Shireen commands talks about the Holy Virgin and the Father and the Son. Silvio the faun swears by the names of a bunch of Roman gods. We hear that Rashid is a Muslim and a talking cat mentions offhand and awkwardly that a bookseller who originally kept Rashid's book is a jew.
At first I thought maybe all of this wasn't central to the book until the themes just kept popping up. The Crusades are spoken of by the siblings' father as attrocious (which they were). When the siblings are united with Rashid and two other girls under the influence of the evil preist, one of the girls holds up a cross and asks if the children acknolege it. It all became too much.
When C.S. Lewis wove the tale of the resurrection into "The Lion The Witch and the Wardrobe", it was done so that the story of sacrifice was in the text, but the world of Narnia could be enjoyed as a secular fantasy as well. This just felt stiff and forced. More than that, the joining of Rashid's story with the story of the three siblings was so confusing at times, I had trouble wanting to suspend my disbelief. And in order to enjoy fantasy you really have to allow yourself to go with it.
I think that the author had two potentially good stories here. Maybe they didn't have to be told in the same book. Maybe they could have been plotted differently. However, if I am reading Christian literature, I would like a bit more warning before having it hit me in the face repeatedly. Aside from that, the story was just so confusing that I had trouble keeping track of what was going on.
Having read a few other middle grade fantasies set in the city of Venice (Water Mirror and The Undrowned Child to name some), I was eager to see what Baucom's magical vision of this ancient landscape. What I read was a tale that was influenced by C.S. Lewis but lacked the subtlety of his religious undertones. In fact, I would call the religious themes in this novel overtones, as they come across as awkward. They seem to insist upon themselves.
The story begins with three siblings. Jared, Shireen and Miranda. Jared and Shireen are adopted from India and Miranda is the biological daughter or their parents. The children are living in Venice with their professor father and mother who home school them. They are drawn into an odd bookshop where they are given an ancient text which talks about the Thousand and One Nights but is the story of a boy named Rashid who travels with his uncle. They are also "given" two magical rings and a magical die. The rings allow the girls to communicate with cats and bring the stone lions of Venice to life. The die allows Jared to call fourth characters in famous paintings. One of these are a faun named Silvio for instance. It also turns out that the siblings' names and descriptions are written in the book of Rashid... who is still somehow alive and under the influence of an evil christian preist from the time of the Crusades. Are you getting a headache yet?
Anyway, at this point there is a lot of oddly placed religious lipservice in the book. Jared, Shireen and Miranda are mentioned to say their prayers everynight. We don't get a sense that they feel any sort of connection to prayer, just that it is something they do. Also, the stone lion (Lorenzo il Picolo) that Shireen commands talks about the Holy Virgin and the Father and the Son. Silvio the faun swears by the names of a bunch of Roman gods. We hear that Rashid is a Muslim and a talking cat mentions offhand and awkwardly that a bookseller who originally kept Rashid's book is a jew.
At first I thought maybe all of this wasn't central to the book until the themes just kept popping up. The Crusades are spoken of by the siblings' father as attrocious (which they were). When the siblings are united with Rashid and two other girls under the influence of the evil preist, one of the girls holds up a cross and asks if the children acknolege it. It all became too much.
When C.S. Lewis wove the tale of the resurrection into "The Lion The Witch and the Wardrobe", it was done so that the story of sacrifice was in the text, but the world of Narnia could be enjoyed as a secular fantasy as well. This just felt stiff and forced. More than that, the joining of Rashid's story with the story of the three siblings was so confusing at times, I had trouble wanting to suspend my disbelief. And in order to enjoy fantasy you really have to allow yourself to go with it.
I think that the author had two potentially good stories here. Maybe they didn't have to be told in the same book. Maybe they could have been plotted differently. However, if I am reading Christian literature, I would like a bit more warning before having it hit me in the face repeatedly. Aside from that, the story was just so confusing that I had trouble keeping track of what was going on.
March 5, 2013
Interesting story set in Venice. At times I loved it. Sometimes though it felt a bit forced. I was about 350 pages in before I started to get bored with the story. I do plan on ordering it once it is available in paperback mainly because I know my 8 year old self would have thought it was the best thing ever.
