A 2-star review may be unfair of me; it's clear that the book has historical importance, as one of the first books published in Wicca that included rites of self-initiation. I suppose that for me, the problem is that this is a Wicca book, not a book on Saxon witchcraft. If you wanted to actually learn about Saxon religion or real recreations of it, this isn't where you go (which Buckland himself clearly states). If, in the other hand, you wanted the brief outline of Wicca with a vaguely Saxon flair, this is it. For someone like me, who's decidedly not Wiccan, it's not super useful. For someone interested in Wicca, though, I'd very happily recommend it.