Caldecott #8 (1945)
If you're a religious person, Christian in particular, and a parent especially, then this book is probably for you and your kids to enjoy, which is your right and pleasure. I, personally, am not religious, and find prayer to be a useless and highly performative gesture that reflects a gullible belief in mysticism and a prideful need to be seen as pious and pure by others rather than coming from any intentional desire for true change or real intervention. Prayers do nothing; actions get things done, including the things we often hail as miracles straight from [insert mythical deity here].
But I digress regarding the text. For a Caldecott winner, the illustrations are cute, cozy, soft, and sweet; very deserving of this distinguished medal, and reflected in my star rating, as a Caldecott review should be. However, I continue to be slightly appalled at the number of Caldecott Winners and Honors that contain religious themes (usually Christianity), and even direct religious indoctrination like scriptures and hymn texts.
I know 2026 is far from 1945; a lot has changed, a lot was going on globally, and I think comprehend the nuance involved with this year's award choice. Perhaps then, with the world at war, and the Allied Forces on the cusp of victory, Americans felt they needed the innocent prayers of children to buoy up their hope and keep their perspective facing toward the future.
But from today's perspective, and my personal view, the United States has no national religion, and religion should be taught privately in homes or in institutions dedicated to faith -- not highlighted in a children's book that receives national acclaim and attention from a federally funded program like the ALA. You can also bet that if this book contained the prayer of a Muslim child to Allah, a Jewish child's benediction to Yahweh, or a Hindi child's appeal to Brahman, the outrage and backlash would be severe and unforgiving in any decade since the Caldecott was first issued.
I'm hoping this pattern fades out as I continue to explore the Caldecott winners chronologically.