Read
August 1, 2021
Trigger & Content Warnings
Antisemitism
Islamomisia
Smoking mentioned
Imprisonment
Animal injury
Antisemitism
Islamomisia
Smoking mentioned
Imprisonment
Animal injury
April 30, 2013
This fascinating modern fantasy has overtones of C.S. Lewis at his best. Jared, Shireen, and Miranda are siblings whose father has taken a visiting professor position in Venice for a semester. While getting their bearings of the city, the three stumble upon an old junk shop, where they meet a mysterious old man. Seeming to know something the children don't, he gifts them with a trinket apiece from a mysterious bag along with a copy of the folktale classic One Thousand and One Nights in Latin. Soon, the children are involved in a fantastic romp through Venice along with a stone lion come to life, a faun who's stepped out of a painting, and another trio of children from another time.
Francesca, Maria, and Rashid are somewhat allegorical characters; the commentary they are meant to represent will be obvious to adult readers, but less so to target-aged middle-grade or YA readers. I loved this book not only for the flights of fancy it took, but also for the imaginative way Baucom used two vastly different contexts to his advantage. For the perceptive, mature middle-grade reader, this will be a delight... but don't read the inside jacket! It spoils a plot point that comes along later and really ruined my enjoyment of the early parts of the book because I was waiting for that plot point to crop up.
This book features a family formed through international adoption - Jared and Shireen were adopted from India, while Miranda is the white biological child of the siblings' parents. This is a point in a few places, but the issues of international adoption are mostly glossed over. Although Baucom describes Jared and Shireen as having brown skin, they are illustrated in cover and interior art as having a skintone roughly the same as Miranda's. Just thought I'd throw that out there in case anyone was looking for books that deal with this issue; although it's a part of this book, it wouldn't be my first pick for a child looking for characters to relate to.
Francesca, Maria, and Rashid are somewhat allegorical characters; the commentary they are meant to represent will be obvious to adult readers, but less so to target-aged middle-grade or YA readers. I loved this book not only for the flights of fancy it took, but also for the imaginative way Baucom used two vastly different contexts to his advantage. For the perceptive, mature middle-grade reader, this will be a delight... but don't read the inside jacket! It spoils a plot point that comes along later and really ruined my enjoyment of the early parts of the book because I was waiting for that plot point to crop up.
This book features a family formed through international adoption - Jared and Shireen were adopted from India, while Miranda is the white biological child of the siblings' parents. This is a point in a few places, but the issues of international adoption are mostly glossed over. Although Baucom describes Jared and Shireen as having brown skin, they are illustrated in cover and interior art as having a skintone roughly the same as Miranda's. Just thought I'd throw that out there in case anyone was looking for books that deal with this issue; although it's a part of this book, it wouldn't be my first pick for a child looking for characters to relate to.
May 15, 2014
When brothers and sisters embark on magical journey in Venice, you never really know what will transpire. This book is an interesting fantasy about a family that spends a semester in Venice, and the kids begin on a quest to help children hostages. This book is a great book to read and great for learning little bit of Italian. There are a lot of strengths and very few weaknesses in Through the Skylight. The clarity of this book is outstanding. Through the Skylight is very easy to read and to understand. The uneven pacing of the book is a weakness. Excessive details drag out the narrative, but the suspense keeps you wanting to read more.
Throughout the book the author highlights the importance of setting. Venice is a greta backdrop for this story. The historical elements are a wonderful tribute to the book. the fact that the setting is in Venice brings light to many adventures described. Also it highlights the culture and the story they tried to solve.
Is it truly possible to connect the past with the present? Will Jared, Shireen, and Miranda work together to patch up broken hearts and save scared children/ Will they solve the the missing pieces to the puzzle and fulfill what has been written? The truth lies between the lines.
Throughout the book the author highlights the importance of setting. Venice is a greta backdrop for this story. The historical elements are a wonderful tribute to the book. the fact that the setting is in Venice brings light to many adventures described. Also it highlights the culture and the story they tried to solve.
Is it truly possible to connect the past with the present? Will Jared, Shireen, and Miranda work together to patch up broken hearts and save scared children/ Will they solve the the missing pieces to the puzzle and fulfill what has been written? The truth lies between the lines.
June 4, 2014
When sibling cross world's a wonderful fantasy about a families trip to Venice changes drastically. The kids encounter magical beings that take them further into a wild quest.
