Well, I think I have read them all and IMHO this is the best of all the Laura Lippman, including everything in her Tess series. And I'm a fan in general- so that is saying something.
4.5 stars - losing just a tiny bit in the few small confusions of the form. Yes, the time shifting time periods worked here wonderfully, you got uniquely framed personality core at each character's exact age. It's unusual for any author to do that switching so often and continually without losing some of the plot tension; and that did not happen here for me. The tension pulled continually. But within a novel that holds these many prime characters, and all their relatives, spouses, and intermediate friends? It's not one you can easy-peasy glide read either. Not at all. You must pay full attention.
So many of the current modern best sellers dwell in a "sisters' world" or "mother/daughter". It seems to me, far more than for the other gender and their sibling or parental relationships, this is true. So it was SUPER surprising to me to find in this genre one of the best sister, sister, sister triangles that I can remember reading.
Is it really a mystery? Yes. But then no, it is more. Considering all the books I've read in the last 3 years (a completely artificial inclusion, I know)- this one reminded me the most of Commonwealth by Ann Patchett. Because it is more firmly a story of family than it is a mystery. Family broken and yet fused in "other" forms for the breaking and the aftermath of breaking. And still a large quotient is unknown too, a mystery.
LOVED THIS BOOK. It addressed change you didn't want and never saw coming. It addressed abandonment. It addressed money and class consciousness to the extremes. It addressed sibling competition. It addressed male and spousal infidelity when it is chronic. And also when it is dual and steady.
And it superbly addressed how we (and this is nearly every single married, divorced, single or bonding homo sapiens who has ever had strong attraction or life long attachment of goals with another) deal with some of the "worst" situations by "not seeing" what we don't want to see and never truly holding a cognition for any length of time that does not continue to serve our emotional "knowledge and connection of record" with another.
This is one of the reasons why a Mom, or even a neighbor- can say of a thug, defiler, murderer of record and obvious repeat occurrence of lifelong result for others that "he is SUCH a nice boy"? Or when law breakers of multiple record are "just misunderstood" despite the harm they have caused the victims or the misery of aftermath for a myriad of others? It's for the same emotional vs cognitive understanding of /for an individual reality. The victim is not (no the victim is NEVER) the core of long term empathy and understanding at all- but the perp is. And often. It is more now in 2017 true than it ever was too, IMHO.
It also rises to the moral questions of crimes aftermath in depth. Who suffers the most? Those in a cell or those who have to live with the results of the acts? Or the cowards who never confront the results of their crimes but run and begin another self-involved and selfish direction.
Good book for those who just like to read about gossip and hear say fall outs too! And also for those who have been, live, have interest in Baltimore with the rise and fall of neighborhoods and "harbor" views.
The plot is nebulous and the triangle of Felix, Bambi and Julie is the heart of the maze. But it turned me out lost in that maze at least twice, and it was masterfully plotted. Have patience and read slowly. I guessed wrong quite near the end.
I must say I do have one LARGE misgiving. And that is the Bambi post Felix support picture. Not even Scarlet O'Hara could have pulled off that living style for decades without "working" an income that is substantial. Especially for one so close to the beltway and how she spent her days. School tuition would have been a mere tip of the iceberg. Knowing women (being one) who has similar circumstance and ESPECIALLY those who had considerable equity or incomes before the severing- they still ALL (those who left with some support and those who had none- but ALL)have had to acquire full time careers out of absolute necessity. Careers that REQUIRED salaries for raising children in such celebrating styles as Bambi holds, on top of it. She would never have applied for government help or food supplement or anything like that either. And didn't. Those girls could not have done what they did with who they did and when they did. Even if he had left access to a more than a million $$$. For THAT long (decades) and also in that particular time frame? Fiction.
I was also entirely delighted by all the Jewish religious and Yiddish references and embedding them so solidly into the characters' lives. LOVED that because it is very RARELY done so well in the last decade. Kudos, Laura Lippman. Her family Shiva and Seder scenes were fully 5 star, in every sense of their word flow and connotation. The tone and information were perfect. I felt like I was at my friend's Seder.
For some time I was truly on the fence with Lippman. This one is TOPS, a real keeper.
And for all of you who have to find that favorite detective- Tess appears in the last few pages. The wonderful character of Sandy in this novel is going to be her new "help" in the agency. That's a tiny spoiler that will not hurt any for fore-knowledge. Read this one without reading ANY plot summations, and you will grasp this one with more up and down intrigue. Also- the older you are the more you will like this one, IMHO. Younger people are probably going to find it lackluster. This is not so much about passion as about loyalty and not "seeing" what we do not want or NEED to see when we are at our happiest. Even about our own kids, friends etc. Something that energy of youth seldom connotes for what it is.
ENJOY!