Cass Hutt, bull rider, has nothing left to lose. The bulls should have killed him by now. Instead, it is his rodeo partner who has died, severing Cass’s only ties to his world. With nothing and no one to hold him, Cass is led back East by the sudden arrival of a mysterious land deed, back to Scotch River, Nova Scotia, and the sketchy boyhood memories he left to die there. In this dark and beautifully written novel, acclaimed author Linda Little introduces an unforgettable cast of characters bound together by the mysteries of blood and the burdens of memory. As it unveils its secrets, Scotch River deftly weaves a profound and deeply moving story of family love in all its ardour and the heartbreaking, indelible acts performed in its name.
The author had an unusual descriptive style that was quite lovely. I can’t say I understood all of what she was referencing when she delved into characters memories which then led me to reread many paragraphs, sometimes several times.
The protagonist, Cass, was a truly sympathetic character whose depth was conveyed by the author and yet it seemed as though we were only allowed to skim the surface. He was so interesting to me that I would have loved to have learned more about his life in all its stages. In fact, each character in this book all had such interesting stories that I could easily see each one of them being the protagonist in their “own” books.
I truly appreciated how Cass’s homosexuality was not treated as a feature of the book but simply as one part of a complex individual, in the same way that heterosexual characters are portrayed. Simply human.
The author’s descriptions of grief were touching and poignant. I truly felt these. “…this was when she knew there was no redemption, that she would walk the rest of her days with the wind whistling through the holes inside her.”
“What cry a living thing can make will never approach the truth. A gull in fog, a coyote at night, the various keenings of uncivilized peoples, even a babe torn-the closest yet still as far from the truth as the distance from the brink to the abyss; there is no sound to match the tearing of the heart. The sound of asunder.”
Perhaps being a Nova Scotian myself is what also led me to having an affinity with all the characters. The characters are people I’ve met before and the scenes are places I’ve visited before.
I got some insanely sick for the entire month of February 2025 and it was so bad I could barely read; I was so disabled by the strongest sinus meds and the associated nausea that I could barely navigate a book chapter without falling asleep or getting queasy. So this book took way too long to read, which is bad news for the book. A former bullrider returns home to a small Nova Scotia town around Y2K to meet the tattered remains of his messed-up family, whom he’d never known. The best part of this book was definitely its rich characters, who definitely brought NS spirit and unusual diversity. The protagonist, Cass, was sympathetic to me. He’s borderline illiterate, a loner, a drifter, and a man out of his time. Of special note, he’s gay, but this is barely relevant to the story as he has no on-page romance throughout the plot. It was really cool to have some old fashioned cowboy vibes, but his emotional core came through well, neither too hard-boiled, nor effeminately sentimental. I also enjoyed the coldness of Granny Eleanor and the grimness of Earl. The plot, however, was a bit plodding and laggy. I was curious to learn about Cass’s birth story and the reality of it was touching, tragic. But the ending was not particularly hopeful. You’re a loner, but at least you’re a landowner now! The characters were just so interesting and well-designed that maybe someday I’ll give this book a second chance and force myself to read it quickly enough to have momentum.
What a great author. She captures the feel of small, rural communities so well, and the feeling of being ostracized and bullied and never really belonging, because everyone knows who your family is and who they were, and you can never outlive that. I didn’t bond as well with the main character Cass, as I did with one of the other characters, Pipe. Little’s books seem to grab me in the gut every time.
Good characters, set in a Nova Scotia village with dysfunctional families - some of the younger generation are destroyed, others are resilient fighters.
I wanted to like it but I thought the writing was confusing at times. The characters would flitter in their thoughts between now and then all in the one paragraph in a vague prose. That, coupled with the slower paced storyline made it for a very tedious read. The characters were excellent and I was interested in them as well as the town but too often I needed to re read a paragraph and figure it out.
it almost scoared me off at the beginning -- i was worried about a Canadian Brokeback Mountain -- but i read on and it was a delightful surprise, rich with imagery and great misfit characters and good themes -- including horses, history and family.
This is the book that beat out Birth House for Atlantic Book of the Year. While I don't identify with Cass as much as with Dora Rare, it's a fantastic book.