The strengths of this book are definitely the location and characters. The location allows a lot of different elements to get involved. For example, the characters have to take the water bus instead of taking the regular bus. They encounter everyday activities that we don't. The characters' attitudes keep the book going. They become more outgoing as they get involved in the magic of the story.
Despite these very enjoyable elements, I was frustrated that some of the transitions make the book hard to understand. There is frequent movement between the present and a past narrative and sometimes I found this confusing.
If you appreciate magical adventures and have a craving for a wild quest I think this is the book for you. It keeps you engaged and takes you to another place.
The strengths of this book are definitely the location and characters. The location allows a lot of different elements to get involved. For example, the characters have to take the water bus instead of taking the regular bus. They encounter everyday activities that we don't. The characters' attitudes keep the book going. They become more outgoing as they get involved in the magic of the story.
Despite these very enjoyable elements, I was frustrated that some of the transitions make the book hard to understand. There is frequent movement between the present and a past narrative and sometimes I found this confusing.
If you appreciate magical adventures and have a craving for a wild quest I think this is the book for you. It keeps you engaged and takes you to another place.
February 11, 2013
A relatively strong version of the modern children go on an adventure genre: here, three siblings in modern day Venice find a mysterious shop and the shopkeeper gives them the opportunity to take a turn at his sack of oddities. They pull out two rings and a die, all somehow magic and somehow integrated in a book about the One Thousand and One Nights. Thanks to these 'trinkets' and the book, Jared, Shireen and Miranda are drawn into an adventure that includes three children enchanted during the Middle Ages, St. George's dragon, a faun, talking cats and the stone lions of Venice coming to life.
While those may sound relatively quotidian to followers of this genre, they're brought together in a way that will engage readers. To my mind, it was better than The Thief Lord, which was supposed to be this sort of magical adventure!
ARC provided by publisher.
While those may sound relatively quotidian to followers of this genre, they're brought together in a way that will engage readers. To my mind, it was better than The Thief Lord, which was supposed to be this sort of magical adventure!
ARC provided by publisher.
May 12, 2014
Though the Skylight is a mysterious, adventurous, and interesting book to read. The main characters in this book are Jared, Shireen, and Miranda. Shireen is a special character and I related to her a lot. Shireen is a key character because she is unique, and her sister and brother are more ordinary. The individual fairy tale stories in this book really come together and make the whole book interesting.
In the beginning, the pace could have been faster. The author could have gotten to the action of the story in a quicker way. The author really challenges you to increase your vocabulary.
There's a lot to learn about historical events. Venice is a great setting for Through the Skylight. If you love fantasy stories, I suggest you read this book. Overall this is an excellent book to read with a class or for a school assignment.
In the beginning, the pace could have been faster. The author could have gotten to the action of the story in a quicker way. The author really challenges you to increase your vocabulary.
There's a lot to learn about historical events. Venice is a great setting for Through the Skylight. If you love fantasy stories, I suggest you read this book. Overall this is an excellent book to read with a class or for a school assignment.
May 15, 2014
A semester in Venice can change the lives of Jared,Shireen and Amanda by a quick map of mythical power that a couple of rings and a die holds.Who knew it would lead them on a long suspenseful journey.This book was a very good book.I have not read a good childrens book in a while and I'm glad it was this one.If your looking for a good bed time story or a good adeventuare book this is the book for you.The book is easy to understand so it's great for younger children.Although the book the book is a slow in the begining as you read along the book captures you attention.The book also taught me a lot about Venice before I read it I had never even heard of Venice.While reading the book I learned little Italian phrases I also learned about diffrent historical places in Venice.
March 9, 2013
I found this to be an unoriginal, confusing, and ineffective mash-up of The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, The Da Vinci Code, and A Wrinkle In Time. The similarities to TLWW were so pervasive that I found it distracting. There is not much here for kids to get excited about. The reading level is too high for the kids who might enjoy the story, and the kids at the appropriate reading level are unlikely to enjoy its over-the-top plot and characters.
Other than an alcoholic, binge-drinking, wine-obsessed faun who is a somewhat secondary character throughout the book, I did not recognize any other potential content issues that parents might object to.
Other than an alcoholic, binge-drinking, wine-obsessed faun who is a somewhat secondary character throughout the book, I did not recognize any other potential content issues that parents might object to.
October 21, 2013
Recommended for gr. 5-8. Three American siblings live in modern-day Venice. They each receive a small gift from a shopkeeper and strange things begin happening. Stone lions come to life, they have conversations with a cat, and creatures step out of paintings. This turns into an adventure fit for a storybook, and in fact, there is a book that seems to be telling their story. Another trio of children from Venice of the past show up, and the American children must put themselves into danger to save the others.
A good story, readable and captures the attention. Boys as well as girls will enjoy this.
A good story, readable and captures the attention. Boys as well as girls will enjoy this.
May 8, 2014
A bedtime story deepens as siblings Jared, Shireen, and Miranda try to solve a problem from the past that has burst into the present. The main characters of the book are Jared, Shireen, and Miranda. An old Venetian shopkeeper unleashed a powerful magic upon them.
Thefts,kidnappings, and betrayals from centuries ago have endangered the lives of people in the present. Now it is up to them to solve this mystery.
Through the Skylight is a mysterious adventure that is told at a leisurely pace, although at certain points of the book the reader gets a little lost. Other than that the book is well-written treatment of a great mystery.
Thefts,kidnappings, and betrayals from centuries ago have endangered the lives of people in the present. Now it is up to them to solve this mystery.
Through the Skylight is a mysterious adventure that is told at a leisurely pace, although at certain points of the book the reader gets a little lost. Other than that the book is well-written treatment of a great mystery.
July 21, 2013
This was a book I picked up on a whim because the cover looked cool and I have this thing for Middle Grade fantasy. I just love it haha. While I had my doubts here and there this book did turn out to be cute and sweet and a nice adventure. There were parts where it seemed a little confusing or slow, but in the end it was a pretty good middle grade book. Definitely one that I would recommend to my siblings. (the main content was brief violence and magic)
September 8, 2014
Through the Skylight is an interesting, exciting, mysterious, and funny book. I found it a very good read because there was humor and suspense in it. When three kids walk into an old shop they get special items or gifts from the storekeeper. They don’t know what the items are for, but they do know that they are special and important. As they wake up the next morning, they notice there was a visitor that night. They don't realize that there lives will change and possibly not for the good.
July 29, 2013
I liked it, and I'm older than its target audience. I did think it wasn't quite bedtime reading material, as there were a few creepy parts that some kids might like but that others (including my adult self) *really* did not need to read right before sleeping...Not the best book I've ever read, but a whole lot better than a lot of YA fiction I've read in the past few years.
October 29, 2015
Not bad. The introduction of magic in this story feels a little forced though, and the large flashback seemed a bit too much information to unload in one chapter. I'd probably like it more if the flashbacks were shorter and spread out over the course of the story, like some other authors do in their books.
July 16, 2013
Loved the first half of the book with the kids discovering the purpose of the objects, the importance of the book in their lives, the personalities of the faun, the lion, and the cat. The second half just didn't work for me.
April 29, 2014
This was a good story of three modern children caught in a magical world of old world Venice. The story is one that will appeal to intermediate and middle grade fantasy fans. This isn't my favorite genre, but I still found it to be a fun read.
August 31, 2016
A magical book set in present-day Venice about three very ordinary children who, with the help of a talking cat, a faun, a stone lion, and a dragon rescue the waifs of medieval Venice from the clutches of a delusional priest. A modern rival to Lewis' Narnia. Absolutely enchanting!
April 2, 2015
Grand adventure for middle school kids set in Venice. We all believe that what is written in books pulls us in and becomes our world, right??
May 22, 2013
It opened with a map so I was immediately hooked. Three kids living abroad in Venice encounter a curious old man and some strange objects from the past.
Sort of predictable but very enjoyable
Sort of predictable but very enjoyable
November 26, 2013
Though this novel had some intrigue and good humor, there were very few times where I felt a need to read on and find out what happened. I would probably not recommend it to anyone or read it again.
July 19, 2013
couldn't get into it. put it down after a few chapters.
December 11, 2013
I thought this book was a good book because it was based in Venice.
Read
August 28, 2013I did not rate this one because I am 100 pages in and just not making a connection. Rare for me to not finish, but there are too many other things to read....
September 9, 2013
Great storytelling for tweens!
December 27, 2013
totally liked this book they should have made book 2 4 it:)it had so much about venice in it.And i love the idea of there powers very original:)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews